GPSC Class 1-2 · Module 19 · Mains depth · 24 min
Indian philosophy II: Buddhist, Jain, Charvaka and Ajivika thought
What GPSC Class 1-2 asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- General Studies · History and culture of India and Gujarat.
- GS 1 · Cultural heritage of India and Gujarat.
GPSC Class 1-2 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: an age of questions
Imagine a town in the Ganga valley around 2,500 years ago. There are new markets, metal coins and rich merchants, and kings are building bigger states. Yet many people feel lost, because the old clan life that gave them security is breaking up.
Why the old answers stopped working. The Vedic religion of the time centred on the yajna, the sacrifice. Sacrifices had grown long, costly and dependent on priests, and many people doubted they could bring real peace. A king in one Upanishad says he feels "like a frog in a dry well", which shows the mood of the age.
The wanderers. So some people left home to find the truth for themselves. These shramanas and parivrajakas (wandering ascetics) lived on alms, meditated and argued in open halls called kutuhala-shalas, 'places that arouse curiosity'. Many new ideas about the soul, the world and freedom came from these debates.
Two kinds of challengers. In the previous chapter you met the six schools that accept the Vedas. This chapter covers the nastika schools that do not. Jainism and Buddhism set the Vedas aside but still seek liberation, while Charvaka rejects the Vedas, the soul and liberation altogether.
Charvaka: only what you can see is real
The name. The school is called Charvaka and also Lokayata, from 'loka' (this world) and 'ayata' (basis). One meaning of Charvaka is 'sweet-tongued', because its ideas please people. Tradition names Brihaspati as its founder.
A school known through its enemies. No original Charvaka text has survived, except one later work, Jayarashi Bhatta's Tattvopaplavasimha, which defends a sceptical position. Almost everything else we know comes from opponents who quoted Charvaka views only to refute them. So when you read about Charvaka, remember you are often hearing its critics.
Only perception counts. For Charvaka, perception (pratyaksha) is the only valid way to know. It rejects inference (anumana) and testimony (shabda), which other schools accept. Take the famous inference, "where there is smoke there is fire": Charvaka asks how you know this for every kitchen, past and future, when you have seen only a few.
Matter is all. Since only what is perceived is real, the world is made of just four elements: earth, water, fire and air. Charvaka drops the fifth element, ether (akasha), because no one can perceive it. Consciousness is real, but it is only a by-product of matter, the way betel leaf and lime, neither of them red, turn red when chewed together.
No soul, no heaven, no moksha. If consciousness comes from the body, it ends when the body dies. So there is no separate soul, no rebirth, no heaven or hell, and no God. Charvaka keeps only two of the four goals of life, artha (wealth) and kama (pleasure), and rejects dharma and moksha.
Its harsh view of ritual. Charvaka mocked the Vedas and rituals as a way for clever priests to earn a living. It said the wise should enjoy life through honest means such as farming, cattle-keeping, trade and government. Its sayings put a sure pleasure today above an uncertain one tomorrow.
How other schools answered. Critics pointed out that Charvaka cannot even argue without inference. To say "all inference is invalid" is itself a general claim drawn by inference. Some scholars therefore think Charvaka rejected inference only about things never perceived, such as heaven or the soul.
The Ajivikas and the other teachers
The largest rival sect. In the Buddha's time, the Ajivikas were a major ascetic order with a recognised organisation. Their best-known leader was Makkhali Gosala, who taught at Sravasti, the capital of Kosala. He is said to have died sixteen years before Mahavira.
Everything is fixed. The Ajivikas' key idea was niyati, an impersonal destiny that decides everything, even the smallest act. A person's misery ends only after a fixed number of births, and no effort can shorten or lengthen that journey. So they accepted rebirth, but not the idea that one's own karma shapes the next life.
Why this mattered. Buddhists and Jainas attacked niyati hard, because their whole path depends on human effort changing one's future. That debate, between fate and free effort, runs through Indian thought ever since. The Ajivikas also practised fasting and nakedness, like the strictest Jaina monks.
Caves for the Ajivikas. The Ajivikas won royal support. The Lomas Rishi cave in the Barabar Hills near Gaya, Bihar, was cut for them in the Mauryan age, in the 3rd century BCE. Its doorway copies the curved roof of a wooden hut in stone, as you saw in the rock-cut caves chapter.
