BPSC AEDO · Module 21 · standard depth · 12 min
Judicial review, judicial activism and the reform of justice
What BPSC AEDO asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Paper 2: General Studies · Polity and economy of India; major changes in the economy of Bihar after independence
BPSC AEDO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for BPSC AEDO. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: who checks the rule-makers?
Imagine a school where the student council makes rules for the canteen. The school also has a rulebook, written by the founders, which says every student has the right to drinking water. If the council makes a rule that only paying students may drink water, someone must be able to say: this rule breaks the rulebook, so it cannot stand.
In a country, the Constitution is that rulebook, and Parliament and the government are the rule-makers. Judicial review is the power of courts to check whether a law or an action of the government fits the Constitution, and to strike it down if it does not.
This chapter explains where this power comes from, how it grew through a long contest between Parliament and the courts, how courts used it actively to help the poor, and why the justice system still struggles with delays.
Where judicial review comes from
The basic logic. Judicial review rests on two ideas. First, the Constitution is a law, not just a statement of ideals. Second, it is a higher law, above the laws made by the legislature that the Constitution itself created. So when the two conflict, the Constitution must win, and courts are the ones who decide.
Three countries, three answers.
| Country | Position |
|---|---|
| England | No written constitution; Parliament is sovereign. Courts cannot strike down Acts of Parliament, but they can review executive action. |
| USA | The judiciary assumed the power to examine laws and executive action through the doctrine of due process. |
| India | The power to declare laws invalid is expressly written into the Constitution. |
India's strong foundation. In India, Fundamental Rights are justiciable, which means a person can go to court to enforce them. The right to constitutional remedies under Article 32 is itself a Fundamental Right. Judicial review extends to ordinary laws, executive actions and even constitutional amendments.
The great contest over amendments
The riddle. Article 13 says the State shall not make any law that takes away or abridges Fundamental Rights, and any such law is void. Article 368 allows Parliament to amend the Constitution. So can Parliament amend Fundamental Rights? It depends on whether an amendment counts as a "law" under Article 13. This riddle troubled the courts for about two decades.
Stage 1: amendments are not "law". In the early years, courts held that a constitutional amendment is not a law under Article 13. So an amendment could not be struck down for violating Fundamental Rights.
Stage 2: Golak Nath, 1967. The Supreme Court reversed this view. It held that an amendment is a law, and can be struck down if it violates Fundamental Rights. But declaring all past amendments void would have unsettled countless transactions. So the Court kept past amendments valid and applied its ruling only to the future. This technique is called prospective overruling.
Stage 3: Parliament strikes back. Around 1970, the Court struck down measures such as the abolition of privy purses and bank nationalisation. After winning a two-thirds majority in the 1971 elections, the government moved to assert Parliament's supremacy. The 25th Amendment (1972) said that laws giving effect to certain Directive Principles could not be challenged for violating Fundamental Rights, and no court could question such a declaration.
Stage 4: Kesavananda Bharati, 1973. In this landmark case, also called the Fundamental Rights case, the Court gave a middle answer:
- Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution, including Fundamental Rights;
- but it cannot alter the basic structure or framework of the Constitution. The Court struck down the second part of Article 31C, which barred courts from questioning a declaration that a law implemented Article 39(b) and (c), because it took away judicial review.
The basic structure at work
After 1973, the basic structure doctrine became the main test for constitutional amendments. Two cases show how it was used.
The 39th Amendment. This amendment created a separate procedure for challenging the election of a person holding the office of Prime Minister. Such an election could be challenged only before an authority set up by a special law, and the validity of that law could not be questioned. The Supreme Court held this invalid. It reasoned that free and fair elections are essential to democracy, and shielding one candidate's election from judicial scrutiny goes against the democratic ideal at the base of the Constitution.
Minerva Mills, 1980. The 42nd Amendment (1976) had added clauses to Article 368 declaring that no constitutional amendment could be questioned in any court, and that Parliament's amending power had no limits. In Minerva Mills, the Court struck these clauses down. It held that judicial review is itself a basic feature of the Constitution, so Parliament cannot remove it.
