Emergency provisions: National Emergency, President's Rule and Financial Emergency
What BPSC LDC asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
Paper 2: General Knowledge (General Studies, General Science and Mathematics, Mental Ability) · Constitution of India, polity, the country's political system, Panchayati Raj, community development
BPSC LDC questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to basic depth for BPSC LDC. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: a federal system with a crisis switch
Think of a building with separate flats, each running its own affairs. In a fire, though, one fire officer takes charge of the whole building, and normal rules pause. India's Constitution has a similar crisis switch.
Three kinds of emergency
In normal times, power is divided between the Union and the States. In an emergency, the Constitution lets the Union take far greater control, so that a federal system can work almost like a unitary one. The framers wanted the country to survive war, rebellion or collapse of government.
There are three types of emergency, all proclaimed by the President:
National Emergency, for war, external aggression or armed rebellion.
President's Rule in a State, when its government cannot run according to the Constitution.
Financial Emergency, for a financial crisis.
Because these powers are so sweeping, the big question is how to stop their misuse. Much of this chapter is about the safeguards added after bitter experience.
National Emergency (Article 352)
Grounds. The President can proclaim a National Emergency if the security of India or any part of it is threatened by war, external aggression or armed rebellion. A Proclamation can be made even before actual war, if the danger is imminent.
Life of a National Emergency
Why "armed rebellion"? The original ground was "internal disturbance", a vague phrase. The Emergency of 1975 was declared on internal grounds, and its misuse led the 44th Amendment to replace it with the narrower "armed rebellion".
Safeguards added by the 44th Amendment:
Safeguard
Rule
Written Cabinet decision
The President acts only when the Union Cabinet's decision is communicated in writing
Quick approval
Both Houses must approve within one month
Special majority
Majority of total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting
Limited life
Six months, renewable six months at a time by fresh resolutions
Lok Sabha can end it
The President must revoke it if the Lok Sabha passes a disapproving resolution
Members can force a sitting
Notice by one-tenth of Lok Sabha members; special sitting within 14 days
How often it has been used. National Emergency has been proclaimed three times: for external threats in 1962 and 1971, and on internal grounds in 1975. The external emergencies raised little controversy, but the 1975 Emergency became a turning point for Indian democracy.
What changes during a National Emergency
Federal effects.
Fundamental Rights during a National Emergency
Parliament can make laws on subjects in the State List. These laws cease to have effect six months after the Emergency ends.
The Union can give directions to any State on any matter of executive power.
The federal system works almost like a unitary one while the Emergency lasts.
Effect on Fundamental Rights.
Provision
Rule after the 44th Amendment
Article 358: Article 19 freedoms
Suspended automatically only in an Emergency on grounds of war or external aggression, not armed rebellion
Article 359: enforcement of other rights
The President may suspend enforcement of Part III rights, except Articles 20 and 21
Why protect Articles 20 and 21? After the experience of the 1975 Emergency, the 44th Amendment made sure that, whatever the crisis, the protections in Article 20 on conviction for offences and the right to life and personal liberty in Article 21 can never be suspended.
Terms of the Houses. The term of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies had been extended to six years during the Emergency era. The 44th Amendment brought it back to five years.
President's Rule (Article 356): the most debated power
What it does. If the President is satisfied, on the Governor's report, that a State's government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution, the President may proclaim President's Rule. The President then takes over the functions of the State government, and the State Legislature's powers are exercised by or under Parliament.
The Bommai safeguards
How long it can last. After the 44th Amendment, an approved Proclamation lasts six months at a time. It cannot continue beyond one year unless two conditions both hold:
a National Emergency is in operation; and
the Election Commission certifies that holding Assembly elections is difficult.
The overall limit of three years remained.
How long President's Rule can last
Meant as a last resort. The provision was intended as a life-saving device for genuine breakdowns. In practice it became the most contentious issue in Centre–State relations. It was used to dismiss governments that still had a majority, to dissolve Assemblies for partisan reasons, and to deny the opposition a chance to form a government.
The record.
Article 356 on the record, 1951 to 1987
The Sarkaria Commission found that of 75 uses between 1951 and 1987, only 26 were inevitable, while 18 were clear misuse for political ends.
In 1977, the new Union government dismissed nine State governments at one go, and in 1980 the next government did the same to nine States.
Punjab remained under President's Rule from May 1987 to February 1992.
The S.R. Bommai judgment (11 March 1994). The Supreme Court laid down strict standards:
the power under Article 356 is conditional, and action under it is judicially reviewable;
the President's satisfaction must rest on relevant material that courts can examine;
the Assembly cannot be dissolved until both Houses approve the Proclamation, and until then it can only be kept in suspended animation; and
after approval, courts can, in fit cases, restore the status quo.
