CGPSC SSE course‹› 0:00 studied

CGPSC SSE · Module 28 · Mains depth · 27 min

The President: powers and position

What CGPSC SSE asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Prelims Paper 1, Part 1 (India) · Constitution and polity

CGPSC SSE questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: one chance to say "think again"

Picture a large joint family. The grandfather signs every big paper: the land deed, the bank loan, the wedding invitations. But the decisions are worked out by the parents, who run the household and answer to the whole family.

Sign, ask again once, then sign

One day the parents bring him a plan to sell the old orchard. He is unsure, so he says: "Think about this once more." The parents sit down again. If they come back with the same plan, he signs. He has used his voice, but he does not overrule the people who run the house.

That is close to how the President works. Huge powers are written in the President's name: appointing the Prime Minister, signing laws, issuing Ordinances, pardoning prisoners. But almost all of them are used on the advice of the Council of Ministers, and the President has a limited right to ask them to reconsider.

This chapter first explains the rule of advice, then the four kinds of powers (executive, legislative, financial, judicial), and finally asks whether the President is a "rubber stamp" or something more.

The golden rule: aid and advice

Article 74(1) is the key to the whole office: there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head to aid and advise the President, who "shall, in the exercise of his functions, act in accordance with such advice".

Advice flows up, orders flow out in the President's name

How the wording changed. The words "shall act in accordance with such advice" were put in by the 42nd Amendment, in force from 3 January 1977. This made it obligatory for the President to act only on the advice of the Council of Ministers.

Then the 44th Amendment (in force from 20 June 1979) added a proviso: the President may require the Council of Ministers to reconsider its advice. But the President shall act on the advice given after reconsideration. So the President gets one "think again", not a veto.

Article 74(2): no court can inquire whether advice was given, or what it was. The advice stays inside the government.

Article 77: everything in the President's name. All executive action of the Government of India is expressed to be taken in the name of the President. Orders in the President's name are authenticated as per rules, and the President makes rules for the transaction of business and its allocation among Ministers. This is why a government notice says "By order and in the name of the President".

Article 78: the Prime Minister keeps the President informed. The PM must communicate all decisions of the Council of Ministers and proposals for legislation, furnish information the President calls for, and, if the President asks, put before the Council any matter decided by a single Minister.

Executive powers: appointments, forces and foreign affairs

The President's powers fall into four groups: executive, legislative, financial and judicial. Start with the executive powers, which are about running the government.

Who the President appoints

1. Appointments. The main ones are:

  • the Prime Minister, and other Ministers on the PM's advice; the President also allocates portfolios and may remove a Minister on the PM's advice;
  • the Attorney-General, the Comptroller and Auditor-General (CAG), the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners, and the Chairman and members of the UPSC;
  • Governors of States and Lieutenant Governors of Union territories;
  • the Chiefs of the Army, Navy and Air Force.

These appointments are made on the advice of the Union Cabinet headed by the Prime Minister.

2. Judges. The President appoints the Chief Justice and Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts. After the Supreme Court's 1993 decision as re-interpreted in 1999, the President is bound by the recommendations of a panel of the senior-most Supreme Court judges headed by the Chief Justice, known as the collegium. The Judiciary module explains this in detail.

3. Defence and foreign affairs. The President is the Supreme Commander of the armed forces (Article 53(2)). The President can declare war and make peace, appoints India's ambassadors and high commissioners, and receives foreign envoys. International treaties are negotiated and concluded in the President's name.

In all three, remember the golden rule: the President acts on advice. The name is the President's; the choice is usually the government's.

Legislative powers: the President and Parliament

The President is an integral part of Parliament. The President does not sit in either House, but Parliament cannot work without the President.

The President and Parliament

Sessions: Article 85.

  • The President summons each House to meet, at such time and place as the President thinks fit.
  • Six months must not pass between the last sitting of one session and the first sitting of the next. So Parliament must meet at least twice a year.
  • The President may prorogue the Houses (end a session) and dissolve the Lok Sabha. An early dissolution happens on the Prime Minister's recommendation.

