CSBC Operator course‹› 0:00 studied

CSBC Operator · Module 4 · basic depth · 19 min

Salient features of the Constitution

What CSBC Operator asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Written exam: GK & social issues 25, Physics 25, Chemistry 25, Maths 25 (intermediate level) · General knowledge and social issues

CSBC Operator questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to basic depth for CSBC Operator. 20 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: what makes a good rulebook?

Imagine your colony starts a cricket club. Before the first match, the members sit down to write a rulebook. What will a good rulebook need?

Ten features in one picture
  1. Write it down, so no one can later say "that was never the rule."
  2. Learn from other clubs: why invent everything when good clubs already have tested rules?
  3. Decide who runs what: a main committee for the whole club, and small teams for each ground.
  4. Decide who actually takes decisions: a captain who answers to the members, not a boss who answers to no one.
  5. Protect each member: "no one can be thrown out without a fair hearing."
  6. Have a referee: someone neutral to settle fights.
  7. Give everyone a vote, one each.
  8. Plan for bad days: what happens in a storm or a crisis?
  9. Allow changes, but not so easily that one angry meeting can tear up the rulebook.

Every one of these is a feature of India's Constitution. "Salient features" simply means the personality of the rulebook: what makes it different from other countries' rulebooks. The picture below shows the main ones together; the rest of the chapter takes them one by one.

Feature 1: a long, written rulebook

Some families run on unwritten habits: everyone just knows who cooks on Sunday. Others pin a written list on the fridge. Britain's constitution is like the first family, mostly unwritten, made of laws, court decisions and customs. India chose the fridge list: a written Constitution, framed at one time and brought into force on a fixed date.

How long is our Constitution?

And it is a long list. The original Constitution had 395 Articles, 22 Parts and 8 Schedules, which is why it is described as the lengthiest constitution in the world. Compare that with the US Constitution, which has only 7 Articles. Amendments have added more over the years; today there are 12 Schedules.

Why so long? Think of what India had to fit into one book:

  • a country of huge diversity, so many groups wanted their safeguards written down;
  • rules for both the Union and the States in the same document;
  • a great deal of administrative detail carried over from the Government of India Act 1935;
  • separate chapters for rights, directive principles, emergencies, elections, services and more.

A longer rulebook leaves less room for confusion, but it also needs more amendments as times change. Keep that trade-off in mind for the Mains section.

Feature 2: borrowed, then made our own

A good cook reads many recipes before writing her own. The framers went through the constitutions of about 60 countries, and Dr Ambedkar said there was nothing to be ashamed of in borrowing. The biggest borrowings to remember:

Where the big ideas came from
Source What India took
Government of India Act, 1935 Federal scheme, office of Governor, judiciary, Public Service Commissions, emergency provisions
Britain Parliamentary government, rule of law, single citizenship, cabinet system, prerogative writs, two Houses
USA Fundamental Rights, independent judiciary, judicial review, impeachment, Vice-President
Ireland Directive Principles, nominating members to Rajya Sabha, method of electing the President
Canada Federation with a strong Centre, residuary powers with the Centre, Governors appointed by the Centre, advisory opinions of the Supreme Court

A memory trick: match the idea to the country's personality.

  • Britain, the oldest parliament: everything about how Parliament and the cabinet work.
  • USA, the land of the Bill of Rights: rights and the courts that guard them.
  • Ireland: the directions for a welfare state.
  • Canada, a federation with a strong Centre: the strong-Centre features.

Borrowing was never copying: each idea was reshaped for Indian conditions. For example, India took Fundamental Rights from the USA but added reasonable restrictions, and took parliamentary government from Britain but put it under a written Constitution that courts can enforce.

Feature 3: a Union of States, with a strong Centre

The basic idea. In a federation there are two levels of government: one for the whole country and one for each State, each with its own powers. The USA is a federation. The UK is unitary: one government holds all power and can create or abolish local bodies at will.

