BPSC CCE · Module 29 · Mains depth · 14 min
Justice in the States: High Courts, district courts and Lok Adalats
What BPSC CCE asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims: General Studies · Indian polity and economy, including Bihar
- Mains: General Studies II · Indian polity
BPSC CCE has asked 1 question from this chapter (2023); 14 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: where does an ordinary case begin?
Suppose a farmer in a village has a dispute with a neighbour over a strip of land. The farmer will not go to the Supreme Court in Delhi. The case will start in a local civil court in the district, which is close, cheap and knows local conditions.
If the farmer loses and believes the decision is wrong, they can appeal to a higher court: first the district court, then the High Court of the State, and only in rare cases the Supreme Court. This ladder of courts lets mistakes be corrected step by step.
India has one integrated judiciary. Unlike the United States, there are no separate federal and state court systems. The same ladder handles cases under both Union and State laws, with the Supreme Court at the top and the High Courts heading the judiciary in each State.
High Courts: one for each State, or shared
At the top of the State judiciary. The Constitution provides for a High Court at the head of the judiciary in each State. High Courts have constitutional status, because the Constitution itself provides for them.
Shared High Courts. Parliament can establish a common High Court for two or more States or for a State and a Union Territory. For example:
- Punjab and Haryana share one High Court.
- Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh share one High Court.
Union Territories. Parliament may extend a High Court's jurisdiction to a Union Territory, or create a separate High Court for it.
| Union Territory | High Court |
|---|---|
| Delhi | Its own High Court |
| Chandigarh | Punjab and Haryana |
| Puducherry | Madras |
| Lakshadweep | Kerala |
| Andaman and Nicobar Islands | Calcutta |
| Dadra and Nagar Haveli | Bombay |
Why share? Small States and territories may not have enough cases to justify a separate High Court. Sharing saves money and keeps experienced judges available, though people may have to travel farther.
High Court judges: appointment, tenure and transfer
How many judges? Unlike the Supreme Court, there is no fixed minimum number of judges for a High Court. The President fixes the number for each High Court from time to time.
Appointment. High Court judges are appointed under Articles 217 and 224.
- The Chief Justice of a High Court is appointed by the President after consulting the Chief Justice of India and the Governor of the State.
- For other judges, the High Court's Chief Justice is also consulted.
- Under the Memorandum of Procedure, proposals start with the High Court's Chief Justice along with the two senior-most judges, at least six months before a vacancy arises. They pass through the State and Union governments to the Supreme Court collegium for advice.
Additional judges. To clear a pile of pending cases, additional judges can be appointed for a period not exceeding two years.
Tenure and removal. A High Court judge holds office until the age of 62. A judge can resign, be appointed to the Supreme Court, or be transferred to another High Court. Removal follows the same procedure as for a Supreme Court judge.
Transfers. Under Article 222, the President may transfer a High Court judge after consulting the Chief Justice of India. Transfer proposals are initiated by the Chief Justice of India with the four senior-most Supreme Court judges.
Vacancies. The sanctioned strength of High Court judges rose from 906 in 2014 to 1,104 in 2022. Yet on 31 March 2022, only 717 judges were in position, leaving 387 posts vacant, which adds to delays.
What a High Court can do
Original jurisdiction. Some cases can start directly in a High Court, including:
- enforcement of Fundamental Rights;
- disputes about elections to Parliament and the State legislature; and
- certain revenue matters.
Appellate jurisdiction. In civil cases, the High Court may hear a first or second appeal. In criminal cases, it hears appeals from Sessions Judges, especially where long prison terms are given.
Powers beyond ordinary cases.
- Writs, wider than the Supreme Court. A High Court can issue writs not only to enforce Fundamental Rights but also ordinary legal rights. This makes its writ jurisdiction wider than the Supreme Court's under Article 32.
- Superintendence. It supervises all courts and tribunals in its area, except those dealing with the armed forces, and can frame rules and give directions for speedier justice.
- Transfer of cases. It can take up a case from a lower court if it involves interpreting the Constitution.
- Own staff. It appoints its own officers and servants, which protects it from government control.
District and subordinate courts
The base of the ladder. Below the High Court is a hierarchy that the Constitution calls subordinate courts. Since State laws create them, their names differ from State to State, but the structure is broadly the same.
- Each district has a district court, whose main job is to hear appeals from lower courts. It also hears some original matters under special laws, such as succession, guardianship and land acquisition.
- Below it are civil courts and magistrate courts of different classes.
- At the very bottom are panchayat courts, such as Nyaya Panchayats, which settle small local disputes.
Appointing district judges. The Governor appoints district judges in consultation with the High Court. A candidate must be an advocate or pleader of seven years' standing, or already in the service of the Union or the State.
Other judicial officers. The Governor appoints them under rules made after consulting the High Court and the State Public Service Commission.
Who controls them. The High Court, not the State government, controls the posting, promotion and leave of members of the State judicial service. This keeps lower judges free from political pressure, which matters because most citizens only ever meet these courts.
