CGPSC SSE · Module 39 · Mains depth · 17 min
Fiscal federalism: the Finance Commission, tax devolution and grants
What CGPSC SSE asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper 1, Part 1 (India) · Indian economy
CGPSC SSE questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: the joint family pot
Think of a joint family. The eldest brother runs the family business and earns most of the money. The younger brothers run the households, raise the children, and look after the parents.
The money is earned in one place but needed in many. So the family keeps a common pot. Each household gets a share, based on the number of members, their needs and how well they manage.
India works the same way. The Centre collects the biggest taxes, like income tax and corporation tax. But states do much of the spending: schools, hospitals, police, roads and farming. This mismatch is called the vertical fiscal imbalance.
To share the money fairly, the Constitution creates the Finance Commission. This chapter explains how it works, what the Sixteenth Finance Commission has recommended for 2026-31, and the debates around sharing.
Article 280: the Finance Commission
What the Constitution says. Under Article 280, the President constitutes a Finance Commission. It has a Chairman and four other members, all appointed by the President.
Its main job. Article 280(2)(a) asks the Commission to recommend the distribution between the Union and the States of the net proceeds of taxes. It also recommends how the states' share is divided among the states, and the grants the Centre should give.
How often. A new Commission is set up roughly every five years, and each covers a five-year award period. The Fifteenth Commission was constituted on 27 November 2017, with N.K. Singh as Chairman.
The Sixteenth Finance Commission. It is chaired by Dr Arvind Panagariya, a former Vice-Chairman of NITI Aayog. It covers 2026-27 to 2030-31, and its report was submitted to the President on 17 November 2025.
Vertical and horizontal sharing
Vertical sharing: Centre vs states. The divisible pool is the part of Union taxes that is shared. The Sixteenth Finance Commission recommended keeping the states' share at 41% of the divisible pool. The government accepted this, as the Budget Speech 2026-27 confirms. The Fifteenth Commission had also set the share of the 28 states at 41%.
Horizontal sharing: among states. The 41% is then divided among the states using a formula. The Sixteenth Commission's criteria are:
- population;
- demographic performance, rewarding states that controlled population growth;
- area;
- forest cover;
- per-capita-income distance, which gives poorer states a bigger share;
- contribution to GDP, a new criterion based on each state's share in national GDP.
Two changes to note. For demographic performance, the Commission now uses the inverse of population growth between 1971 and 2011, instead of the inverse total fertility rate. It also cut the minimum area share given to every state from 2% to 1.5%.
Why this matters: the formula balances equity (help poorer states) with efficiency (reward states that grow and manage well). The new GDP criterion responds to richer states' complaint that they give more than they get back.
Grants: local bodies and disasters
Besides tax shares, the Finance Commission recommends grants. These are money the Centre gives for specific purposes.
Local body grants. For 2026-27 to 2030-31, the Sixteenth Commission recommended ₹7,91,493 crore for duly constituted rural and urban local bodies. Rural bodies get 60% and urban bodies 40%. The grants are split 80:20 into basic and performance-linked parts.
Disaster grants.
- States: a total corpus of ₹2,04,401 crore for the State Disaster Response Fund (SDRF) and State Disaster Mitigation Fund (SDMF).
- National: ₹79,406 crore for the national disaster response and mitigation funds.
For 2026-27 alone, the Budget Speech says ₹1.4 lakh crore has been provided to states as Finance Commission grants, including local body and disaster management grants.
What goes into the pot: the divisible pool and the rising share
Start with the family pot again. Imagine the joint family agrees to share the father's salary equally with the sons' households. But the father starts receiving part of his pay as a separate "special allowance" that is not counted as salary, so the shared pot shrinks even though his total income grows. This is close to the argument States make about the Centre's cesses and surcharges.
What the divisible pool is. The Finance Commission does not divide all of the Centre's tax revenue. It divides the divisible pool, which is what is left after deducting cesses, surcharges and the cost of collection. Cesses and surcharges stay entirely with the Centre, so when the Centre raises more money through them, the States' share of total tax revenue falls even if the Commission's percentage stays the same.
