HPSC Engineering · Module 31 · standard depth · 15 min
Amendment and the basic structure
What HPSC Engineering asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Screening test (general) · Indian culture, polity and economy
HPSC Engineering questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for HPSC Engineering. 15 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: should rules ever change?
When you were five, your parents probably said: "In bed by eight." At fifteen, that rule changed to ten o'clock, because you had grown. A rule that made sense once stopped fitting. But some family rules never change at any age: "We don't hit each other." "We tell the truth." These are the family's core values.
A country's rulebook faces the same problem, only bigger. India in 1950 had no internet, far fewer cities, and very different problems from today. If the Constitution could never change, it would slowly stop fitting the country, and people might start ignoring it or breaking it. But if it could be changed too easily, whichever party won one election could rewrite the rules to suit itself, perhaps even cancel the next election.
So a good Constitution needs two things at once:
- a door for change, so it can grow with the country;
- a lock on that door, so change needs wide agreement and cannot destroy the core.
This chapter is about both. Article 368 is the door. The basic structure idea, created by the Supreme Court, is the lock on the most important rooms.
Article 368: the door for change
Part XX of the Constitution has just one Article: Article 368. Its title is "Power of Parliament to amend the Constitution and procedure therefor". It does two jobs: it gives Parliament the power to amend, and it lays down how.
Clause (1), added by the 24th Amendment (in force from 5 November 1971), says Parliament may, in exercise of its constituent power, amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any provision of the Constitution. Three words, three kinds of change:
- Addition: put in something new, like a new Article.
- Variation: change the wording of an existing provision.
- Repeal: remove a provision altogether.
Constituent power vs ordinary law-making. When Parliament passes an ordinary law, say on road safety, it is working under the Constitution. When it amends the Constitution, it is changing the rulebook itself. That higher power is called constituent power, and that is why the Constitution asks for a stricter procedure.
An amendment can begin only by introducing a Bill in either House of Parliament, the Lok Sabha or the Rajya Sabha. It cannot start in a State Legislature.
Three levels of difficulty
Not every change needs the same effort. Think of three locks of increasing strength.
Lock 1: Simple majority, outside Article 368. Some changes are made by an ordinary law, passed by a simple majority (more votes for than against), and the Constitution itself says they are not amendments for the purposes of Article 368:
- laws under Articles 2 and 3 that create new States or change their names and boundaries (Article 4);
- laws that create or abolish a Legislative Council in a State, after the State Assembly asks for it (Article 169);
- laws that amend the Fifth Schedule on Scheduled Areas (para 7 of that Schedule).
Lock 2: Special majority. Most amendments need each House to pass the Bill by both:
- a majority of its total membership, and
- not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting.
Here is how the double test works. Imagine a House with 500 members. On the day of the vote, 420 are present and all of them vote. The Bill needs at least 280 votes (two-thirds of 420) and at least 251 votes (more than half of 500).
If 280 vote yes, both tests are passed. But if only 300 were present, two-thirds would be 200, which is not enough, because 251 out of the total is still required. The double test stops a small group from amending the Constitution on a thin day.
Lock 3: Special majority plus the States. If the amendment touches the federal balance between the Union and the States, the Legislatures of not less than one-half of the States must also ratify it, before the Bill goes to the President. These provisions are:
- the election of the President (Articles 54, 55);
- the executive power of the Union and the States (Articles 73, 162), and Article 241;
- the GST Council (Article 279A);
- the Union Judiciary (Chapter IV of Part V) and the High Courts (Chapter V of Part VI);
- legislative relations between Union and States (Chapter I of Part XI) and the Lists in the Seventh Schedule;
- the representation of States in Parliament;
- and Article 368 itself.
The journey of an amendment Bill, step by step
Follow a Bill from start to finish:
- Introduced in either House of Parliament.
- Passed in that House by special majority.
- Passed in the other House by special majority, in the same form.
- If federal provisions are touched, ratified by at least half the State Legislatures.
- Presented to the President, who shall give assent. After the 24th Amendment (1971), the President has no option to withhold assent or send it back.
- The Constitution stands amended in the terms of the Bill.
Five traps examiners love:
- The Bill can start in either House, not only the Lok Sabha.
- If the two Houses disagree, there is no joint sitting for an amendment Bill. Each House must pass it on its own.
- The President must give assent.
- State ratification is needed only for the federal list, and only from half the States, not all.
- Laws under Articles 2, 3, 169 and the Fifth Schedule change the text but are not "amendments" under Article 368.
Who guards the rulebook? A tug of war
Go back to the family. Suppose the eldest sibling is allowed to update house rules. One day they propose: "From now on, the younger ones can't complain to Mum and Dad." Can they?
The rule-maker is trying to remove the very protection that keeps them in check. Someone has to decide whether that kind of change is allowed.
India faced exactly this question with Fundamental Rights. Article 13 says the State cannot make a law that takes away or abridges these rights. But is an amendment a "law"?
If not, Parliament could amend away any right. From 1951 to 1973, Parliament and the Supreme Court pulled in opposite directions:
- Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1965): the Court sided with Parliament. It upheld the power to amend Fundamental Rights under Article 368.
