BPSC AEDO course‹› 0:00 studied

BPSC AEDO · Module 25 · standard depth · 9 min

Public Service Commissions: UPSC, State PSCs and the merit system

What BPSC AEDO asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 2: General Studies · Polity and economy of India; major changes in the economy of Bihar after independence

BPSC AEDO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for BPSC AEDO. 9 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: why a commission picks civil servants

Imagine if every minister could hire officers of their choice. Jobs would go to relatives and party workers, and every change of government would bring a new set of officials. The administration would lose both competence and continuity.

The answer is the merit system: recruitment through open competition, judged on ability alone. To make it credible, recruitment was taken away from the executive and given to a separate, extra-departmental body, the Public Service Commission, with constitutional status.

Why a commission and not a department? In a commission, a group of experts decides together. Individual biases tend to cancel out, professional criteria get due weight, and the rigid routine of government departments is avoided. Note one key point from the start: the Commission recruits and recommends, but the government appoints.

History and constitutional basis

Colonial roots. The Government of India Act, 1919 first provided for a Public Service Commission. Strongly backed by the Lee Commission, a Central Public Service Commission was set up in 1926. On the Simon Commission's recommendation it became the Federal Public Service Commission in 1937, and it kept that name till 1950.

Three kinds of Public Service Commission

After the Constitution. When the Constitution came into force in 1950, the body was renamed the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC). Articles 315 to 323 now deal with Public Service Commissions.

Three kinds of Commissions (Article 315):

Commission Serves
Union Public Service Commission Services of the Union
State Public Service Commission Services of a State
Joint Public Service Commission Two or more States that agree to share one

Why constitutional status? When the Commission's composition, appointment, removal and functions are fixed in the Constitution, the executive has no discretion over them. Constitutional status is thus a safeguard against encroachment on the Commission's authority and independence.

The UPSC: composition and functions

Composition. The UPSC has a Chairperson and other members, all appointed by the President. The Constitution does not fix the number; the President decides it. When it began in 1950, the UPSC had four members including the Chairperson.

From 1919 to the UPSC

The experience rule. At least half of the members must be persons who, when appointed, had held office for at least ten years under the Government of India or a State government. This brings administrative experience into the Commission, while the rest can come from other fields.

When must it be consulted? The Commission advises the government on:

When the UPSC must be consulted
  1. Methods of recruitment to civil services and posts.
  2. Principles for appointments, promotions and transfers, and the suitability of candidates.
  3. All disciplinary matters affecting a civil servant, including petitions.
  4. Claims that a civil servant's legal costs for defending official acts should be paid from the Consolidated Fund.
  5. Any other matter the President refers to it.

Extra powers. Parliament can extend the UPSC's functions by law, for example to the services of local or autonomous bodies. The President may make regulations on reservation in appointments, and may consult the Commission on other matters too.

Recruiting for the States too. The UPSC recruits officers of the All India Services such as the IAS and IPS. They are allotted to State cadres, work under the joint control of the Centre and the State, and move between the two. This gives every State a minimum, uniform level of administrative talent.

Why only advice? The advisory role

Advice, not orders. The Commission's views are advice. The government is not bound to accept them.

Advice, not orders: the annual report check

The reasoning. In a parliamentary system, the Cabinet is responsible to the Legislature for running the administration. It cannot hand that responsibility to another body by binding itself to its opinion. If the Commission's decisions were binding, there would in effect be two governments.

The safeguard. To stop governments from ignoring advice casually, the Commission presents an annual report: the UPSC to the President, and a State PSC to the Governor. The report records cases where its advice was not accepted, and it is placed before Parliament or the State Legislature along with the government's reasons. Public scrutiny makes rejection costly, and in practice such cases have been very few.

State Public Service Commissions and their independence

Composition. The Governor decides the number of members of a State PSC and appoints them. As with the UPSC, at least half must have ten years of government service. Members serve a six-year term, subject to an age limit.

Recruits, recommends, government appoints

A deliberate split. The Governor appoints members, but only the President can remove them. Separating the appointing and removing authorities is a check against misuse of power by the State government.