Four more voices. Buddhist texts name other teachers of the time. Ajita Kesakambalin was a materialist who said everything ends at death, a line later linked with Charvaka. Purana Kassapa taught that actions bring neither merit nor sin, Pakudha Kachchayana said the body breaks into seven eternal elements, and Sanjaya Belatthaputta was a sceptic who refused to commit to any view.
Jainism I: souls, matter and karma
The conqueror. The word Jainism comes from jina, 'conqueror', meaning one who has conquered his passions and desires. Jainism sees itself as an old faith taught by 24 tirthankaras, or 'ford-makers' who build a crossing over the river of rebirth. Rishabha was the first and Vardhamana Mahavira, a contemporary of the Buddha, the 24th and last.
Before Mahavira. Mahavira first followed the path of the Nirgranthas, 'those free from fetters', founded about two centuries earlier by Parshvanatha, the 23rd tirthankara. He gave this older path its classic shape. His life and the later split into Digambaras and Svetambaras are told in the History chapter on Jainism.
Two kinds of things. Jainism sorts the whole universe into jiva and ajiva. Jiva is the conscious soul, and there are countless jivas, not one world-soul; even stones, rocks and running water have souls. Ajiva is everything without life: matter (pudgala), time (kala), space (akasha), dharma, the medium that allows motion, and adharma, the medium that allows rest.
No creator. In Jainism there is no supreme creator God. The universe runs by its own laws, and karma works by itself. The highest beings are perfected souls, the arhats and siddhas, who have freed themselves.
Karma as fine dust. Here Jainism has a very unusual idea: karma is a kind of subtle matter. Every action, especially a cruel one, draws karmic particles into the soul, and this inflow is called asrava; once they stick, that is bandha (bondage). Disciplined conduct stops new inflow (samvara), and penance wears away old karma (nirjara).
Knowledge hidden inside. For Jainas, knowledge is the very nature of the soul, but karma covers it like clouds over the sun. They count five levels of knowledge: mati through the senses and mind, shruta from words and scripture, avadhi (clairvoyance), manahparyaya (knowing other minds) and kevala jnana, perfect omniscience. When every trace of karma is gone, the soul reaches kevala jnana and rises to the top of the universe in endless bliss.
Both lasting and changing. Jainism also takes a middle position on change. The clay stays while the lump becomes a pot: substance lasts while its forms, called paryayas, keep changing. It thus disagrees both with the Upanishadic view that only the unchanging is real and with the Buddhist view that only change is real.
Jainism II: many-sided truth, three jewels, five vows
Six blind men and an elephant. Six blind men touch an elephant: one feels the trunk and says "a snake", another the leg and says "a pillar", another the ear and says "a fan". Each is partly right and none has the whole truth. Jainas use this story to explain anekantavada, the view that reality has many sides.
Standpoints. Every statement is true only from a particular standpoint, called a naya. Taking one standpoint for the whole truth is a mistake. So absolute 'yes' and absolute 'no' are both wrong.
Seven 'maybes'. Jainas put this into a method called syadvada, the doctrine of 'maybe' (syat). It gives seven conditional forms of a statement, also called saptabhangi. These run from "maybe it is", "maybe it is not" and "maybe it is and is not" to "maybe it is inexpressible" and three combinations of these.
The seven forms.
| Form | Meaning |
|---|---|
| syat asti | In some way, it is |
| syat nasti | In some way, it is not |
| syat asti nasti | In some way, it is and is not |
| syat avaktavya | In some way, it cannot be described |
| syat asti avaktavya | It is, and cannot be described |
| syat nasti avaktavya | It is not, and cannot be described |
| syat asti nasti avaktavya | It is, is not, and cannot be described |
Why it matters today. Anekantavada teaches humility: my view is one window, not the whole house. Many writers see in it a philosophical basis for tolerance and dialogue between faiths. Critics in classical times replied that adding up partial truths does not give the whole truth.
The three jewels. The Jain path to freedom is the triratna: right faith (samyag darshana), right knowledge (samyag jnana) and right conduct (samyak charitra). Right faith comes first, because good action with wrong beliefs loses much of its value. The three work together, like three legs of a stool.
Five great vows. To stop new karma, monks take five mahavratas. They are ahimsa (non-injury), satya (truth), asteya (non-stealing), brahmacharya (celibacy) and aparigraha (non-possession). Lay followers keep milder forms called anuvratas.