Addresses and messages: Article 86. The President may address either House or both together, and send messages to them, for example about a pending Bill. The President addresses both Houses together at the first session after every general election and at the start of the first session each year. This address sets out the policies of the government of the day, and The Cabinet prepares its text.

Nominations: Article 80(1)(a). The President nominates twelve members to the Rajya Sabha. They are persons with special knowledge of literature, science, art and social service.

Joint sitting. The President can call a joint sitting of both Houses when they disagree on a Bill that is not a Money Bill. The Parliament module covers how a joint sitting works.

Two more legislative powers are big enough for their own sections: assent to Bills and Ordinances.

Assent to Bills: three doors

No Bill becomes a law without the President's signature. Under Article 111, when a Bill passed by both Houses reaches the President, the President must declare one of these:

Three doors for a Bill
  1. Assent: the Bill becomes an Act.
  2. Withhold assent: the Bill does not become law.
  3. Return the Bill to the Houses "as soon as possible", with a message asking them to reconsider it or some provisions, and perhaps suggesting amendments. This door is not open for a Money Bill.

The returned Bill. If the Houses pass the Bill again, with or without the suggested amendments, and present it to the President, the President "shall not withhold assent". So returning a Bill buys time and a second debate; it cannot kill the Bill.

Why can't a Money Bill be returned? A Money Bill comes to Parliament only on the President's own recommendation. Sending it back would be like the President questioning a proposal the President had already allowed.

Ordinances: a law for the gap

Parliament does not sit all year. Suppose a sudden crisis needs a new law in a month when Parliament is not meeting. Article 123 gives the answer: an Ordinance.

The life of an Ordinance

When can it be issued? Two conditions, both from Article 123(1):

  • both Houses of Parliament are not in session at that time (if even one House is sitting, the power is not available); and
  • the President is satisfied that circumstances make immediate action necessary.

As with other powers, the President acts on the Council of Ministers' advice. The Cabinet is responsible for Ordinances issued when Parliament is not in session.

How strong is it? An Ordinance has the same force and effect as an Act of Parliament (Article 123(2)). But it is a temporary law, with three ways to end:

  • (a) it must be laid before both Houses, and it ceases six weeks after Parliament reassembles. If the Houses reassemble on different dates, the six weeks count from the later date;
  • if both Houses pass resolutions disapproving it before then, it ends when the second resolution passes;
  • (b) the President may withdraw it at any time.

The government usually brings a Bill to replace the Ordinance with a regular Act.

Its limits. Article 123(3): if an Ordinance makes a provision that Parliament itself could not enact, it is void to that extent. So an Ordinance cannot, for example, take away a Fundamental Right that Parliament could not take away by law.

History. The 38th Amendment (1975) added a clause (4) to Article 123. The 44th Amendment omitted it with effect from 20 June 1979, and the official text now shows it only as asterisks.

Financial powers

Money is the fuel of government, and here too the President's name opens the door. These are the financial powers:

  • Money Bills are introduced in the Lok Sabha only with the President's prior recommendation.
  • The annual budget is introduced on the President's recommendation. Article 112(1) says the President shall, for every financial year, cause to be laid before both Houses a statement of the estimated receipts and expenditure, called the annual financial statement.
  • If more money is needed in the middle of the year, the government can present supplementary demands.
  • The President controls the Contingency Fund of India, a fund kept for unforeseen expenses, and permits withdrawals from it.
  • The President appoints the Finance Commission every five years. It recommends, among other things, how Central taxes are shared between the Union and the States.
  • The President receives the reports of the CAG and has them laid before Parliament.

Why route all this through the President? It ensures that no private member can push a spending or tax Bill on their own; money proposals come only from the government, which answers to the Lok Sabha. The Parliament module explains Money Bills and the budget in full.

