BPSC ASO course‹› 0:00 studied

BPSC ASO · Module 40 · standard depth · 18 min

Planning in India: from Five Year Plans to NITI Aayog

What BPSC ASO asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Preliminary: General Knowledge (General Studies 50, General Science and Mathematics 50, Mental Ability 50) · Geography, economic affairs, Indian agriculture and natural resources, five-year plans
  • Mains Paper 2: General Knowledge (General Studies 50, General Science and Mathematics 50, Mental Ability 50) · Geography, economic affairs, Indian agriculture and natural resources, five-year plans

BPSC ASO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for BPSC ASO. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: a family's five-year plan

Think of a farming family that sits down together and makes a plan for the next five years. First, save to dig a tube well, so the fields get water all year. Then buy a small tractor. In the last two years, save for the children's college.

A family's five-year plan

They cannot do everything at once, so they set priorities, fix targets, and decide how much to save and spend each year.

After independence in 1947, India faced the same kind of choice, but for a whole nation. The country was poor, with low farm output, few industries and little infrastructure. Leaders believed that a plan, made by the state, could direct scarce resources to the most important needs.

This chapter tells the story of planning in India: the Planning Commission, the Five Year Plans from 1951 to 2017, and the move to NITI Aayog in 2015.

The Planning Commission and the early plans

The Planning Commission. The Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 through a Cabinet Resolution. It prepared the Five Year Plans and decided how plan resources were used.

The first two plans

The First Plan (1951-56). MoSPI describes it as focused on agriculture, price stability, power and transport. It was based on the Harrod-Domar model, which links growth to savings and investment. Its growth target was 2.1%, and actual growth was 3.6%.

The Second Plan (1956-61). Also called the Mahalanobis Plan, it focused on rapid industrialisation through heavy and basic industries, such as steel, machinery and power. The idea was that heavy industries would build the base for all other industries. Its target was 4.5%, and actual growth was 4.3%.

Why this matters: these choices shaped India for decades. The First Plan's focus on farms responded to food shortages, while the Second Plan's push for heavy industry set up the large public sector.

Twelve plans and three breaks

Plan Years Plan Years
First 1951-56 Seventh 1985-90
Second 1956-61 Eighth 1992-97
Third 1961-66 Ninth 1997-2002
Fourth 1969-74 Tenth 2002-07
Fifth 1974-79 Eleventh 2007-12
Sixth 1980-85 Twelfth 2012-17

The breaks. MoSPI notes three gaps in the sequence:

Timeline of India's plans, 1951–2017
  • 1966-69: three Annual Plans, described as a "Plan holiday".
  • 1978-80: when the Janata Party came to power in 1978, the Fifth Plan was terminated, and a Rolling Plan followed.
  • 1990-91 and 1991-92: treated as Annual Plans, before the Eighth Plan began in 1992.

Why the breaks matter: each break came at a time of strain or political change. Plans needed stable resources and politics to work.

Targets and results

MoSPI gives the growth target and the actual growth for each plan.

Target vs achieved growth
Plan Target (%) Actual (%)
First 2.1 3.6
Second 4.5 4.3
Third 5.6 2.8
Fourth 5.7 3.3
Fifth 4.4 4.8
Sixth 5.2 5.7
Seventh 5.0 6.0
Eighth 5.6 6.8
Ninth 6.5 5.4
Tenth 8.0 7.6
Eleventh 9.0 8.0

The last two plans. The Eleventh Plan (2007-12) aimed at "Faster and More Inclusive Growth". The Twelfth Plan (2012-17) aimed at "Faster, Sustainable and More Inclusive Growth", with a target of 8% real GDP growth. MoSPI's chapter does not give its achieved growth.

Reading the table. The Third Plan fell furthest short of its target. The Eighth Plan, which followed the 1991 reforms, beat its target by the widest margin.

NITI Aayog: a new model

The change. On 1 January 2015, the government replaced the Planning Commission with a new institution, NITI Aayog (National Institution for Transforming India). The government said the new resolution replaced the March 1950 resolution that had set up the Planning Commission.

Planning Commission vs NITI Aayog

Structure:

  • Chairperson: the Prime Minister.
  • Governing Council: the Chief Ministers of all states and Lt Governors of Union Territories.
  • Vice-Chairperson: appointed by the Prime Minister.
  • Chief Executive Officer: appointed by the Prime Minister for a fixed tenure, in the rank of Secretary to the Government of India.

