GPSC Class 1-2 · Module 35 · Mains depth · 16 min
Running Parliament: presiding officers, sessions and questions
What GPSC Class 1-2 asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- General Studies · Indian Constitution, polity, social justice and international relations.
- GS 2 · Indian polity and Constitution.
GPSC Class 1-2 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: who keeps order in a room full of leaders?
Imagine a class debate with fifty students, all eager to speak. Without someone in charge, everyone would talk at once and nothing would get decided. So the class picks a chairperson who decides who speaks next, stops shouting, and makes sure every side gets a fair turn.
Parliament faces the same problem on a much larger scale. More than five hundred members, from many parties, meet to argue about the country's future. Each House therefore has a presiding officer: the Speaker in the Lok Sabha and the Chairman in the Rajya Sabha.
Parliament also needs a calendar, so that it meets regularly, and daily tools that let members question the government. The most famous of these is Question Hour, when Ministers must answer members' questions in public.
This chapter explains who runs each House, when Parliament meets, and how members use questions and motions to hold the government to account.
The Speaker: the guardian of the Lok Sabha
The Lok Sabha has two presiding officers: the Speaker and the Deputy Speaker, who presides when the Speaker is absent. The office is modelled on the Speaker of the British House of Commons. Once elected, the Speaker is expected to act impartially and to protect the rights of every member, whatever the party.
What the Speaker does.
- Conducts the proceedings, keeps order and decorum, and decides points of order by interpreting the rules; the Speaker's decision on these is final.
- Decides whether questions, motions and resolutions can be admitted.
- Certifies whether a Bill is a Money Bill, and this decision is final.
- Authenticates a Bill passed by the House before it goes to the other House or to the President.
- Fixes the order of business in consultation with the Leader of the House.
- Appoints the chairpersons of the House's committees and controls its secretariat.
Voting. The Speaker does not vote in the first instance. If the votes are tied, the Speaker has a casting vote (Article 100), which breaks the tie.
Protecting the office. The Speaker's conduct can be discussed in the House only on a substantive motion, not in passing during a debate. The Speaker's salary and allowances are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India, so they do not need a yearly vote and cannot be used to pressure the Speaker.
When the House is dissolved, and when the chair is empty
The Speaker outlives the House. When the Lok Sabha is dissolved, the Speaker does not vacate office. The Speaker continues until just before the first meeting of the new House, so that the office is never empty during the changeover. The other ways in which the office ends are set out in Articles 94, 101 and 102.
Pro tem Speaker. After a general election, the new House has not yet chosen its Speaker. When the offices of both the Speaker and the Deputy Speaker are vacant, the President appoints a member to perform the Speaker's duties. This member is commonly called the pro tem Speaker, and the main task is to swear in new members and conduct the election of the new Speaker.
Panel of chairpersons. The Speaker nominates a panel of up to ten members, any of whom can preside when both the Speaker and the Deputy Speaker are absent.
History. India's first Speaker, G. V. Mavalankar, was elected on 15 May 1952, two days after the first session of the first Lok Sabha began.
The Chairman of the Rajya Sabha
The Rajya Sabha does not elect its own head from among its members. The Vice-President of India is its ex officio Chairman, which means the Vice-President holds this post because of the office he or she already holds.
There is one exception. When the Vice-President is acting as President, or performing the President's functions, he or she does not preside over the Rajya Sabha. At such times the Deputy Chairman, whom the House chooses from among its members, takes the chair.
The Chairman also nominates a panel of Vice-Chairpersons, any one of whom can preside when both the Chairman and the Deputy Chairman are absent. The Chairman's powers in running the House are broadly the same as the Speaker's in the Lok Sabha.
When does Parliament meet?
Summoning and prorogation. Parliament does not sit all year. The President summons each House to meet and prorogues it, that is, ends its session (Article 85(2)(a)). The President can also dissolve the Lok Sabha (Article 85(2)(b)).
The six-month rule. The Constitution requires that the gap between two sessions must not exceed six months. This means Parliament must meet at least twice a year. In practice, it usually meets three times.
The three sessions.
- Budget Session: from late January to mid-April. It has a break from mid-February to mid-March, so that the Department-related Standing Committees can study each Ministry's Demands for Grants.
- Monsoon Session: from mid-July to the end of August.
- Winter Session: from the end of November to the end of December.
Quorum. For a sitting to go on, at least one-tenth of the members must be present. In the Lok Sabha, this is 55 members, including the presiding officer.
Question Hour and Zero Hour
Question Hour. Unless the presiding officer directs otherwise, every sitting of the Lok Sabha begins with Question Hour, the first hour (11 a.m. to 12 noon). In the Rajya Sabha, Question Hour was moved to 1 p.m. Asking questions is the right of every member, whatever the party. Questions expose weak spots in administration and reveal the government's thinking on policy.
Kinds of questions.
- Starred question: marked with an asterisk, answered orally, and members can ask supplementary questions. At most 20 are taken up in a day.
- Unstarred question: answered in writing, with no supplementaries. At most 230 are listed in a day.
- Short notice question: on a matter of urgent public importance, asked with less than the usual notice of 15 clear days, and answered orally.
Half-an-hour discussion. If a member is not satisfied with an answer and feels a fuller explanation is needed in the public interest, the presiding officer can allow a half-an-hour discussion, usually at the end of a sitting.
