BPSC AEDO · Module 24 · standard depth · 10 min
Panchayats at work: Gram Sabha, elections, PESA and the problems of devolution
What BPSC AEDO asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Paper 2: General Studies · Polity and economy of India; major changes in the economy of Bihar after independence
BPSC AEDO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for BPSC AEDO. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: from paper to practice
The 73rd Amendment created the framework: three tiers, regular elections, reservation and a Finance Commission. A framework, though, is only a skeleton. Whether a Panchayat actually fixes the village road depends on the powers, money and staff it gets, and on how alert the villagers are.
Scholars such as Nirmal Mukherjee and Balveer Arora call Panchayats a third layer of federalism, added below the Centre and the States. The Panchayati Raj Ministry also describes India as having three tiers of government. This is a big claim, and this chapter tests it against how Panchayats really work.
We look at the Gram Sabha and the tiers, at elections and the courts, at PESA for tribal areas, at the tools of accountability, and finally at the problems that still hold Panchayats back.
The Gram Sabha and the work of each tier
The Gram Sabha in practice. State laws give the Gram Sabha several jobs:
- Discussing the annual statement of accounts, administration reports and audit.
- Selecting beneficiaries of anti-poverty programmes.
- Vetting and monitoring development plans before and during their implementation.
A few States go further and let the Gram Sabha approve the Panchayat budget. Every elected representative is answerable to it, so its strength largely decides whether the system succeeds.
The Gram Panchayat. Its obligatory functions include safe drinking water and the upkeep of public wells, ponds, dispensaries and schools. It now also handles development work such as minor irrigation, rural electrification, cottage and small industries and poverty alleviation programmes.
The Panchayat Samiti. The block-level body supplies improved seeds and fertilisers, maintains schools, hospitals and roads, runs anti-poverty programmes and supervises the Gram Panchayats.
The Zila Parishad. It is the apex body. It approves budgets, coordinates the Samitis, runs educational and irrigation schemes and programmes for weaker sections, and prepares an annual district plan built up from block and village plans.
How office-bearers are chosen. In most States the heads of Gram Panchayats are elected directly, while those of the intermediate and district tiers are elected indirectly by members. A few States use direct election at all tiers.
Elections, the courts and the two-child norm
The State Election Commission at work. The SEC has the exclusive task of superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and the conduct of all Panchayat elections. It also allots symbols, issues voter identity cards and deals with qualifications and disqualifications. It does not conduct elections to the State Legislature, which remain with the Election Commission of India.
When States delay elections. Even after 1993, many States did not hold Panchayat elections on time. In Rural Litigation and Entitlement Kendra v Government of UP (1995), the Supreme Court held that the provisions on elections and the five-year duration are mandatory. States may hold back elections only for genuine supervening difficulties, such as floods, earthquakes or a grave emergency.
The two-child norm. Some States added a disqualification: a person with more than two children cannot contest or hold a Panchayat post. Rajasthan began it in 1992, and States such as Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and Odisha followed. The stated aim was population control, with leaders serving as role models.
The court and the critics. In Javed v State of Haryana (2003), the Supreme Court upheld the norm as neither arbitrary nor discriminatory and in line with population policy. Critics, however, pointed to studies showing it hit women, SCs and STs hardest, encouraged sex-selective abortion and the abandonment of girl children, and clashed with the National Population Policy, 2000, which rejected coercion. After campaigns, Himachal Pradesh withdrew the norm in April 2005.
PESA: self-rule for tribal areas
Why a separate law? Part IX did not automatically apply to the Scheduled Areas under the Fifth Schedule, where tribal communities live by their own customs. Applying the ordinary Panchayat model there could have overridden traditional village institutions. So Parliament passed a special law.
The Act. The Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA) came into force on 24 December 1996. It extends Panchayats to Fifth Schedule areas with changes suited to tribal life. States had to make their own laws in line with it within one year.
Its spirit. PESA aims to let tribal society control its own destiny and to protect its traditional rights over natural resources. It makes the Gram Sabha the centre of power, with wide authority to decide matters that affect it directly.
Powers given to the Gram Sabha include:
- Control over minor forest produce.
- A say before land acquisition in the area.
- Certifying works done in the village, which makes it a tool for social audit.
Keeping Panchayats honest: audit, social audit and RTI
Audit (Article 243J). The Constitution lets the State Legislature provide for the maintenance and audit of Panchayat accounts. Some States have used this to require that accounts be placed before the Gram Sabha. This makes the Panchayat answerable directly to the people of the village.
Social audit. A social audit means sharing with citizens the details of the money and other resources used for development work, and letting them check it. It involves collecting records, organising beneficiaries and examining the information together. The Gram Sabha thus becomes a watchdog over its own Panchayat.
Civil society leads. The Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS), under its campaign "Hamara Paisa, Hamara Hisaab" (our money, our accounts), held public hearings called Jan Sunwai. Government records on schools and public works were read aloud, and villagers pointed out gaps. This also spread awareness of the right to information.
The Right to Information Act, 2005. RTI lets citizens demand records that show how public money was used. Combined with social audit in the Gram Sabha, it can make sure that the spirit of the 73rd Amendment, people's say in their own governance, is real.
What still holds Panchayats back
1. A weak Gram Sabha. The Constitution does not list the Gram Sabha's powers, so many State laws make it a rubber stamp for the Panchayat's decisions. The Chief Ministers' Conference of August 1997 said it should be able to sanction benefits in open meetings, decide matters such as the location of hand pumps, and manage local natural resources.
2. Bureaucratic control. State laws give officials wide powers to suspend and dismiss elected Panchayat members. Panchayats need repeated technical and financial sanctions from block offices. This puts elected heads below even middle-level officials and encourages corruption.
3. The three Fs. Real self-government needs funds, functions and functionaries:
- Functions: States have transferred only part of the 29 subjects.
- Funds: State Finance Commissions have reported, but few States have implemented their recommendations.
- Functionaries: even where health or education is transferred, Panchayats have little control over the staff and budget.
Among the States, Kerala stands out for real devolution.
4. Proxy leadership. Many women members have acted as proxies of male relatives. Yet reservation has raised women's confidence, and in many places they now lead effectively. They need training in planning, budgets and audit to use their power fully.
5. Parallel bodies. Single-purpose committees such as Joint Forest Management Committees, Village Education Committees and Water User Groups are often nominated rather than elected. They overlap with Panchayats and confuse jurisdiction, which can weaken Panchayats. Similarly, MPLADS money is spent through the Collector, not through Panchayats.
Quick revision
- Panchayats are called the third layer of federalism (Mukherjee, Arora).
- Gram Sabha discusses accounts, selects beneficiaries and vets plans; some States let it approve the budget.
- SEC runs Panchayat elections, symbols, rolls and ID cards, but not Assembly polls.
- RLEK v UP (1995): Panchayat elections and the five-year term are mandatory.
- Two-child norm: Rajasthan 1992; upheld in Javed (2003); withdrawn by Himachal Pradesh April 2005.
- PESA: in force 24 December 1996; Fifth Schedule areas; Gram Sabha powers over minor forest produce, land acquisition and certification of works.
- 243J audit; social audit by MKSS (Jan Sunwai); RTI 2005.
- CM Conference, August 1997: empower the Gram Sabha.
- Problems: weak Gram Sabha, bureaucratic control, the three Fs, proxy leadership, parallel bodies, MPLADS through Collectors; Kerala stands out.