BPSC ASO course‹› 0:00 studied

BPSC ASO · Module 67 · standard depth · 15 min

Critical reasoning: strengthen, weaken, assumption, flaw

What BPSC ASO asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Preliminary: General Knowledge (General Studies 50, General Science and Mathematics 50, Mental Ability 50) · Mental ability: analogies, similarities and differences, spatial visualisation and configuration, problem solving, analysis, visual memory, odd one out, observation, relationship concepts, arithmetic reasoning, verbal and non-verbal classification, number and non-verbal series, coding and decoding
  • Mains Paper 2: General Knowledge (General Studies 50, General Science and Mathematics 50, Mental Ability 50) · Mental ability: analogies, similarities and differences, spatial visualisation and configuration, problem solving, analysis, visual memory, odd one out, observation, relationship concepts, arithmetic reasoning, verbal and non-verbal classification, number and non-verbal series, coding and decoding

BPSC ASO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for BPSC ASO. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: is the reason good enough?

A town installs streetlights on all its main roads. A year later, night-time thefts have fallen by half, and the council says, "So streetlights reduce theft." It sounds convincing, but a careful reader asks one more question: what else changed that year?

Streetlights and theft: what else changed?

If the town also hired many more police officers that year, the fall in theft may have little to do with the lights. If nearby towns without new lights saw no fall, the claim becomes much stronger. Critical reasoning is the skill of asking such questions about any argument.

Why it matters. Proposals in government always come with reasons. Some reasons are solid, and some rest on a hidden assumption or a mistaken link. An officer who can test arguments quickly spends public money better.

What this chapter does. We learn to find the conclusion, to strengthen and weaken an argument, to spot its necessary assumption, and to name common flaws. We end with inference and paradox questions, which test the same skills from another angle.

Finding the conclusion, then strengthening and weakening

Find the conclusion first. The conclusion is the claim the speaker wants you to accept. It often follows words such as "so", "therefore", "hence" and "thus", or comes after "this shows that". Everything else is a premise offered in support.

Premises, link and conclusion

Find the link. Between the premises and the conclusion lies a gap that the speaker fills with an unstated link. In the streetlight case, the link is "nothing else caused the fall in theft". Strengthen and weaken questions are almost always about this link.

Strengthening. A strengthening option makes the link more likely. It may rule out another cause, show a comparison group that did not change, or show that more of the cause brings more of the effect. "Towns without new lights saw no fall in theft" is a classic strengthener.

Weakening. A weakening option makes the link less likely. It may offer another cause, such as more police, show a counter-example, or show that the data came from a biased sample. It does not have to prove the conclusion false; it only has to make it less believable.

Why it matters. Most real claims are about causes. Knowing how to test the link between "we did X" and "Y happened" is the core of evaluating any scheme.

The necessary assumption

What it is. A necessary assumption is a belief the argument cannot do without. If it were false, the conclusion would no longer follow. It is usually modest, not sweeping.

The negation test again. Take each option, turn it into its opposite, and ask whether the argument collapses. "A district will give free bicycles to girls in Class 9 to cut dropouts" depends on "distance to school is one reason some girls drop out". Negate it to "distance plays no part in dropouts", and the plan loses its point.

Why sweeping options fail. "All girls want bicycles" is not necessary; the plan can work if many girls use them. "Bicycles are the cheapest form of transport" is also not needed. Sweeping options are usually sufficient to help the argument, but not necessary for it.

Assumption versus strengthener. A strengthener adds support, while an assumption is required. Many options strengthen without being required. Use the negation test to tell them apart.

Why it matters. Every scheme rests on such assumptions, and when one is false the scheme fails quietly. Officers who name the key assumption early can check it before money is spent.

Naming the flaw

Correlation taken as cause. "Most toppers in our state studied in Hindi medium, so Hindi medium makes toppers" ignores that most students in the state study in Hindi medium. Two things appearing together do not show that one causes the other. Look for a missing comparison or a third factor.

Five common flaws

Attacking the person. "Ravi says the new tax is bad, but he failed economics, so the tax must be good" judges the speaker, not the claim. A weak speaker can make a strong point. The flaw is the shift from the argument to the person.

