Module 7 · 18 min read · Free chapter
Linear seating arrangement
Number the seats from one end and note which way people face, because left and right are always from the sitter's own view. Place fixed clues first, such as ends, the middle or the nth seat, then fixed gaps. When a clue allows more than one place, draw each case as a separate row and carry them forward until a later clue rules one out.
Start from zero: five friends in a cinema row
Five friends, A, B, C, D and E, sit in a row of five seats facing the screen, which is to the north. C sits in the middle seat and A sits at the extreme left. B sits immediately to the right of C, and D does not sit next to A. Who sits where?
Number the seats 1 to 5 from the left. C is in seat 3, A is in seat 1 and B is in seat 4. Only seats 2 and 5 are left for D and E. Seat 2 is next to A, so D cannot sit there.
So D takes seat 5 and E takes seat 2, and the order is A E C B D. Notice what happened: three clues placed people directly, and the last clue only had to choose between two seats. That is the shape of almost every seating puzzle.
Why this topic exists. Arrangement puzzles test whether you can hold many small facts together and build one consistent picture. Officers do the same when they fix a duty roster, plan seating for a meeting or match people to tasks under rules. The skill is not memory but order: which fact to use first and how to record it.
Set the frame: seats, facing and the sitter's left
Draw before you read. Draw a row of empty boxes, one per person, and number them 1, 2, 3 and so on from the left side of your page. Write the facing direction above the row with an arrow. Every clue will now become a statement about box numbers.
Left and right belong to the sitter. "X is to the left of Y" always means Y's own left. If the row faces north, away from you on the page, the sitter's left is your left, so it is a smaller box number. If the row faces south, towards you, the sitter's left is your right, so it is a larger box number.
| Facing | Sitter's left on paper | Sitter's right on paper |
|---|---|---|
| North (away from you) | Smaller seat number | Larger seat number |
| South (towards you) | Larger seat number | Smaller seat number |
Words that set the gap. "Immediately to the left" means the very next seat on that side, a gap of 1. "Second to the right" means a gap of 2, with one person in between. "Only two people sit between X and Y" means the seat numbers differ by 3, on either side, and "X sits to the left of Y" with no "immediately" means any seat on that side.
A clue can fix an end by itself. "Q sits third to the right of T, and T sits at an end" is enough to place T: there must be room for three seats on T's right. So T is at the left end from the sitters' own view, whichever way they face. Spotting such hidden certainty saves a whole case.
Why it matters. Most wrong answers in seating come from the frame, not the logic. A south-facing row drawn as if it faced north reverses every left and right clue, and the puzzle then seems to have no answer.
Use the clues in order of certainty
The three kinds of clue. A fixed clue names a seat: "at an end", "in the middle", "third from the left". A gap clue links two people: "immediately right of", "second to the left of", "two people between". A negative clue only removes options: "not at an end", "not next to".
Worked example. Seven people, P, Q, R, S, T, U and V, sit in a row facing north. T sits at an end, and Q sits third to the right of T; only one person sits between Q and V, and V does not sit next to T. U sits immediately to the left of P, and R does not sit at an end.
Step 1: the anchor. T at an end with three seats on its right means T is in seat 1, so Q is in seat 4. Step 2: the gap clue. One person between Q and V puts V in seat 2 or seat 6, and seat 2 is next to T, so V is in seat 6.
Step 3: the pair. The free seats are 2, 3, 5 and 7, and the pair U P needs two seats side by side; only seats 2 and 3 are side by side, so U is in seat 2 and P in seat 3. Step 4: the negative clue. R and S share seats 5 and 7, and R is not at an end, so R is in seat 5 and S in seat 7.
The row is T U P Q R V S. Each clue was used once, in the order of how much it fixed. Starting with the U P pair instead would have opened four cases for nothing.
Pairs and blocks. A clue like "U sits immediately left of P" turns two people into one block of two seats. Blocks are easy to place once only a few free seats remain, because they need neighbouring seats. Look for such blocks after the anchors are down.
Why it matters. Order of use is the whole skill. A fixed clue is a sure step, a gap clue becomes sure once one person is placed, and a negative clue is only useful at the end, when it chooses between the last two options.
Branch into cases, then cut
When a clue leaves two places, draw both. Six people, A to F, sit in a row facing north. C sits at the extreme right end, B sits second to the left of E, and only two people sit between E and A. The first clue puts C in seat 6, but the other two leave choices.
Find the cases. E and A are three seats apart, and B is two seats left of E; if E were in seat 3, A would need seat 6, which is C's, so that fails. If E is in seat 4, A is in seat 1 and B in seat 2: Case 1 is A B _ E _ C. If E is in seat 5, A is in seat 2 and B in seat 3: Case 2 is _ A B _ E C.
Let the next clue choose. Now add "F sits at an end". In Case 1 both ends are taken by A and C, so Case 1 dies. In Case 2, F takes seat 1, and D fills the only seat left, seat 4, giving F A B D E C.
