GPSC Class 1-2 course‹› 0:00 studied

GPSC Class 1-2 · Module 31 · Mains depth · 19 min

The twelve Schedules: what each holds and why

What GPSC Class 1-2 asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • General Studies · Indian Constitution, polity, social justice and international relations.
  • GS 2 · Indian polity and Constitution.

GPSC Class 1-2 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: the back pages of a school diary

Open any school diary. The front pages tell you the rules: when to reach school, how to wear the uniform, what happens if you are late. The back pages are different. They hold a timetable, a list of holidays and a chart of fees.

Why keep them at the back? The rules are short and stay the same for years, but the lists are long and change often. Putting the details at the back keeps the main rules easy to read.

The Constitution of India works in the same way. Its Articles set out the rules, and its Schedules hold the long lists and details at the back. This chapter takes you through all twelve Schedules, what each one holds, and why each one was needed.

What a Schedule is, and how 8 became 12

A Schedule is an attached part of the Constitution that gives details for one or more Articles. The Article says what must be done, and the Schedule fills in the list, the form or the table. For example, Article 1 says India is a Union of States, and the First Schedule names those States.

The Constitution of 1950 had 8 Schedules. Four were added later, each in answer to a new problem. That is why the newer Schedules carry some of the most debated parts of the Constitution.

Schedule What it holds Added by
First to Eighth States, pay, oaths, Rajya Sabha seats, tribal areas, the three lists, languages Original, 1950
Ninth Laws protected from challenge, mostly land reform First Amendment, 1951
Tenth Anti-defection rules 52nd Amendment, 1985
Eleventh 29 matters for panchayats 73rd Amendment, 1992
Twelfth 18 matters for municipalities 74th Amendment, 1992

Why this matters: the dates of the new Schedules read like a short history of independent India. Land reform in 1951, unstable governments in the 1980s and local democracy in 1992 each left a Schedule behind.

First to Fourth: the map, the pay, the oath and the seats

First Schedule: the map. It lists the names of the States and Union Territories and the areas each one covers. It goes with Articles 1 and 4, so every time a new State is formed, this list changes. Today it has 28 States and 8 Union Territories.

Second Schedule: the pay. It sets out the emoluments, allowances and privileges of the President, the Governors, the Speaker and Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha, the Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, and their state-level counterparts. It also covers the judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts and the Comptroller and Auditor-General. Fixing their pay in the Constitution protects their independence, because a government cannot cut it to punish them.

Third Schedule: the oath. It gives the forms of oaths or affirmations for Union and state ministers, candidates for and members of Parliament and state legislatures, judges, and the CAG. An oath turns a personal promise into a constitutional duty. Note the trap: the oaths of the President, Vice-President and Governor are written in Articles 60, 69 and 159, not in this Schedule.

Fourth Schedule: the seats. It allocates Rajya Sabha seats to the States and Union Territories, broadly in line with population. That is why Uttar Pradesh has the most seats and smaller states have one or a few. The Rajya Sabha therefore represents States unequally, unlike the equal two seats per state in the US Senate.

Why it matters: these four Schedules hold the plain machinery of government. Yet each guards something bigger, such as the unity of the map, the independence of judges and the federal voice of the states.

Fifth and Sixth: two ways to protect tribal areas

The problem. Tribal communities had their own land customs, councils and ways of life. Ordinary laws on land, forests and moneylending often helped outsiders take their land. The framers wanted a shield, but they saw that tribal areas in central India and in the North-East were very different.

Fifth Schedule: guardianship. It covers Scheduled Areas and Scheduled Tribes in states other than Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. The President declares an area a Scheduled Area, and each such state has a Tribes Advisory Council, most of whose members are tribal legislators. The Governor can direct that a law of Parliament or the state shall not apply to the area, or apply with changes, and can make regulations to stop land transfer and unfair moneylending.

Sixth Schedule: self-rule. It covers the tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. Here the tribes run their own affairs through Autonomous District Councils, which can make laws on land, forests, inheritance and village customs, and can run courts for local disputes. There are ten such councils today.

Why two models? In the North-East, tribes were a large majority in compact hill areas with strong traditional institutions, so self-rule could work. In central India, tribal people lived mixed with others and were often a minority, so the state had to act as their guardian. Both Schedules are flexible, because Parliament can change them by ordinary law without a formal constitutional amendment.

Why it matters: the debate on giving Sixth Schedule status to places such as Ladakh shows that this choice is still alive. Weak use of Fifth Schedule powers by Governors is also a common point in Mains answers on tribal land loss.

Seventh: three lists that divide power

The idea. In a federation, someone must decide who makes laws on what. The Seventh Schedule does this with three lists, which go with Article 246. It is the heart of Centre-State relations.

The three lists.

