CSBC Constable course‹› 0:00 studied

CSBC Constable · Module 12 · basic depth · 10 min

Members and the health of Parliament: privileges, defection, committees and decline

What CSBC Constable asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Written exam (12th level, OMR) · Social science: history, geography, civics, economics

CSBC Constable questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to basic depth for CSBC Constable. 15 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: what keeps Parliament healthy?

Imagine a school council where students raise complaints about the canteen. If a student could be punished by the principal for speaking up, nobody would speak. If members could switch sides for a reward, no decision would last. If the council had to check every bill in one big noisy meeting, nothing would get checked properly.

Parliament faces the same three problems. Parliament answers them with privileges that protect free speech, the anti-defection law that stops members from switching sides at will, and committees that do the detailed work in small groups.

This chapter explains these three tools. It then asks a harder question: has Parliament grown weaker compared with the executive, and what can be done about it?

Parliamentary privileges

What they are. Privileges are special rights that let members and the Houses do their work freely and without fear. They belong to the House as a whole and to members as individuals. They are not personal favours, but protections for the job of representing the people.

The shield of privilege

Enumerated privileges. These are spelt out, and the main ones are:

  1. Freedom of speech in each House.
  2. Immunity from court proceedings for anything said or any vote given in Parliament or its committees.
  3. Immunity for publications made by or under the authority of a House, such as reports, papers and proceedings.
  4. Freedom from arrest in civil cases during a session and for 40 days before and after it.
  5. Exemption from attending as a witness in a court while the House is sitting.

Unenumerated privileges. Beyond the listed ones, the Houses have privileges similar to those of the British House of Commons. The most important is the power to punish for contempt. Like the Commons, Parliament can punish any person, member or not, who commits contempt of the House.

Why free speech in the House matters. A member may need to expose a scam, criticise a powerful person or raise an uncomfortable fact. If every such statement could lead to a defamation case, members would stay silent. The privilege ensures that what is said in the House is answerable to the House, not to the courts.

Defection and the anti-defection law

What defection means. Defection, also called crossing the floor, means a member changing allegiance from one party to another. Voters usually elect a candidate because of the party ticket. So when a member switches sides after the election, the voters' choice is overturned without their consent.

Why the anti-defection law came

Why a law was needed. During the fourth Lok Sabha (1967-70), defections and party splits became common in Parliament and especially in the States. Governments rose and fell as members changed sides, sometimes more than once. This instability built a strong case for a law against defection.

The law. In the eighth Lok Sabha (1985-89), Parliament passed a constitutional amendment providing for disqualification of members on the ground of defection. The provisions are in the Tenth Schedule, read with Article 102(2) for Parliament and Article 191(2) for State Legislatures. A member who defects loses the seat.

The debate it raised. The law brought stability, but it also tied members tightly to the party whip. Critics argue that a member can no longer vote freely on a matter of conscience. Others point out that the law has not fully stopped defections, because groups of members still find ways to change sides.

Parliamentary committees: the House in miniature

Why committees. Parliament is supposed to keep a close watch on the government. But the full House has too little time and too many members to study complex administration and accounts in detail. So it creates committees, smaller groups of members that can study a subject closely and report back.

Four families of committees

Four families of committees.

Group Purpose Example
House organisation Deal with the House's own rules and powers Rules Committee
Law-making Study Bills in detail Select committees
Accountability Make departments answerable Department-related Standing Committees
Money Watch over public spending PAC, Estimates Committee

Standing and ad hoc. A standing committee is permanent. It is constituted every year or from time to time, by election by the House or by nomination by the presiding officer. An ad hoc committee is set up for a specific task and ends when that task is done.

How they are kept fair. Seats on a committee are shared in proportion to party strength in the House. A Minister in charge of a Bill before a committee does not take part in its deliberations, which limits the influence of the executive.

Why they work. Committees meet away from cameras, so members can discuss sensitive matters in a less partisan way. They can call officials and experts and examine records. By convention, Ministries report on the action taken on the recommendations of the financial committees, which gives those reports real weight.

Is Parliament sovereign? Parliament and the courts

The British idea. In Britain, Parliament is sovereign: it can make or unmake any law, and no court can set it aside. India borrowed the parliamentary system, but not this idea in full. Indian Parliament works within a written Constitution, and the courts can review its laws.