Zero Hour. The time right after Question Hour and the laying of papers, starting around 12 noon, has come to be called Zero Hour. Members use it to raise urgent matters that cannot wait for the normal notice period. Zero Hour is not formally recognised in the rules; the presiding officer decides which matters are raised.
Motions: when a question is not enough
Sometimes a question and answer are not enough, and members want the whole House to discuss a matter or even judge the government. Parliament's rules provide several motions for this.
| Device | What it does | Vote at the end? |
|---|---|---|
| Calling attention | A member asks a Minister to make a statement on an urgent matter | No |
| Short duration discussion (Rule 193) | A brief debate on a matter of public importance | No |
| Adjournment motion | Sets aside normal business to discuss a recent, urgent matter; needs the Speaker's consent | Yes; adoption amounts to censure |
| No-confidence motion (Rule 198) | Tests whether the Council of Ministers as a whole still has the House's support | Yes; if passed, the government must go |
Why the adjournment motion is special. It is an extraordinary procedure. It is meant for a definite, recent matter of urgent public importance with serious consequences, where waiting for an ordinary motion would be too late. Because it stops the normal business of the House, its adoption is treated as a censure of the government.
Why the no-confidence motion targets everyone. It is moved against the Council of Ministers as a whole, not against one Minister. This follows from collective responsibility: the Ministers stand or fall together.
Why these rules exist
Each rule in this chapter answers a real need: fairness in debate, continuity of the House, and accountability of the government. Read the table as "need, then answer".
| Rule | Why it is there | What it means in practice |
|---|---|---|
| Impartial Speaker | Every party, especially the opposition, must get a fair hearing | Final say on order, admissibility and Money Bills; conduct discussed only on a substantive motion |
| Casting vote only | The chair should not take sides in ordinary votes | The Speaker votes only to break a tie |
| Speaker stays after dissolution | The office should never be empty | Continues until just before the new House first meets |
| Six-month gap | A government should not avoid Parliament for long | At least two sessions a year; three in practice |
| Question Hour | Ministers must explain their work in public | The first hour of every Lok Sabha sitting |
| Zero Hour | Urgent issues cannot always wait for notice | Matters raised around noon with the chair's permission |
The big picture. A government with a majority can win every vote. These rules make sure it still has to listen, answer and explain. The presiding officer protects that space, and question and motion devices fill it.
Mains lens: is Parliament losing its edge as a watchdog?
A common question: "Disruptions and executive dominance have weakened Parliament's ability to hold the government accountable." Discuss.
Points of concern:
- When sittings are lost to noise, Question Hour is often the first casualty, and Ministers escape public questioning.
- The government controls most of the House's time, and party discipline means members rarely vote against their own side.
- The Speaker comes from the ruling side, so the impartiality of decisions on admissibility, Money Bill certificates and debate time is sometimes questioned.
- Laws often leave details to rules framed by the executive, so Parliament sees less of the real policy.
Points on the other side:
- Devices such as Zero Hour, calling attention and adjournment motions give the opposition daily chances to raise issues.
- The six-month rule forces regular sessions, and the no-confidence motion keeps the government dependent on the House.
- The Speaker's office has strong protections: a casting vote only, salary charged on the Consolidated Fund, and conduct discussed only on a substantive motion.
Way forward: protect Question Hour from disruption, fix a minimum number of sitting days, give more time to the opposition's agenda, and build conventions that keep the Speaker visibly neutral. A strong answer ends by saying that accountability depends as much on how members use these tools as on the tools themselves.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Office: "The Speaker is the guardian of the rights of the House." Examine the powers and position of the Speaker.
- List the powers over order, admissibility, Money Bill certificates, authentication and committees.
- Explain the casting vote and the protections of the office.
- Note that the Speaker continues after dissolution until the new House meets.
- Conclude that the office's authority rests on visible impartiality.
2. Comparison: Compare the presiding officers of the two Houses of Parliament.
- Explain that the Speaker is elected by the Lok Sabha, while the Vice-President is ex officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
- Note that the Chairman is not a member of the House and does not preside while acting as President.
- Mention the Deputy Speaker, the Deputy Chairman and the panels of presiding members.
- Conclude that both offices aim at fair conduct of business.
3. Accountability: How do Question Hour and Zero Hour help Parliament control the executive?
- Describe starred, unstarred and short notice questions.
- Explain Zero Hour as an informal space for urgent issues.
- Add the half-an-hour discussion and calling attention as follow-ups.
- Conclude that daily questioning keeps Ministers answerable between elections.
Quick revision
- The Speaker and Deputy Speaker preside over the Lok Sabha, and the Speaker has only a casting vote (Article 100).
- The Speaker certifies Money Bills (final), authenticates Bills, decides admissibility and appoints committee chairpersons.
- After dissolution, the Speaker stays in office until just before the new House first meets.
- When both offices are vacant, the President appoints a member to act as Speaker (pro tem).
- The Vice-President is ex officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha but does not preside while acting as President.
- The President summons and prorogues the Houses, and the gap between sessions cannot exceed six months.
- Question Hour is the first hour (11 to 12 in the Lok Sabha); starred questions are oral (up to 20), unstarred are written (up to 230).
- Zero Hour starts around noon and is not in the rules.
- An adjournment motion amounts to censure; a no-confidence motion (Rule 198) is against the whole Council of Ministers.