Small or biased sample. "Ten people at the bus stand liked the new timetable, so the city likes it" uses a tiny and unrepresentative group. Bus users at one stand may differ from the rest of the city. Ask who was counted and who was left out.

False choice and circular reasoning. "Either we close all liquor shops or crime will keep rising" offers only two options when others exist. "This scheme is the best because no scheme is better" repeats the conclusion as its own reason. Both are common flaw options.

Why it matters. Naming a flaw makes it easier to answer it in a meeting or a file note. These five patterns cover most faulty reasoning in public debate.

Inference and paradox questions

Inference. An inference question asks what must be true if the passage is true. "All trains to Patna stop at Gaya; the 6 am express does not stop at Gaya" gives "the 6 am express does not go to Patna". The right option stays close to the text and uses no outside facts.

Choosing among inferences. Wrong options often go a step too far, add a cause, or use an extreme word. If no option must be true, a "none of these" option may be correct. From "every committee member is a senior officer" and "some senior officers are on leave", nothing definite follows about committee members on leave.

Paradox. A paradox question gives two facts that seem to clash and asks which option explains both. "Hospital A has a higher death rate than hospital B, yet doctors send serious cases to A" seems odd. If A treats far more critically ill patients, both facts make sense.

The test for a paradox answer. The right option must keep both facts true, not deny one of them. An option that says "the death-rate data is wrong" removes the puzzle by cheating. Look for a new fact that fits both.

Why it matters. Data in government often looks contradictory at first. Finding the fact that reconciles it, instead of dismissing one side, is a mark of sound judgement.

Where and why this is asked

Why examiners test it. Officers constantly receive arguments: proposals from departments, claims from contractors, complaints from citizens. They must find the conclusion, see what it depends on and judge how strong it is. Critical reasoning questions test exactly that.

Where it shows up. The UPSC aptitude paper uses short-argument questions on assumptions, inferences and the logical conclusion of a passage almost every year. State aptitude papers use them as well, often in the comprehension section. The skills also help in Mains answers that must evaluate a policy.

When it goes wrong. The usual slips are picking an option that repeats a premise instead of addressing the link, choosing a sweeping option as the necessary assumption, and answering a paradox by denying one of the facts. Another is using outside knowledge to judge the conclusion.

The habit to build. Underline the conclusion, state the link in your own words, and then judge each option only by its effect on that link. For assumptions, apply the negation test to the two best options.

Practice set: twelve solved problems

Each problem gives a short argument, a question and four options. Try each problem first, then read the steps.

1. After a town put streetlights on all main roads, night thefts fell by half within a year, so streetlights reduce theft. Which option most strengthens this? (a) The town also hired more police that year; (b) in nearby towns without new lights, thefts did not fall; (c) streetlights use a lot of electricity; (d) most thefts happen in the daytime.

Option (b) rules out a region-wide fall in theft as the cause. The answer is (b).

2. After a town put streetlights on all main roads, night thefts fell by half within a year, so streetlights reduce theft. Which option most weakens this? (a) The town also hired many more police that year; (b) residents like the new lights; (c) the lights were made in India; (d) thefts were already rare in the daytime.

Option (a) offers another cause for the fall. The answer is (a).

3. A district will give free bicycles to girls in Class 9 to cut school dropouts. Which is a necessary assumption? (a) Distance to school is one reason some girls drop out; (b) all girls want bicycles; (c) boys never drop out; (d) bicycles are the cheapest transport.

Negate (a), and the plan has no point; the others are sweeping or irrelevant. The answer is (a).

4. Most toppers in our state studied in Hindi medium, so Hindi medium makes students toppers. What is the flaw? (a) It treats a correlation as a cause, ignoring that most students study in Hindi medium; (b) it attacks a person; (c) it uses circular reasoning; (d) it offers a false choice.

The claim jumps from "together" to "because" without a comparison. The answer is (a).

5. All trains to Patna stop at Gaya, and the 6 am express does not stop at Gaya. What must be true? (a) The 6 am express is late; (b) the 6 am express does not go to Patna; (c) no train stops at Gaya at 6 am; (d) all trains that stop at Gaya go to Patna.

If the express went to Patna, it would stop at Gaya. The answer is (b).

