CSBC Special Branch · Module 48 · standard depth · 14 min
Syllogisms
What CSBC Special Branch asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Paper 1: Reasoning 50, English 30, Hindi 20 · Reasoning and mental ability
CSBC Special Branch questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for CSBC Special Branch. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: what follows and what does not
A notice says, "All clerks in this office are graduates." Someone then says, "So all graduates in this office are clerks." Most people sense at once that this is wrong. The officers, too, may be graduates, so the second claim does not follow from the first.
Syllogism questions test exactly this sense, but in a careful and checkable way. You get two or three statements and two or more conclusions. You must decide which conclusions must be true if the statements are true, even when the statements sound odd, such as "All pens are trees".
Why the statements can be strange. The examiner wants to test your reasoning, not your general knowledge. If a statement said "All roses are flowers", you might mark conclusions from what you already know. Strange statements force you to use only what is written.
What this chapter does. We learn the four kinds of statements, a picture method using circles, the rules for turning statements around and for joining two of them, and the special "either or" case. By the end, every syllogism becomes a quick drawing exercise.
The four statements and their pictures
Groups as circles. Each term, such as "pens" or "books", stands for a group of things. We draw each group as a circle. A statement tells us how two circles sit with respect to each other.
| Statement | What it says | Picture |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | Every A is inside B | A circle inside B, or A and B the same circle |
| No A is B | A and B share nothing | Two separate circles |
| Some A are B | At least one A is a B | Circles that overlap, with the overlap sure to hold something |
| Some A are not B | At least one A lies outside B | Part of A sure to lie outside B |
What "some" means. In logic, "some" means at least one, and it does not rule out "all". "Some pens are books" is still true if every pen is a book. Words like "a few", "at least one" and "many" are read the same way.
The golden rule. A conclusion follows only if it is true in every picture that fits the statements. If you can draw even one fitting picture where the conclusion fails, it does not follow. If it is true in some pictures but not others, it is only possible.
Why it matters. Most errors come from drawing just one picture and reading the answer from it. The habit of asking "can I draw it another way?" is the whole skill.
Turning a statement around
All A are B. From "All clerks are graduates" we get "Some graduates are clerks", because the clerks are graduates. We cannot get "All graduates are clerks". So "All A are B" turns around only into "Some B are A".
No A is B. "No cat is a dog" means the two circles are apart. Then "No dog is a cat" is equally true. This statement turns around fully.
Some A are B. "Some boys are players" means at least one person is both. That same person shows "Some players are boys". This statement also turns around fully.
Some A are not B. "Some fruits are not apples" is true, because bananas exist. But "Some apples are not fruits" is false. This form cannot be turned around at all, and exams test this often.
Why it matters. Many conclusions are just one statement turned around. Knowing the four rules lets you mark them in seconds without drawing anything.
Joining two statements
The middle term. Two statements usually share one term, such as "books" in "All pens are books" and "All books are bags". That shared term links the other two. The conclusion is about the two outer terms, pens and bags.
| First | Second | Conclusion about A and C |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | All B are C | All A are C |
| All A are B | No B is C | No A is C |
| Some A are B | All B are C | Some A are C |
| Some A are B | No B is C | Some A are not C |
| All A are B | Some B are C | Nothing definite |
| Some A are B | Some B are C | Nothing definite |
Why "All + Some" gives nothing. Take "All A are B" and "Some B are C". The C circle may touch the part of B that holds A, or only the part outside A. Both pictures fit, so nothing definite can be said about A and C.
Order matters. "Some A are B" with "All B are C" gives "Some A are C". But "All A are B" with "Some B are C" gives nothing. Always check which statement says "all" and which term it is about.
Why it matters. These six rows cover most two-statement questions. When a pair is not in the table, draw both pictures and test each conclusion.
Either or, and possibility questions
The either-or case. Sometimes neither conclusion follows, yet one of the two must be true. Take "Some kings are queens" and "Some queens are rings", with conclusions "Some kings are rings" and "No king is a ring". Kings and rings either share something or they do not, so exactly one conclusion holds.
The test for either-or. Three things must be true. Neither conclusion follows on its own, both are about the same two terms, and together they cover every case, like "Some A are B" with "No A is B", or "All A are B" with "Some A are not B". If any of the three fails, the answer is "neither".
Possibility questions. Newer papers ask whether a conclusion "can be true". Here the test is reversed: you need just one fitting picture where it holds. From "All A are B", the conclusion "All B can be A" is possible, because A and B may be the same circle.
