CSBC Special Branch course‹› 0:00 studied

CSBC Special Branch · Module 17 · standard depth · 16 min

The Union and its territory

What CSBC Special Branch asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper 2: GS and current affairs 50, Mathematics 30, Bihar GK 20 · General studies and current affairs

CSBC Special Branch questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for CSBC Special Branch. 10 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: one house, many rooms

Think of a big family house. It has many rooms, and over the years the family knocks down a wall, adds a room, or gives a room a new name. The rooms keep changing, but the house stays one house. No room can pick itself up and walk away.

A family home with rooms that can be rebuilt

India works like that house. The rooms are the States. The house is the Union. The Constitution lets Parliament redraw the rooms, but no State can leave the Union.

This chapter reads the first four Articles of the Constitution. They answer three simple questions: What is India called? What does its territory include? Who can change the map, and how?

By the end you will know why India is a "Union of States", how Telangana or Jharkhand were created, and why such changes do not need the hard process of a constitutional amendment.

India, that is Bharat: a Union of States

Article 1(1) opens Part I with one sentence: "India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States." So the Constitution gives the country two names, India and Bharat, and both are official.

"Union of States": two meanings

Why "Union" and not "Federation"? The words "Union of States" carry two meanings. First, the Union is not the result of an agreement among the States. The States did not come together and sign a pact to form India. Second, the States have no freedom to secede, that is, to break away from the Union.

The Constitution of the Union and the States is one single framework. Neither can get out of it, and both must work within it. That is why the Indian federation is called indestructible.

Compare with the house. In the family house, the rooms came out of the house; the house did not come out of the rooms. In the same way, in India the States are units of the Union. They were not separate countries that joined together.

What does the territory of India include?

Article 1(2) says the States and their territories are listed in the First Schedule. Article 1(3) then says the territory of India has three parts:

The eight Union territories
  • (a) the territories of the States;
  • (b) the Union territories listed in the First Schedule; and
  • (c) such other territories as may be acquired.

Two words to keep apart. "Union of States" in Article 1(1) covers only the States. "Territory of India" in Article 1(3) is wider: it covers States, Union territories and acquired territories. A Union territory is part of India's territory, but it is not a State.

The count today. The Constitution pocket edition, as on 1 May 2024, lists 28 States and 8 Union territories in the First Schedule. The 8 UTs are Delhi, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep, Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu, Puducherry, Chandigarh, Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh.

Union of States vs territory of India

Clause (c) in practice. Territories that India acquires later become part of its territory under clause (c). For example, the First Schedule describes Puducherry as the former French Establishments of Pondicherry, Karikal, Mahe and Yanam. It also describes Dadra and Nagar Haveli as the former "Free Dadra and Nagar Haveli".

Article 2: admitting or establishing new States

Article 2 says: "Parliament may by law admit into the Union, or establish, new States on such terms and conditions as it thinks fit."

Article 2 vs Article 3. Article 2 is about areas that are not yet part of India being brought in as States. Article 3 is about reshaping States that already exist inside India. Keep this split clear, because statement questions often mix the two.

The Sikkim story. For a short time the Constitution had an Article 2A, "Sikkim to be associated with the Union". It was inserted by the 35th Amendment, in force from 1 March 1975. Within weeks, the 36th Amendment omitted it, from 26 April 1975, and Sikkim became a full State.

So Article 2A is today a blank entry in the Constitution. The exam may ask which amendment made Sikkim an "associate" and which ended that status.

Article 3: Parliament redraws the map

Article 3 gives Parliament five powers. By law, Parliament may:

How a new State is made
  • (a) form a new State, by separating territory from a State, by uniting two or more States or parts of States, or by uniting any territory to a part of a State;
  • (b) increase the area of a State;
  • (c) diminish the area of a State;
  • (d) alter the boundaries of a State; and
  • (e) alter the name of a State.

The proviso: two conditions. The proviso was substituted by the 5th Amendment, in force from 24 December 1955. It says such a Bill can be introduced in either House only on the recommendation of the President. And if the Bill affects the area, boundaries or name of a State, the President must first refer it to that State's Legislature to express its views within a period the President fixes. The period can be extended.

