HPSC Engineering · Module 43 · standard depth · 24 min
Effects of inflation and how it is controlled
What HPSC Engineering asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Screening test (general) · Indian culture, polity and economy
HPSC Engineering questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for HPSC Engineering. 19 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: does money keep its value?
On your tenth birthday your grandfather gave you ₹500. It was enough for a cricket bat and a ball. You kept the note in a box and forgot about it. Ten years later you find it and go to the same shop.
The ₹500 now buys only the ball. The note did not change. The shop did not cheat you. Prices rose, and your money quietly lost value while it sat in the box.
Now think of two other people in your town.
- Sharma-ji, a retired clerk, gets a fixed pension of ₹15,000 that rises only rarely. Each year his pension buys less milk, fewer medicines and less vegetables.
- Raju, a young shopkeeper, took a ₹1,00,000 loan to stock his shop. As prices rise, his sales in rupees rise too, and the ₹1,00,000 he has to repay feels lighter every year.
The same inflation hurt one and helped the other. This is the first lesson of this chapter: inflation is not neutral. It moves purchasing power between people, and it changes how the whole economy behaves.
The second lesson is that a country does not just suffer inflation; it can fight it. The RBI can make borrowing costlier, the government can spend more carefully and keep stocks of onions and pulses to release in a shortage, and workers can be protected by linking their pay to prices. This chapter answers three questions:
- Whom does inflation hurt and help, and why does it matter for the economy?
- Is there a trade-off between inflation and jobs? (the Phillips curve and stagflation)
- What tools does India use to control inflation?
Effects on people: winners, losers and hidden costs
1. Fixed incomes lose. Pensioners, people living on rent or interest, and workers whose pay is revised only after years all lose when prices rise faster than their income. The poorest lose most, because they spend most of their income on food and have the least bargaining power.
2. Savers and lenders lose, borrowers gain (when inflation is higher than expected). We saw this with the real interest rate in the chapter on the meaning and causes of inflation: real rate ≈ nominal rate − inflation. A 7% fixed deposit with 8% inflation gives a negative real return.
3. Indexation: the shield. One way to protect people is to index their pay to prices.
In India, the CPI for Industrial Workers (CPI-IW), compiled by the Labour Bureau, is primarily used to regulate the dearness allowance (DA) of government employees and industrial workers. When CPI-IW rises, DA is revised upward, so real pay is protected. Most informal workers, however, have no such shield.
4. Hidden costs, even when inflation is expected:
- Menu costs: shops, restaurants and companies must keep reprinting price lists, labels and catalogues. Small for one shop, large for the whole economy.
- Shoe-leather costs: people hold less cash and make more trips to the bank or ATM to avoid losing value. (The name comes from wearing out shoes walking to the bank.)
- Confusion and planning errors: when prices keep changing, it is hard to tell whether a product has become more popular or whether all prices are simply rising. Families and firms make worse decisions.
- Bracket creep: if income tax slabs are not adjusted for inflation, a pay rise that only keeps up with prices can push a person into a higher tax slab. They pay more tax without being richer.
Why this matters: inflation works like an invisible tax that falls hardest on those with fixed incomes and cash savings. That is why controlling it is not just an economic goal but a matter of fairness.
Effects on the economy: why both high and very low inflation are bad
High inflation hurts growth in several ways:
- Uncertainty kills planning. A firm deciding whether to build a new factory needs to know its future costs and prices. When inflation is high and jumpy, long-term investment falls.
- Savings move into unproductive assets. When bank deposits lose value, families buy gold and land instead. Money that could have funded factories and roads through banks sits idle in lockers and plots.
- Exports lose competitiveness. If Indian prices rise faster than prices abroad and the rupee does not adjust, Indian goods become costlier for foreign buyers and imports become relatively cheaper.
- Inequality rises. As we saw in an earlier section, inflation shifts purchasing power away from the poor and the fixed-income groups.
- Interest rates rise. Lenders demand higher rates to protect themselves, which makes credit costlier for everyone.
But very low inflation, or deflation, is also dangerous:
- If people expect prices to fall, they postpone purchases ("why buy a scooter now if it will be cheaper next year?"). Sales fall, firms cut jobs, incomes fall, and prices fall further. This can become a deflationary spiral.