Three lists and the leftover box

India's choice. Powers are divided between the Union and the States. Article 246 does this through the Seventh Schedule, which has three lists:

  • List I, the Union List: subjects only Parliament can make laws on.
  • List II, the State List: subjects for the State Legislatures.
  • List III, the Concurrent List: subjects on which both can make laws.

What about a subject that appears in no list? Under Article 248, Parliament alone can make laws on it, including any tax not mentioned in the lists. These are called residuary powers, and giving them to the Centre was an idea taken from Canada.

The lean towards the Centre. The division favours the Union, and the Governor of every State is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure (Articles 155 and 156). So India is called quasi-federal: federal in structure, with more power at the Centre.

Notice the words of Article 1: "India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States." The Constitution never calls India a "federal state". The word "Union" signals that the country is one whole, not a club of States that joined and could leave.

Feature 4: who really runs the government?

India follows a parliamentary democracy, adopted from the British system. Think of a cricket team: the captain makes the calls on the field, while the board president hands over the trophy. The selectors can drop the captain if the team stops trusting him.

Who holds real power in a parliamentary system
  • The President is the Head of State but a nominal head, like the board president.
  • Article 74(1): there is a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at its head to aid and advise the President, and the President acts in accordance with that advice. The President may ask the Council to reconsider once, but must then follow the advice given after reconsideration.
  • Article 75(1): the President appoints the Prime Minister, and appoints the other Ministers on the Prime Minister's advice.
  • Article 75(3): the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. It stays in office only while it keeps the Lok Sabha's confidence. The Lok Sabha is the "selectors".

Parliamentary vs presidential. In the USA (presidential system), the President is both the real head and separate from the legislature; Congress cannot remove the President just because it disagrees with his policies. In India the executive comes from the legislature and answers to it every day, through questions, debates and the threat of a no-confidence motion. That close link is the heart of the parliamentary system.

Feature 5: rights, directions and duties

Three parts of the Constitution speak directly to you and to the government:

Claim, aim, duty

Fundamental Rights (Part III): what you can claim. They are justiciable: if one is violated, you can go to court. Article 32 itself guarantees the right to move the Supreme Court to enforce them, and the Court can issue writs of habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto and certiorari. A right with a remedy attached is a real right, not a promise.

Directive Principles (Part IV): what the government should aim for. They were adopted from the Irish Constitution and guide the State towards a welfare state, where wealth is not concentrated in a few hands. Article 37 says they are not enforceable by any court, but they are fundamental in the governance of the country, and it is the State's duty to apply them in making laws.

Fundamental Duties (Part IVA): what you are expected to do. They are in Article 51A. The 42nd Amendment (1976) added a list of 10 duties, and the 86th Amendment (2002) added an 11th, as clause (k).

A simple way to hold them apart: rights are what you can claim, directives are what the government should aim for, duties are what you are expected to do.

Feature 6: one court system, independent of government

One integrated judiciary. Picture a pyramid. The Supreme Court (set up by Article 124) is at the top, a High Court for each State (Article 214) is in the middle, and the lower courts are at the base, with High Courts supervising the courts below them. The USA has two parallel systems of courts, federal and state; India has one pyramid enforcing both Union and State laws.

One judiciary, shaped like a pyramid

The referee between Centre and States. Under Article 131, only the Supreme Court can hear disputes between the Government of India and one or more States, or between States. In a federation, someone neutral must settle such fights; in India that is the Supreme Court.

Independence. Judges are appointed on the basis of their qualifications and cannot be removed easily, so they can rule against the government without fear. The Constitution also tells the State, through Article 50, to separate the judiciary from the executive in the public services, so that the same officer is not both prosecutor and judge.

Judicial review. Because the Constitution is written and supreme, courts can strike down laws and orders that violate it. This idea came from the USA. Its most famous use is the basic structure doctrine, under which courts test even constitutional amendments.