Views, not consent. Notice the exact words. The State Legislature gives its views, and the condition is only that the period has expired. The text does not say Parliament must accept those views, or that the State must agree. So Parliament can create, split or rename a State even if the State's Legislature disagrees.

Union territories too. The 18th Amendment, in force from 27 August 1966, added two Explanations. Explanation I: in clauses (a) to (e), "State" includes a Union territory, but in the proviso it does not. So a UT's views need not be sought. Explanation II: Parliament can form a new State or Union territory by uniting a part of a State or UT with another.

Article 4: why this is not a "constitutional amendment"

When a new State is made, the Constitution itself must change. The First Schedule lists the States, and the Fourth Schedule gives each State its seats in the Rajya Sabha. So the map change must reach both Schedules.

Article 4(1) handles this. Any law under Article 2 or 3 shall contain provisions to amend the First and Fourth Schedules as needed. It may also add supplemental, incidental and consequential provisions, including on representation in Parliament and in the Legislatures of the affected States.

Article 4(2) is the key line: no such law "shall be deemed to be an amendment of this Constitution for the purposes of article 368". Article 368 is the amendment Article, which needs a special majority. So a law to create or reshape a State is passed like an ordinary law, by a simple majority, even though it changes the Schedules.

Worked example. When Parliament passed the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014, it created Telangana, in force from 2 June 2014. The First Schedule footnote shows that this Act itself inserted Telangana into the list. No separate constitutional amendment under Article 368 was needed.

Redrawing the map: the story in the First Schedule

The footnotes of the First Schedule are a short history of India's map. Each change below was made by an Act of Parliament using Articles 3 and 4, except the 1956 change, which came through the 7th Amendment.

Redrawing the map, 1956 to 2019
Date in force Change Law
1 November 1956 Whole First Schedule replaced; Part A and Part B States ended 7th Amendment
1 May 1960 Gujarat and Maharashtra formed Bombay Reorganisation Act 1960
1 November 1966 Haryana formed; Chandigarh made a UT Punjab Reorganisation Act 1966
14 January 1969 Madras renamed Tamil Nadu Madras State (Alteration of Name) Act 1968
1 November 1973 Mysore renamed Karnataka Mysore State (Alteration of Name) Act 1973
1, 9 and 15 November 2000 Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand (then Uttaranchal) and Jharkhand formed Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar Reorganisation Acts 2000
1 November 2011 Orissa renamed Odisha Orissa (Alteration of Name) Act 2011
2 June 2014 Telangana formed Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act 2014
31 October 2019 J&K removed from States; UTs of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh added Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act 2019
19 December 2019 Dadra and Nagar Haveli merged with Daman and Diu Merger of Union territories Act 2019

Other renamings. Uttaranchal became Uttarakhand from 1 January 2007, and Pondicherry became Puducherry from 1 October 2006.

One pattern to notice. Every row after 1956 is an ordinary Act of Parliament, not an Article 368 amendment. This is Article 4(2) at work.

A worked example: the birth of Jharkhand

Let us walk through one real case step by step, using only what the Constitution's text and First Schedule show.

The birth of Jharkhand, step by step

Step 1: the power. Article 3(a) lets Parliament form a new State by separating territory from any State. Here the territory came from Bihar.

Step 2: the procedure. Under the proviso, the Bill needed the President's recommendation. Since it affected Bihar's area and boundaries, it had to be referred to the Bihar Legislature for its views first.

Step 3: the law. Parliament passed the Bihar Reorganisation Act, 2000. The First Schedule footnote shows that this Act changed Bihar's entry, in force from 15 November 2000, and Jharkhand appears as a separate State in the list.

Step 4: the Schedules. As Article 4(1) requires, the Act changed the First Schedule (the list of States) and the Fourth Schedule (Rajya Sabha seats). Under Article 4(2), none of this counted as an Article 368 amendment.

Common traps in this topic

Statement True or false Why
"Territory of India" and "Union of India" mean the same False Territory also has UTs and acquired areas (Art 1(3))
A State's consent is needed to change its boundary False Only its views within a period (Art 3 proviso)
The Bill can be introduced by any MP without the President False Needs the President's recommendation
Creating a State needs a special majority under Art 368 False Art 4(2): not an amendment for Art 368
Parliament can change the name of a State True Art 3(e)
A UT's views must be sought before changing it False Explanation I: "State" in the proviso excludes UTs

Why the Union was designed this way, and what it means

Articles 1 to 4 look like simple definitions. But each one carries a choice the framers made after Partition, when keeping India together was the first worry.

