CSBC Special Branch course‹› 0:00 studied

CSBC Special Branch · Module 24 · standard depth · 13 min

Panchayati Raj: from Ripon to the 73rd Amendment

What CSBC Special Branch asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 2: GS and current affairs 50, Mathematics 30, Bihar GK 20 · General studies and current affairs

CSBC Special Branch questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for CSBC Special Branch. 9 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: government at your doorstep

Think of the hand pump that has stopped working, the lane that floods every monsoon, or the list of families who will get a house under a scheme. None of these needs a decision from Delhi or even from the State capital. They need a government that is close enough to see the problem and answerable to the people who live with it.

Three levels of government

That is the idea of local self-government. India shares political power among three levels: the Centre, the States and local governments. In villages the local government is the system of Panchayati Raj Institutions, and in towns it is the municipal bodies.

For a long time these bodies existed only under State laws, so a State could ignore them, starve them of money or skip their elections. The 73rd and 74th Amendments of 1992 changed that by giving them a place in the Constitution from 1993. This chapter traces how Panchayati Raj grew, why it failed at first, and what the 73rd Amendment finally guaranteed.

Roots: villages, the British and the Ripon Resolution

An old idea. Village communities in India organised their own institutions to manage their affairs since ancient times. Even under strong empires, village life was left largely to itself. So the idea of a panchayat was not new when modern local government began.

The British framework. Modern, formal local government is more a continuation of the British system than of the older village councils. Lord Mayo's Resolution of 1870 encouraged an elected president in municipalities. Lord Ripon's Resolution of 18 May 1882 then gave local self-government its formal structure, and is often called the foundation of local self-government in India.

Why did the British do it? The purpose was practical. Local bodies gave the colonial administration the backing of local Indian elites. Self-government in the full sense was not the goal.

The Decentralisation Commission. The Royal Commission on Decentralisation (1907) recommended village panchayats with some judicial and administrative powers and a share of land cesses and grants. They were to be under the deputy commissioner, not under the district or local boards.

After Independence: Community Development and the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee

Development from above. Soon after Independence, planners knew that India could not develop unless its villages did. The Community Development Programme (1952) and the National Extension Service set out to attack hunger, poverty, disease and ignorance through self-help. They created a large staff of Block Development Officers (BDOs) and Village Level Workers (VLWs).

The long road to the 73rd Amendment

Why it fell short. The programmes were run by officials, so villagers saw them as the government's projects rather than their own. They also worked in an ad hoc way. The missing piece was people's participation.

The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee. A committee on plan projects under Balwant Rai G. Mehta studied the problem and reported in 1957. Its key idea was "democratic decentralisation". Unless an elected local body was given real power and money, it said, local interest and initiative in development would never be awakened.

Its three tiers:

Tier Body How formed and role
Village Gram Panchayat Directly elected; basic civic and development work
Block Panchayat Samiti Indirectly elected by panchayat members; the key unit for development
District Zila Parishad Samiti heads, MPs, MLAs and officers; advisory and supervisory, coordinating Samitis

Why the block? The Committee said the block was large enough for work a village could not do, yet small enough to keep the interest of its people. So it placed real development power at the Panchayat Samiti.

Acceptance. The National Development Council accepted the recommendations in January 1958, and democratic decentralisation became a national goal. The details were left to each State, so different patterns grew in different States. Nagaur district in Rajasthan was the first place where Panchayati Raj was introduced.

Decline, revival and the demand for a constitutional base

"A god that failed." By the 1960s Panchayati Raj had lost its shine. State politicians did not want to share power with district and village leaders, who might become rivals. The bodies lacked money, staff and real authority, depended on official development staff, and were often captured by dominant castes and richer groups.

Balwant Rai Mehta vs Ashok Mehta

Neglect. By the mid-1970s both the Centre and the States had become indifferent. In most places elections were not held, and sitting councils were dissolved or suspended. Without regular elections, the whole idea of local democracy was hollow.