Its roles. The government describes NITI Aayog as the "Think Tank" of the government. Among its objectives are to foster cooperative federalism and to develop mechanisms to formulate credible plans at the village level and aggregate them progressively at higher levels of government. It also aims to design long-term policy frameworks and to monitor and evaluate programmes.

Why this matters: the Planning Commission worked from the top down. NITI Aayog is meant to work with states as partners and to build plans from the village up.

How planners thought about growth: savings and capital

Start with a tailor's savings. A tailor saves ₹10,000 and buys a second sewing machine, which lets her earn ₹2,500 more each year. The more she saves and the more each machine adds to her output, the faster her income grows. India's early planners thought about the whole country in much the same way.

Growth = investment ÷ ICOR

The basic idea. The Harrod-Domar model, used in the First Plan, links growth to two things: how much a country saves and invests, and how much extra output each unit of new capital produces. The second idea is often measured by the incremental capital-output ratio (ICOR), which is the amount of new investment needed to produce one more unit of output. In simple terms, the growth rate is roughly the investment rate divided by the ICOR.

A worked example. If India invests 30% of its GDP and the ICOR is 4, the economy can grow at about 30 ÷ 4 = 7.5% a year. If the ICOR rises to 5 because projects are delayed or capital is wasted, growth falls to about 6% with the same investment. So growth depends not only on how much is invested but on how efficiently it is used.

Why this shaped the Plans. Since poor countries save little, planners concluded that the state must raise savings and direct investment, especially into machines, steel and power. This logic led to the Second Plan's push for heavy industry and to a large public sector. It also explains why later reforms focused on using capital better, through competition and private investment.

The Mains angle. The ICOR is still a handy tool for judging any growth target. A good answer asks two questions about a target: can the country raise enough investment, and will that investment be used efficiently? Link this to planning targets in this chapter and to infrastructure finance in Building with private partners: EPC, BOT, HAM, TOT, InvITs and monetisation.

Two kinds of planning, and the Mahalanobis bet

Two ways to plan. In imperative planning, the state decides what each unit will produce, as in the former Soviet Union. In indicative planning, the state sets goals and uses budgets, taxes, credit and public investment to nudge private firms. The economist W. Arthur Lewis called this "planning through the market".

Command or nudge: two kinds of planning

What India chose, and why. India took a middle path: indicative planning for the private sector, with a large public sector holding the "commanding heights" such as steel, power and heavy machinery. Targets for farmers and private industry were really projections, because nobody could be ordered to meet them. After 1991, Indian planning became almost purely indicative.

Why planners felt the market alone would not do. At Independence, India saved too little to invest on the scale needed. It was dependent on other countries for food, machines, aid and technology, and private capital avoided long, risky projects. Planners also believed that growth left to the market would not reach the poor.

The Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata, founded by P. C. Mahalanobis
The Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata, founded by P. C. MahalanobisPhoto: Ravi Dwivedi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Mahalanobis bet. P.C. Mahalanobis, the architect of the Second Plan, argued that India should build capital goods first, the machines that make other machines. This meant slower consumption growth at first but faster growth later, and the public sector was to lead. Critics such as Vakil and Brahmananda argued instead for wage goods like food and cloth, which create jobs quickly.

Where the bet went wrong. The strategy assumed growth would trickle down, and it had no separate plan for jobs. It neglected food, and the gap in resources was filled by foreign borrowing. By the mid-1960s, food imports, trade deficits and dependence on aid led to the Plan holiday of 1966-69.

How the strategy changed, plan by plan

Why strategies kept shifting. Each Plan was a response to the failure or crisis left by the one before. Reading them in sequence shows how India's thinking moved from heavy industry to poverty, then to farm-led growth, and finally to markets.

What each Plan put first

After the Plan holiday. The Fourth Plan (1969-74) resumed with quicker-yielding projects and the new farm technology of the Green Revolution. The Fifth Plan (1974-79) put poverty removal forward and launched the Minimum Needs Programme for basic services such as rural roads, drinking water and primary schools. The Sixth Plan (1980-85) joined growth with direct attacks on poverty through IRDP and the National Rural Employment Programme (NREP).