Other safeguards of independence:

  • Removal only in the manner and on the grounds laid down in the Constitution.
  • Salary and conditions of service cannot be changed to a member's disadvantage after appointment.
  • Expenses are charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State, so they are not voted on.
  • After leaving office, members cannot take other government jobs, except in Public Service Commissions.

These rules keep members beyond the reach of both the lure of future office and the threat of insecurity.

Safeguards for a State PSC

Functions. The State PSC conducts examinations for State services, advises on recruitment, promotions and discipline, takes on extra functions given by a State law, and reports annually to the Governor.

How State recruitment works. The PSC advertises vacancies, holds a written examination and a personality test, and sends a merit list to the government. The government then issues appointment letters. State services fill the middle levels of administration, below the All India Services.

How Commissions are bypassed in practice

Patronage finds a way. Despite the safeguards, governments are often able to have their way in appointments. The common methods are:

How Commissions are bypassed
  1. Ad hoc appointments made without consulting the Commission, then renewed again and again. The appointee gains experience, and the Commission faces a fait accompli.
  2. Excluding posts from the Commission's purview, including some higher posts, sometimes without consulting it.
  3. Advertisements drafted by departments to suit particular candidates, which the Commission cannot change.
  4. Revising terms or the merit list after selection without consulting the Commission.
  5. Delays in appointment letters, which make the best candidates take other jobs and raise suspicion.

Problems of membership. In some States, members have been appointed for party or political affiliation rather than merit, and may feel beholden to their patrons. The intended balance between official and non-official members is often missing. Professions such as teaching, law, engineering, science and medicine are poorly represented.

Why this matters. When recruitment is compromised, the merit system weakens, and with it the neutrality and continuity of the civil service. Public trust in recruitment exams, which millions of aspirants depend on, also suffers.

Quick revision

  • 1919 Act provided for a PSC; Lee Commission; Central PSC 1926; Federal PSC 1937; UPSC 1950.
  • Article 315: UPSC, State PSC, Joint PSC (for two or more States).
  • UPSC: members appointed by the President, who fixes the number; half with ten years of government service; began with four members.
  • Consulted on recruitment methods, appointment and promotion principles, discipline, legal-cost claims; advice not binding.
  • Advisory because the Cabinet is responsible to the Legislature (else "two governments").
  • Annual report with rejected advice: UPSC to President, State PSC to Governor; laid before the legislature with reasons.
  • State PSC: Governor appoints, President removes; six-year term subject to an age limit.
  • Safeguards: no change to disadvantage, expenses charged, no later government office except in PSCs.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 9 answered

  1. The Central Public Service Commission was first set up in:

  2. Article 315 provides for how many types of Public Service Commission?

  3. About UPSC members: 1. They are appointed by the President. 2. The President fixes their number. 3. At least half must have held office for ten years under a government. Which are correct?

  4. The advice of the UPSC to the government is:

  5. Why is the PSC's advice kept non-binding?

  6. A State PSC's annual report is presented to:

  7. Members of a State Public Service Commission can be removed by:

  8. Which is NOT a safeguard of PSC independence?

  9. Which practice is commonly used to bypass PSCs?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'Public Service Commissions are guardians of the merit system, but their effectiveness depends on governments.' Discuss. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Merit system; why a commission and not a department
    • Article 315; UPSC/SPSC appointment and removal
    • Consultation areas; advisory nature and 'two governments' logic
    • Safeguards of independence
    • Bypassing: ad hoc posts, exclusions, delays, political appointees
    • Way forward: time-bound recruitment, merit-based appointment of members

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

When was the Public Service Commission first set up in India?

A Central Public Service Commission was set up in 1926, following the Government of India Act 1919 and the Lee Commission. It became the Federal PSC in 1937 and the UPSC in 1950.

Is UPSC's advice binding on the government?

No. Under parliamentary government the Cabinet answers to the legislature and cannot bind itself to another body, so the Commission only advises.

Who appoints members of a State Public Service Commission?

The Governor of the State. UPSC members are appointed by the President.

To whom does UPSC submit its annual report?

To the President, who lays it before Parliament with reasons for any advice not accepted. A State PSC reports to the Governor.