Feature 7: one citizenship, one vote each

Single citizenship. The USA gives its people double citizenship: of the country and of their State. In India you are a citizen of India only, wherever you were born or live. So a person from Bihar can study in Chennai, work in Mumbai and settle in Delhi as an equal citizen everywhere. Single citizenship is one of the threads that hold a diverse country together.

One citizenship, one vote

Universal adult franchise. Every citizen aged 18 or above can vote, whatever their caste, sex, religion, education or wealth. Article 326 bases elections to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies on adult suffrage, and the age of 18 was put there by the 61st Amendment. One person, one vote: a landless labourer's vote counts exactly as much as a billionaire's.

Why was this bold? In 1950 most Indians could not read or write, and many older democracies had given the vote step by step, first to property owners, then to others. India gave it to every adult from the very first election. The framers trusted ordinary people to choose their rulers.

Feature 9: when normal rules pause

The framers knew that some days are not ordinary days. A school runs on its timetable, but during a fire drill everyone follows one set of instructions from one person. The Constitution has three such "drills":

The three emergencies
  1. National Emergency (Article 352): when the security of India is threatened by war, external aggression or armed rebellion.
  2. Failure of constitutional machinery in a State (Article 356): often called President's Rule, when a State government cannot be run according to the Constitution.
  3. Financial Emergency (Article 360): when the financial stability or credit of India is threatened.

During an emergency, the federal structure can work like a unitary one: the Centre gets power to direct the States, and during a National Emergency some Fundamental Rights can be suspended, an idea taken from Weimar Germany.

Why India chose each feature, and what it means for you

Every salient feature was a choice. The framers could have gone another way. Knowing why they chose as they did turns a list of features into an argument you can write in Mains.

Feature Why it was chosen What it means in practice
Long, detailed text A new, diverse country wanted clear rules, not unwritten customs Fewer gaps, but frequent amendments to keep it up to date
Strong Centre (quasi-federal) Partition, princely States and the fear of break-up Union can act fast in a crisis; States often complain of too little room
Parliamentary government Indians knew the British model; it keeps the executive answerable daily Government can fall on a no-confidence vote; PM must keep the Lok Sabha's trust
Justiciable Fundamental Rights Colonial rule had shown power without limits Any person can go to court (Article 32) when a right is violated
Non-justiciable Directive Principles Welfare goals needed money and time; courts could not order them at once They guide laws and policies; voters judge governments on them (Article 37)
Single integrated judiciary One country, one law; avoid conflicting court systems Supreme Court rulings bind all courts; one final umpire for Centre-State disputes (Article 131)
Single citizenship Unity of a country with many regions Equal status everywhere; you can work in any State
Universal adult franchise from day one The framers trusted ordinary people, literate or not Every adult citizen of 18 has an equal vote (Article 326)
Independent referees (EC, CAG) Elections and public money needed neutral guardians Fair elections and audited accounts, outside the control of the ruling party
Emergency provisions War, rebellion or breakdown could threaten the country The system can turn unitary in a crisis, so safeguards against misuse matter

One thread runs through all of them. In 1947 the framers wanted two things at once: unity and safety for a new nation, and freedom and dignity for each citizen. Features like a strong Centre, single citizenship and emergency powers serve the first goal. Rights, adult franchise and independent courts serve the second.