Mercy powers: Article 72

Courts decide guilt and punishment. But the law also keeps a door open for mercy, for example when new facts appear or a sentence seems too harsh. Article 72(1) gives the President the power to:

Mercy powers under Article 72
  • grant pardons, reprieves, respites or remissions of punishment; or
  • suspend, remit or commute the sentence of any person convicted of an offence.

In plain words: a pardon forgives the punishment fully; to suspend is to put it on hold; to remit is to reduce it; to commute is to change it to a lighter kind. Reprieve and respite are forms of delay or relief; their exact legal meanings are best learnt from a law text.

Which cases? The power covers three kinds:

  • (a) all sentences by a Court Martial (military courts);
  • (b) all offences against a law on a matter to which the Union's executive power extends; and
  • (c) all death sentences.

The Governor's side. Article 72(3) says the President's power over death sentences does not affect the Governor's power to suspend, remit or commute a death sentence under any law in force. Article 72(2) similarly saves the powers that armed forces officers have by law over Court Martial sentences.

The President exercises this power on advice (it mentions the Law Ministry), not personally. This is one of the most serious powers of the office, because a person's life may depend on it.

Asking the Supreme Court for an opinion: Article 143

Sometimes the government faces a legal question so important that it wants the Supreme Court's view before acting, not after a case is filed. Article 143(1) allows this.

If it appears to the President that a question of law or fact has arisen, or is likely to arise, of such a nature and public importance that it is expedient to get the Supreme Court's opinion, the President may refer it to the Court. The Court, after such hearing as it thinks fit, may report its opinion to the President.

Notice the two "mays". The President is not bound to refer, and the wording of clause (1) also uses "may" for the Court's reply. Article 143(2) separately lets the President refer certain disputes mentioned in the proviso to Article 131, on which the Court "shall" report.

Think of it as asking a senior doctor for a second opinion before an operation. It is an advisory role, explained further in the Judiciary module.

So how powerful is the President?

After reading this long list, it is easy to think the President rules India. The answer is clear: the office is one of high dignity and eminence, not of real powers. The powers vested in the President are actually exercised by the Union Council of Ministers, in the President's name.

Dr B. R. Ambedkar said the President "occupies the same position as the King in the British Constitution". In his words, the President is the head of the State but not of the executive, represents the nation but does not rule it, and is the symbol of the nation.

But not a rubber stamp. The President is not a mere rubber stamp:

  • the President takes an oath to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution (Article 60);
  • all Cabinet decisions are communicated to the President, who can call for information (Article 78);
  • the President can send advice back once for reconsideration (Article 74) and return a Bill once (Article 111);
  • The President can ask a newly appointed Prime Minister to seek a vote of confidence in the Lok Sabha within a stipulated time.

Using these, the President can suggest, encourage and even warn the government. The President emerges as an adviser, a friend and even a critic.

Why the President's powers were shaped this way

The President's powers look huge on paper. The rules that limit them were added for clear reasons, often after real disputes.

Rule Why it is there What it means in practice
Aid and advise (Art 74(1)) Parliamentary government needs power with those who answer to the Lok Sabha Ministers decide; the President acts on their advice
"Shall act" (42nd Amendment) To remove any doubt that the advice was binding The President must follow ministerial advice
Reconsideration proviso (44th Amendment) To give the President one chance to make the government think again A pause, not a veto: the second advice is binding
Article 74(2) Advice between Ministers and the President should stay confidential Courts cannot ask what advice was given
Return of Bills (Art 111) A last check on hasty laws Parliament can pass it again, and then the President must assent
Ordinances (Art 123) Urgent action may be needed when Parliament is not sitting Temporary law; lapses six weeks after Parliament reassembles unless approved
Clause (4) of Art 123 removed (44th) The 38th Amendment had tried to shut out court review of the President's "satisfaction" Ordinance-making is again open to challenge in court
Mercy power (Art 72) Courts can make mistakes, and some cases need compassion A final humane check, used on government advice
Advisory jurisdiction (Art 143) The government may need legal clarity before acting The Supreme Court can give its opinion on questions of public importance

The story of 1976 to 1979. The 42nd Amendment tightened the rule so the President "shall act" on advice. The 44th Amendment then added the right to send advice back once. This pair of amendments shows the framers' balance in action: the President is bound, but not voiceless.