- Debts become heavier in real terms when prices and incomes fall, so borrowers struggle and banks see more bad loans.
So what is "just right"? Most central banks aim for low and stable inflation, not zero.
A little inflation greases the wheels: it lets real wages adjust without nominal pay cuts and keeps a safe distance from deflation. That is exactly why India's target is 4% with a band of 2% to 6%, and why falling below 2% for three consecutive quarters counts as a failure, just like rising above 6%. The government retained this target on 25 March 2026 for 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2031.
The Phillips curve and stagflation: is there a trade-off?
A simple picture: the busy wedding season. During the wedding season, every tent house, caterer and band in town is fully booked. They hire extra workers, and because everyone wants them, they raise their rates.
Jobs are plentiful and prices rise together. In the off-season, the opposite: workers sit idle and nobody can raise prices. This everyday pattern is the idea behind the Phillips curve.
The Phillips curve shows an inverse relationship between unemployment and inflation in the short run: when unemployment is low (the economy is running hot), inflation tends to be high; when unemployment is high, inflation tends to be low. Drawn on a graph with unemployment on the x-axis and inflation on the y-axis, it slopes downward.
For policymakers it seemed to offer a menu: accept a little more inflation to get a little less unemployment, or the reverse.
The catch: expectations. If the government keeps pushing demand to hold unemployment very low, workers and firms soon expect higher inflation and build it into wages and prices (the wage-price spiral of the chapter on the meaning and causes of inflation).
Then the same unemployment comes with ever-higher inflation. In the long run, economists argue, the curve becomes vertical: you cannot permanently buy lower unemployment with higher inflation. Unemployment returns to a "natural" level set by skills, technology and labour markets, and only inflation stays higher.
Stagflation breaks the menu. Sometimes both get worse together: high inflation and high unemployment with slow growth. This is stagflation.
It usually follows a big cost-push supply shock, such as a sharp rise in oil prices. Costs rise for every business, so output falls (unemployment up) while prices rise (inflation up). Now the policymaker faces a cruel choice:
- cut interest rates to support jobs, and risk feeding inflation; or
- raise interest rates to fight inflation, and risk deepening the slowdown.
Why this matters for India: India's flexible inflation targeting is a modern answer to the Phillips curve. The 4% target anchors expectations, so the long-run trap is avoided, while the 2–6% band gives the RBI room to support growth in the short run and to look through temporary supply shocks.
Tool 1: monetary policy, the RBI's levers
A simple picture: the water tap. Think of money and credit in the economy as water flowing into a garden.
Too much water floods it (inflation); too little dries it (slowdown). The RBI controls the tap. Turning it tighter means making money costlier and scarcer; loosening it means making money cheaper and more plentiful.
The main lever: the policy repo rate. The repo rate is the interest rate at which the RBI provides liquidity (short-term money) to banks under the liquidity adjustment facility (LAF). It is decided by the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), which must meet at least four times a year. Its quorum is four; each member has one vote, and if votes are tied the Governor has a casting vote.
How a repo hike reaches your kitchen (transmission): repo rate ↑ → banks' cost of funds ↑ → loan rates and EMIs ↑ → people and firms borrow and spend less → demand cools → price pressure eases.
The corridor. Around the repo rate sits a corridor:
- Ceiling: Marginal Standing Facility (MSF), a penal rate at which banks can borrow overnight in an emergency, 25 basis points above the repo rate.
- Floor: Standing Deposit Facility (SDF), the rate at which the RBI accepts overnight deposits from banks without collateral, 25 basis points below the repo rate. Since April 2022 the SDF has replaced the fixed reverse repo rate as the floor. Short-term market interest rates stay within this corridor, close to the repo rate.
Other levers:
- Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR): the average daily balance a bank must keep with the RBI as a per cent of its net demand and time liabilities (NDTL), broadly its deposits. Raising CRR locks up more of banks' money, so they can lend less.
- Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR): every bank must keep in India safe assets (such as government securities, cash and gold) worth at least a set percentage of its demand and time liabilities. A higher SLR also leaves less to lend.
- Open Market Operations (OMO): outright sale of government securities by the RBI soaks money out of the system (anti-inflation); purchase puts money in.