Ahimsa taken furthest. Jainism took non-violence further than any other tradition. Any act that injures a living being, even unintentionally, draws in karma. That is why the faith even discourages farming, since ploughing and harvesting destroy life in plants and soil.
Buddhism I: the doctor's method
A practical teacher. The Buddha did not want to argue about how the universe began. His teaching was like a doctor's: find the illness, its cause, whether it can be cured, and the medicine.
The Four Noble Truths. First, life contains suffering (dukkha). Second, suffering has a cause, which is craving (tanha): desire, ambition and selfish longing. Third, suffering ends when craving ends, and that state is nirvana; fourth, there is a path to that end.
The Eightfold Path. The path has eight parts: right view, right aim, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness and right concentration. It is a Middle Path between a life of luxury and a life of self-torture. The Buddha had tried both extremes before his awakening and found neither worked.
Dependent origination. The deepest idea behind the Truths is pratityasamutpada, 'dependent origination': nothing exists on its own, and everything arises because of something else. Buddhists describe a chain of twelve links that leads from ignorance to birth, old age and death. Break the first link, ignorance, and the whole chain falls apart.
Three marks of existence. Everything in the world is dukkha (unsatisfying), anicca (impermanent) and anatta (without a permanent soul). A person is only a bundle of five changing parts: body, feelings, perceptions, mental states and awareness. The old man is not quite the same person as the baby he once was, and not even the same as a minute ago.
Rebirth without a soul. If there is no soul, what is reborn? Buddhists answer that nothing passes over, yet a chain of cause and effect links one life to the next. Like a flame lighting another lamp, the new life is caused by the old without being the same thing.
How the teaching was kept. The Buddha's words were sifted at councils held at Rajagriha, Vaishali and Pataliputra. The Pali canon, the Tipitaka, was finally written down in Sri Lanka under King Vattagamani (89-77 BCE). The story of the Buddha's life and the councils is in the History chapter on Buddhism.
Buddhism II: the four later schools
Why schools arose. The Buddha left many deep questions unanswered, so his followers later read his teaching in different ways. Scholars count as many as eighteen early schools in India alone. For study, they are grouped under two broad heads, Hinayana and Mahayana, with two main philosophical schools in each.
A note on names. Mahayana means 'great vehicle', and Hinayana 'small vehicle'. The name Hinayana was given by Mahayana thinkers and sounds belittling, so the older tradition calls itself Theravada, 'teaching of the elders'. In exams both terms appear.
The realists. The Vaibhashika and Sautrantika schools are realists: they hold that objects really exist outside the mind, even if only for a moment. The Vaibhashikas say we see objects directly. The Sautrantikas say we only see a mental copy and infer the object from it, since by the time we perceive it, the moment has passed.
The idealists. The Yogachara school, also called Vijnanavada, says only consciousness (vijnana) is real. Its great teachers were the brothers Asanga and Vasubandhu. It points to dreams, where we see things that are not there, and speaks of a storehouse consciousness (alaya-vijnana) holding the seeds of all past experience.
The middle way of emptiness. The Madhyamika school of Nagarjuna teaches shunyata, 'emptiness'. This does not mean nothing exists; it means nothing exists on its own, because everything depends on something else. Nagarjuna showed that every claim can be pushed into contradiction using a four-cornered method of argument called catushkoti.
The bodhisattva ideal. The biggest practical difference is the ideal of life. The older schools honour the arhat, who reaches nirvana for himself. Mahayana honours the bodhisattva, who delays his own release to help all beings, and it came to revere the Buddha as divine and to worship his image.
Why this mattered for art. This change shaped Indian art. The image of the Buddha and the graceful bodhisattva figures of Gandhara, Mathura and Ajanta grew with Mahayana devotion, as you saw in the stupa and relief art chapter.
| School | Branch | Key idea | Key names |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vaibhashika | Hinayana | Objects real, seen directly | — |
| Sautrantika | Hinayana | Objects real, inferred from mental copies | Kumaralabdha (founder) |
| Yogachara (Vijnanavada) | Mahayana | Only consciousness is real; storehouse consciousness | Asanga, Vasubandhu |
| Madhyamika (Shunyavada) | Mahayana | Emptiness as the middle way | Nagarjuna, Aryadeva |
Side by side: what the four agree and differ on
What unites them. All four reject the authority of the Vedas and the power of Vedic sacrifice. None of them needs a creator God to explain the world. Each also grew out of the same restless age of wandering teachers and open debate.
