HPSC Engineering course‹› 0:00 studied

HPSC Engineering · Module 11 · standard depth · 13 min

The Acts of 1919 and 1935 and the provincial ministries

What HPSC Engineering asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Screening test (general) · History of India; Indian and world geography

HPSC Engineering questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for HPSC Engineering. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: power that is given, and power that is real

Imagine a school that lets students run the canteen committee but keeps the fees, exams and discipline in the principal's hands. The students can make choices, but only about small things. They can also be blamed for whatever goes wrong in the canteen.

Power that is given, power that is kept

This is how many Indians saw the constitutional reforms the British offered between 1909 and 1935. Each set of reforms gave Indians a little more say, especially in the provinces. Yet each kept the real powers, such as money, police, defence and foreign affairs, in British hands.

Why did the British offer reforms at all? Partly to meet the rising demands of the national movement and partly to win over moderate Indians while keeping control. The reforms also had lasting effects that no one fully planned, including the spread of separate electorates and a working model that later shaped India's own Constitution.

This chapter explains the Acts of 1919 and 1935 and what happened when Indians ran provincial governments in 1937. Keep one question in mind as you read. Were these reforms steps towards freedom, or ways of delaying it?

The reforms at a glance

This table compares the three main sets of reforms. Each is explained in the sections below.

Three steps of reform, 1909-1935
Reform Main features Main limits
Indian Councils Act 1909 (Morley-Minto) Larger legislatures; separate electorates for Muslims No real power for the legislatures
Government of India Act 1919 (Montagu-Chelmsford) Dyarchy in provinces; bicameralism; direct elections; separate electorates extended Key powers stay with the colonial government
Government of India Act 1935 Provincial autonomy; proposed All-India Federation; wider franchise About 14% could vote; no control over defence and foreign affairs; federation never formed

Two events then tested the 1935 Act in practice: the provincial elections of 1937, and the resignation of the Congress ministries in 1939 when Britain took India into the Second World War without asking.

Before 1919: the Morley-Minto Reforms

What did the 1909 Act do? The Indian Councils Act of 1909, known as the Morley-Minto Reforms after the Secretary of State Morley and the Viceroy Minto, enlarged the legislative councils. More Indians could now sit in them and speak on public matters. However, the councils still had no real power over the government.

How separate electorates kept spreading

Separate electorates. The most lasting feature of the 1909 Act was the introduction of separate electorates for Muslims. Under this system, Muslim voters elected Muslim representatives separately from other voters. The idea was presented as protection for a minority, but it encouraged people to think of politics in terms of religious communities.

Why does this matter for 1919 and after? Separate electorates did not stay limited to Muslims. In 1919 they were extended to Sikhs, Europeans, Anglo-Indians and Indian Christians. Later, the Communal Award of 1932 offered them to the depressed classes as well, which led to the crisis described in the chapter on Civil Disobedience and the Poona Pact.

The bigger pattern. Each reform widened Indian participation a little, but it also divided the electorate into more and more separate groups. This is a key reason why historians link the reforms to the later growth of communal politics. A Mains answer on Partition should trace this thread back to 1909.

The Act of 1919 and dyarchy

Why 1919? During the First World War, Indians had given soldiers and money, and the British wanted to keep moderate Indian opinion on their side. The Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, named after two senior British officials, were put into law in 1919. They came in the same year as the Rowlatt Act and Jallianwala Bagh, which coloured how Indians received them.

Dyarchy: one province, two masters

What was dyarchy? The word means 'rule of two'. In each province, the government was split into two parts: one part was run by Indian ministers who were responsible to the elected legislature, and the other remained with the Governor and his officials. The Governor's side kept the more important subjects.

Other changes. The 1919 reforms also brought bicameralism, that is, legislatures with two houses, and direct elections for many seats. More Indians could now vote and sit in legislatures than ever before. Yet the key decision-making powers remained with the colonial government.