The jump to 42% (2015). The 14th Finance Commission raised the States' share of the divisible pool to 42%, a big jump from the 32% recommended by the 13th. The idea was to give States more untied money, which they can spend on their own priorities, rather than money tied to central schemes. It was one of the largest shifts of fiscal power towards the States since the Constitution came into force.
41% and beyond. The 15th Finance Commission kept the vertical share at 41% for 2021-26. The change of about 1% was not a cut in spirit, because the former State of Jammu and Kashmir had become Union Territories, which are funded directly by the Centre. The 16th Commission has also kept 41% for 2026-31.
Why it matters. The percentage in the headline is only half the story, because the size of the pool depends on how much the Centre collects through cesses and surcharges. This is why States often ask for cesses and surcharges to be capped or brought into the divisible pool. A good Mains answer looks at both the share and the size of the pool before judging whether States are getting a fair deal.
Who gets how much: the formula and the grants
Start with a fair split. Suppose a teacher must share a box of sweets among students of different sizes and hunger. Giving everyone the same number seems fair, but a hungry student who had no lunch might need more. A Finance Commission faces the same puzzle when it divides the States' share among 28 very different States.
The 15th Commission's formula. The 15th Finance Commission gave each criterion a weight. Income distance, which gives more to States whose income per person is further below the richest, carried 45%. Population and area carried 15% each, forest and ecology 10%, demographic performance 12.5%, and tax and fiscal efforts 2.5%.
Why each criterion is there. Income distance tries to equalise, so that a child in a poor State can get roughly similar public services as one in a rich State. Population and area capture need, because more people and more land mean more schools, roads and police. Forest cover rewards States that keep forests and give up land for development, demographic performance rewards States that controlled population growth, and tax effort rewards States that collect their own taxes well.
Grants on top. Some States still cannot balance their revenue budgets even after their share of taxes. For them, the 15th Commission recommended revenue deficit grants of ₹2,94,514 crore to seventeen States over 2021-26. These grants fill the gap between what a State needs to spend on revenue account and what it can raise or receive.
Why it matters. The formula is a balance between equity, which helps poorer States, and efficiency, which rewards States that perform well. Richer and better-governed States often argue that equity weights punish them for success, while poorer States say they need more to catch up. A good Mains answer explains this tension and suggests ways to reward effort without abandoning equity.
Why a Finance Commission every five years: when, where and why
The problem: money and duties sit in different hands. The Centre collects the biggest, most buoyant taxes, such as income tax and corporation tax. The states run police, hospitals, schools and much of farming and rural roads. So the states' duties are larger than their own revenues, while the Centre's revenues are larger than its own duties. Economists call this vertical fiscal imbalance.
A second problem: states differ. Some states are rich and some poor, some large and some small, some full of forests that cannot be cut. If taxes were shared only by where they are collected, the poorer states would fall further behind. This is horizontal imbalance.
The answer the Constitution gives (Article 280). The makers of the Constitution created an expert, independent Finance Commission, set up by the President every five years. It recommends how much of the Union's tax pool goes to the states (vertical sharing) and how it is divided among states (horizontal sharing). The first, chaired by K.C. Neogy, reported in 1952.
Why a commission and not just the Centre's decision? If the Centre alone decided, sharing could be bent by politics. An independent body with a formula, renewed every five years, makes transfers more predictable and fair, and lets states plan.

How the answer has changed. The share of states, set at 41% by the Fifteenth Commission (N.K. Singh), was kept at 41% by the Sixteenth (Arvind Panagariya) for 2026-31. The Sixteenth added a criterion for contribution to GDP, which tries to balance fairness to poorer states with rewarding states that grow.
Implications. Transfers fund a large part of state budgets, so the formula shapes schools and hospitals across India. Debates over what counts in the shared pool and over rewarding population control show that the Finance Commission sits at the heart of fiscal federalism.
