CSBC Special Branch course‹› 0:00 studied

CSBC Special Branch · Module 19 · standard depth · 18 min

Prime Minister, Council of Ministers and Attorney-General

What CSBC Special Branch asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 2: GS and current affairs 50, Mathematics 30, Bihar GK 20 · General studies and current affairs

CSBC Special Branch questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for CSBC Special Branch. 13 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: the captain and the team

Think of a cricket team. The board names the captain, and the captain picks the playing eleven. During the match, the captain sets the field, changes the bowlers and takes the big calls. If a player keeps dropping catches, the captain can drop that player without breaking up the team.

Captain and team

But the team also wins and loses together. When the team loses badly, nobody says "I bowled well, so the loss is not mine". And if the captain leaves, the old line-up ends and a new team is picked.

India's Prime Minister is that captain, and the Council of Ministers is the team. The President formally appoints them, much like the board, but the real game is run by the PM and the ministers. They answer to the Lok Sabha, which is like the people who can sack the whole side.

This chapter covers how the PM and ministers are appointed, the limits on their number, the difference between the Council and the Cabinet, what the PM does, and what "responsibility to the Lok Sabha" really means. At the end, we meet the government's top lawyer, the Attorney-General.

Aid and advise: where real power sits

Article 74(1) says: "There shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head to aid and advise the President who shall, in the exercise of his functions, act in accordance with such advice." Here we look at it from the Prime Minister's side.

Notice the word "shall". It means the Council of Ministers must always exist; the President cannot function without it. So even when a government resigns, it continues until a new one takes over.

Simply: the President is the constitutional head of State, but the real head of the government is the Prime Minister. Article 77 shows the same split. All executive action is expressed to be taken in the name of the President, but the President makes rules that divide the actual work among the Ministers.

A small amendment point on Article 77: clause (4) was added by the 42nd Amendment and later omitted by the 44th Amendment. So the Article today has only three clauses.

How the Prime Minister is appointed

Article 75(1) says only: "The Prime Minister shall be appointed by the President." It says nothing about majority, party or House. The rule comes from how a parliamentary system works.

How a Prime Minister is chosen

The President does not have a free choice. Normally the President invites the leader of the majority party in the Lok Sabha. If no single party has a clear majority, the President invites the person most likely to win the support of two or more parties that together make a majority.

Once appointed, the PM stays only as long as they keep the support of a majority in the Lok Sabha. That is the real test, not the appointment itself.

Must the PM be from the Lok Sabha? Usually yes, but not always. Several Rajya Sabha members have become PM: Indira Gandhi (first appointed in 1966), I. K. Gujral (1997) and Manmohan Singh (2004).

A PM from neither House. In 1996, H. D. Deve Gowda was not a member of either House when he became PM; he later entered the Rajya Sabha.

The six-month rule. Article 75(5) says a Minister who is not a member of either House for six consecutive months stops being a Minister when that period ends. The PM is also a Minister, so the same rule applies. This is how a non-member can be appointed and then get elected or nominated within six months.

The other Ministers: number, oath and pay

Appointment. Under Article 75(1), other Ministers are appointed by the President on the advice of the Prime Minister. The PM tries to give fair representation to regions, religions and caste groups. In a coalition, partner parties also get their share.

The 15 per cent cap. The 91st Amendment, in force from 1 January 2004, added Article 75(1A). The total number of Ministers, including the Prime Minister, cannot be more than 15 per cent of the total members of the Lok Sabha. Note two traps: the PM is counted, and the base is the Lok Sabha only, not both Houses.

Worked example. Suppose the Lok Sabha has 540 members. Then 15 per cent of 540 is 81. So the Council of Ministers, PM included, can have at most 81 members.

No reward for defectors. The same amendment added Article 75(1B). A member disqualified for defection under paragraph 2 of the Tenth Schedule cannot be made a Minister. The bar lasts until the date their term as a member would have ended, or until they are elected again, whichever comes first.

Oath, tenure and pay. Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President (Article 75(2)). Before taking office, the President gives them two oaths: the oath of office and the oath of secrecy, in the forms set out in the Third Schedule (Article 75(4)). Their salaries and allowances are fixed by Parliament by law (Article 75(6)).

Council of Ministers and Cabinet: not the same thing

People often use "Council of Ministers" and "Cabinet" as if they mean the same thing. Clearly that they do not.

Council of Ministers and Cabinet

Three ranks in the Council. They are:

  • Cabinet Ministers: usually senior members of the ruling party or coalition, heading major ministries.
  • Ministers of State: next in rank. Some have independent charge of a department; others assist Cabinet Ministers.
  • Deputy Ministers: sometimes appointed to assist Ministers.

The Cabinet is the inner circle. The Cabinet is "an inner body within the Council of Ministers". It meets often, is chaired by the PM and decides all policy matters. Ministers outside the Cabinet normally do not attend its meetings.