Edwin Montagu, Secretary of State for India
Edwin Montagu, Secretary of State for IndiaPhoto: Central News Agency, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why did it disappoint? Indian ministers were given responsibility without real power. If something went wrong in their departments, they could be blamed, while the Governor controlled money and order. This gap between responsibility and power is why the Swarajists, described in the chapter on the Swarajists and the Simon Commission, entered the councils to expose dyarchy from within.

The Government of India Act 1935

How was it made? After the Simon Commission and the Round Table Conferences, the British government set out its plan in a White Paper in March 1933. A Bill was introduced in December 1934, and the Government of India Act received royal assent on 2 August 1935. It was a far larger scheme than anything offered before.

How the 1935 Act was made

Provincial autonomy. The Act gave the provinces provincial autonomy. Elected members in the provincial legislatures gained more power, and ministries responsible to them would run the provincial governments. Elections under the Act were held in 1937.

The All-India Federation. The Act also proposed an All-India Federation of the British provinces and the princely states. Joining was compulsory for the provinces but voluntary for the princely states. In the end, this federal part never came into operation.

The 1935 Act: what it gave and what it held back

Franchise and its limits. The Act extended voting rights, yet only about 14 per cent of the people could vote. Indians still had no control over defence and foreign affairs. Both Jawaharlal Nehru and Muhammad Ali Jinnah condemned the Act, though for different reasons.

Why the 1935 Act still matters

A bridge to the Constitution. Although Indians criticised the 1935 Act, it became the major source of the present Constitution. The Constitution took from it the federal scheme, the office of Governor, the judiciary, Public Service Commissions and the emergency provisions. A large part of India's administrative framework therefore has its roots in 1935.

From the 1935 Act to the Constitution of 1950

Why borrow from a colonial law? The makers of the Constitution were practical. The 1935 Act had already set up working institutions, and Indians had gained experience of running them in the provinces from 1937. Keeping what worked, while changing its spirit from colonial control to democratic accountability, gave the new state stability.

The break with the past. Article 395 of the Constitution repealed the Government of India Act 1935 and the Indian Independence Act 1947. The Constitution came into force on 26 January 1950, replacing the colonial framework with one made by Indians. How this happened is explained in the chapter on the historical background of the Constitution.

Exam angle. Prelims often asks which features of the Constitution were drawn from the 1935 Act. Remember the five: federal scheme, Governor, judiciary, Public Service Commissions and emergency provisions. Mains may ask you to assess whether this borrowing was wise.

The provincial ministries, 1937–1939

The 1937 elections. The Congress had condemned the 1935 Act but decided to contest the provincial elections of 1937. It won absolute majorities in five of the eleven provinces and formed ministries in seven of them. For the first time, Indian nationalists ran governments, even if only at the provincial level.

1937: Congress in power in the provinces

What did the ministries do? The Congress ministries released political prisoners and worked on agrarian relief and basic education. In Madras, the Congress won the assembly, with S. Satyamurti among those who worked for the victory. In Odisha, Vishwanath Das served as premier from 1937 to 1939.

The League and the coalition question. When the Congress refused to form coalition governments with it, the League's demands grew sharper. This episode is often cited as one step in the widening gap between the Congress and the League.

Why does this period matter? The ministries gave Indians practical experience of government and raised the prestige of the Congress. At the same time, the bitterness over coalitions fed the League's later claim that Muslims needed separate protection. Both effects shaped the road to 1947.

1939: war and the resignation of the ministries

What happened in 1939? When the Second World War broke out in 1939, Britain declared India a party to the war without consulting Indian leaders or the elected ministries. To the Congress, this showed that provincial autonomy meant little when the big decisions were still made in London. Towards the end of 1939, the Congress ministries resigned in protest.

From resignation to individual satyagraha, 1939-1940

Why resign rather than stay? Staying in office would have meant helping to run a war effort that Indians had not been asked about. Resigning made the point that India's consent mattered. It also freed the Congress to press its demand for independence in the years that followed.

Attempts at a settlement. In 1940 C. Rajagopalachari proposed a provisional national government at the Centre, but the Viceroy, Linlithgow, rejected the idea. In October 1940 the Congress began a limited individual satyagraha, in which chosen individuals offered protest one by one, and Vinoba Bhave was the first satyagrahi. These moves showed that the Congress still sought a settlement while refusing to support the war unconditionally.