Lok Adalats: justice by settlement
What they are. Lok Adalats, or people's courts, settle disputes by agreement between the parties, instead of a full trial. They have statutory status under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987. Their members act as conciliators, helping parties reach a fair compromise.
Key features.
- No court fee is charged. If a case already pending in court is settled at a Lok Adalat, the court fee paid is refunded.
- The award is deemed a decree of a civil court. It is final and binding, and no appeal lies against it.
- A party that does not agree to a settlement can still pursue the case in the regular court.
- Matters involving non-compoundable offences, that is, crimes that cannot be settled by compromise, are excluded.
Permanent Lok Adalats. These are set up under Section 22-B of the Act. Their awards are final and binding, and they can handle matters up to Rs 10 lakh.
Why they matter. Courts face huge backlogs, and many disputes, such as motor accident claims or bank loan recoveries, can be settled quickly by agreement. Lok Adalats reduce the burden on courts and give people cheap, speedy justice.
Why the State judiciary is built this way
| Feature | Why it exists | Concern |
|---|---|---|
| Integrated judiciary | One ladder for Union and State laws; uniform justice | Top courts flooded with appeals |
| Shared High Courts | Saves cost for small States and UTs | Long distances for litigants |
| Wide writ power of High Courts | Relief close to home for any legal wrong | Heavy load on High Courts |
| High Court control of lower courts | Lower judges free from State government pressure | Supervision stretched thin |
| Lok Adalats | Quick, free settlement of suitable disputes | Pressure on weaker party to compromise |
The big idea. Justice must be both independent and close to the people. The State judiciary tries to do both, but vacancies and backlogs often stand in the way.
Mains lens: justice delayed in the lower courts
A common question: "For most citizens, the face of Indian justice is the district court." Examine the problems of the subordinate judiciary and suggest reforms.
Problems:
- Vacancies: even in High Courts, hundreds of sanctioned posts stay empty, as the 2022 figure of 387 vacancies shows, and the shortage is felt down the ladder.
- Backlog and delay: multiple levels of appeal let cases drag on for years.
- Cost and procedure: cumbersome procedures and fees keep the poor away from courts.
- Distance: shared High Courts and district headquarters can be far from villages.
What exists already:
- High Court control over postings and promotions protects lower judges' independence.
- Lok Adalats settle suitable disputes free of cost and finally.
- Panchayat-level courts bring small disputes close to people.
Reforms suggested: fill vacancies on time; use Lok Adalats and settlement more widely; simplify procedures; strengthen court infrastructure; and limit repeated appeals in minor matters. A balanced answer concludes that strengthening the base of the judicial pyramid is the surest way to reduce the load at the top.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Comparison: Compare the jurisdiction of High Courts and the Supreme Court in protecting rights.
- Supreme Court: Article 32, only Fundamental Rights, itself a Fundamental Right.
- High Court: writs for Fundamental Rights and ordinary legal rights.
- High Court's superintendence over lower courts and tribunals.
- Conclude that High Courts are often the nearest and widest door to justice.
2. Structure: "India has an integrated judiciary in a federal system." Explain.
- One ladder from panchayat courts to the Supreme Court for all laws.
- High Courts head the State judiciary; shared High Courts and UT jurisdiction.
- Appointments involve both Union and judiciary; control of lower courts by the High Court.
- Contrast with dual court systems elsewhere.
3. Analysis: Assess the role of Lok Adalats in reducing the burden on courts.
- Statutory basis in the 1987 Act; settlement by agreement.
- No fee, award final and binding, no appeal; exclusions.
- Benefits: speed, cost, relief to courts.
- Concerns: pressure on weaker parties; need for fair conciliation.
Quick revision
- India has an integrated judiciary: Supreme Court, High Courts, then district and subordinate courts.
- Parliament can create common High Courts (Punjab and Haryana; Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh) and extend jurisdiction to UTs.
- UTs: Delhi has its own; Chandigarh to Punjab and Haryana, Puducherry to Madras, Lakshadweep to Kerala, A&N to Calcutta, Dadra and Nagar Haveli to Bombay.
- High Court judges: no fixed minimum number; appointed under Articles 217 and 224; retire at 62; additional judges up to 2 years; transfer under Article 222.
- High Court writs cover Fundamental Rights and ordinary legal rights, wider than the Supreme Court.
- Superintendence over all courts and tribunals except armed forces tribunals.
- District judges: appointed by the Governor with the High Court; 7 years as advocate; the High Court controls postings and promotions.
- Lok Adalats: 1987 Act; no fee; award is a civil court decree, final, no appeal; Permanent Lok Adalats up to Rs 10 lakh.
BPSC CCE questions from this chapter
The authority to determine the number of Judges in a High Court rests with which of the following entities?
- (a) The President
- (b) The Chief Minister of the State
- (c) The Prime Minister
- (d) The Parliament
Show answer
(a) The President · our answer; official key awaited