Farm-led growth in the 1980s. The Seventh Plan (1985-90) stressed food, work and productivity and gave priority to farm output, an approach close to the old wage-goods idea. Growth in the 1980s was faster, but large fiscal deficits helped cause the crisis of 1991 (see The 1991 crisis and the LPG reforms).

Plans in a market economy. The Eighth Plan began in April 1992 after a two-year break and grew about 6.8%, above its target. The Ninth Plan (1997-2002) aimed at 6.5% but managed about 5.4%. The Tenth Plan (2002-07) set an 8% target and, for the first time, monitorable targets for social goals such as cutting poverty and getting all children into school.

The lesson for answers. Plans did best when the strategy fitted the main bottleneck of the time, such as food in the late 1960s. They did worst when resources fell short or when targets ignored jobs. This is why NITI Aayog now speaks of outcomes and indicators rather than outlays.

Why India planned, and why it stopped: when, where and why

Why plan at all (1950)? At Independence India was poor, with little industry, weak infrastructure and a farm sector at the mercy of the monsoon. Private capital was too small to build steel plants, dams and power grids on its own. So the government chose to direct investment through Five Year Plans, and set up the Planning Commission on 15 March 1950 by a Cabinet Resolution.

Why India planned, and why it stopped

Why the focus kept changing. Each Plan answered the problem of its time. The First Plan (1951-56) put farming, prices, power and transport first, using the Harrod-Domar model, while the Second turned to heavy industry. The sequence was also broken more than once, as in the Plan holiday of 1966-69 and the Annual Plans of 1990-92.

Why it was replaced (2015). The government's own reasons were that India had grown from an under-developed economy into an emergent global nation. A one-size-fits-all central plan could create needless tensions, and the states did not want to be mere appendages of the Centre. So the centre-to-state one-way flow of policy was to give way to a partnership with the states, with the government as an enabler rather than the provider of everything.

Implications. NITI Aayog is a think tank, not a body that hands out plan money, so its influence comes from ideas, data and cooperation with states. This shift mirrors the bigger change in India's economy, from a state-led model to one where markets play a larger role (see Economic systems: capitalist, socialist and mixed, and India's choice).

The first two Plans on the ground: steel, dams and a food gap

Business agreed, at first. It surprises many students that India's big industrialists backed a strong state role. Their own Bombay Plan of 1944 asked the government to build the costly core sectors, such as power, steel and transport, which private firms could not finance. So planning began with wide support from business, labour and political leaders.

What the First Plan built. The First Plan put its money into farms, irrigation and hydel power, and large multipurpose dams such as Bhakra-Nangal and Hirakud took shape. Savings and investment rose as a share of national income, and the public sector did most of the investing. This early success gave planners the confidence to aim much higher in the next Plan.

What the Second Plan built. Three public sector steel plants came up at Bhilai (with Soviet help), Rourkela (with West German help) and Durgapur (with British help). Coal, railways and heavy machinery also grew fast. But farming's share of plan money was cut, and food output lagged behind a fast-growing population.

The hidden costs. To fill the food gap, India imported American wheat on easy terms under PL-480, which made the country depend on foreign food aid. At the same time, the rule that private firms needed a government licence to start or expand a factory grew into the licence-permit raj. Both problems shaped the crises of the mid-1960s and the reforms that came much later.

Quick revision

  • The Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 by a Cabinet Resolution.
  • India had twelve Five Year Plans between 1951 and 2017.
  • The First Plan (1951-56) focused on agriculture, price stability, power and transport, used the Harrod-Domar model, and achieved 3.6% growth against a 2.1% target.
  • The Second Plan (1956-61), called the Mahalanobis Plan, pushed heavy and basic industries and achieved 4.3% against a 4.5% target.
  • The sequence broke for Annual Plans in 1966-69 (the "Plan holiday"), a Rolling Plan in 1978-80, and Annual Plans in 1990-92.
  • The Eleventh Plan (2007-12) targeted 9% and achieved 8%, and the Twelfth (2012-17) targeted 8%.
  • NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015 as a think tank, with the Prime Minister as Chairperson and a Governing Council of all Chief Ministers and Lt Governors.
  • The government replaced the Commission because India had changed, and a one-size-fits-all central plan no longer suited a partnership with the states.
  • Under the Harrod-Domar idea, growth ≈ investment rate ÷ ICOR; a higher ICOR means capital is used less efficiently.
  • Indicative planning (by inducement, 'planning through the market') vs imperative (by command); India indicative with strong public sector. Mahalanobis (2nd Plan): capital goods first; critics Vakil-Brahmananda (wage goods); flaws led to the 1966-69 Plan holiday.
  • Shifts: 4th quick projects; 5th poverty + Minimum Needs Programme; 6th IRDP, NREP; 7th food, work, productivity; 8th from April 1992 (~6.8%); 9th 5.4% vs 6.5%; 10th 8% + monitorable targets.

