CGPSC SSE course‹› 0:00 studied

CGPSC SSE · Module 34 · Mains depth · 11 min

Keepers of public money: the CAG and the Finance Commission at work

What CGPSC SSE asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Prelims Paper 1, Part 1 (India) · Constitution and polity

CGPSC SSE questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: who checks the government's money?

Every rupee the government spends comes from the people, through taxes and borrowing. Parliament votes the money, but voting is not enough. Someone must later check whether it was spent lawfully, for the purpose voted, and without waste.

Two money referees

That job belongs to the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG). A second constitutional body, the Finance Commission, decides a different money question: how tax revenue should be shared between the Centre and the States. One looks back at how money was spent, and the other looks forward at how it should be divided.

This chapter studies how the Constitution protects the CAG's independence, how audit reports reach the legislature, and how a Finance Commission actually works. The sharing formulas and grants are covered in the chapter on Centre–State financial relations.

The CAG: appointment and independence

Appointment. Under Article 148, the CAG is appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal. The CAG audits the very government that appoints the office-holder, so the Constitution surrounds the post with strong protections.

Shields around the CAG

Protections in the Constitution:

  • Removal only in the same manner and on the same grounds as a Supreme Court judge.
  • No further office under the Government of India or any State after the CAG leaves office, so there is no reward to hope for.
  • Administrative expenses of the office are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India, so they do not depend on a vote.
  • Salary and conditions are fixed by Parliament by law, not by the executive.

The 1971 Act. Parliament fixed these terms in the CAG (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act, 1971:

Matter Rule
Salary Equal to a Supreme Court judge
Term Six years, or until age 65, whichever is earlier
Resignation In writing to the President
Other conditions Those of a Supreme Court judge apply

Why so much protection? An auditor who fears removal or hopes for a later job may soften findings against the government. Matching the CAG's status with a Supreme Court judge signals that the office answers to the Constitution and Parliament, not to ministers.

What the CAG does and where the reports go

Duties and powers (Article 149). The CAG performs duties and exercises powers in relation to the accounts of the Union and of the States, as laid down by Parliament. The 1971 Act is that law. So one office audits both the Union and every State, which keeps audit standards uniform across the country.

From audit to accountability

Form of accounts (Article 150). The accounts of the Union and the States are kept in the form the President prescribes on the CAG's advice. Common formats make it possible to compare and audit accounts across governments.

Reports (Article 151):

Articles 148 to 151 in one view
Accounts of Report goes to Laid before
The Union The President Each House of Parliament
A State The Governor The State Legislature

From audit to accountability. A report placed before the House is examined in detail by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC), which then reports to the House. Ministries must answer the PAC's questions, and its findings shape debate. In this way the CAG acts as the legislature's eyes on public money, while the legislature acts on what is found.

The Finance Commission: composition and mandate

When it is formed. Article 280 required the President to set up a Finance Commission within two years of the Constitution coming into force, and then every five years or earlier if needed. Each Commission is given terms of reference for its work.

Who sits on a Finance Commission

Who sits on it. The Constitution fixes the strength at a Chairperson and four other members. The 1951 Act lays down qualifications. The Chairperson must have experience in public affairs, and the members are drawn from persons who:

  1. Are, have been, or are qualified to be High Court judges.
  2. Have expertise in finance and accounts.
  3. Are experienced administrators.
  4. Have expertise in economics.

What it recommends:

  • How the net proceeds of taxes are shared between the Union and the States (vertical sharing), and among the States (horizontal sharing).
  • The principles of grants-in-aid to States from the Consolidated Fund of India.
  • Measures to augment a State's funds to support its Panchayats and municipalities, based on its State Finance Commission's recommendations.
  • Any other matter the President refers.

Why it matters. The Centre collects the more buoyant taxes, while States carry many spending responsibilities. The Finance Commission corrects this vertical imbalance and helps States provide comparable public services, which makes it a balancing wheel of fiscal federalism.

How a Finance Commission works

Step by step. A Finance Commission's work follows a clear sequence:

How a Finance Commission builds its report
  1. Once the Government announces its composition and terms of reference, the Commission writes to every State asking for estimates of its revenue and expenditure for the next five years.
  2. It scrutinises these estimates and calls State officers to Delhi for clarification, revising the estimates where needed.
  3. It tours every State, hearing the Chief Minister and Finance Minister, who present a memorandum of the State's needs. It also hears industry and bankers.
  4. It meets in Delhi to finalise the report and submits it to the President a few months before the annual budget.

