BPSC CCE · Module 32 · Mains depth · 14 min
Urban local government: the 74th Amendment, Mayors, Commissioners and municipal money
What BPSC CCE asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims: General Studies · Indian polity and economy, including Bihar
- Mains: General Studies II · Indian polity
11 BPSC CCE questions in our bank come from this module (Local government).
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: why cities need their own government
A city is a huge crowd of people in a small space. Water must reach every tap, garbage must leave every street, and drains must carry the monsoon away. When any of this fails, thousands feel it within hours, so a city needs a government that is close, quick and specialised.
In law, an area becomes urban when it is formally declared so, by setting up a municipal body, a notified area or a cantonment. Municipal bodies are created under each State's Municipal Act, while cantonments are governed by central law.
Cities are under great pressure. Lack of jobs in villages pushes people into big cities, where population grows faster than roads, water supply, housing, drainage and transport. The result is slums and chronic shortages, and this is the problem that urban local government must solve.
From Madras 1687 to Ripon 1882
The first corporation. Urban local government in India is older than rural. Madras got the country's first Municipal Corporation in 1687. Corporations in other port cities followed.
Mayo and Ripon. Lord Mayo's Resolution of 1870 encouraged an elected president in municipalities. Lord Ripon's Resolution of 1882 gave urban local bodies their present form and structure, placing them on a sound organisational footing.
The colonial legacy. These bodies were set up by statute and worked with different degrees of success. Many features, such as State control and a strong appointed executive, still shape city government today.
The 74th Amendment: three bodies, wards and reservation
The Act. The 74th Amendment Act, 1992 added Part IXA and the Twelfth Schedule to the Constitution and came into force on 1 June 1993. Its aim was to make urban government more representative, accountable, efficient and transparent.
Five became three. Before the Amendment there were five types of urban bodies. The Amendment provides for three, and the State decides which type an area gets:
| Before (five types) | After the 74th Amendment | For which area |
|---|---|---|
| Municipal Corporation | Municipal Corporation | Larger urban areas |
| Municipal Council | Municipal Council | Smaller urban areas |
| Town Area and Notified Area Committees | Nagar Panchayat | Areas in transition from rural to urban |
| Cantonment Board | Remains under central law | Military areas with civil population |
Composition. Most members are elected from wards. State law may also add MPs and MLAs whose constituencies fall in the area, Rajya Sabha and Legislative Council members registered as voters there, and chairpersons of committees. Persons with special knowledge of municipal administration may be added, but without the right to vote.
Ward Committees (Article 243S). Every municipality with a population of three lakh or more must have Ward Committees. Two or more wards may be grouped together, and the State decides their composition. They bring city government closer to citizens.
Term, dissolution and elections. A municipality has a five-year term. If the State wants to dissolve it, the body must first get an opportunity of being heard, and fresh elections must follow within six months. A State Election Commission runs the elections.
Reservation. Seats are reserved for SCs and STs, and at least one-third for women. This mirrors the rule for Panchayats.
Functions, finance commissions and planning
The Twelfth Schedule (18 items). It lists what municipalities may be asked to do. Key items include:
- Urban planning, town planning and regulation of land use and buildings.
- Planning for economic and social development; roads and bridges.
- Water supply; public health, sanitation and solid waste management; fire services.
- Urban forestry and the environment; protection of weaker sections, including the disabled.
- Slum improvement; urban poverty alleviation; parks and playgrounds.
- Burial and cremation grounds; cattle pounds; registration of births and deaths; street lighting, parking and bus stops; regulation of slaughterhouses and tanneries.
Obligatory and discretionary. Municipal laws divide work into two kinds. Obligatory functions include drinking water, building and lighting streets, sewers, public hospitals, primary schools, registering births, naming streets and numbering houses. Discretionary ones include parks, libraries, museums, planting trees, housing for low-income groups and public exhibitions.
Money and planning. The State Finance Commission, set up every five years, also reviews municipal finances and recommends shares of State taxes and grants. The needs of municipalities are now considered by the Union Finance Commission as well, so federal transfers reach them. A District Planning Committee combines rural and urban plans, and Metropolitan Planning Committees are set up for metropolitan areas.
Bright and grey. The Amendment gave city government constitutional status, a five-year life, wider participation and regular funds. However, it did not fix municipal functions or sources of revenue, so States can still decide how much to give or take away.
Who runs a city: Mayor, Commissioner and committees
The Municipal Corporation. It is the top form of city government, found in large cities. It is created by a special Act of the State Legislature, or by Parliament in Union Territories. Some cities have their own Act, while in other States one law covers all Corporations.
The Mayor. The Mayor is the city's first citizen and presides over Corporation meetings. In many States the council elects the Mayor from among councillors, often for a short term, so the Mayor is largely ceremonial. In several other States, voters elect the Mayor directly, and the Mayor then holds executive powers, though their extent varies.
The Commissioner. The post was first created in 1888, on the idea that making policy and carrying it out should be separate. The Royal Commission on Decentralisation supported it in 1909. The Commissioner is the chief executive, appointed by the State government and usually an IAS officer, with wide powers over administration, finance and staff.
Committees. Corporations work through statutory committees, such as the standing, planning, health and education committees, and non-statutory ones such as transport. The Standing Committee is the most important, with executive, supervisory, financial and personnel powers.