Keep cases short. Write each case as one line of letters with blanks, not a new drawing. Most exam puzzles open at most two or three cases, and one clue usually closes them. If you find yourself with more than four, go back and look for a fixed clue you skipped.
When cases survive. Sometimes the puzzle ends with two cases still alive. Then answer a question only if both cases agree on it. If they disagree, the answer is "cannot be determined", which is a real option and often the correct one.
Why it matters. Branching feels slow but is the fastest safe method. Guessing one case and pushing on wastes far more time when it collapses three clues later.
Two rows facing each other
The set-up. Two rows of four seats face each other. P, Q, R and S sit in row 1 facing south, and A, B, C and D sit in row 2 facing north. Draw row 1 at the top of your page and row 2 below it, with seats numbered 1 to 4 from your left in both rows; seat 1 of row 1 faces seat 1 of row 2, and so on.
Each row keeps its own left and right. Row 2 faces north, so its sitters' right is your right. Row 1 faces south, so its sitters' right is your left. This is why the right end of one row faces the left end of the other.
Worked example. A sits at an end of row 2 and faces Q, and R sits second to the right of Q. C faces R, and D sits immediately to the right of C. S sits at an end of row 1.
Solving it. R is two seats to Q's own right, which on paper is two seats to your left, so Q must be in seat 3 or 4; A is at an end and faces Q, so Q is in seat 4, A in seat 4 and R in seat 2. C faces R, so C is in seat 2, and D is to C's right, which for row 2 is your right, so D is in seat 3. Then B takes seat 1, S takes the end seat 1 of row 1, and P takes seat 3.
So row 1 reads S R P Q and row 2 reads B C D A, seat by seat. B faces S, C faces R, D faces P and A faces Q. Every "right of" clue was turned into a seat number using that row's own direction.
Why it matters. Facing-rows puzzles are where most candidates lose time, because left and right flip between the rows. Converting every clue to seat numbers before placing anyone removes the confusion completely.
A second attribute, and what you may answer
Two things per person. Many puzzles give each person a seat and one more feature, such as a sport, a city or a colour. Make a two-line table: seats on top, and below each seat the person and the feature. Fill a cell only when a clue forces it.
Worked example. K, L, M, N and O sit in a row facing north, and each likes a different sport: cricket, hockey, chess, football and tennis. M sits in the middle, and L likes chess and sits at the extreme left; K sits immediately to the right of M and likes hockey, and N sits at the extreme right. Only one person sits between the tennis lover and the cricket lover.
Fill what is forced. L is in seat 1 with chess, M in seat 3, K in seat 4 with hockey and N in seat 5, so O is in seat 2. The sports left are cricket, football and tennis for O, M and N. Tennis and cricket must be two seats apart, and among seats 2, 3 and 5 only seats 3 and 5 are two apart, so M and N hold tennis and cricket, and O likes football.
What can you answer now? "Who sits second from the left?" is O, and "what does O like?" is football, because every case agrees. "Who likes tennis?" cannot be answered yet: it is M in one case and N in the other. If the puzzle now adds "M does not like tennis", the cases close, M likes cricket and N likes tennis.
Why it matters. The trap is to fill the last cells by a hunch so that the table looks complete. Exams deliberately ask about the one fact that stays open, and "cannot be determined" is then the only right answer.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners test it. Seating puzzles measure organised thinking under time pressure: reading every word, recording facts cleanly and not assuming what was not said. Administrative work is full of such constraint problems, from exam-hall seating to duty rosters, and an officer must spot when the rules leave a choice open.
Where it shows up. Linear arrangements are standard in state aptitude papers and in bank, railway and teacher recruitment exams, often as a set of three to five questions on one puzzle. The union aptitude paper asks shorter puzzles with fewer people, but it likes "cannot be determined" and minimum-or-maximum twists.
When it goes wrong. The usual slips are reading a south-facing row as north-facing, treating "to the left" as "immediately to the left", counting "two people between" as a gap of two, and filling an open cell by guesswork. In sets of questions, one wrong seat early ruins every answer, so a quick final check against all clues is worth the seconds.
The habit to build. Number the seats, mark the facing, place certain clues first and write cases as short lines. Before marking any answer, run your eye down the clue list once and tick each clue against the final row.
Exam lens: five question types and how to beat each
These are practice questions written by us, in the styles the papers use. Real past questions from your exam appear in the PYQ panel of this module.
Type 1: direct placing. "A, B, C, D and E sit in a row facing north. C is in the middle, A is at the right end, E is immediately left of C and D is not at an end. Who is at the left end?" C is in seat 3, A in seat 5 and E in seat 2; D cannot take seat 1, so D is in seat 4 and the answer is B.
