BPSC TRE 4.0 · Module 58 · standard depth · 15 min
Data sufficiency
What BPSC TRE 4.0 asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Class 1 to 5 teacher · Part II, General Studies (120 questions): elementary mathematics, mental ability, general awareness, general science, social science, Indian National Movement, geography and environment (SCERT/NCERT-based).
BPSC TRE 4.0 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for BPSC TRE 4.0. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: do I know enough to decide?
A district officer is asked how many tents a flood camp needs. Before doing any arithmetic, the officer first checks whether the file holds enough facts. If the number of families is there but not the size of a tent, no amount of calculation will give the answer.
Data sufficiency questions test exactly this habit. Each question gives a problem and two statements, labelled I and II. You do not have to find the answer; you have to decide whether the statements are enough to find it.
Why this format exists. In real work, the first question is often whether you can decide at all. Asking for more data than needed wastes time, and deciding on too little data leads to errors. Data sufficiency checks whether you can tell the two apart quickly.
What this chapter does. We learn the five standard answers, the order in which to test the statements, and what "sufficient" really means. Then we look at the hidden traps and the shortcuts that let you answer without solving the problem fully.
The five answers and the order of testing
The standard choices. Almost every paper uses the same five outcomes, though the letters attached to them change. The table lists them in a fixed order, and this chapter uses these letters throughout.
| Letter | Meaning |
|---|---|
| A | Statement I alone is enough, II alone is not |
| B | Statement II alone is enough, I alone is not |
| C | Either statement alone is enough |
| D | Both together are needed, neither alone is enough |
| E | Even both together are not enough |
Papers differ in labels. One paper may call "neither" option (d) and another option (e). Read the option list once at the start of each set and note which letter means what. Most errors in this topic come from a correct judgement marked with the wrong letter.
The order of testing. First test statement I alone, as if II did not exist. Then test statement II alone, as if I did not exist. Only if neither alone works do you combine them.
Why the order matters. If both statements work alone, the answer is C, and testing them together would have hidden that. If one works alone, the answer is A or B, and combining is not needed. Following the order keeps you from marking D when a single statement was enough.
What "sufficient" really means
Exactly one answer. A statement is sufficient when it pins the answer down to one value. Take the question "What is x?" with statement I, 3x + 2 = 17, and statement II, x² = 25, where statement I gives x = 5 only and so is sufficient. Statement II gives x = 5 or x = −5, so it is not.
Yes or no questions. Many questions ask "Is n even?" or "Is P taller than Q?". Here a statement is sufficient if it always gives the same answer, whether that answer is yes or no. A definite no is just as good as a definite yes.
An example. "Is n even?" Statement I says n is a multiple of 4, so n is always even, and I is sufficient. Statement II says n + 1 is a prime number; n = 1 gives the prime 2 and n = 2 gives the prime 3, so n could be odd or even. II is not sufficient, and the answer is A.
Testing with examples. To show a statement is not sufficient, find two cases that fit it but give different answers. To show it is sufficient, you need a reason that covers every case. Trying a few small numbers, including 0, negatives and fractions, is the fastest way to find a breaking case.
Why it matters. Students often think "I found an answer, so it is sufficient". The real test is whether only one answer is possible. This single idea settles most data sufficiency questions.
Hidden assumptions and borrowing
No borrowing. When you test statement II alone, forget everything statement I told you. This is harder than it sounds, because after reading I your mind already holds its facts. A good habit is to cover statement I with your hand or write "II only" before you start.
No hidden assumptions. Do not assume that a number is positive, a whole number or different from another unless the question says so. "x² > 0" tells you only that x is not zero; x could be 3 or −3. "Is x > 0?" therefore cannot be settled by x² > 0, but it can by x³ > 0, since a cube keeps the sign.
Common sense facts are allowed. You may use facts everyone knows, such as a week having seven days or a person's age being positive. You may also use standard formulas, such as distance = speed × time. What you may not do is add a fact about this particular problem that the question does not give.
Why it matters. Officers are trained to separate what the file says from what they assume. A decision built on an unstated assumption can fall apart in court or in audit. This chapter's traps are a small version of that discipline.
Shortcuts: decide without solving
Stop once you know. You need to know that an answer can be found, not to find it. When two independent equations in two unknowns appear, you can stop: they will give one answer. Solving them fully only costs time.
Count equations, but check they differ. Two unknowns need two equations that say different things. The pair x + y = 10 and 2x + 2y = 20 is really one equation written twice, since the second is just the first doubled. Such a pair never fixes x, and the answer is E.
The asked quantity may need less. Sometimes you do not need every unknown. For a rectangle, statement I gives the perimeter 30 cm, so l + w = 15, and statement II gives the diagonal 13 cm, so l² + w² = 169. Since (l + w)² = l² + w² + 2lw, the area lw = (225 − 169) ÷ 2 = 28 cm², and the answer is D.