What can never be possible. A possibility fails if it contradicts a statement. With "No A is B", the possibility "Some A can be B" fails, since the circles must stay apart. Check every possibility against each given statement before marking it.
Why it matters. These two cases decide many close questions. Students who know the either-or test and the reversed rule for possibility gain marks that others lose.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners test it. A file note often says "all such cases" or "some applicants". An officer must see what follows from such words and what does not. A wrong leap from "some" to "all" can deny a benefit to people who deserve it.
Where it shows up. Syllogisms are a regular part of state PSC mental-ability sections and of bank and staff-selection exams. The UPSC aptitude paper tests the same skill through statement-and-conclusion questions and passages that ask what can be inferred. The Venn method also helps in set-counting questions, covered in a later module.
When it goes wrong. The usual slips are using outside knowledge, reversing "Some A are not B", treating "some" as "only some", and marking "either or" when the two conclusions are about different terms. Another is drawing one picture and stopping there.
The habit to build. Draw the most "separate" picture that still fits the statements, since it is the one most likely to break a conclusion. Test each conclusion against it, and then try one more picture before you mark.
Practice set: twelve solved problems
For each problem, choose one answer: only I follows, only II follows, either I or II follows, neither follows, or both follow. Try each problem first, then read the steps.
1. All pens are books, and all books are bags. Conclusions: (I) All pens are bags; (II) Some bags are pens.
All + All gives "All pens are bags", and that turns around into "Some bags are pens". The answer is both follow.
2. Some cats are dogs, and all dogs are rats. Conclusions: (I) Some cats are rats; (II) All rats are cats.
Some + All gives "Some cats are rats". Nothing says every rat is a cat, so the answer is only I follows.
3. All roses are flowers, and no flower is a tree. Conclusions: (I) No rose is a tree; (II) Some trees are roses.
All + No gives "No rose is a tree", which directly contradicts II. The answer is only I follows.
4. Some books are pens, and some pens are chairs. Conclusions: (I) Some books are chairs; (II) All chairs are pens.
Some + Some gives nothing definite, and II goes beyond "some pens are chairs". The two are not a matching pair on the same terms, so the answer is neither follows.
5. All A are B, and some B are C. Conclusions: (I) Some A are C; (II) No A is C.
All + Some gives nothing definite about A and C. But I and II are a complementary pair on A and C, so the answer is either I or II follows.
6. No car is a bus, and all buses are trucks. Conclusions: (I) Some trucks are not cars; (II) No truck is a car.
The trucks that are buses are not cars, so I is definite. Other trucks may be cars, so II does not follow, and the answer is only I follows.
7. All teachers are graduates, and some graduates are doctors. Conclusions: (I) All doctors are teachers; (II) Some doctors are graduates.
"Some graduates are doctors" turns around into II. Nothing supports I, so the answer is only II follows.
8. Some kings are queens, and some queens are rings. Conclusions: (I) Some kings are rings; (II) No king is a ring.
Some + Some gives nothing definite. I and II are a complementary pair on kings and rings, so the answer is either I or II follows.
9. All apples are fruits, and all fruits are sweet. Conclusions: (I) All sweet things are apples; (II) Some sweet things are fruits.
"All fruits are sweet" turns around into II. I reverses an "all" statement, so the answer is only II follows.
10. No stone is a metal, and no metal is wood. Conclusions: (I) No stone is wood; (II) Some stones are wood.
No + No gives nothing definite about stones and wood. I and II cover every case for those two terms, so the answer is either I or II follows.
11. All lions are animals, and no animal is a plant. Conclusions: (I) No lion is a plant; (II) No plant is a lion.
All + No gives I, and a "no" statement turns around fully into II. The answer is both follow.
12. Some boys are players, and all players are tall. Conclusions: (I) All boys are tall; (II) Some tall persons are boys.
Some + All gives "Some boys are tall", which turns around into II. Other boys may be short, so the answer is only II follows.
Quick revision
- Four forms: All A are B, No A is B, Some A are B, Some A are not B.
- "Some" means at least one and may mean all.
- A conclusion follows only if it holds in every fitting picture.
- All turns into Some; No and Some turn around fully; Some-not never turns around.
- All + All = All; All + No = No; Some + All = Some; Some + No = Some-not; All + Some and Some + Some give nothing.
- Either-or needs both conclusions to fail alone, share the same terms and cover every case.
- A possibility needs just one fitting picture and must not contradict any statement.