Rule Why it is there What it means in practice
"Union of States", not "federation" (Art 1) The Union was not a pact among States, so no State could claim a right to leave Secession has no constitutional route; the Union is indestructible
"Territory of India" wider than the States (Art 1(3)) Some areas, such as small or strategic ones, are better run directly by the Union Union territories and acquired areas are fully part of India without being States
Parliament can redraw States (Art 3) Old provincial borders did not match language, culture or administration New States like Gujarat, Haryana, Jharkhand and Telangana could be created by law
State gives views, not consent (Art 3 proviso) A State could otherwise block the creation of a new State from its own territory The national Parliament has the final word, after hearing the State
President's recommendation (Art 3 proviso) Changing the map is serious; it should come through the government, not a private member Only a government-backed Bill can reshape a State
Not an amendment for Art 368 (Art 4(2)) Reorganising States should not need the hardest amendment process Map changes pass by simple majority, even though they alter the Schedules

The trade-off. This design gives the country flexibility: it can respond to people's demands for new States without long delays. The price is that States have less protection for their own borders than in a classic federation such as the USA.

Why it matters today. Demands for new States, the 2019 change in Jammu and Kashmir, and border or name disputes all turn on Articles 3 and 4. A good answer explains both the unity these Articles protect and the consultation they expect, even when the text does not demand consent.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • Art 1(1) "India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States." It did not come from an agreement, there is no right to secede, and it is indestructible.
  • Art 1(3) says the territory of India is made up of the States, the Union territories and any acquired territories. The First Schedule (as on 1 May 2024) lists 28 States and 8 UTs.
  • Art 2 lets Parliament admit or establish new States from areas not yet in India. Art 2A on Sikkim was added by the 35th Amendment (1 Mar 1975) and omitted by the 36th (26 Apr 1975).
  • Art 3 lets Parliament form States, increase or diminish their area, and alter their boundaries or names. Its proviso (5th Amendment, 1955) requires the President's recommendation and a reference to the State Legislature for its views within a set period.
  • The Explanations (18th Amendment, 1966) say that "State" includes a UT in clauses (a) to (e), but not in the proviso.
  • Under Art 4, such a law also amends the First and Fourth Schedules; by 4(2) it is not an amendment for Art 368, so a simple majority is enough.
  • The 7th Amendment (1 Nov 1956) replaced the First Schedule. Telangana was formed on 2 Jun 2014, and the UTs of J&K and Ladakh on 31 Oct 2019.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 7 answered

  1. Article 1 of the Constitution describes India as a:

  2. Consider the following statements about Article 1: 1. The territory of India includes Union territories. 2. The 'Union of States' includes Union territories. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. Consider the following statements about Article 3: 1. A Bill to alter the boundary of a State can be introduced only on the recommendation of the President. 2. Parliament cannot pass such a Bill if the State Legislature opposes it. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  4. A law under Article 3 to create a new State is passed by:

  5. Article 2A, which associated Sikkim with the Union, was omitted by the:

  6. Under Explanation I to Article 3, the word 'State' in the proviso:

  7. Telangana came into existence as a State on:

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'India is an indestructible Union of destructible States.' Examine with reference to Articles 1 to 4. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Art 1: Union of States, not from agreement, no secession
    • Art 3: Parliament forms, alters, renames States; views not consent
    • Art 4(2): simple law, not Art 368
    • Examples: 2000, 2014 States; J&K to UTs in 2019; need for consultation

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What does 'Union of States' mean?

The Union is not the result of an agreement among the States, so no State has the freedom to leave it. The federation is indestructible.

Does a State have to agree before its borders are changed?

No. The President must refer the Bill to the State Legislature for its views within a set time, but Parliament is not bound by those views.

Is a law creating a new State a constitutional amendment?

No. Under Article 4(2), a law under Article 2 or 3 is not deemed an amendment for Article 368, so it passes by a simple majority.

What does the territory of India include?

Under Article 1(3): the territories of the States, the Union territories in the First Schedule, and any other territories that may be acquired.