Look at the target first. Before reading the statements, ask what exactly is needed: a value, a yes or no, or a ratio. A ratio question may be settled by a statement that gives no actual values. Keeping the target in view saves you from chasing numbers you do not need.
Why it matters. These sets are often timed tightly, with five questions on one page. Deciding without solving lets you finish each question in under a minute and leaves time for the harder ones.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners use it. Data sufficiency tests judgement more than arithmetic. It checks whether a candidate knows what information a decision needs, which is the first step of any file note. It also rewards clear thinking over long calculation.
Where it shows up. State PSC aptitude papers and mental-ability sections often include one or two sets, built on arithmetic, ages, ranking and directions. Bank and staff-selection style exams use it heavily. The UPSC aptitude paper uses the idea inside reasoning questions that ask whether a conclusion can be drawn from given facts.
When it goes wrong. The usual slips are borrowing facts across statements, assuming numbers are positive, calling a repeated equation new information and marking the wrong letter. Another slip is answering D without checking whether one statement alone was enough.
The habit to build. Write the target at the top, test I alone, test II alone, then combine. Note the paper's letter for each outcome before the set begins.
A quick self-check. After choosing, ask one question: could a smaller amount of information have done the job? If yes, your answer is probably D where it should be A, B or C. This one check removes the most common lost mark in the topic.
Practice set: twelve solved problems
Use the letters from the table: A for I alone, B for II alone, C for either alone, D for both together and E for neither. Try each problem first, then read the steps.
1. What is the price of one pen? I: 4 pens and 3 pencils cost ₹50. II: 2 pens and 3 pencils cost ₹34.
Each statement alone has two unknowns. Subtracting II from I gives 2 pens = ₹16, so a pen costs ₹8. The answer is D.
2. What is Ravi's age? I: Ravi is 5 years older than Sita. II: Sita's age is half of Ravi's.
Neither alone fixes Ravi's age. Together, R = S + 5 and S = R ÷ 2 give R = 10. The answer is D.
3. Is x > 0? I: x² > 0. II: x³ > 0.
Statement I only says x is not zero, so x could be negative. A cube keeps the sign, so II gives a definite yes. The answer is B.
4. What is the area of a rectangle? I: its perimeter is 30 cm. II: its diagonal is 13 cm.
Neither alone is enough. Together, (l + w)² − (l² + w²) = 225 − 169 = 56 = 2lw, so the area is 28 cm². The answer is D.
5. What is a two-digit number? I: its digits add to 9. II: reversing its digits gives a number 27 larger.
I allows 18, 27, 36 and more, and II only says the units digit is 3 more than the tens digit. Together the digits are 3 and 6, so the number is 36. The answer is D.
6. How many students are in the class? I: Riya is 12th from the top and 18th from the bottom. II: the class has 16 girls and 13 boys.
Statement I gives 12 + 18 − 1 = 29. Statement II gives 16 + 13 = 29. Each works alone, so the answer is C.
7. Is the whole number n divisible by 6? I: n is divisible by 3. II: n is divisible by 4.
I allows 3, which is not divisible by 6, and 6, which is. II allows 4 and 12, which also differ. Together n is divisible by 12, so it is divisible by 6, and the answer is D.
8. What is the simple interest on ₹5,000 for 3 years? I: the rate is 8% a year. II: the simple interest for 2 years is ₹800.
I gives 5,000 × 8 × 3 ÷ 100 = ₹1,200. II gives ₹400 a year, so ₹1,200 for 3 years. The answer is C.
9. Who is the tallest of P, Q and R? I: P is taller than Q. II: R is shorter than Q.
I says nothing about R, and II says nothing about P. Together P > Q > R, so P is the tallest. The answer is D.
10. What is x? I: x + y = 10. II: 2x + 2y = 20.
Statement II is statement I doubled, so together they are still one equation in two unknowns. The answer is E.
11. Is a > b? I: a − b = 4. II: a² > b².
I gives a definite yes. II allows a = 5, b = 1, where the answer is yes, and a = −5, b = 1, where it is no. The answer is A.
12. What is the speed of a train? I: it crosses a pole in 10 seconds. II: it covers 360 km in 4 hours.
I needs the train's length, which is not given. II gives 360 ÷ 4 = 90 km/h. The answer is B.
Quick revision
- Decide whether the statements are enough; you do not need the answer itself.
- Test I alone, then II alone, and combine only if neither alone works.
- Sufficient means exactly one answer; a definite no counts as sufficient.
- To prove "not sufficient", find two cases that fit but give different answers.
- Do not carry facts from one statement into the other, and assume nothing unstated.
- A repeated equation in a new form adds no information.
- Check the paper's letters for the five outcomes before you start.