C. Rajagopalachari (left) with Vallabhbhai Patel and Jawaharlal Nehru
C. Rajagopalachari (left) with Vallabhbhai Patel and Jawaharlal NehruPhoto: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

What came next? The resignations opened a new phase of the struggle, which led through the individual satyagraha and the failure of the Cripps Mission to the Quit India Movement. That story is told in the chapter on Quit India, Subhas Bose and the INA.

Quick revision

  • 1909 Morley-Minto: larger councils, no real power; separate electorates for Muslims.
  • 1919 Montagu-Chelmsford: dyarchy in provinces (part responsible to legislature, part to Governor); bicameralism; direct elections; key powers with the colonial government.
  • 1919: separate electorates extended to Sikhs, Europeans, Anglo-Indians, Indian Christians; 1932 Communal Award: depressed classes too.
  • 1935 Act: White Paper March 1933; Bill December 1934; assent 2 August 1935.
  • Provincial autonomy; elections 1937; All-India Federation (provinces compulsory, princely states voluntary) never operated.
  • About 14% could vote; no control over defence and foreign affairs; condemned by Nehru and Jinnah.
  • Constitution borrowed: federal scheme, Governor, judiciary, Public Service Commissions, emergency provisions; Article 395 repealed the 1935 Act.
  • 1937: Congress majorities in 5 of 11 provinces, ministries in 7; prisoners released, agrarian relief, basic education.
  • League's demands grew after the Congress refused coalitions.
  • 1939: India declared at war without consultation; Congress ministries resigned.
  • 1940: Rajagopalachari's provisional government plan rejected by Linlithgow; individual satyagraha from October 1940, Vinoba Bhave first.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. Separate electorates for Muslims were first introduced by the:

  2. Dyarchy, under which one part of the provincial government was responsible to the legislature and the other to the Governor, was introduced by the:

  3. In 1919 separate electorates were extended to which of the following? 1. Sikhs 2. Anglo-Indians 3. Indian Christians Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  4. Consider the following statements about the Government of India Act 1935: 1. It proposed an All-India Federation in which joining was compulsory for the provinces. 2. Joining the federation was compulsory for the princely states as well. 3. The federal part of the Act never came into operation. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  5. Which of the following was NOT drawn by the Constitution of India from the Government of India Act 1935?

  6. Which Article of the Constitution of India repealed the Government of India Act 1935 and the Indian Independence Act 1947?

  7. Assertion (A): Indian leaders such as Jawaharlal Nehru condemned the Government of India Act 1935. Reason (R): Under the Act, Indians had no control over defence and foreign affairs, and only about 14 per cent of the people could vote.

  8. In the provincial elections of 1937, the Congress formed ministries in how many of the eleven provinces?

  9. Why did the Congress ministries resign towards the end of 1939?

  10. Who was the first satyagrahi of the individual satyagraha launched in October 1940?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. "The constitutional reforms of 1909–1935 were designed to preserve British control, yet they shaped the institutions of independent India." Critically examine. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • 1909: larger councils, no real power, separate electorates
    • 1919: dyarchy, bicameralism, direct elections; responsibility without power; electorates extended
    • 1935: provincial autonomy, unrealised federation, 14% franchise, no defence or foreign affairs control
    • 1937–39 ministries: experience of governing; coalition issue with the League; resignation in 1939
    • Legacy: federal scheme, Governor, judiciary, PSCs, emergency provisions; Article 395
    • Communal thread and balanced conclusion

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

In how many provinces did Congress form ministries in 1937?

Initially in seven of the eleven provinces, later rising to eight.

Why did the Congress ministries resign in 1939?

Because the Viceroy declared India at war with Germany without consulting Indian leaders.

What did the Muslim League observe after the resignations?

It observed 22 December 1939 as 'Day of Deliverance'.

Which Act first brought dyarchy?

The Government of India Act 1919, in the provinces; the 1935 Act proposed dyarchy at the centre instead, which never came into force.