Applying the test. The Court upheld the December 1992 dismissals of the governments of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh, because their anti-secular actions went against a secular Constitution. But it held unconstitutional the uses in Karnataka (1989), Meghalaya (1991) and Nagaland.
The President steps in. President K.R. Narayanan sent Cabinet recommendations for President's Rule back for reconsideration, first for Uttar Pradesh and again for Bihar in September 1998.
Financial Emergency (Article 360)
When. The President can proclaim a Financial Emergency to deal with a financial crisis. It has never been declared.
Financial Emergency (Article 360)
Approval. After the 44th Amendment, the Proclamation ceases after two months unless both Houses approve it.
Powers during it. The President can:
direct States to observe canons of financial propriety;
reduce salaries and allowances of persons serving the State; and
require Money Bills and other financial Bills of States to be reserved for the President.
Why it exists. A country's credit is shared. A financial crisis in one part can harm the whole, so the Union is given power to impose discipline across governments in such a case.
Why the safeguards were added
Change
Problem it answered
Effect
"Armed rebellion" for "internal disturbance"
A vague ground used in 1975
Emergency only for a serious armed threat
Written Cabinet decision
Fear of a decision by one person
Collective responsibility on record
One-month approval, special majority
Long, unchecked Emergencies
Parliament's strong consent needed
Articles 20 and 21 protected
Experience of 1975
Core rights survive any crisis
Limits on President's Rule
States kept under central rule for years
Beyond one year only with strict conditions
Bommai judgment
Partisan dismissals of State governments
Court review and no hasty dissolution
The lesson. The emergency provisions show both the strength and the danger of a flexible Constitution. Safeguards came from Parliament, through the 44th Amendment, and from the courts, through Bommai.
Quick revision
Three emergencies: National (352), President's Rule (356), Financial (360). Financial Emergency has never been declared.
National Emergency: war, external aggression, armed rebellion ("internal disturbance" removed by the 44th Amendment); used in 1962, 1971, 1975.
Written Cabinet decision; approval within one month by special majority in both Houses; six months, renewable.
Lok Sabha disapproval forces revocation; one-tenth notice, sitting within 14 days.
Article 19 auto-suspended only for war or external aggression; Articles 20 and 21 never suspended.
President's Rule: six months at a time; beyond one year only with National Emergency plus Election Commission certificate; three-year cap.
Bommai (1994): judicial review, relevant material, suspended animation before approval, courts can restore.
Financial Emergency: approval within two months; salary cuts, financial directions, Money Bills reserved.
Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered
The 44th Amendment replaced 'internal disturbance' as a ground for National Emergency with:
Consider about a National Emergency: 1. It must be approved by both Houses within one month. 2. Approval needs a simple majority of members present. 3. Once approved it lasts six months unless renewed. Which are correct?
The President can proclaim a National Emergency only when:
A National Emergency must be revoked if a resolution disapproving it is passed by:
Consider: 1. Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended during a National Emergency. 2. Article 19 is automatically suspended in an Emergency declared on the ground of armed rebellion. Which are correct?
President's Rule can continue beyond one year only if: 1. A National Emergency is in operation. 2. The Election Commission certifies difficulty in holding Assembly elections. 3. The Governor recommends it. Which conditions are required?
In S.R. Bommai (1994), the Supreme Court held that before both Houses approve a Proclamation under Article 356, the State Assembly:
According to the Sarkaria Commission, of 75 uses of Article 356 between 1951 and 1987, how many were inevitable?
Which statement about Financial Emergency under Article 360 is correct?
Regarding President's Rule under Article 356, which one of the following statements is not correct?
Mains answer practice
Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.
'Article 356 has been the most abused provision of the Constitution.' Examine in the light of the Bommai judgment. (150 words)
Show answer points
Sarkaria: 75 uses, 26 inevitable, 18 misuse; 1977 and 1980 mass dismissals; Punjab 1987–92
Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.
Frequently asked questions
What replaced 'internal disturbance' in Article 352?
The 44th Amendment replaced it with 'armed rebellion', alongside war and external aggression.
Which rights cannot be suspended during an Emergency?
The rights in Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended under Article 359.
When is Article 19 suspended automatically?
Only when the Emergency is declared on grounds of war or external aggression, not armed rebellion.
How can the Lok Sabha end a National Emergency?
By passing a resolution disapproving it. One-tenth of Lok Sabha members can give notice, and a special sitting must be held within 14 days; the President must then revoke it.