Limits of the tap: monetary policy acts with a lag of several months and works best on demand-pull inflation. It cannot make it rain or lower world oil prices. That is why the government's tools in the later sections are needed too. The full working of these tools is explained in the chapter on the RBI and monetary policy.
Tool 2: fiscal policy, the government's budget
A simple picture: the biggest shopper in town. The government is the largest single buyer in the economy: roads, salaries, subsidies, defence, schemes. If this giant shopper keeps spending far more than it earns, it adds to demand and can push prices up, especially if it borrows heavily or the extra money goes into consumption rather than into building capacity.
Fiscal tools against inflation:
- Reduce the fiscal deficit: spend less or collect more, so that the government adds less to total demand. (Deficits are explained in the chapter on deficits and the FRBM Act.)
- Shift spending from consumption to capacity: money spent on roads, storage, irrigation and power increases supply over time and lowers future inflation.
- Cut indirect taxes on key items: lowering excise duty on fuel or GST on essential goods reduces their prices directly. Because fuel is used in transporting almost everything, a fuel tax cut can lower many prices at once.
- Targeted subsidies instead of blanket ones: support the poor directly (for example through food grain distribution) rather than holding down prices for everyone, which can create shortages and black markets.
The coordination problem. If the RBI raises interest rates to cool demand while the government pumps in large deficits, the two push in opposite directions, and interest rates must rise even more. Good outcomes need fiscal and monetary policy to pull together. That is one reason why India set a statutory inflation target decided by the Central Government in consultation with the RBI: both sides share ownership of the 4% goal.
Why this matters: in a country like India, where much inflation comes from food and fuel, the government's budget choices (fuel taxes, food stocks, farm spending) can matter as much as the repo rate.
Tool 3: supply-side and administrative steps
A simple picture: the family store-room. A wise family buys extra wheat after the harvest when it is cheap and stores it, so that it does not have to buy at high prices before the next harvest. The government does something similar for the whole country.
1. The Price Stabilisation Fund (PSF).
- Set up in 2014-15 as a Central Sector Scheme with a corpus of ₹500 crore, initially for onion and potato; pulses were added later.
- Since 1 April 2016 it has been run by the Department of Consumer Affairs.
- How it works: the government buys directly from farmers at the farm gate or mandi, keeps a strategic buffer stock (pulses such as tur, urad, moong, masur and gram, and onion), and releases it in a calibrated way when prices spike. This moderates price volatility and discourages hoarding and speculation. Tomatoes too have been procured under the PSF.
2. Selling cheap staples directly. When wheat and atta prices were high, the government launched 'Bharat' Atta on 6 November 2023 at an MRP not exceeding ₹27.50 per kg, sold through Kendriya Bhandar, NAFED and NCCF, using wheat from the Open Market Sale Scheme (Domestic). Releasing government stocks into the market increases supply and cools prices.
3. Trade measures and stock limits. To keep grain at home, the government can ban or restrict exports (as it did with wheat) and allow imports at lower duties. To stop traders from hoarding, it can impose stock limits, capping how much a trader may hold.
4. Long-term supply fixes. The real cure for food inflation is more and steadier supply: irrigation so that crops depend less on the monsoon, cold storage and warehouses so that less produce rots, better roads and markets so that farm produce reaches cities quickly, and higher productivity of pulses and oilseeds.
Why this matters: these tools act where monetary policy cannot, on the supply side. But they have side effects, which we debate in a later section: an export ban that helps urban consumers can hurt farmers who lose a better price abroad.
Accountability: what happens when the target is missed
The school-report example. If a class does badly in three tests in a row, the class teacher must write to the principal: why it happened, what will be done, and by when results will improve. India's monetary framework works the same way.
When is the target missed? When average CPI inflation is above 6% or below 2% for any three consecutive quarters.
What must the RBI do then? It must send a report to the Central Government stating:
- the reasons for failing to achieve the target;
- the remedial actions it proposes to take; and
- an estimate of the time within which the target will be achieved.
Other transparency rules:
- The minutes of every MPC meeting are published on the 14th day after the meeting, so the public can see how each member voted and why.
