CSBC Special Branch course‹› 0:00 studied

CSBC Special Branch · Module 20 · standard depth · 15 min

How a law is made: Bills, readings and joint sittings

What CSBC Special Branch asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 2: GS and current affairs 50, Mathematics 30, Bihar GK 20 · General studies and current affairs

CSBC Special Branch questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for CSBC Special Branch. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: how does an idea become a rule?

Suppose a student in your class wants a new rule: "Mobile phones stay in the bag during class." She cannot simply write it on the board and expect everyone to follow it. First she reads her idea out to the class. Then a small group of students looks at it closely and suggests changes, such as "allowed during the computer period".

From idea to law

After that, the whole class votes on the final wording. Even then, the rule is not final until the class teacher signs the rule book. Each step has a purpose: the reading tells everyone what is coming, the small group fixes the details, the vote shows that most students agree, and the signature makes it official.

Parliament makes laws in almost exactly this way. A proposal for a law is called a Bill. It is read and debated, often studied by a committee, and voted on in both Houses. It becomes an Act only after the President gives assent.

This chapter follows a Bill from the day it is introduced to the day it becomes law. It also explains what happens when the two Houses disagree, and why the process has so many steps.

What is a Bill, and who can bring one?

A Bill is a draft of a proposed law. It becomes an Act only after it is passed by both Houses and receives the President's assent. Until then, it is only a proposal, however strongly the government supports it.

Eight kinds of Bills

Who brings it. A Bill moved by a Minister is a Government Bill. A Bill moved by any other member, from the ruling side or the opposition, is a Private Member's Bill. Most laws begin as Government Bills, because the government has a majority in the Lok Sabha and controls most of the House's time.

Where it starts. Under Article 107(1), a Bill may begin in either House. The big exception is the Money Bill, which can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha, because taxes and spending are decided by the House the people elect directly.

Kinds of Bills. By their content, Bills are of eight kinds:

  • Original Bills, which bring in new proposals or policies;
  • Amending Bills, which change an existing Act;
  • Consolidating Bills, which gather the existing laws on one subject into one Act;
  • Expiring Laws (Continuance) Bills, which keep alive an Act that would otherwise end on a fixed date;
  • Repealing Bills, which remove old laws;
  • Bills to replace Ordinances, which turn an ordinance issued by the President into a regular law;
  • Constitution (Amendment) Bills;
  • Money Bills and Financial Bills.

Three readings in each House

A Bill does not pass in one go. In each House it goes through three readings, and each reading asks a different question.

Three readings in each House

First reading: "Should this be put before the House?" The member asks for leave to introduce the Bill. Once the House grants leave, the Bill is introduced. Usually there is no debate on its details at this stage; the Bill is simply placed on record.

Second reading: "Is this a good law, and is every clause right?" This is the longest and most important stage. It has two parts:

  • First comes a general discussion on the principles of the Bill. At this point the House can decide to take it up straight away, refer it to a Select Committee of that House or a Joint Committee of both Houses, or circulate it to get public opinion.
  • Then the House takes up the Bill clause by clause, and members move amendments to each clause.

When a Bill is sent to a committee, the Chairman and the Speaker ordinarily give the committee three months to report. The committee can call experts, hear the people affected and suggest changes, which is much harder to do on the floor of a crowded House.

Third reading: "Should the House pass it?" The member in charge moves that the Bill be passed. Only formal, verbal or consequential amendments are allowed now; the time for changing the substance is over. If the motion is carried, the Bill goes to the other House, where the same three stages are repeated.

How many votes does a Bill need?

Not every Bill needs the same support. The rule depends on how serious the change is.

How many votes does a Bill need?

Ordinary Bills. An ordinary Bill is passed by a simple majority of the members present and voting. If 300 members vote, 151 votes in favour are enough. Members who are absent, or present but not voting, are not counted.

Constitution Amendment Bills. Changing the Constitution needs much more. Under Article 368, such a Bill must win, in each House separately, a majority of the total membership of that House and at least two-thirds of the members present and voting. Some amendments also need ratification by the State Legislatures.

This high bar is real, not a formality. In 1970, the Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill failed in the Rajya Sabha by just one vote, even though more members voted for it than against it. It did not reach two-thirds of those present and voting.

Money Bills. A Money Bill is passed by the Lok Sabha by a simple majority. The Rajya Sabha can only recommend amendments, and it must return the Bill within fourteen days. If it does not, the Bill is deemed passed by both Houses in the form the Lok Sabha passed it. The full rules on money and the budget are explained in the chapter on how Parliament controls money.

When the two Houses disagree: the joint sitting

India has two Houses, and sometimes they do not agree. If the Lok Sabha passes a Bill and the Rajya Sabha blocks it, the Bill could get stuck forever. Article 108 gives a way out: a joint sitting of both Houses.

When the Houses disagree

When it can be called. The President may summon a joint sitting in three situations:

  1. one House rejects a Bill passed by the other;
  2. the two Houses finally disagree on the amendments to be made;
  3. more than six months pass after the other House receives the Bill without it being passed.

Where it cannot be used. There is no joint sitting for a Money Bill, because the Rajya Sabha cannot block it anyway, or for a Constitution Amendment Bill, which must pass each House on its own.

Only three joint sittings so far

How it works. The joint sitting is presided over by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha (Article 118(4)). The question is decided by a majority of the total members of both Houses present and voting. Because the Lok Sabha has roughly twice as many members as the Rajya Sabha, the side with a majority in the Lok Sabha usually has the advantage.