Why the tours matter. Hearing each State directly gives every government, large or small, a voice. It also lets the Commission test claims against ground realities before deciding shares.

The Fifteenth Finance Commission. It was constituted by a notification of 27 November 2017, with N.K. Singh as Chairperson. It covered five years from 1 April 2020. Its main aims were to strengthen cooperative federalism, improve the quality of public spending and protect fiscal stability, balancing equity with efficiency.

Mains lens: the CAG as guardian of the public purse

A common question: "The CAG is the guardian of the public purse." Discuss the constitutional safeguards for the CAG's independence and the limits of its role.

Safeguards:

  • Appointment by the President; removal only like a Supreme Court judge.
  • Salary and conditions by law (1971 Act): pay equal to a Supreme Court judge; six years or age 65.
  • No further government office after retirement.
  • Expenses charged on the Consolidated Fund.

How it secures accountability:

  • Uniform audit of the Union and all States (Articles 149, 150).
  • Reports laid before Parliament and State Legislatures (Article 151).
  • Examination by the Public Accounts Committee.

Limits:

  • The CAG reports after money is spent; it cannot stop spending.
  • Action depends on the legislature and its committees, and on the government responding.
  • Delays in reports and in PAC follow-up reduce impact.

Conclusion. The CAG's independence is well protected on paper. Its effectiveness depends on timely reports and on how seriously the legislature acts on them.

Mains practice: more questions, different angles

Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.

1. Compare: Compare the CAG and the Finance Commission as constitutional bodies dealing with public money.

  • CAG: permanent office; audits spending after the event; reports to legislature.
  • Finance Commission: set up every five years; recommends sharing before spending.
  • Both protect fiscal accountability and federal balance.

2. Process: Describe the procedure followed by a Finance Commission in preparing its report.

  • Terms of reference; estimates from States; scrutiny.
  • State tours: CMs, FMs, memoranda; industry and bankers.
  • Report to the President before the budget.

3. Local bodies: How does the Union Finance Commission support Panchayats and municipalities?

  • Mandate to augment State funds for local bodies.
  • Link with State Finance Commissions.
  • Third tier of federalism; dependence on State action.

Quick revision

  • Article 148: CAG appointed by the President by warrant; removed like a Supreme Court judge; no further government office; expenses charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
  • 1971 Act: salary equal to an SC judge; term six years or age 65, whichever is earlier; resigns in writing to the President.
  • Article 149: duties and powers for Union and State accounts. Article 150: form of accounts, prescribed by the President on the CAG's advice.
  • Article 151: Union reports to the President → both Houses; State reports to the Governor → State Legislature; examined by the PAC.
  • Article 280: Finance Commission within two years, then every five years or earlier; Chairperson + four members.
  • 1951 Act qualifications: public affairs (Chair); HC judge-qualified, finance and accounts, administration, economics.
  • Mandate: vertical and horizontal sharing, grants-in-aid, local-body support, matters referred.
  • 15th FC: notified 27 November 2017, N.K. Singh, five years from 1 April 2020.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 9 answered

  1. The Comptroller and Auditor General is provided for in:

  2. About the CAG: 1. After retirement, the CAG cannot hold further office under the Union or any State. 2. The expenses of the CAG's office are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India. 3. The CAG can be removed by the President at pleasure. Which are correct?

  3. Under the 1971 Act, the CAG holds office for:

  4. The CAG's audit reports on a State's accounts are submitted to:

  5. Which committee of the legislature examines the CAG's audit reports?

  6. The Finance Commission consists of:

  7. Qualifications of Finance Commission members are laid down by:

  8. Which is NOT a function of the Finance Commission?

  9. The Fifteenth Finance Commission was chaired by:

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The CAG is the guardian of the public purse, but audit alone cannot ensure accountability.' Discuss. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Article 148 independence: appointment, removal, no further office, charged expenses
    • Articles 149–151: Union and State audit, reports to President/Governor
    • Public Accounts Committee turns audit into accountability
    • Limits: audit after spending; action depends on legislature and government
    • Way forward: timely PAC follow-up, action-taken reports

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What is the term of the CAG?

Six years or until the age of 65, whichever is earlier, under the CAG (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act, 1971.

To whom does the CAG submit reports on Union accounts?

To the President, who has them laid before each House of Parliament. Reports on a State's accounts go to the Governor.

Which committee examines CAG reports?

The Public Accounts Committee of the legislature, which reports its findings to the House.

How many members does the Finance Commission have?

A Chairperson and four other members, appointed every five years or earlier under Article 280.