Why it matters today. Debates on Ordinances, delays in mercy petitions and the President's role in a hung Parliament all come back to one question: how much room does the President really have? The answer is little in law, but real in influence, through the rights to be informed, to warn and to ask the government to think again.

Mains lens: rubber stamp or guardian?

A common question: "The President of India is a constitutional head, not a rubber stamp." Discuss.

Introduction: India has a parliamentary system. Executive power is vested in the President (Article 53), but exercised on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers (Article 74(1)). So the President is the nominal executive and the Council of Ministers is the real executive.

Why "constitutional head":

  • Article 74(1), after the 42nd Amendment, says the President "shall act" on advice.
  • Even the reconsideration right ends with "shall act in accordance with the advice tendered after such reconsideration" (44th Amendment).
  • Ambedkar compared the office to the British King, and acting against ministers would cause a constitutional crisis.

Why "not a rubber stamp":

  • Information and influence: Article 78 makes the PM share all Cabinet decisions and furnish information the President calls for.
  • Delay and second thought: one return of advice (Article 74) and of a non-Money Bill (Article 111) forces a second debate.
  • Guardian's oath: the President swears to "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution" (Article 60), and has a real role at moments such as appointing a PM when no party has a clear majority.

Conclusion: the President is best seen as the Constitution's conscience-keeper: bound by advice in the end, but able to slow down, question and warn. The phrase "an adviser, a friend and even a critic" makes a strong closing line.

Mains lens: Ordinances, emergency tool or shortcut?

A common question: "The Ordinance-making power is an emergency power, not a parallel law-making power." Examine.

Why the power exists:

  • Parliament is not always in session, but urgent situations can arise at any time.
  • Article 123 lets the executive act immediately, with the same force as an Act.

Built-in safeguards in the text:

  • Only when both Houses are not in session, and only when the President is satisfied that immediate action is needed (Article 123(1)).
  • It must be laid before both Houses; it lapses six weeks after reassembly, or earlier if both Houses disapprove (Article 123(2)).
  • It is void wherever it goes beyond what Parliament could enact (Article 123(3)).
  • The 38th Amendment's clause (4) was omitted by the 44th Amendment, which shows the Constitution's move back towards limits after the Emergency years.

Concerns to raise (analysis):

  • If used often, Ordinances can bypass debate in Parliament, where Bills are examined and amended.
  • An Ordinance can create facts on the ground before Parliament has had a say.
  • The six-week rule protects Parliament only if the government brings a proper Bill in time.

Conclusion: the Ordinance is meant as a bridge across a gap, not a road that replaces Parliament. Its legitimacy depends on genuine urgency and quick replacement by an Act.

Mains practice: more questions, different angles

Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton; add facts from this chapter.

1. Amendment history: How did the 42nd and 44th Amendments change the relationship between the President and the Council of Ministers?

  • Quote the 42nd Amendment: the President "shall act in accordance with such advice".
  • Then show the 44th Amendment's change: the President may ask for reconsideration once, after which the advice binds.
  • Add that the 44th Amendment also removed the bar on court review of Ordinances.
  • Conclude that the President moved from being simply bound to being bound but consulted.

2. Critical: "Ordinances have become a parallel route of law-making." Examine.

  • Give the purpose: Article 123 meets urgent needs when Parliament is not in session.
  • Give the limits: the Ordinance lapses after six weeks, and it is void if it goes beyond Parliament's power (123(3)).
  • Raise the concern that frequent use bypasses debate.
  • Conclude that the Ordinance is an emergency tool that needs restraint.

3. Ethics and law: Discuss the significance of the President's power of pardon under Article 72.

  • Explain the scope: the power covers Court Martial sentences, death sentences and offences against Union laws.
  • Show its purpose: it can correct a judicial error and leave room for mercy.
  • Note that it is exercised on ministerial advice.
  • Conclude that it brings compassion within the rule of law.