Parliament vs Court on amending power

The long tussle over amending power.

Year Event What it said
1967 Golaknath case By 6:5, Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights
1971 24th Amendment Parliament reasserted its power; an amendment is not 'law' under Article 13
1973 Kesavananda Bharati case Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights but cannot alter the basic structure
1976 42nd Amendment Declared Parliament's amending power unlimited and beyond court review
1980 Minerva Mills case Struck down clauses (4) and (5) of Article 368, as judicial review is a basic feature

Two views. Supporters of parliamentary supremacy argue that Parliament, elected by all adults, speaks for the people, while "basic structure" is not written anywhere in the Constitution. The other side argues that if Parliament could amend anything without court review, the Constitution would be at the mercy of a passing majority. The settled position today is a balance: Parliament has wide power, but within the basic structure.

Why these rules exist

Each tool in this chapter answers a specific danger to a representative House. Read the table as "danger, then answer".

Every protection has a price
Tool Danger it answers Cost or limit
Free speech in the House Members silenced by fear of lawsuits Can be misused to make unfair attacks
Power to punish contempt Outsiders obstructing the House The House acts as judge in its own cause
Anti-defection law Governments toppled by members switching sides Less freedom for conscience votes
Committees No time for detailed scrutiny on the floor Reports are advisory and often not debated
Judicial review and basic structure A passing majority rewriting the Constitution Tension between elected Parliament and unelected judges

The pattern. Every protection has a price. Good answers in the exam show both the reason for a rule and its cost, and then suggest how the balance can be improved.

Quick revision

  • Privileges are enumerated and unenumerated; the enumerated ones include free speech, immunity for words and votes, protected publications, freedom from civil arrest (session plus 40 days before and after) and exemption from being a witness.
  • Parliament can punish anyone, member or not, for contempt; contempt is wider than breach of privilege.
  • Defection leads to disqualification under the Tenth Schedule with Articles 102(2) and 191(2), added in the eighth Lok Sabha after the defections of the late 1960s.
  • Committees fall into four families: House organisation, law-making, accountability and money.
  • Standing committees are permanent; ad hoc committees end with their task.
  • In the Rajya Sabha, the Chairman recognises the Leader of the Opposition, and that decision is final.
  • Indian Parliament is supreme but not sovereign: Golaknath 1967, Kesavananda 1973 (basic structure), Minerva Mills 1980.
  • Decline: delegated legislation, party dominance, defections, weak opposition.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. A Member of Parliament enjoys freedom from arrest:

  2. Parliament's power to punish for contempt of the House extends to:

  3. Consider: 1. Provisions on disqualification for defection are in the Tenth Schedule. 2. They apply to Parliament but not to State Legislatures. 3. Article 102(2) links defection to disqualification of Members of Parliament. Which are correct?

  4. Which Lok Sabha was especially marked by defections and party splits?

  5. Which of these is an example of contempt of the House?

  6. A parliamentary committee set up for a specific task, which ends when the task is done, is called:

  7. The basic structure doctrine was laid down in:

  8. In the Rajya Sabha, the Leader of the Opposition is recognised by:

  9. Which factor is most directly linked to the transfer of law-making detail from Parliament to the executive?

  10. The Tenth Schedule (anti-defection provisions) was added to the Constitution of India during the prime ministership of

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'In theory the legislature controls the executive; in practice power has passed to the executive.' Discuss with reference to the Indian Parliament. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Reasons: delegated legislation, party dominance and whip, defections, weak opposition and public opinion
    • Counter: Question Hour, adjournment motions, committees, opposition voice
    • Committees work non-partisan; action taken reports
    • Way forward: more sittings, more Bills to committees, debate reports, scrutiny of rules

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Where is the anti-defection law in the Constitution?

In the Tenth Schedule, read with Articles 102(2) and 191(2). It disqualifies members who change party allegiance.

What are the two kinds of parliamentary privileges?

Enumerated privileges, such as freedom of speech in the House and immunity for votes and speeches, and unenumerated privileges similar to those of the British House of Commons.

Is the Indian Parliament sovereign?

No. Its laws can be struck down by courts, and since Kesavananda Bharati (1973) it cannot alter the basic structure of the Constitution.

Can Parliament punish a non-member for contempt?

Yes. Like the House of Commons, Parliament can punish any person, member or not, for contempt of the House.