Point Council of Ministers Cabinet
Who is in it All ranks: Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State, Deputy Ministers Senior Ministers only
Size Can be more than 70 About 15 to 30
How often it meets Rarely as a whole As often as needed
Role Collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (Art 75(3)) Decides policy and acts in the Council's name

The word "Cabinet". The word "Cabinet" was not in the Constitution before the 44th Amendment. The Cabinet grew mostly as a practice of parliamentary government.

When the PM goes, everyone goes. If the Prime Minister dies or resigns, the whole Council of Ministers goes out of office. The PM creates the Council and heads it, so it cannot outlive the PM.

What the Prime Minister does

The PM is "the most important and powerful functionary" of the Union Government. The work falls into four groups.

North Block and South Block, New Delhi; the PM's Office is in South Block
North Block and South Block, New Delhi; the PM's Office is in South BlockPhoto: Nikhilb239, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

1. Head of the team.

  • Chooses the Ministers who are then sworn in by the President, and they remain Ministers as long as they keep the PM's confidence.
  • Distributes portfolios and can change them at will.
  • Can drop a Minister or ask for a resignation.

2. Head of the Cabinet.

  • Presides over Cabinet meetings and largely shapes its decisions.
  • Coordinates the work of different ministries and settles disagreements between Ministers.

3. Link with the President (Article 78). The Constitution puts three duties on the PM:

  • (a) to communicate to the President all decisions of the Council of Ministers about the administration of the Union and proposals for legislation;
  • (b) to furnish information on these matters that the President calls for; and
  • (c) if the President asks, to place before the Council any matter that a single Minister decided without the Council considering it.

The President makes important appointments on the PM's advice. It is also on the PM's advice that the President summons and prorogues Parliament and dissolves the Lok Sabha.

4. Leader in Parliament and the nation. The PM is the chief spokesperson of government policy in Parliament and defends Ministers who cannot defend themselves. At election time, the PM seeks the people's mandate. The PM plays a key role in foreign policy and represents India at international meetings.

Personality matters. The PM's real power depends on personality and political situation. A leader with a strong party majority is far more effective than one who depends on support from outside the party.

Responsibility to the Lok Sabha

On paper, Ministers hold office "during the pleasure of the President" (Article 75(2)). In practice, They are responsible to, and removable by, the Lok Sabha. Article 75(3) says so directly: the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the House of the People.

Ministerial responsibility is the essential feature of parliamentary government. It has two sides: collective and individual.

Collective and individual responsibility

Collective responsibility has two meanings.

Collective vs individual responsibility

First: one voice. Every member of the Council accepts responsibility for every Cabinet decision. Once the Cabinet decides, each Minister must stand by it in public. A Minister who disagrees has only one option: resign. In a well-known phrase, Ministers "swim and sink together".

Second: one fate. A vote of no-confidence against the PM is a vote against the whole Council of Ministers. In the same way, if the Lok Sabha defeats a government Bill or the budget, it shows lack of confidence in the entire Council, not just the Minister who moved it.

No-confidence motion. It is a motion moved by a member expressing the House's lack of confidence in the Council of Ministers. If it is adopted, the Council of Ministers has to resign.

Individual responsibility. Ministers are also responsible one by one. If a Minister's action, taken without the Cabinet or PM agreeing, is criticised and not approved by Parliament, or if their personal conduct is improper, they may have to resign. This happens without bringing down the government. And if a Minister becomes a liability, the PM can ask them to quit.

A simple way to remember it: collective responsibility means the whole boat sinks. Individual responsibility means one passenger steps off and the boat sails on.

The Attorney-General: the government's top lawyer

Every government needs legal advice. Under Article 76, the Attorney-General for India is the highest law officer of the Union.

The Attorney-General at a glance

Appointment and qualification (76(1)). The President appoints a person who is qualified to be appointed a Judge of the Supreme Court. The AG does not need to be a sitting judge, only someone who meets that standard.

Duties (76(2)). The AG:

  • advises the Government of India on legal matters referred by the President;
  • performs other legal duties assigned by the President; and
  • carries out functions given by the Constitution or any other law.

Right of audience (76(3)). In doing this work, the AG has the right of audience in all courts in the territory of India. "Right of audience" means the right to appear and be heard.

Tenure and pay (76(4)). The AG holds office during the pleasure of the President and gets the remuneration the President decides. The Constitution fixes no term.

In Parliament (Article 88). Every Minister and the Attorney-General may speak in and take part in the proceedings of either House, a joint sitting, and any committee they are named to. But Article 88 does not give them a vote. This is why the AG, who is not an MP, can still address Parliament, while a Minister who is an MP votes only in their own House as a member.