Common confusions and exam traps:

Revision card: planning in India
  • The Planning Commission was set up by a Cabinet Resolution, not by the Constitution or an Act of Parliament.
  • The Rolling Plan was 1978-80, not 1966-69.
  • The Second Plan, not the First, is the Mahalanobis Plan.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 9 answered

  1. The Planning Commission of India was set up in 1950 by:

  2. Which Five Year Plan is known as the Mahalanobis Plan?

  3. The 'Rolling Plan' in India operated during:

  4. Consider the following statements: 1. The Eleventh Plan targeted 9% growth and achieved 8%. 2. The First Plan was based on the Harrod-Domar model. 3. The Third Plan exceeded its growth target. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  5. Who is the Chairperson of NITI Aayog?

  6. Assertion (A): NITI Aayog has a Governing Council of all Chief Ministers and Lt Governors of Union Territories. Reason (R): One of NITI Aayog's objectives is to foster cooperative federalism.

  7. If an economy invests 28% of its GDP and its incremental capital-output ratio (ICOR) is 4, its approximate growth rate will be:

  8. Consider the following statements about planning in India: 1. India followed indicative planning, in which targets for the private sector were largely projections rather than commands. 2. The Mahalanobis strategy of the Second Plan gave priority to wage goods such as food and cloth. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  9. The Minimum Needs Programme was introduced in which Five Year Plan?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. Compare the Planning Commission and NITI Aayog. Has the shift from planning to a 'think tank' model strengthened cooperative federalism? (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Planning Commission: 15 Mar 1950, Cabinet Resolution; 12 Plans 1951-2017
    • Achievements and limits (targets vs actual)
    • NITI Aayog 1 Jan 2015: PM chair, Governing Council, think tank, village-level plans
    • Federalism angle: partnership vs top-down
    • Conclusion
  2. Why was the Planning Commission replaced by NITI Aayog in 2015? Has the change served its purpose? (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Planning Commission 15 March 1950; plans for a poor economy
    • 2015 reasons: emergent global nation; one-size-fits-all; states not appendages
    • Centre-to-state one-way flow to partnership; government as enabler
    • NITI as think tank with Governing Council of CMs
    • Assessment: influence through ideas, data and cooperation; no plan funds
  3. Trace how the strategy of Indian planning shifted from heavy industry to poverty alleviation and then to market-led growth. What lessons does this hold for NITI Aayog? (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Mahalanobis (2nd Plan): capital goods, public sector, trickle-down; flaws: jobs, food, foreign borrowing; Plan holiday 1966-69.
    • 4th-5th: quicker projects, Green Revolution, poverty removal, Minimum Needs Programme.
    • 6th-7th: IRDP, NREP; food, work and productivity; farm-led growth; fiscal strain to 1991.
    • 8th-10th: indicative planning in a market economy; 8th about 6.7%, 9th 5.4% vs 6.5%; 10th monitorable targets.
    • Lessons: fit strategy to the bottleneck, plan for jobs, track outcomes not outlays, cooperative federalism via NITI.

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

When was the Planning Commission set up?

The Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 through a Cabinet Resolution, not through the Constitution or a law.

How many Five Year Plans did India have?

India had twelve Five Year Plans from 1951 to 2017. The First Plan (1951-56) focused on agriculture and was based on the Harrod-Domar model.

What was the plan holiday?

Between 1966 and 1969, India had three Annual Plans instead of a Five Year Plan. This break is called the plan holiday.

Why was the Planning Commission replaced by NITI Aayog?

The government said India had changed into an emerging global economy and a one-size-fits-all plan no longer suited it. NITI Aayog, set up on 1 January 2015, acts as a think tank and promotes cooperative federalism.