HPSC Engineering · Module 40 · standard depth · 10 min
Watchdog bodies: CVC, Lokpal, Information Commission and rights commissions
What HPSC Engineering asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
Screening test (general) · Indian culture, polity and economy
HPSC Engineering questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Cut to standard depth for HPSC Engineering. 9 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: who watches the watchers?
Governments hold huge power: they hire, award contracts, police and spend. Elections punish bad governments only once in five years. In between, citizens need bodies that can check corruption, open up information and protect rights every day.
Constitutional, statutory and executive bodies
India has built many such watchdog bodies. A commission is an appointed, not elected, body with a defined term, functions and powers. Some are created by the Constitution itself, some by an Act of Parliament (statutory bodies), and some by an executive order of the government.
The source of a body matters, because it decides how easily it can be changed or weakened. This chapter studies the Central Vigilance Commission in detail, and then the Lokpal, the Central Information Commission, the National Human Rights Commission and the commissions for Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes.
The Central Vigilance Commission: origin and structure
Origin. The Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) was set up by a Government of India resolution of 11 February 1964. It followed the recommendation of the Committee on Prevention of Corruption, headed by K. Santhanam. At first it was only an executive body.
How the CVC grew
Becoming statutory. An ordinance in 1998 gave the CVC statutory status, and Parliament passed the CVC Act in 2003. It is now an autonomous body, free of control by any executive authority. It monitors all vigilance activity in Central government organisations and advises them on planning, executing and reforming vigilance work.
Composition and appointment. The CVC has a Central Vigilance Commissioner and two Vigilance Commissioners. They are appointed by the President on the recommendation of a committee of:
Appointing and removing the CVC
The Prime Minister (Chairperson).
The Minister of Home Affairs.
The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha.
Removal. The President can remove the CVC or a Vigilance Commissioner for proved misbehaviour or incapacity only after the Supreme Court, on a reference from the President, inquires and recommends removal. The President may also remove a Commissioner who is declared insolvent, is convicted of an offence involving moral turpitude, takes paid outside employment, becomes unfit through infirmity, or acquires an interest that could prejudice the work.
Wings of the CVC. Besides a Secretariat, it has a Chief Technical Examiners' wing, which carries out technical audit of government construction works and helps the CBI in technical matters. It also has Commissioners for Departmental Inquiries, who act as inquiry officers in departmental proceedings against public servants.
What the CVC can and cannot do
Powers:
CVC and CBI: who controls what
Superintendence over the CBI (the Delhi Special Police Establishment) in investigations under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, including reviewing their progress.
Since 2004, the designated agency to receive written complaints from whistle-blowers on corruption or misuse of office.
Publishing a list of cases where permission to investigate is still pending, some more than a year old.
An annual report to the President that records system failures, preventive steps and cases where its advice was not accepted.
Limits:
The CVC's tools beyond punishment
It is only advisory; departments may ignore its advice.
It has a small staff compared with the huge number of establishments it oversees.
It cannot on its own direct the CBI to inquire into officers of Joint Secretary rank and above; the department's permission is needed.
It cannot register criminal cases; it deals with vigilance and disciplinary matters.
It cannot call for CBI files or direct how a case is investigated, and the CBI is under the administrative control of the Department of Personnel and Training.
Appointments remain indirectly in the government's hands, even with the Leader of the Opposition on the committee.
Prevention, not just punishment. The CVC promotes a national anti-corruption strategy, use of technology, integrity in public procurement, whistle-blower protection and preventive vigilance. Every year it drives Vigilance Awareness Week in the last week of October, coinciding with the birthday of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel.
Lokpal and the Central Information Commission
Lokpal: an ombudsman against corruption. An ombudsman is an independent authority that inquires into complaints against public functionaries. India's national ombudsman for corruption was created by the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013. The Act received the President's assent on 1 January 2014, came into force on 16 January 2014, and has been amended once, in 2016.
Lokpal and the Information Commission
Why a Lokpal when there is a CVC? The CVC is mainly an advisory body for vigilance in government departments, and it depends on others for prosecution. A Lokpal was meant to be a stronger, independent authority to inquire into corruption complaints against public functionaries. As its name shows, the Act also covers Lokayuktas for the States.
The Central Information Commission. The Right to Information Act, 2005 gave citizens a legal right to government information. To enforce it, the Central Information Commission was constituted from 12 October 2005. It hears complaints and second appeals when information is refused or delayed, and can impose penalties on officials. Its decisions are final and binding.
Why it matters. Information is the raw material of accountability. Social audits, media investigations and citizens' complaints to bodies like the CVC all depend on access to records, which the Information Commission protects.
Rights commissions: NHRC, NCSC and NCBC
The National Human Rights Commission. The NHRC was set up under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, and marks its Foundation Day on 12 October. Its composition is designed to give it judicial weight:
Rights commissions
Member
Qualification
Chairperson
Has been Chief Justice of India or a Supreme Court judge
One member
Is or has been a Supreme Court judge
One member
Is or has been Chief Justice of a High Court
Three members
At least one must be a woman
The National Commission for Scheduled Castes. The NCSC is a constitutional body, set up to provide safeguards against the exploitation of Scheduled Castes.
The National Commission for Backward Classes. The NCBC was first created by law, the NCBC Act, 1993. The 102nd Amendment Act, 2018 made it a constitutional body. Its duty is to investigate and monitor all matters relating to the safeguards for socially and educationally backward classes.
Why constitutional status for the NCBC? A statutory body can be changed by an ordinary law, while a constitutional body needs an amendment. Raising the NCBC to constitutional status gave backward classes a commission with the same standing as the one for Scheduled Castes.
Quick revision
CVC: resolution of 11 February 1964, Santhanam Committee; statutory by 1998 ordinance and 2003 Act.
CVC + two Vigilance Commissioners; selection committee: PM, Home Minister, Leader of Opposition (Lok Sabha); removal after a Supreme Court inquiry.
Supervises the CBI in Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 cases; whistle-blower agency since 2004; annual report to the President.
Limits: advisory, small staff, no criminal cases, no direction to CBI for Joint Secretary+ without permission; CBI under DoPT.
Vigilance Awareness Week: last week of October (Patel's birthday).
Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013: assent 1 January 2014; in force 16 January 2014; amended 2016.
CIC: from 12 October 2005 under RTI Act; decisions final and binding.
NHRC: PHRA 1993; Chairperson ex-CJI or SC judge; plus SC judge, HC Chief Justice, three members (one woman).
NCBC: Act 1993; constitutional by 102nd Amendment, 2018. NCSC: constitutional body for SC safeguards.
Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 9 answered
The Central Vigilance Commission was set up in 1964 on the recommendation of:
The CVC got statutory status through:
The committee recommending the appointment of the CVC includes: 1. The Prime Minister 2. The Home Minister 3. The Chief Justice of India 4. The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha. Select:
Administrative control of the CBI lies with:
Vigilance Awareness Week is observed in the last week of October because it coincides with the birthday of:
The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 came into force on:
The Central Information Commission was constituted under:
The Chairperson of the NHRC must have been:
Consider: 1. The NCBC became a constitutional body through the 102nd Amendment, 2018. 2. The NHRC is a constitutional body. 3. The NCSC is a constitutional body. Which are correct?
Mains answer practice
Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.
'India's anti-corruption institutions are many but weak.' Critically examine with reference to the CVC and the Lokpal. (250 words)