Where they split. They differ sharply on the soul, karma and freedom. Jainism has countless eternal souls, Buddhism no permanent soul at all, and Charvaka no soul beyond the body. The Ajivikas accepted rebirth but left no room for effort to change it.
| Question | Buddhism | Jainism | Charvaka | Ajivika |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vedas | Set aside | Set aside | Rejected fiercely | Rejected |
| Creator God | No | No | No | No (fate rules) |
| Soul | No permanent soul (anatta) | Countless souls (jiva) | Body is the self | Accepted rebirth |
| Karma | Yes, shapes rebirth | Yes, as subtle matter | No | No; niyati decides |
| Goal | Nirvana | Kaivalya (kevala jnana) | Pleasure in this life | End after fixed births |
| Means of knowledge | Perception and inference | Many standpoints (naya) | Perception only | — |
The lasting legacy. These schools left gifts that outlived their age. Jaina ahimsa and anekanta fed later ideas of non-violence and tolerance, and Buddhist ideas of compassion spread across Asia. Charvaka's demand for evidence reminds every age that claims should be tested.
Mains lens: practice questions
Protest or philosophy? It is tempting to see these schools only as social protest against priests and caste. That is part of the story, but each also built a serious theory of knowledge, reality and ethics. A strong answer shows both the social roots and the philosophical depth.
Living ideas. Mains questions often ask about relevance today. Ahimsa, anekantavada, the Middle Path and the bodhisattva's compassion can be linked to tolerance, environmental ethics and public service. Charvaka can be linked to the scientific temper that the Constitution asks citizens to develop.
These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from your exam appear in the PYQ panel.
| Angle | Question | Key points to cover |
|---|---|---|
| Origins | Why did so many heterodox sects arise in the sixth century BCE? | Second urbanisation; costly sacrifices; kshatriya power; ascetic debates; individual salvation. |
| Comparison | Compare the Buddhist and Jaina views of soul, karma and liberation. | Anatta vs many jivas; karma as cause chain vs subtle matter; nirvana vs kaivalya; Middle Path vs severe penance. |
| Relevance | How can anekantavada help a diverse democracy? | Many standpoints; humility; dialogue; tolerance; limits of relativism. |
| Materialism | Was Charvaka only hedonism, or an early rational critique? | Perception only; critique of inference; anti-ritual; known via opponents; scientific temper. |
Answer plan for the comparison question. Begin with what Buddhism and Jainism share: rejection of Vedic authority, no creator God, karma and rebirth. Then compare them point by point on soul, karma, path and goal, using a small table. End with their shared legacy of ahimsa and compassion, and one line on their influence on art and society.
Quick revision
- Nastika = not accepting the Vedas: Buddhism, Jainism (seek liberation) and Charvaka (rejects moksha); plus Ajivikas.
- Charvaka / Lokayata: founder by tradition Brihaspati; perception only; four elements (no ether); consciousness from matter; artha + kama only; known via opponents; Tattvopaplavasimha (Jayarashi Bhatta).
- Ajivikas: Makkhali Gosala, Sravasti, niyati (fate); rebirth yes, karma no; Lomas Rishi cave (Barabar Hills, Mauryan).
- Other teachers: Ajita Kesakambalin (materialist), Purana Kassapa (no merit or sin), Pakudha Kachchayana (seven elements), Sanjaya (sceptic).
- Jainism: 24 tirthankaras, Rishabha first, Parshvanatha 23rd, Mahavira 24th; jiva/ajiva; karma as subtle matter (asrava, bandha, samvara, nirjara); five knowledges ending in kevala jnana.
- Anekantavada + syadvada (seven 'syat' forms); triratna = right faith, knowledge, conduct; mahavrata / anuvrata.
- Buddhism: Four Noble Truths, Eightfold Path, Middle Path; pratityasamutpada (12 links); dukkha, anicca, anatta; five aggregates; Pali canon written in Sri Lanka under Vattagamani.
- Later schools: Vaibhashika, Sautrantika (realist, Hinayana); Yogachara (Asanga, Vasubandhu; idealist); Madhyamika (Nagarjuna, shunyata); bodhisattva vs arhat.