How often has it happened? Very rarely. There have been only three joint sittings:

  • May 1961: the Dowry Prohibition Bill, 1959;
  • May 1978: the Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill, 1977;
  • 26 March 2002: the Prevention of Terrorism Bill, 2002.

The last step: the President's assent

Once both Houses have passed a Bill, it goes to the President. Under Article 111, the President has three choices:

The President's three choices
  • give assent, and the Bill becomes an Act;
  • withhold assent, and the Bill does not become law;
  • return the Bill to Parliament with a message asking it to reconsider the Bill or some of its provisions.

The third choice has two limits. A Money Bill cannot be returned, because it comes to Parliament only after the government has prepared it. And if the Houses pass the returned Bill again, with or without amendments, the President must give assent. So the President can make Parliament think twice, but cannot block it for ever.

Constitution Amendment Bills are different again. When Parliament passes such a Bill in the prescribed manner, the President is bound to give assent. The Constitution trusts the special majority more than it trusts any single office.

Private members' Bills, and what happens to pending Bills

Private Members' Bills. Any member who is not a Minister can bring a Bill. Such a Bill needs one month's notice, unless the presiding officer allows a shorter period, and it is taken up only on the days set aside for private members' business. These Bills let members raise issues the government has not taken up.

Prorogation vs dissolution

Very few of them become law. Since 1952, only 14 Private Members' Bills have reached the statute book, and five of them began in the Rajya Sabha. Even so, they matter: a Private Member's Bill often starts a public debate, and the government sometimes brings its own Bill on the same subject later.

Prorogation and dissolution. A session ends when the President prorogues the House. Prorogation does not kill pending Bills; they carry over to the next session. But when the Lok Sabha is dissolved, all business pending before it lapses, and a Bill would have to be introduced again in the new House.

Why law-making has so many steps

Each step in the process answers a real risk: a hasty law, a careless clause, or one House or one office acting alone. Read the table as "risk, then answer".

Step Why it is there What it means in practice
Three readings A law passed in one sitting may be careless The principle, the details and the final text are each looked at separately
Select or Joint Committee A crowded House cannot study every clause or hear experts A small group studies the Bill, usually within three months
Two Houses One House alone may act in haste or ignore the States The Rajya Sabha gives a second look; the joint sitting prevents a permanent deadlock
Lok Sabha's edge on money Taxes should be decided by the directly elected House The Rajya Sabha can only recommend changes and must act within 14 days
Special majority for amendments The basic law should not change on a narrow vote Wide agreement is needed in each House; no joint sitting
President's assent A last check before a Bill becomes binding The President can ask once for a rethink, but cannot block Parliament for ever

The big picture. The process balances speed and care. A government with a majority can still make laws, but it has to explain them, face questions, and let the other House and the President look again.

Why it matters today. Debates about Bills passed in a hurry, Bills sent or not sent to committees, and the use of the Money Bill route all turn on these steps. A strong answer names the purpose of a step and then asks whether it is being used as intended.

Quick revision

  • A Bill becomes an Act only after both Houses pass it and the President gives assent.
  • Under Article 107(1) a Bill may start in either House, but a Money Bill can start only in the Lok Sabha.
  • A Minister's Bill is a Government Bill, and any other member's Bill is a Private Member's Bill; only 14 Private Members' Bills have become law since 1952.
  • Each House gives a Bill three readings: introduction with leave, then discussion with a possible committee and clause-by-clause study, then the motion to pass.
  • An ordinary Bill needs a simple majority of members present and voting, while a Constitution Amendment Bill needs a special majority in each House.
  • A joint sitting under Article 108 is summoned by the President, presided over by the Speaker, and has been held only three times (1961, 1978, 2002).
  • Under Article 111, the President may assent, withhold assent, or return a Bill once; a Money Bill cannot be returned.
  • Bills survive prorogation but business pending before the Lok Sabha lapses on dissolution.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 9 answered

  1. A Money Bill can be introduced in:

  2. Who presides over a joint sitting of the two Houses of Parliament?

  3. Consider the statements about a joint sitting under Article 108: 1. It can be called if more than six months pass without the other House passing the Bill. 2. It can be called on a Constitution Amendment Bill. 3. It cannot be called on a Money Bill. Which are correct?

  4. Which of these Bills was NOT passed at a joint sitting?

  5. At which stage of a Bill are amendments to its substance moved clause by clause?

  6. Under Article 111, if Parliament passes again a Bill returned by the President, the President:

  7. What happens to a Bill pending in the Lok Sabha when the House is prorogued?

  8. In 1970, which Bill failed in the Rajya Sabha by a single vote?

  9. Since 1952, about how many Private Members' Bills have become law?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. How does the Constitution resolve a deadlock between the two Houses of Parliament? Assess how often the method has been used. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Article 108: three triggers (rejection, final disagreement, six months)
    • President summons; Speaker presides; majority of members of both Houses present and voting
    • Not for Money Bills or Constitution Amendment Bills
    • Only three joint sittings (1961, 1978, 2002): consensus is the normal route

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

How many joint sittings of Parliament have been held?

Three: on the Dowry Prohibition Bill (1961), the Banking Service Commission (Repeal) Bill (1978) and the Prevention of Terrorism Bill (2002).

When can a joint sitting be called?

When one House rejects a Bill passed by the other, when the Houses finally disagree on amendments, or when more than six months pass without the other House passing it.

What is a Private Member's Bill?

A Bill introduced by any member who is not a Minister. A Bill introduced by a Minister is a Government Bill.

What majority does an ordinary Bill need?

A simple majority of the members present and voting in each House.