BPSC AEDO · Module 49 · standard depth · 14 min
Cause and effect, assertion and reason
What BPSC AEDO asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Paper 3: General Aptitude · Reasoning: analogy, similarities and differences, space visualisation, problem solving, classification, number and non-verbal series, coding-decoding
BPSC AEDO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for BPSC AEDO. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: why did this happen?
After three days of heavy rain in the hills, a river in the plains rises above the danger mark. Almost everyone sees the link at once. The rain came first, and water flows downhill into the river, so the rain caused the flood.
Many links are not so plain. Umbrella sales and raincoat sales may both rise in the same week, yet neither causes the other; both come from the start of the rains. An officer who mistakes such pairs for cause and effect will act on the wrong thing.
Why this matters. Every report on a problem, from crop loss to school dropouts, claims some cause. Policies built on a wrong cause waste money and leave the real cause untouched. Testing whether a link is real is therefore a basic administrative skill.
What this chapter does. We learn the five standard ways two events can be related and how to tell them apart. We then learn the assertion-reason format, where you judge two statements and whether one explains the other.
The five standard answers
The options. Cause-and-effect questions give two events, I and II, and usually five choices. The table lists them with the test for each.
| Option | Meaning | Test |
|---|---|---|
| A | I is the cause, II is its effect | I comes first and produces II |
| B | II is the cause, I is its effect | II comes first and produces I |
| C | Both are independent causes | Each separately pushes toward the same result |
| D | Both are effects of independent causes | Unrelated events with separate causes |
| E | Both are effects of a common cause | One unstated event explains both |
Test one: order in time. A cause must come before its effect. If the statements show II happening first, A is ruled out at once. Words such as "after", "following" and "since" often reveal the order.
Test two: a believable mechanism. Ask how one event could produce the other. A rise in the support price for pulses can make farmers switch to pulses; a new cricket stadium cannot change petrol prices. No mechanism means no direct cause.
Test three: a hidden third event. If two events are both results, look for one cause behind them. School closures and washed-away roads in a district both point to a flood. If you can name such a cause, the answer is E.
Why it matters. Following these three tests in order settles almost every question. The table then tells you which letter to mark.
Together is not the same as because
The correlation trap. Two things that rise together are not necessarily cause and effect. Ice-cream sales and cases of heatstroke both rise in May. Neither causes the other; both come from hot weather.
Independent causes. Sometimes both events push the same way without depending on each other. A cut in the import duty on edible oil and a bumper groundnut crop can each lower oil prices. Neither causes the other, and together they are independent causes of the same result, which is option C.
Independent effects. Two events in the same month may simply be unrelated. "Petrol prices rose this month" and "a new stadium opened this month" share a date and nothing else. They are effects of separate causes, which is option D.
Reverse direction. Students often assume that the first statement is the cause because it is printed first. "Many farmers shifted to pulses" is printed as I, but its cause is II, "the support price for pulses was raised sharply". Read both events before deciding the direction.
Several causes at once. Real events often have more than one cause. Rising onion prices may come from a poor crop, higher transport costs and hoarding together. Exam options name one link at a time, so pick the option that matches the two events given, not the full story behind them.
Why it matters. Public debate often treats "after this" as "because of this". Separating real causes from coincidences and shared causes is how sound policy is made.
Assertion and reason
The format. You get an Assertion (A) and a Reason (R). Usually there are four choices: both true and R explains A; both true but R does not explain A; A true but R false; A false but R true. Some papers add a fifth: both false.
Step one: judge A alone. Read the assertion as a plain statement and decide whether it is true. Do not let the reason influence you. "Sound travels faster than light" is false, whatever reason follows it.
Step two: judge R alone. Do the same for the reason. "Ice is denser than water" is false, since ice floats because it is less dense. Only if both are true do you need step three.
Step three: the "because" test. Join them as "A, because R" and ask whether R really answers "why is A true?". "Iron rusts faster near the sea, because salty, moist air speeds up rusting" works, so R explains A. "Summer days are longer in the north, because the Moon goes round the Earth" joins two true facts that have nothing to do with each other.
Why it matters. This format tests knowledge and reasoning together. Many candidates know both facts but lose the mark by not checking whether one explains the other.
