BPSC Stenographer in BPSC course‹› 0:00 studied

BPSC Stenographer in BPSC · Module 67 · basic depth · 6 min

Logical connectives: if–then, only if, unless, either–or

What BPSC Stenographer in BPSC asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Written: GS 50, General Science and Mathematics 50, Mental Ability 50 · Mental ability: analogies, similarities and differences, spatial visualisation and configuration, problem solving, analysis, visual memory, odd one out, observation, relationship concepts, arithmetic reasoning, verbal and non-verbal classification, number and non-verbal series, coding and decoding

BPSC Stenographer in BPSC questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to basic depth for BPSC Stenographer in BPSC. 48 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: what a rule really promises

A notice at a ground reads, "If it rains, the match is cancelled." On a rainy day, the match is off, as promised. But suppose the match is cancelled on a dry day because the pitch is damaged. Did the notice lie?

A promise and what it really binds

It did not. The notice only promised what happens if it rains. It said nothing about dry days, so a cancellation on a dry day breaks no promise. This small example holds the key to a whole family of exam questions.

Why this matters. Laws, rules and eligibility conditions are written with words such as "if", "only if" and "unless". Reading them correctly decides who gets a benefit, who must comply and who is exempt. A wrong reading can deny a right or grant one wrongly.

What this chapter does. We learn the two valid and two invalid moves with "if–then", translate everyday words into one standard form, and practise negations. Every rule here is checked with a truth table, which lists every possible case.

If–then: two valid moves and two traps

The truth table. Write P for "it rains" and Q for "the match is cancelled". The rule "If P then Q" is broken in only one case: it rains and the match is not cancelled. In the other three cases the rule stands.

Truth table for if–then
P (rain) Q (cancelled) Is the rule kept?
Yes Yes Kept
Yes No Broken
No Yes Kept
No No Kept

Valid move 1: from P to Q. "It rained" puts us in the first two rows, and the rule rules out the second. So the match was cancelled. This move is called affirming the condition.

Valid move 2: from not-Q to not-P. "The match was not cancelled" leaves rows two and four, and row two is ruled out. So it did not rain. This is the move people most often miss.

Trap 1: from Q to P. "The match was cancelled" leaves rows one and three, so it may or may not have rained. Trap 2: from not-P to not-Q. "It did not rain" leaves rows three and four, so the match may or may not have been held.

Why it matters. These four moves cover most if–then questions. The two traps are the most common wrong options in the papers.

The contrapositive and the converse

Same meaning, new words. "If P then Q" says exactly the same as "If not-Q then not-P". This second form is called the contrapositive. "If a person is a minister, then that person is a member of the legislature" means the same as "If a person is not a member of the legislature, that person is not a minister".

A different meaning. "If Q then P" is the converse, and it is a different claim. "If a person is a member of the legislature, then that person is a minister" is clearly not the same. Exams often offer the converse as a tempting wrong answer.

The inverse. "If not-P then not-Q" is called the inverse. It says the same as the converse, and it too differs from the original. "If a person is not a minister, then that person is not a member of the legislature" is false for most legislators.

Necessary and sufficient. In "If P then Q", P is a sufficient condition for Q, because P alone guarantees Q. Q is a necessary condition for P, because P cannot happen without Q. Rain is sufficient for cancellation under the notice, and cancellation is necessary for a rainy day.

A quick check. To test whether two if–then sentences mean the same, find the one case that breaks each. If both are broken by the same case, they are equivalent. The original and the contrapositive are both broken only by "P true, Q false".

Why it matters. Rules are often restated in reports and orders. Spotting whether a restatement keeps the meaning, or quietly reverses it, protects against errors in application.

Quick revision

One-page summary box
  • "If P then Q" is broken only when P is true and Q is false.
  • Valid: P gives Q; not-Q gives not-P. Invalid: Q gives P; not-P gives not-Q.
  • The contrapositive keeps the meaning; the converse and inverse do not.
  • "Q only if P" means "If Q then P"; "Unless P, Q" means "If not-P then Q".
  • "Either P or Q" means at least one: not-P gives Q, but P alone says nothing about Q.
  • Not "All A are B" is "Some A are not B"; not "If P then Q" is "P and not-Q".
  • Not "P and Q" is "not-P or not-Q"; not "P or Q" is "neither P nor Q".

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 23 answered

  1. Rule: Unless the land record is verified, the loan is not sanctioned. Fact: the loan is not sanctioned. What must be true about whether the land record is verified?

  2. Rule: Either the pump is faulty or the pipe is blocked (or both). Fact: the pipe is not blocked. What must be true about whether the pump is faulty?

  3. Rule: The match is cancelled only if it rains. Fact: it rains. What must be true about whether the match is cancelled?

  4. Rule: If the land record is verified, then the loan is sanctioned. Fact: the land record is not verified. What must be true about whether the loan is sanctioned?

  5. Rule: Either the meeting is postponed or the hall is booked (or both). Fact: the hall is not booked. What must be true about whether the meeting is postponed?

  6. Rule: Either the meeting is postponed or the hall is booked (or both). Fact: the meeting is not postponed. What must be true about whether the hall is booked?

  7. Rule: If the budget is passed, then salaries are paid. Fact: salaries are paid. What must be true about whether the budget is passed?

  8. Rule: Salaries are paid only if the budget is passed. Fact: the budget is passed. What must be true about whether salaries are paid?

  9. Rule: Unless the officer is present, the file is not signed. Fact: the officer is present. What must be true about whether the file is not signed?

  10. Rule: Salaries are paid only if the budget is passed. Fact: salaries are not paid. What must be true about whether the budget is passed?

  11. Rule: If the officer is present, then the file is signed. Fact: the officer is absent. What must be true about whether the file is signed?

  12. Rule: If it rains, then the match is cancelled. Fact: it rains. What must be true about whether the match is cancelled?

  13. Rule: Unless the land record is verified, the loan is not sanctioned. Fact: the land record is verified. What must be true about whether the loan is not sanctioned?

  14. Rule: Unless the officer is present, the file is not signed. Fact: the file is signed. What must be true about whether the officer is present?

  15. Rule: Unless the budget is passed, salaries are not paid. Fact: salaries are not paid. What must be true about whether the budget is passed?

  16. Rule: If it rains, then the match is cancelled. Fact: the match is not cancelled. What must be true about whether it rains?

  17. Rule: The file is signed only if the officer is present. Fact: the file is not signed. What must be true about whether the officer is present?

  18. Rule: Either the pump is faulty or the pipe is blocked (or both). Fact: the pump is not faulty. What must be true about whether the pipe is blocked?

  19. Rule: The file is signed only if the officer is present. Fact: the file is signed. What must be true about whether the officer is present?

  20. Rule: If it rains, then the match is cancelled. Fact: it does not rain. What must be true about whether the match is cancelled?

  21. Rule: Unless the budget is passed, salaries are not paid. Fact: the budget is passed. What must be true about whether salaries are not paid?

  22. Rule: Unless the officer is present, the file is not signed. Fact: the file is not signed. What must be true about whether the officer is present?

  23. Rule: Salaries are paid only if the budget is passed. Fact: the budget is not passed. What must be true about whether salaries are paid?

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

'If it rains, the match is cancelled.' The match was cancelled. Did it rain?

Not necessarily; the match may have been cancelled for another reason.

What is the contrapositive of 'If P then Q'?

'If not-Q then not-P', which is always equivalent.

What does 'You can enter only if you have a pass' mean?

If you entered, you had a pass; having a pass alone does not guarantee entry.

What does 'Unless you study, you will fail' mean?

If you do not study, you will fail.