Why the PM and Ministers work under these rules

Each rule in this chapter answers a question that every parliamentary democracy faces: how do you give a government enough power to act, but keep it answerable every day?

Rule Why it is there What it means in practice
Council of Ministers "shall" exist (Art 74) The President must never act alone A caretaker government continues until a new one is formed
Collective responsibility (Art 75(3)) The elected House must be able to remove the government A no-confidence vote ends the whole Council
Six-month rule (Art 75(5)) Allow talent from outside, but keep Ministers inside Parliament A non-member must win or get a seat within six months
15 per cent cap (91st Amendment, 2004) Very large ministries strain public money and reward loyalty A ceiling on the size of the team, PM included
Defectors barred (Art 75(1B)) Without a bar, a ministry could be offered as a reward for defecting Defection cannot be rewarded with a ministry
Oath of secrecy (Art 75(4)) Cabinet discussions must be frank Ministers cannot reveal Cabinet matters
PM's duties to inform (Art 78) The President's formal role needs real information The President can ask questions and refer a Minister's decision to the Council
Attorney-General (Art 76, 88) The government needs top legal advice, including in Parliament The AG advises, appears in all courts and can speak in both Houses, without a vote

The core idea: power with a leash. The PM and Cabinet hold most real power, but every rule above ties that power back to the Lok Sabha, and through it to the voters. Remove collective responsibility and India would drift towards a presidential system.

Why the 2003 reforms matter. The 91st Amendment tackled two old problems together: oversized ministries and defection for office. Both damaged public trust. Its rules are a good example of the Constitution being amended to fix a practice that had gone wrong.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • Under Art 74(1), there shall be a Council of Ministers with the PM at its head to aid and advise the President; the word "shall" means it must always exist.
  • Under Art 75(1), the President appoints the PM, and other Ministers on the PM's advice. The PM is the majority leader or the person who can win majority support; PMs came from the Rajya Sabha in 1966, 1997 and 2004, and Deve Gowda in 1996 was in neither House.
  • Under Art 75(1A), total Ministers including the PM cannot exceed 15% of the Lok Sabha's strength, and under Art 75(1B) defectors are barred from office; both came with the 91st Amendment (w.e.f. 1 Jan 2004).
  • Under Art 75(2), Ministers hold office during the President's pleasure, and under 75(3) they are collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. 75(4) sets the oaths of office and secrecy (Third Schedule), under 75(5) a non-member Minister must leave after six consecutive months, and under 75(6) Parliament fixes their pay.
  • Under Art 77, all action is taken in the President's name under business rules; clause (4) was added by the 42nd Amendment and omitted by the 44th.
  • Under Art 78, the PM must communicate decisions to the President, furnish information and, if asked, refer a single Minister's decision to the Council.
  • The Council has Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State and Deputy Ministers; the Cabinet is its inner body, and the PM's exit ends the whole Council.
  • Under Art 76, the AG must be qualified to be an SC judge, advises the Government of India, has a right of audience in all courts and holds office at the President's pleasure, with no fixed term. Under Art 88, Ministers and the AG can speak in both Houses, but have no vote under this Article.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 7 answered

  1. Under Article 75(1A), the total number of Ministers in the Union Council of Ministers, including the PM, cannot exceed:

  2. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to:

  3. Consider the following statements about Ministers: 1. A person who is not a member of either House can be appointed a Minister. 2. Such a person ceases to be a Minister if not a member of either House for six consecutive months. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  4. Which Article lays down the duty of the Prime Minister to communicate Council of Ministers' decisions to the President?

  5. Consider the following statements about the Attorney-General for India: 1. The Attorney-General must be qualified to be appointed a Judge of the Supreme Court. 2. The Attorney-General holds office for a fixed term of five years. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  6. Under Article 88, the Attorney-General of India can:

  7. Which statement about the Cabinet is correct?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'Collective responsibility is the bedrock of parliamentary government in India.' Explain. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Art 75(3): Council answerable to the Lok Sabha; no-confidence motion
    • One voice: defend Cabinet decisions or resign
    • Links the real executive to the people's House (Art 74, 75)
    • Limits: large majorities; need for individual responsibility

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What is the maximum size of the Council of Ministers?

The total number of Ministers, including the Prime Minister, cannot exceed 15 per cent of the Lok Sabha's total membership, under Article 75(1A) added by the 91st Amendment.

To which House is the Council of Ministers responsible?

Only to the Lok Sabha, under Article 75(3). A no-confidence vote there is against the whole Council.

Can a non-member of Parliament become a Minister?

Yes, but under Article 75(5) a Minister who is not a member of either House for six consecutive months ceases to be a Minister.

What is collective responsibility?

Every Minister stands by every Cabinet decision or resigns. A defeat of the government in the Lok Sabha is a defeat of the whole Council, so Ministers swim and sink together.