- The RBI publishes a Monetary Policy Report once every six months, explaining the sources of inflation and its forecasts.
Why this matters: accountability makes the target credible. When people can see that the RBI must explain itself in writing if inflation stays too high or too low, they trust that it will act, and this trust itself helps anchor inflation expectations. A target that nobody is answerable for would be just a wish.
Why each tool exists: when, where and why
Start from the purpose. Every tool in this chapter exists to solve a specific problem. If you know the problem, you can explain the tool, its limits and its side effects, which is exactly what Mains asks.
Why the RBI cares about prices at all. The Preamble to the RBI Act, 1934, as the RBI quotes it, says the primary objective of monetary policy is to maintain price stability while keeping in mind the objective of growth. So the RBI is not told to ignore growth. It is told that stable prices come first, because high and uncertain inflation hurts both growth and the poor.
Why monetary tools work on demand, not supply. The repo rate, CRR, SLR and OMOs all change how much money and credit flow through banks. They can cool spending when there is too much money chasing goods. They cannot grow more onions after a failed monsoon, which is why the government needs a second set of tools.
Why the Price Stabilisation Fund was created (2014-15). Prices of perishable crops like onion and potato swing wildly: a glut one season, a shortage the next. In March 2015 the Centre approved the PSF to fund market interventions for such crops. The idea was to buy directly from farmers when prices are low, hold a buffer, and release it when prices jump, to moderate volatility and discourage hoarding and speculation.
Pulses were added later, and from 1 April 2016 the fund moved to the Department of Consumer Affairs. The move itself tells you its main goal had become protecting consumers.
Why 'Bharat' Atta, export bans and stock limits (2023). When wheat prices rose in 2023, the government sold wheat from the Open Market Sale Scheme as 'Bharat' Atta at no more than ₹27.50 per kg. It also banned wheat exports and imposed stock limits. Each tool answers one problem: selling stock adds supply, an export ban keeps grain at home, and stock limits stop traders from hoarding.
Why accountability is written into the law. Since 2016, if inflation stays outside the 2–6% band for three quarters in a row, the RBI must report to the government the reasons, the remedial actions and the time needed. MPC minutes record each member's vote and a short statement justifying it. A central bank that must explain itself in public finds it harder to drift away from its target, and that strengthens trust in the target.
Quick revision
- Inflation hurts people on fixed incomes, savers, lenders and the poor, but it helps borrowers and owners of real assets such as land and gold.
- To protect government employees, their dearness allowance (DA) is indexed to the CPI for industrial workers, which the Labour Bureau compiles.
- Inflation also has hidden costs, such as menu costs of changing prices, shoe-leather costs of holding less cash, planning errors and bracket creep in income tax.
- Very low inflation or deflation is harmful too, because people postpone buying and the real burden of debt grows heavier.
- The Phillips curve shows that in the short run lower unemployment comes with higher inflation, but in the long run the curve is vertical.
- Stagflation breaks this pattern, because high inflation then comes together with high unemployment and slow growth.
- The MPC meets at least four times a year with a quorum of four, and the Governor has a casting vote on a tie.
- Its minutes are published on the 14th day after a meeting, and the RBI releases a Monetary Policy Report every six months.
- The policy corridor runs from the SDF (floor, 25 bps below repo) through the repo rate to the MSF (ceiling, 25 bps above repo).
- The SDF replaced the fixed reverse repo as the floor in April 2022, because it lets the RBI absorb money without giving collateral.
- CRR is the share of a bank's NDTL kept as a balance with the RBI, and SLR is the share kept in safe liquid assets in India.
- Through open market operations (OMO), the RBI buys or sells government securities to add or remove money.
- If the target is missed for three quarters, the RBI must report the reasons, the remedial actions and the time needed to return to target.
- The Price Stabilisation Fund started in 2014-15 with ₹500 crore for onion and potato, later added pulses, and has been with the Department of Consumer Affairs since 1 April 2016.
Common confusions and exam traps:
- MSF is the ceiling, SDF the floor; the repo rate is in the middle.
- CRR is kept with the RBI; SLR assets are kept by the bank itself in India.
- The PSF is a Central Sector Scheme, not a centrally sponsored scheme.
- Stagflation is not the same as deflation.