Fine points in assertion-reason
A partial explanation. Sometimes R is true and related, but explains only a small part of A, or a different aspect. "The Sun rises in the east, because the Earth rotates from west to east" is a full explanation. If R were "the Earth is round", it would be true but would not explain why the east in particular.
A true reason cannot save a false assertion. If A is false, the answer is "A false, R true" or "both false", however good R sounds. Students sometimes mark option (a) because R is a famous fact. Judge A first, every time.
Watch absolute words. An assertion with "always", "never" or "all" is false if one exception exists. "Compound interest is never less than simple interest for one year or more at the same rate" is true, because interest on interest can only add. But "compound interest is always more than simple interest" fails, because for exactly one year with yearly compounding the two are equal, so read every condition and every absolute word.
The direction of "because". R must explain A, not the other way round. If A explains R instead, the answer is "both true, but R does not explain A". Read the pair in the order "A because R" and check that it makes sense.
Why it matters. These points decide the hardest assertion-reason items. They also train you to read scientific and policy claims with care about their exact conditions.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners test it. Diagnosing a problem before treating it is the heart of administration. Cause-and-effect questions test whether you can spot the real driver of an event. Assertion-reason questions test whether your knowledge is connected, not just memorised.
Where it shows up. Cause-and-effect pairs appear in state PSC mental-ability sections and in staff-selection style exams. Assertion-reason items have appeared in UPSC and several state Prelims papers across subjects, from science to polity. The same skills help in Mains answers that must explain causes and consequences.
When it goes wrong. The usual slips are taking the first-printed event as the cause, mistaking events that happen together for cause and effect, judging R before A, and marking (a) for two true but unrelated facts. Another is ignoring words like "always" in the assertion.
The habit to build. For cause and effect, check time order, mechanism and a possible third cause, in that order. For assertion and reason, judge A, then R, then join them with "because".
Practice set: twelve solved problems
Problems 1 to 6 use the cause-and-effect options A to E from the table. Problems 7 to 12 use four assertion-reason options: (a) both true and R explains A, (b) both true but R does not explain A, (c) A true but R false, (d) A false but R true. Try each problem first, then read the steps.
1. (I) Heavy rain fell in the hills for three days; (II) the river in the plains rose above the danger mark.
The rain came first, and runoff raises the river. The answer is A.
2. (I) Many farmers in the district shifted from paddy to pulses; (II) the state sharply raised the support price for pulses.
A better price for pulses explains the switch, and it comes first. The answer is B.
3. (I) The government cut the import duty on edible oil; (II) a bumper groundnut crop was harvested this year.
Neither causes the other, but each can lower oil prices on its own. The answer is C.
4. (I) Petrol prices rose this month; (II) a new cricket stadium opened in the city this month.
The two share only a month and have separate causes. The answer is D.
5. (I) Many schools in the district were closed; (II) several roads in the district were washed away.
A flood can explain both events at once. The answer is E.
6. (I) Sales of umbrellas went up; (II) sales of raincoats went up.
Neither purchase causes the other; the start of the rainy season explains both. The answer is E.
7. A: Iron objects rust faster near the sea. R: Salty, moist air speeds up rusting.
Both are true, and R tells us why A happens. The answer is (a).
8. A: The Sun appears to rise in the east. R: The Earth rotates from west to east.
Both are true, and the direction of rotation is exactly why the Sun appears in the east. The answer is (a).
9. A: In the northern hemisphere, days are longer in summer. R: The Moon revolves around the Earth.
Both are true, but day length depends on the tilt of the Earth's axis. The answer is (b).
10. A: Ice floats on water. R: Ice is denser than water.
A is true, but ice floats because it is less dense than water. The answer is (c).
11. A: Sound travels faster than light. R: Sound needs a medium to travel.
A is false, since light is far faster. R is true, so the answer is (d).
12. A: For the same rate and a period of one year or more, compound interest is never less than simple interest. R: In compound interest, interest is also earned on earlier interest.
Both are true, and interest on interest is the reason compound interest cannot fall behind. The answer is (a).
Quick revision
- A cause comes first and has a believable way of producing its effect.
- Five links: I causes II, II causes I, independent causes, effects of independent causes, effects of a common cause.
- Events that rise together may share a hidden third cause.
- Do not assume the first-printed event is the cause.
- Assertion-reason: judge A, then R, then test "A because R".
- Two true but unrelated facts give "both true, R does not explain A".
- A true reason never rescues a false assertion.