4. Judiciary link: How useful is the advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 143?

  • Explain that the President may refer to the Supreme Court a question of law or fact of public importance.
  • Show that this gives legal clarity before the government acts.
  • Note that the opinion is advisory, not a judgment between parties.
  • Conclude that it is a tool for clarity in hard constitutional questions.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • Under Art 74(1), the Council of Ministers headed by the PM aids and advises the President, who "shall act" on that advice (42nd Amendment); the President may ask for reconsideration once, and must then act (44th Amendment). Under 74(2), courts cannot inquire into the advice.
  • Under Art 77, all executive action is taken in the President's name under business rules, and under Art 78 the PM keeps the President informed.
  • Executive: the President appoints the PM, other Ministers on the PM's advice, the AG, CAG, CEC and ECs, UPSC members, Governors and service chiefs, and appoints judges on the collegium's recommendation. The President is Supreme Commander, and treaties are made in the President's name.
  • Legislative: under Art 85 the President summons and prorogues the Houses and dissolves the Lok Sabha, with a gap of under six months between sessions. Under Art 86 the President can address and send messages, under Art 80(1)(a) nominates 12 members to the Rajya Sabha, and can call a joint sitting.
  • Under Art 111, the President may assent to a Bill, withhold assent, or return it once (but not a Money Bill), and must assent if it is passed again.
  • Under Art 123, an Ordinance can be issued only when both Houses are not in session. It has the same force as an Act, lapses six weeks after reassembly, can be withdrawn and is void beyond Parliament's competence; clause (4), added by the 38th Amendment, was omitted by the 44th.
  • Financial: Money Bills need the President's prior recommendation, and the President controls the Contingency Fund, appoints a Finance Commission every five years and receives the CAG's reports. Under Art 112, the President causes the annual financial statement to be laid before both Houses.
  • Under Art 72, the President can pardon or reduce sentences for Court Martial cases, Union-law offences and all death sentences, while the Governor's death-sentence power is saved. Under Art 143, the President can seek the Supreme Court's advisory opinion.
  • Position: the President is the head of State, not of the executive (Ambedkar), and acts as an adviser, friend and critic.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 5 answered

  1. Under the proviso to Article 74(1), if the President sends advice back for reconsideration, the President must:

  2. Consider the following statements about Ordinances: 1. An Ordinance can be issued only when both Houses of Parliament are in session. 2. An Ordinance ceases to operate six weeks after Parliament reassembles unless approved earlier. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. Under Article 72, the President's power to grant pardon extends to cases where:

  4. Under which Article can the President seek the opinion of the Supreme Court on a question of law or fact of public importance?

  5. Consider the following statements about advice and executive action: 1. No court can inquire whether any advice, and if so what advice, was given by Ministers to the President. 2. All executive action of the Government of India is expressed to be taken in the name of the Prime Minister. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The President of India is neither a rubber stamp nor a rival centre of power.' Discuss. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Art 74(1) binding advice after 42nd and 44th Amdts
    • Reconsideration proviso; Art 78 right to information
    • Discretion in hung House, Art 111 return of Bills, Art 143
    • Ambedkar: like the King; Adviser, friend, critic

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Is the President bound by the advice of ministers?

Yes. Article 74(1) says the President shall act on the Council of Ministers' advice. Since the 44th Amendment, the President may ask them to reconsider once, but must act on the advice given after that.

Can the President return a Money Bill?

No. Under Article 111 the President may return only a non-Money Bill, once. If Parliament passes it again, the President cannot withhold assent.

How many members does the President nominate to the Rajya Sabha?

Twelve, under Article 80(1)(a), for special knowledge or practical experience in literature, science, art and social service.

What is the maximum gap between two sessions of Parliament?

Six months. Article 85 requires the President to summon each House so that six months do not pass between the last sitting of one session and the first sitting of the next.