Mains lens: tensions in fiscal federalism
1. Richer vs poorer states. Criteria like per-capita-income distance send more money to poorer states. Richer, faster-growing states argue that they are penalised for success. The new GDP-contribution criterion tries to balance this.
2. Population and fairness. States that controlled population growth feared losing shares if current population were used. Using demographic performance rewards them.
3. Cesses and surcharges. States often argue that the Centre's cesses and surcharges are not shared with them. In their view, a rising share of such levies shrinks what they actually receive, even when the formal share stays at 41%.
4. GST and dependence. After GST, states have less independent taxing power (see GST: one tax for one market, the GST Council and the 2025 reform), so they rely more on Finance Commission transfers.
A good conclusion: fiscal federalism works best when transfers are predictable, formula-based and fair to both needy and well-performing states. Strong local bodies, backed by assured grants, take this cooperation down to the village and ward.
Mains practice: five questions, five angles
These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam are in the PYQ panel of this module.
| Angle | Question | Key points to cover |
|---|---|---|
| Why (origin) | Why does the Constitution provide for a Finance Commission? | Explain vertical and horizontal imbalance and the answer given in Article 280. Then stress the value of independence and mention the first Commission under K.C. Neogy in 1952. |
| Criteria | Examine the criteria used by the Sixteenth Finance Commission for horizontal devolution. | List population, demographic performance, area, forest, income distance and the new criterion of contribution to GDP. Then weigh equity for poorer states against efficiency and reward for growth. |
| Debate | Should states that controlled population growth be rewarded in devolution? Discuss. | Explain the demographic performance criterion and why it exists. Then weigh fairness to poorer, larger states against the need for good incentives. |
| Local bodies | Discuss the role of Finance Commission grants in strengthening local bodies and disaster management. | Use the ₹7,91,493 crore local body grants, split 60:40 between rural and urban, and the ₹2,04,401 crore for state disaster funds. Then explain how the conditions attached push reform. |
| Way forward | Suggest reforms to make fiscal federalism in India more cooperative. | Suggest clear rules on what goes into the divisible pool and a stable formula. Then add the GST Council as a model, fiscal rules for states and more own revenue for local bodies. |
How to use this table: each answer should explain the what, then the why from the section above, and end with a way forward.
Quick revision
- Under Article 280, the President constitutes a Finance Commission of a chairman and four members, and it recommends how net tax proceeds are shared.
- The 15th Finance Commission, chaired by N.K. Singh and constituted on 27 November 2017, set the states' share at 41%.
- The 16th Finance Commission, chaired by Dr Arvind Panagariya, covers 2026-27 to 2030-31 and submitted its report on 17 November 2025.
- It kept the states' vertical share at 41% of the divisible pool, and the government accepted this.
- For the horizontal split among states, it uses population, demographic performance, area, forest, distance from the highest per capita income and, as a new criterion, contribution to GDP.
- It cut the minimum area share from 2% to 1.5%, and it measures demographic performance by inverse population growth between 1971 and 2011.
- For 2026-31, it recommended ₹7,91,493 crore for local bodies, split 60:40 between rural and urban and 80:20 between basic and performance grants.
- It also recommended ₹2,04,401 crore for state disaster response and mitigation funds, and ₹79,406 crore for the national disaster funds.
- The Finance Commission divides the divisible pool, which excludes cesses, surcharges and the cost of collection; the States' share rose from 32% (13th) to 42% (14th) and is 41% under the 15th and 16th.
- The 15th Commission's weights were income distance 45%, population 15%, area 15%, forest and ecology 10%, demographic performance 12.5% and tax effort 2.5%, plus ₹2,94,514 crore of revenue deficit grants to 17 States.
Common confusions and exam traps:
- Vertical = Centre vs states; horizontal = among states.
- The 41% is of the divisible pool, not of the Centre's total revenue.
- The Finance Commission is a constitutional body (Art 280); it is not part of NITI Aayog.