Type 2: counting between. "In a row of 12 facing north, P is 4th from the left and Q is 3rd from the right. How many people sit between them?" Q is in seat 10, so 10 − 4 − 1 = 5 people sit between them.
Type 3: open fact. "Five people sit in a row facing north. D sits at an end and B sits second to the left of D. Who sits at the left end?" D must be at the right end and B in seat 3, but seats 1, 2 and 4 are open, so the answer is cannot be determined.
Type 4: facing south. "Seven people sit in a row facing south. N sits at an end and M sits third to the right of N. At which end does N sit?" There must be room on N's own right, so N is at the sitters' own left end, which is the right side of your drawing.
Type 5: facing rows. "Two rows of three face each other. X sits at the right end of the row facing south. Is the person facing X at the right end or the left end of the north-facing row?" The rows have opposite left and right, so X's partner is at the left end of the north-facing row.
Time plan. Types 1 to 4 should take under a minute each. A full puzzle with a set of questions deserves three to four minutes, spent mostly on the drawing; after that each question takes seconds.
Practice set: twelve solved problems
Try each problem first, then read the steps. All rows face north unless the problem says otherwise, and the problems go from easy to hard.
1. A, B, C, D and E sit in a row. B sits at the extreme right end, D sits immediately left of B and A sits in the middle, while C does not sit at the left end. Who sits at the left end?
B is in seat 5, D in seat 4 and A in seat 3, and C cannot take seat 1, so C is in seat 2. The answer is E.
2. In a row of 8, X is 3rd from the left end and Y is 2nd from the right end. How many people sit between X and Y?
Y is in seat 7, so 7 − 3 − 1 people sit between them. The answer is 3.
3. Six people sit in a row. Q sits at the extreme right end and P sits second to the left of Q. What is P's position from the left end?
Q is in seat 6, so P is in seat 4. The answer is 4th.
4. Seven people sit in a row facing south. N sits at an end and M sits third to the right of N. At which end does N sit, as seen by the sitters themselves?
N needs three seats on its own right. The answer is their own left end.
5. P, Q, R, S and T sit in a row. Q sits second to the right of P, R sits immediately left of P and S sits at the extreme right end. Who sits in the middle?
The block R P _ Q fits only in seats 1 to 4, so T fills seat 3. The answer is T.
6. Eight people sit in a row. B sits second from the right end, A sits third to the left of B and only two people sit between A and C. Who sits at the extreme left end?
B is in seat 7 and A in seat 4, so C is in seat 1 or seat 7, and seat 7 is taken. The answer is C.
7. Six people sit in a row. K sits at an end, L sits second to the right of K and only one person sits between L and N. What is N's position from the left end?
K must be in seat 1 and L in seat 3, so N is in seat 1 or 5, and seat 1 is taken. The answer is 5th.
8. P, Q and R sit in a row facing south, and A, B and C sit in a row facing north, each facing one person. Q sits in the middle, A faces Q, P sits immediately to the right of Q and C sits immediately to the right of A. Who faces R?
P is on Q's own right, which is seat 1 on paper, so R is in seat 3; C is on A's right, which is seat 3. The answer is C.
9. Four people, A, B, C and D, sit in a row. A sits at the left end and B sits immediately right of A. Who sits at the right end?
C and D can take seats 3 and 4 either way. The answer is cannot be determined.
10. In how many ways can four people sit in a row of four seats if A and B must sit next to each other?
Treat A B as one block: 3 units give 3 × 2 × 1 = 6 orders, and the block can be A B or B A. The answer is 12.
11. Seven people, A to G, sit in a row. D sits at the left end and F sits third to the right of D; only one person sits between F and A, B sits immediately left of A, and C sits immediately left of G. Who sits at the extreme right end?
D is in seat 1 and F in seat 4; A in seat 2 would push B onto D, so A is in seat 6 and B in seat 5, and C G take seats 2 and 3. The answer is E.
12. P, Q, R and S sit in a row facing south, and A, B, C and D sit in a row facing north, each facing one person. S sits at an end and B faces S; Q sits second to the left of S, P sits immediately right of Q, D sits immediately right of B and A faces Q. Who faces R?
S can only be in seat 1 so that Q, two seats to S's own left, lands in seat 3; P is in seat 2 and R in seat 4, while B, D and A take seats 1, 2 and 3. The answer is C.
Quick revision
- Number the seats from the left of your page and mark the facing direction.
- Left and right are the sitter's own: facing south, the sitter's right is your left.
- "Immediately" means the next seat; "k people between" means a gap of k + 1.
- Use fixed clues first, then gap clues, then negative clues.
- A clue like "third to the right of someone at an end" fixes which end.
- Turn "immediately next to" pairs into blocks of two seats.
- When a clue allows two places, write both cases and let later clues cut them.
- In facing rows, seat i faces seat i; one row's right end faces the other's left end.
- Answer only what every surviving case agrees on; otherwise "cannot be determined".