- Golak Nath (1967): the Court changed course. By a narrow 6:5 majority it held that an amendment that takes away or abridges a Fundamental Right is void.
- 24th Amendment (1971): Parliament pulled back hard. It declared it can amend any part of the Constitution, Fundamental Rights included, and added that Article 13 does not apply to amendments made under Article 368.
- Kesavananda Bharati (1973): the Court found a middle path. Heard by 13 judges, the largest Constitution Bench ever, it decided by a 7:6 majority, overruled Golak Nath, and held that Parliament can amend any part, but Article 368 does not let it alter the basic structure of the Constitution.
Think of a house: you may repaint the walls or add a room, but you cannot pull out the pillars it stands on.
After Kesavananda: the doctrine tested
- Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975): the basic structure doctrine was reaffirmed and applied, showing it was not a one-time idea.
- 42nd Amendment (1976): Parliament tried once more to shut the door on the courts. Section 55 of this Amendment added clauses (4) and (5) to Article 368. Clause (4) said no amendment could be questioned in any court on any ground. Clause (5) said there was no limitation whatever on Parliament's power to amend. These came into force on 3 January 1977.
- Minerva Mills (1980): the Court struck down section 55 of the 42nd Amendment. It held that a limited amending power is itself a basic feature of the Constitution. If Parliament could give itself unlimited power, the limit would be meaningless.
A detail worth noticing: the official text of the Constitution still prints clauses (4) and (5) of Article 368, with a footnote saying the section that inserted them was declared invalid in Minerva Mills. So if you read the bare text, you will see them, but they have no force.
Also remember the 24th Amendment's two shields: Article 368(3) and Article 13(4) both say that Article 13 does not apply to amendments made under Article 368. After Kesavananda, this means an amendment is not tested under Article 13, but it can still be struck down if it damages the basic structure.
So what is the basic structure?
There is no fixed list, and you will not find the words "basic structure" anywhere in the Constitution. The idea comes from judgments. The Court has said the basic features are not finite and it decides case by case. Features it has named include:
- supremacy of the Constitution and the rule of law;
- separation of powers and judicial review;
- federalism and secularism;
- the sovereign, democratic, republican structure and the parliamentary system;
- free and fair elections and the independence of the judiciary.
Why these? Ask a simple question about each: "If this were removed, would it still be the same Constitution?" Without free elections, it would not be a democracy. Without judicial review, nobody could stop a law that breaks the rules.
Without federalism, the States would become mere offices of the Union. These are the pillars.
Why the amendment rules are built this way, and what followed
The amendment chapter is really a story of two questions. Why should change be possible at all? And who stops change from going too far? Each rule and each case was an answer to one of these.
| Rule or case | Why it came | What followed |
|---|---|---|
| Article 368: Parliament can amend | A frozen text would break when society changed | Many amendments since 1950 have kept the text in step with the times |
| Special majority | Change should need broad agreement, not a thin majority | Ruling parties usually need support beyond their own numbers |
| Ratification by half the States | Federal features affect States, so States should agree | States have a real voice on matters like the election of the President |
| Simple-majority changes outside Art 368 | Routine matters like new States should not need the hardest route | The map and some details change easily, while the core stays protected |
| Golak Nath (1967) | Fear that amendments could wipe out Fundamental Rights | Parliament answered with the 24th Amendment (1971) |
| Kesavananda Bharati (1973) | A middle path was needed between "amend nothing" and "amend everything" | Parliament can amend any part, but not destroy the basic structure |
| Minerva Mills (1980) | The 42nd Amendment tried to put amendments beyond any court | Limited amending power itself became part of the basic structure |
The balance it created. Before 1973, the contest swung between Parliament and the courts. The basic structure doctrine settled it in a middle way: Parliament changes the Constitution, and the courts guard its identity. Neither has unlimited power.
Why it matters today. Whenever a major amendment is passed, such as one on reservations, the judiciary or federal powers, the first question is whether it touches the basic structure. That is why the doctrine appears again and again in current affairs and in Mains questions.
Quick revision
- Article 368 (Part XX) gives Parliament the power to amend by addition, variation or repeal, and it sets the procedure.
- A Bill can start in either House, and it needs a special majority in each House: a majority of the total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting.
- There is no joint sitting, and the President must assent (24th Amendment, 1971).
- Federal provisions also need ratification by half the States; these include Arts 54, 55, 73, 162, 241 and 279A, the Union Judiciary, the High Courts, legislative relations, the Seventh Schedule Lists, States' representation and Art 368 itself.
- Some changes are not amendments under Article 368: those made under Articles 2 and 3 (through Art 4), Article 169 and para 7 of the Fifth Schedule.
- The cases run in this order: Shankari Prasad 1951 → Sajjan Singh 1965 → Golak Nath 1967 (6:5) → 24th Amdt 1971 → Kesavananda 1973 (13 judges) → Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain 1975 → 42nd Amdt 1976 → Minerva Mills 1980.