  • Union List (List I): subjects of national importance, such as defence, foreign affairs, railways, currency and atomic energy. It began with 97 entries.
  • State List (List II): subjects best handled locally, such as police, public order, public health, agriculture and land. It began with 66 entries.
  • Concurrent List (List III): subjects on which both may make laws, such as criminal law, marriage, education and forests. It began with 47 entries.

Who wins a clash? If a Union law and a State law on a Concurrent subject conflict, the Union law usually prevails. Subjects that appear in no list are residuary, and Parliament alone can make laws on them. This tilt towards the Centre was a deliberate choice made just after Partition.

The 1976 shift. The 42nd Amendment moved five subjects from the State List to the Concurrent List: education, forests, weights and measures, protection of wild animals and birds, and administration of justice. Supporters said national standards were needed, while critics saw it as a loss of state power. The debate returns whenever states ask for education to go back to the State List.

Eighth: the languages of the Republic

What it holds. The Eighth Schedule lists the languages recognised by the Constitution. It goes with Articles 344 and 351, which deal with a commission on the official language and the growth of Hindi. Being in the list matters for exams such as the civil services, for the official language commission and for state support to the language.

How it grew. The list began with 14 languages in 1950. Sindhi was added in 1967 by the 21st Amendment. Konkani, Manipuri and Nepali came in 1992 by the 71st Amendment, and Bodo, Dogri, Maithili and Santhali in 2003 by the 92nd Amendment, which makes 22.

Why people ask to be included. For a community, a place in the Schedule is a mark of respect and identity. It also brings practical gains, such as use in competitive exams and funds for literature. That is why demands from speakers of languages such as Bhojpuri, Rajasthani and Tulu keep coming up.

Ninth: a shield for land reform, and its limits

Why it came. Soon after 1950, states passed laws to abolish zamindari and give land to tillers. Landlords went to court, saying these laws violated their fundamental right to property, and some courts agreed. To save land reform, the First Amendment (1951) added Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule.

How the shield worked. Any law placed in the Ninth Schedule could not be struck down for violating fundamental rights. It began with 13 land laws, but over the decades more than 280 laws were added, some of them having little to do with land reform. The shield meant to help the landless was sometimes used simply to keep any law away from the courts.

The hole in the shield. In I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007), a nine-judge bench held that laws added to the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973, the date of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment, can be tested against the basic structure. So placing a law in this Schedule no longer gives it full immunity. The Court reasoned that no device should let Parliament escape judicial review completely.

Why it matters: the Ninth Schedule shows the old tension between social reform and individual rights. A good Mains answer credits its role in land reform, then notes its misuse and the balance struck by the 2007 judgment.

Tenth: the anti-defection law

Why it came. In the late 1960s and after, many legislators switched parties for office or money, and governments fell overnight. The phrase "Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram" came from a legislator in Haryana who changed parties several times in a single day. The 52nd Amendment (1985) added the Tenth Schedule to stop this.

When a member loses the seat.

  • A party member voluntarily gives up membership of the party.
  • A member votes or abstains against the party's direction (the whip) without permission, unless the party forgives it within 15 days.
  • An independent member joins a party after the election.
  • A nominated member joins a party more than six months after taking the seat.

The one exception. The original law allowed a "split" if one-third of a legislature party broke away. This was misused, so the 91st Amendment (2003) removed it. Now only a merger with another party, backed by two-thirds of the legislature party, is protected.

Who decides, and the debate. The Speaker or Chairman decides on disqualification. In Kihoto Hollohan (1992), the Supreme Court upheld the law but held that this decision can be reviewed by courts. Critics say the law silences members who want to vote by conscience and that Speakers sometimes delay decisions for years, so many suggest giving the power to the Election Commission or a tribunal.

Eleventh and Twelfth: work lists for villages and towns

Why they came. For decades, panchayats and municipalities depended on the goodwill of state governments, which often did not hold their elections or give them work. The 73rd and 74th Amendments (1992) gave them constitutional status. To show what work they could take up, two new Schedules were added.

Eleventh Schedule: 29 matters for panchayats. It goes with Article 243G and includes agriculture, minor irrigation, drinking water, rural roads, primary and secondary schools, health and sanitation, markets and poverty programmes. Twelfth Schedule: 18 matters for municipalities. It goes with Article 243W and includes urban planning, water supply, roads and bridges, public health, slum improvement, fire services and urban forestry.

The catch. These lists are only suggestions. The State legislature decides how many of these matters, and how much money and staff, actually reach local bodies. That is why the real test of local democracy is the "three Fs": funds, functions and functionaries.

Why it matters: Mains questions on local government often ask why panchayats remain weak. The answer begins here, because the Constitution lists the work but leaves the transfer of power to the states.