6. Sales of a new fertiliser doubled this year, so farmers are clearly satisfied with it. Which option most weakens this? (a) The fertiliser comes in larger bags; (b) farmers also bought more seeds; (c) this year the government gave a large subsidy on this fertiliser only; (d) the company has a new logo.

A subsidy can explain higher sales without any satisfaction. The answer is (c).

7. An office says its new yoga classes reduced sick leave. Which option most strengthens this? (a) Yoga is popular; (b) staff who attended took fewer sick days than staff of the same age who did not; (c) the classes are free; (d) sick leave rules were unchanged in other offices.

Option (b) compares like with like and links attendance to fewer sick days. The answer is (b).

8. We should build a flyover at this junction because jams here waste thousands of hours each week. Which is a necessary assumption? (a) Flyovers are always cheap; (b) the junction is the busiest in India; (c) a flyover will reduce the jams at this junction; (d) all drivers support flyovers.

Negate (c), and the reason for building it disappears. The answer is (c).

9. Ravi says the new tax is harmful, but Ravi failed his economics exam, so the tax must be good. What is the flaw? (a) Small sample; (b) it attacks the person instead of the argument; (c) false choice; (d) correlation taken as cause.

Ravi's exam result says nothing about the tax. The answer is (b).

10. Every member of the committee is a senior officer, and some senior officers are on leave. What must be true? (a) Some committee members are on leave; (b) no committee member is on leave; (c) every senior officer is on the committee; (d) none of these must be true.

The officers on leave may or may not be committee members. The answer is (d).

11. Reading scores in a district rose after new textbooks were introduced, so the textbooks improved reading. Which option most weakens this? (a) The new books have colour pictures; (b) this year's reading test was much easier than last year's; (c) teachers liked the books; (d) the books cost less.

An easier test can raise scores without better reading. The answer is (b).

12. Hospital A has a higher death rate than hospital B, yet doctors send serious cases to A. Which option best explains this? (a) Hospital A treats far more critically ill patients than B; (b) hospital B is newer; (c) the death-rate data is wrong; (d) hospital A has a larger car park.

Option (a) keeps both facts true and explains them. The answer is (a).

Quick revision

One-page summary box
  • Find the conclusion first, then state the link from premises to conclusion.
  • Strengtheners support the link: rule out other causes or show a comparison group.
  • Weakeners attack the link: another cause, a counter-example or a biased sample.
  • A necessary assumption is one whose negation breaks the argument.
  • Five common flaws: correlation as cause, attacking the person, poor sample, false choice, circular reasoning.
  • An inference must be true from the text alone, without outside facts.
  • A paradox answer keeps both facts true and explains them together.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 12 answered

  1. After a town put streetlights on all main roads, night thefts fell by half within a year, so streetlights reduce theft. Which option most strengthens this?

  2. After a town put streetlights on all main roads, night thefts fell by half within a year, so streetlights reduce theft. Which option most weakens this?

  3. A district will give free bicycles to girls in Class 9 to cut school dropouts. Which is a necessary assumption?

  4. Most toppers in our state studied in Hindi medium, so Hindi medium makes students toppers. What is the flaw?

  5. All trains to Patna stop at Gaya, and the 6 am express does not stop at Gaya. What must be true?

  6. Sales of a new fertiliser doubled this year, so farmers are clearly satisfied with it. Which option most weakens this?

  7. An office says its new yoga classes reduced sick leave. Which option most strengthens this?

  8. We should build a flyover at this junction because jams here waste thousands of hours each week. Which is a necessary assumption?

  9. Ravi says the new tax is harmful, but Ravi failed his economics exam, so the tax must be good. What is the flaw?

  10. Every member of the committee is a senior officer, and some senior officers are on leave. What must be true?

  11. Reading scores in a district rose after new textbooks were introduced, so the textbooks improved reading. Which option most weakens this?

  12. Hospital A has a higher death rate than hospital B, yet doctors send serious cases to A. Which option best explains this?

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What is a false cause flaw?

Assuming that because B followed A, A caused B.

What is an ad hominem flaw?

Attacking the person making the claim instead of the claim itself.

Does a strengthener have to prove the conclusion?

No. It only has to make the conclusion more likely.

What is a false dilemma?

Presenting only two options when more exist.