The Ashok Mehta Committee. In the late 1970s the Janata government, committed to Gandhian ideas, set up a committee under Ashok Mehta. It refused to call Panchayati Raj a failed god, crediting it with making citizens more aware of their rights. Its main proposals were:

  • A two-tier system: the Zila Parishad at the district and Mandal Panchayats below it, each covering a group of villages with 15,000 to 20,000 people.
  • Open participation of political parties in Panchayat elections, to link them with national politics and make them more accountable.
  • Reservation of seats for women and weaker sections.

What happened next. The Janata government fell, and the report was not implemented at the national level. However, non-Congress governments in Karnataka, West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh revived their Panchayats, and Karnataka's system took in most of the Ashok Mehta ideas.

More committees. The C.H. Hanumantha Rao working group (1983) and the G.V.K. Rao Committee (1985) stressed linking Panchayats with development administration. The L.M. Singhvi Committee (1986) wanted them closely involved in rural planning. Both the Singhvi and Ashok Mehta Committees recommended a constitutional basis, because forty years had shown that a State law alone could not protect Panchayats.

The 73rd Amendment: Gram Sabha, three tiers and reservation

What it added. The 73rd Amendment Act, 1992 added Part IX (16 Articles) and the Eleventh Schedule (29 subjects) to the Constitution. It came into force on 24 April 1993, the day now observed as National Panchayati Raj Day. Its aim was a genuine transfer of power, resources and responsibility to rural local bodies.

The three tiers and the Gram Sabha

Gram Sabha (Article 243A). The Gram Sabha is made up of all persons on the electoral roll of the village. It exercises such powers as the State Legislature gives it. Members of a Panchayat change every five years, but the villagers do not, so the Gram Sabha is the only permanent unit of the system.

Three tiers (Article 243B). There are Panchayats at the village, intermediate (block or taluka) and district levels. A State with a population below 20 lakh may choose not to have the intermediate level. The block-level body has different names in different States, such as Taluka Panchayat, Kshetra Panchayat or Janpad Panchayat.

Composition (Article 243C). All seats are filled by direct election from territorial constituencies. State law may also give a seat in the intermediate and district Panchayats to chairpersons of lower tiers and to legislators such as MLAs and MLCs, with the same voting rights. Legislators do not sit in the village Panchayat.

Reservation under Article 243D

Reservation (Article 243D). The Constitution tackles caste and gender exclusion directly:

  1. Seats for SCs and STs in proportion to their population in the Panchayat area.
  2. At least one-third of all seats for women, and one-third of the SC and ST seats for SC and ST women, counted within the women's quota.
  3. Posts of chairpersons are also reserved for SCs, STs and women.
  4. Reserved seats and posts rotate, so that over time every Panchayat gets a chance to be led by a woman.

Backward classes and the 50% line. States may also reserve seats for backward classes. In Krishna Kumar Mishra v State of Bihar (1996), the Patna High Court upheld such reservation but held that total reservation cannot exceed 50% of seats.

Term, elections, money and functions

Five years, no long gaps. Every Panchayat has a five-year term. If it is dissolved earlier, fresh elections must be held within six months. This ended the old habit of keeping Panchayats suspended for years.

What the 73rd Amendment guarantees

State Election Commission. Elections to Panchayats are run by a State Election Commission, separate from the Election Commission of India. The Governor appoints the State Election Commissioner. To protect independence, the Commissioner can be removed only in the manner of a High Court judge.

State Finance Commission. Every five years the State must set up a State Finance Commission. It reviews the finances of Panchayats and recommends how State taxes, duties, tolls and fees should be shared with them, which taxes they may levy, and what grants they should get from the State's Consolidated Fund.

Planning. A District Planning Committee consolidates the plans of Panchayats and municipalities into a draft plan for the whole district. This brings village plans into the State's planning system.