Why this matters today. Most present-day debates are about the balance between these two goals. Examples include Centre-State tensions over money and Governors, how far rights can be limited for security, and how freely emergency-type powers may be used. When you write such an answer, name both goals and show how the Constitution tries to hold them together.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • Written and lengthiest: the original text had 395 Articles, 22 Parts and 8 Schedules, and today there are 12 Schedules; the US Constitution has only 7 Articles.
  • Borrowed: features came from the 1935 Act (federal scheme, Governor, judiciary, PSCs, emergency), Britain (parliamentary system, rule of law, single citizenship, writs), the USA (Fundamental Rights, judicial review, impeachment), Ireland (DPSP, President's election, Rajya Sabha nomination), Canada (strong Centre, residuary powers), Australia (Concurrent List, joint sitting), Weimar Germany (suspension of rights), the USSR (duties), France (liberty, equality, fraternity), South Africa (amendment) and Japan (procedure established by law).
  • Union of States (Art 1): powers are split into three lists (Art 246, Seventh Schedule), residuary powers lie with Parliament (Art 248), and the Governor is appointed by the President (Art 155).
  • Parliamentary system: the Council of Ministers aids and advises the President (Art 74), the President appoints the PM (Art 75(1)), and the Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (Art 75(3)).
  • Rights, directives, duties: Art 32 gives the writs, Art 37 makes DPSPs unenforceable but fundamental, and Art 51A lists 10 duties added by the 42nd Amendment and an 11th added by the 86th.
  • Judiciary: there is a Supreme Court (Art 124) and a High Court for each State (Art 214); the Supreme Court settles Centre-State disputes (Art 131), and the judiciary is to be separate from the executive (Art 50).
  • Citizenship and vote: India has single citizenship, and adult suffrage begins at 18 (Art 326, 61st Amendment).
  • Independent bodies: these include the Election Commission (Art 324), the CAG (Art 148) and the Public Service Commissions (Art 315).
  • Emergencies: the three kinds are in Articles 352, 356 and 360.
  • Amendment: Article 368 sets the procedure, and amendments fall into three categories.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 16 answered

  1. 'India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States' is in:

  2. Fundamental Duties are contained in:

  3. The Directive Principles of State Policy were adopted from the Constitution of:

  4. Match the feature with the source it was borrowed from: A. Judicial review B. Residuary powers with the Centre C. Single citizenship D. Nomination of members to Rajya Sabha 1. Britain 2. Canada 3. USA 4. Ireland

  5. Consider the following statements: 1. The Concurrent List was borrowed from the Australian Constitution. 2. The idea of Fundamental Duties came from the Constitution of the former Soviet Union. 3. 'Procedure established by law' was borrowed from the Constitution of the USA. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  6. Which of these is a feature of Indian citizenship?

  7. Financial Emergency is provided for in:

  8. The 11th Fundamental Duty, clause (k) of Article 51A, was added by the:

  9. Consider the following statements: 1. In India's parliamentary system, the President is the nominal head of the State. 2. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  10. Article 1 of the Constitution describes India as:

  11. Which Article guarantees the right to move the Supreme Court for enforcement of Fundamental Rights?

  12. Consider the following statements about the Directive Principles: 1. They are not enforceable by any court. 2. They are fundamental in the governance of the country. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  13. Residuary powers of legislation in India rest with:

  14. The Governor of a State is appointed by:

  15. A dispute between the Government of India and a State goes, under Article 131, to:

  16. The Comptroller and Auditor-General of India can be removed from office:

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The Indian Constitution is federal in form but unitary in spirit.' Comment. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Federal: two levels, three lists, Supreme Court for disputes
    • Unitary: powers favour Union, Governors appointed by Union, one judiciary, single citizenship, emergencies
    • Conclusion: quasi-federal by design after Partition; States keep real powers in normal times
  2. 'India is federal in form but unitary in spirit.' Critically examine. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Federal: two levels, three lists (Art 246), rigid federal amendment, Art 131
    • Unitary: Union bias, residuary Art 248, Governor Art 155-156, single judiciary and citizenship, emergencies
    • Reasons: Partition, integration of princely States
    • Normal times: real State powers; quasi-federal, cooperative federalism

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Why is India called quasi-federal?

Powers are divided between the Union and the States through three lists, but more powers go to the Union. The Constitution also calls India a 'Union of States' and never uses the word 'federal'.

How long was the original Indian Constitution?

It had 395 Articles, 22 Parts and 8 Schedules, which makes it the lengthiest written constitution in the world. The US Constitution has only 7 Articles.

From which country did India borrow the Directive Principles?

From the Irish Constitution. They aim at a welfare state without concentration of wealth in a few hands.

Who holds real executive power under the Indian Constitution?

The Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister, which is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The President is the nominal head, as in the British system.