Why it matters: what the Schedules tell us about the Constitution

Flexible where change is expected. Some Schedules can be changed without the full amendment process. A law under Article 4 that creates a new State also changes the First and Fourth Schedules, and Parliament can change the Fifth and Sixth Schedules by ordinary law. The framers expected maps, seats and tribal arrangements to change, so they kept these easy to adjust.

Rigid where trust is at stake. Changes to the Seventh Schedule's lists need an amendment under Article 368 with the approval of half the State legislatures. This is because the lists decide the power of states, and the states must have a say before their power is cut. The same Constitution is therefore flexible in some places and rigid in others.

A record of India's choices. Each later Schedule records a choice the country made. The Ninth chose land reform over property, the Tenth chose stable governments over free movement of legislators, and the Eleventh and Twelfth chose to take democracy down to villages and towns. Reading the Schedules in this way turns a list to be memorised into a story to be explained.

Mains lens: four questions, four angles

These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam are in the PYQ panel of this module.

Angle Question Key points to cover
Why (origin) Why did the Constitution adopt two different models for tribal areas in the Fifth and Sixth Schedules? Contrast compact tribal majorities with strong institutions in the North-East with mixed, minority settings in central India. Then explain guardianship by the Governor against self-rule by district councils.
Evaluate Has the Ninth Schedule served its original purpose? Credit it with saving land reform in the 1950s. Then show that it grew to over 280 laws and explain the 2007 basic structure check.
Debate Has the anti-defection law strengthened or weakened parliamentary democracy? Show that it brought stability after the era of frequent defections. Then raise the loss of free debate and delayed decisions by Speakers, and end with reform ideas.
Federalism Why do the Eleventh and Twelfth Schedules not ensure strong local bodies? Explain that the lists are suggestions left to state laws. Then use the idea of funds, functions and functionaries to show the gap.

How to use this table: each answer should explain what the Schedule holds, why it was added, and what it means today, and end with a way forward.

Quick revision

  • The Constitution began with 8 Schedules; the Ninth (1951), Tenth (1985), and Eleventh and Twelfth (1992) were added later.
  • The First lists States and Union Territories, the Second covers pay and privileges, the Third gives oaths, and the Fourth allocates Rajya Sabha seats.
  • The Fifth protects Scheduled Areas through the Governor and a Tribes Advisory Council, while the Sixth gives self-rule to tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram through Autonomous District Councils.
  • The Seventh has the Union, State and Concurrent Lists, which began with 97, 66 and 47 entries, and residuary powers lie with Parliament.
  • The 42nd Amendment moved education, forests, weights and measures, wildlife protection and administration of justice to the Concurrent List.
  • The Eighth lists 22 languages, growing from 14 through the 21st, 71st and 92nd Amendments.
  • The Ninth shielded land reform laws, but laws added after 24 April 1973 can be tested on the basic structure (I.R. Coelho, 2007).
  • The Tenth is the anti-defection law, and since the 91st Amendment (2003) only a merger backed by two-thirds is protected.
  • The Eleventh lists 29 matters for panchayats and the Twelfth lists 18 for municipalities.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 11 answered

  1. How many Schedules did the original Constitution of 1950 have?

  2. Which Schedule allocates seats in the Rajya Sabha to the States and Union Territories?

  3. The form of oath of which of these is NOT given in the Third Schedule?

  4. The Sixth Schedule applies to tribal areas in which group of states?

  5. Under the Indian Constitution, residuary powers of legislation rest with:

  6. Which of these subjects was NOT moved to the Concurrent List by the 42nd Amendment?

  7. Which languages were added to the Eighth Schedule by the 92nd Amendment (2003)?

  8. In I.R. Coelho (2007), laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after which date were held open to basic structure review?

  9. Which amendment removed the 'split' exception from the anti-defection law?

  10. How many matters are listed in the Eleventh Schedule for panchayats?

  11. Which of these can Parliament change by an ordinary law that is not treated as an amendment under Article 368?

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

How many Schedules does the Indian Constitution have?

It has 12 Schedules. The original Constitution had 8; the Ninth was added in 1951, the Tenth in 1985, and the Eleventh and Twelfth in 1992.

Which Schedule has the Union, State and Concurrent Lists?

The Seventh Schedule. It divides law-making powers between the Union and the States, and residuary powers lie with Parliament.

What is the difference between the Fifth and Sixth Schedules?

The Fifth protects Scheduled Areas through the Governor and a Tribes Advisory Council. The Sixth gives self-rule through Autonomous District Councils in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.

Why was the Ninth Schedule added?

The First Amendment (1951) added it to protect land reform laws from challenge on fundamental rights grounds. Since 2007, laws added after 24 April 1973 can be tested against the basic structure.