Where things stand. It is now well established that judicial review is part of the basic structure. Parliament has wide power to amend, but the courts remain the final judges of whether an amendment crosses that line.
Judicial activism and public interest litigation
The old barrier: locus standi. Traditionally, only a person who was personally harmed by a law or action could go to court. This rule is called locus standi. It meant that the poorest people, who often did not know their rights or could not afford a lawyer, were left out.
Opening the door. From the late 1970s, the Supreme Court began to take an active role, often called judicial activism, to protect the rights of the disadvantaged.
- In 1979, the Court heard a case filed not by the affected persons but by others on their behalf, because it involved the public interest.
- In 1982, in a case about the rights of construction workers for the Asian Games, the Court allowed the People's Union for Democratic Rights to bring public interest litigation (PIL).
- Drawing on the idea of epistolary jurisdiction, the Court said that any public-spirited person or organisation could move the court, even by writing a letter.
What PIL covers. In 1988, the Supreme Court listed the kinds of matters it would hear as PIL. They included bonded labour, neglected children, petitions from prisoners, complaints against the police, atrocities on women, children, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, the environment, adulteration of food and drugs, and heritage.
The double edge. PIL greatly widened access to justice and brought relief in matters such as the environment and the rights of workers and prisoners. But the resulting flood of petitions has added to the burden on courts that were already overloaded.
Justice delayed: pendency and reform
The scale of the problem. The biggest criticism of the justice system is the huge number of pending cases and long delays.
- In the early 1990s, more than two crore cases were pending in courts across the country.
- In August 2010, Chief Justice S.H. Kapadia pointed out that over one crore cases had been pending for more than a year.
Why cases pile up.
- Structural and procedural flaws in the judiciary.
- Multiple levels of appeal, which dishonest litigants can misuse to delay a final decision.
- Cumbersome procedures and the high cost of justice.
- Vacancies in judges' posts at every level.
An overloaded top court. Reform proposals have pointed out that the Supreme Court of India was taking up nearly one lakh cases a year, while the US Supreme Court accepts only about 100 to 150 of some five thousand filed. Suggestions have included a separate Constitutional Court and Zonal Courts of Appeal.
Why delay matters. As the saying goes, justice delayed is justice denied. Long delays hurt the poor most, encourage people to settle disputes outside the law, and weaken trust in courts. Lok Adalats, filling vacancies and simpler procedure are all part of the answer.
Why judicial review takes this shape
| Idea | Why it exists | Concern |
|---|---|---|
| Express judicial review | A written Constitution needs a guardian | Unelected judges overruling elected bodies |
| Prospective overruling | Avoid chaos from undoing past actions | Courts acting like legislators |
| Basic structure | Stop a passing majority from destroying the Constitution's core | Not written in the text; its limits are set by judges |
| PIL | Bring justice to those who cannot reach courts | Overload and misuse; risk of judicial overreach |
The underlying balance. Judicial review protects the Constitution from the majority of the day. But judges are not elected, so they must use this power with restraint, leaving policy choices to Parliament and the government wherever the Constitution allows.
Quick revision
- Judicial review: courts test laws and actions against the Constitution; express in India, assumed in the USA, limited to executive action in the UK.
- Article 13 vs Article 368: is an amendment a "law"? Early answer: no.
- Golak Nath 1967: amendments are law; Fundamental Rights cannot be abridged; prospective overruling.
- 25th Amendment 1972: protected laws implementing certain Directive Principles.
- Kesavananda 1973: Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights but not the basic structure; second part of Article 31C struck down.
- 39th Amendment clause on the PM's election held invalid; Minerva Mills 1980 struck down the 42nd Amendment's bar on review.
- PIL: locus standi relaxed from the late 1970s; 1982 PUDR Asian Games case; letters accepted; 1988 list of PIL matters.
- Pendency: over two crore cases in the early 1990s; over one crore pending for more than a year in 2010.