Functions (Article 243G). State law may give Panchayats the powers needed to work as institutions of self-government. They prepare and implement plans for economic development and social justice, including on the 29 subjects of the Eleventh Schedule. These include agriculture, land reform, minor irrigation, drinking water, rural roads, poverty alleviation, primary and secondary education, health, women and child development and the welfare of weaker sections.

Who can contest. A candidate must be on the voters' list of the area and at least 21 years old. States may add disqualifications, which the next chapter examines.

Quick revision

  • Mayo 1870: elected municipal presidents. Ripon, 18 May 1882: formal local self-government. Decentralisation Commission 1907: village panchayats.
  • Community Development 1952: BDOs and VLWs, but no people's participation.
  • Balwant Rai Mehta (report 1957): democratic decentralisation; three tiers; Panchayat Samiti the key unit; NDC, January 1958; first in Nagaur, Rajasthan.
  • Ashok Mehta (late 1970s, Janata): two tiers, Mandal Panchayat for 15,000–20,000 people, parties, reservation.
  • Hanumantha Rao 1983, G.V.K. Rao 1985, L.M. Singhvi 1986; Singhvi and Ashok Mehta asked for constitutional status.
  • 73rd Amendment: Part IX, 16 Articles, Eleventh Schedule 29 subjects; in force 24 April 1993 (National Panchayati Raj Day).
  • 243A Gram Sabha; 243B three tiers, intermediate optional below 20 lakh; 243C direct election; 243D reservation.
  • Five-year term, election within six months of dissolution; SEC (Governor appoints, removal like an HC judge); SFC every five years; minimum age 21.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. 'Democratic decentralisation' was the key recommendation of:

  2. Under the Balwant Rai Mehta scheme, the key unit for development was the:

  3. Consider about the Ashok Mehta Committee: 1. It proposed a two-tier system. 2. It favoured participation of political parties in Panchayat elections. 3. It was set up by the Janata government. Which are correct?

  4. The resolution of 1882 that gave local self-government in India its formal structure is associated with:

  5. Under Article 243B, a State need not constitute Panchayats at the intermediate level if its population is below:

  6. Consider about reservation in Panchayats under Article 243D: 1. SC and ST seats are in proportion to their population in the Panchayat area. 2. Not less than one-third of all seats are reserved for women. 3. Posts of chairpersons cannot be reserved. Which are correct?

  7. The 73rd Amendment added to the Constitution:

  8. Consider: 1. Elections to a dissolved Panchayat must be held within six months. 2. The State Election Commissioner is appointed by the President. 3. A State Finance Commission is constituted every five years. Which are correct?

  9. Which is described as the only permanent unit of the Panchayati Raj system?

  10. Which Schedule of the Constitution of India lists the subjects that may be entrusted to Panchayats?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. Trace the evolution of Panchayati Raj in India from the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee to the 73rd Amendment. Why was constitutional status necessary? (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Community Development's failure; Balwant Rai Mehta 1957, NDC 1958
    • Decline: State resistance, no funds, caste capture, no elections
    • Ashok Mehta: two tiers, parties, reservation; Karnataka, WB, AP
    • Singhvi and Ashok Mehta call for constitutional basis
    • 73rd: Gram Sabha, three tiers, reservation, SEC, SFC, five-year term
    • Constitutional status gave survival and inclusion; autonomy still depends on States

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Where was Panchayati Raj first introduced?

In Nagaur district of Rajasthan, after the National Development Council accepted the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee's ideas in January 1958.

What did the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee recommend?

Democratic decentralisation through three tiers: an elected Gram Panchayat, a Panchayat Samiti at the block, and a Zila Parishad at the district.

Why is Lord Ripon called the father of local self-government?

His Resolution of 18 May 1882 gave local self-government its formal structure in India.

What did the Ashok Mehta Committee propose?

A two-tier system of Zila Parishads and Mandal Panchayats for groups of villages, with participation of political parties.