The Mayor-in-Council model. The Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980 tried to give the elected wing real power:
- A cabinet-like Mayor-in-Council: the Mayor, Deputy Mayor and up to ten elected members, chosen by the Mayor and collectively responsible to the Corporation.
- A Chairman who presides over meetings like a Speaker.
- A Municipal Accounts Committee working like a Public Accounts Committee.
- Borough Committees as a second tier, with Ward Committees below.
- The Commissioner works under the Mayor's supervision.
This model now covers all Municipal Corporations in West Bengal.
Money, staff, development authorities and State control
No list of their own. Unlike the Union and the States, municipalities have no separate list of taxes in the Constitution. The State decides which taxes, fees and tolls they may levy and what grants they get.
Main sources of money:
- Tax revenue. Property tax, based on the rental value of land and buildings, is the largest source where there is no octroi. Others include taxes on professions and vehicles other than motor vehicles.
- Octroi. This was a tax on goods entering a city for use or sale, and gave 60 to 80% of revenue where it was levied. It was subsumed into GST from 1 July 2017, which hit municipal income.
- Non-tax revenue. Licence fees and user charges for water, parking, playgrounds and swimming pools.
- Grants. General-purpose grants for normal work and specific-purpose grants for things like education or road maintenance; they are often ad hoc.
- Borrowing. Under the Local Authorities Loans Act, 1914, for construction, relief, epidemics, land acquisition and repaying loans.
Weak own revenue. Own revenue of urban bodies is low, around 32% of their total revenue on an all-India average. The 14th Finance Commission tied performance grants to improving own revenue, which also builds autonomy and accountability.
Staff. Three personnel systems exist. In the integrated system, State and municipal staff are interchangeable. In the unified system, a State-wide municipal cadre moves between municipalities. In the separate system, each municipality hires its own staff, which is best for autonomy.
Development authorities. When cities spill beyond municipal limits, planned growth needs a body with more power and money. The Estimates Committee of the Fifth Lok Sabha recommended development authorities, and the Delhi Development Authority (1957) was the first. They prepare master and zonal plans and control land use, but often clash with municipal bodies.
State control. States create municipalities by law, fund them and lend them staff, so they also control them. The power of supersession was badly misused: by 1989, 39 of 73 Municipal Corporations had been superseded at different times. The 74th Amendment now limits a dissolved body to six months before fresh elections.
Mains lens: a landmark with an unfinished agenda
A common question: "The 74th Amendment is a landmark in urban governance, but its promise remains unfulfilled." Examine.
Why it is a landmark:
- First constitutional status for city government; a uniform set of three bodies.
- Five-year term, hearing before dissolution, elections within six months; an end to long supersessions.
- Reservation for SCs, STs and women; Ward Committees for citizen participation.
- Twelfth Schedule, State and Union Finance Commission support, and District and Metropolitan Planning Committees.
Why the promise is unfulfilled:
- Functions and revenue sources were not fixed; States still decide.
- Weak own revenue; loss of octroi after GST; ad hoc grants.
- Mayors are mostly ceremonial while State-appointed Commissioners run cities.
- Parallel bodies such as development authorities; staff shortages; poor capacity.
Way forward. Timely State Finance Commission reports and their implementation, better property tax collection and user charges, empowered and accountable Mayors, capacity building and, where needed, public-private partnership and market borrowing. A balanced answer ends by stressing that cities need both money and real power to match their growing burden.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Compare: Compare the Commissioner model and the Mayor-in-Council model of city government.
- Commissioner since 1888: separation of policy and execution; State-appointed.
- Kolkata 1980: cabinet-like council, collective responsibility, Chairman, accounts committee.
- Democratic control versus administrative efficiency.
2. Analysis: Why have Urban Development Authorities been criticised for weakening municipal bodies?
- Origin: Estimates Committee, DDA 1957.
- Planning and land-use control outside elected bodies.
- Coordination problems, overlapping jurisdiction.
3. Administration: Discuss the merits of integrated, unified and separate personnel systems for municipalities.
- Integrated: access to State officers, but weak local loyalty.
- Unified: specialisation and experience, but weaker local control.
- Separate: full autonomy, but small bodies cannot attract talent.
Quick revision
- Madras 1687: first Municipal Corporation. Mayo 1870, Ripon 1882.
- 74th Amendment: Part IXA, Twelfth Schedule (18 items); in force 1 June 1993.
- Three bodies: Nagar Panchayat (transitional), Municipal Council (smaller), Municipal Corporation (larger); the State decides.
- Ward Committees where population is three lakh or more (Article 243S).
- Five-year term; hearing before dissolution; elections within six months; SEC; at least one-third seats for women.
- SFC every five years; Union FC also considers municipal needs; DPC and Metropolitan Planning Committee.
- Commissioner since 1888; usually IAS. Mayor first citizen, often ceremonial; directly elected in several States.
- Kolkata Act 1980: Mayor-in-Council (Mayor, Deputy, up to ten members).
- Money: property tax; octroi (60–80%) into GST, 1 July 2017; grants; loans under the 1914 Act; own revenue about 32%.
- DDA 1957 first development authority. 1989: 39 of 73 corporations superseded.