HPSC HCS · Module 69 · Mains depth · 16 min
Statements: conclusions and assumptions
What HPSC HCS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · General mental ability
- Prelims Paper II: CSAT · Logical reasoning and analytical ability
HPSC HCS has asked 6 questions from this chapter (2021); 17 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: reading what is said and what is behind it
A notice on the office door reads, "The canteen will open at 11 am tomorrow instead of 9 am." From this you can say, with full confidence, that the canteen will open later than usual tomorrow. That is a conclusion: it follows from what is written.
The notice also rests on something it does not say. Whoever wrote it believed that people would read the notice and that 9 am is the usual time. These unstated beliefs are assumptions. Without them, writing the notice would make no sense.
Why the two are tested together. Officers read notes, orders and complaints every day. They must see what a document actually commits to, and what it quietly takes for granted. A plan built on a hidden assumption that turns out false can fail badly.
What this chapter does. We learn tests for a conclusion and for an assumption, the common traps, and the five-grade "inference" format. By the end, you can judge any statement-based question in under a minute.
Testing a conclusion
The core test. Assume the statement is completely true, even if it sounds odd. Then ask: must this conclusion also be true? If you can imagine the statement being true while the conclusion is false, the conclusion does not follow.
What you may use. You may use the statement and common knowledge that everyone shares, such as "a week has seven days". You may not use special knowledge, news or opinions. If a conclusion needs an outside fact, it does not follow.
Restatements follow. A conclusion that says the same thing in other words always follows. If the statement is "Rainfall this year was 30% below normal", then "Rainfall this year was below normal" follows. Students sometimes reject such conclusions because they look too obvious.
Rules and members. When a statement gives a rule, a conclusion about one member follows. "Only those who cleared the written test will be called for interview" and "Meena has been called" give "Meena cleared the written test". But "Meena will be selected" does not follow, because the interview is still ahead.
Why it matters. The test is strict on purpose. It trains you to separate what a document proves from what it merely suggests.
Testing an assumption
What an assumption is. An assumption is a belief the speaker must hold for the statement to make sense, but does not say. It sits behind the statement, not after it. A conclusion comes out of a statement; an assumption goes into it.
The negation test. Write the proposed assumption, then flip it to its opposite. If the flipped version makes the statement pointless or self-defeating, the assumption is implicit. If the statement still makes sense, it is not.
An example. "Use our solar lamps and cut your electricity bill." Flip "People want to lower their electricity bills" to "Nobody cares about the bill", and the advertisement becomes pointless, so this is implicit. Flip "Solar lamps are cheaper than all other lamps" to "Some lamp is cheaper", and the advertisement still works, so this is not implicit.
Standard implicit assumptions. A notice assumes that people will read it. An advertisement assumes that people are influenced by advertisements. Advice assumes that following it will help, and a plan assumes that it can be carried out.
Why it matters. Every policy rests on assumptions, such as that people will use a new facility or that funds will arrive on time. Spotting them early is how good officers prevent failure.
The common traps
Extreme words. Options that use "only", "all", "always", "never", "best" or "must" usually go beyond the statement. "Walk daily to stay healthy" assumes walking helps health, not that walking is the only way. Accept an extreme word only when the statement itself uses it.
Predictions. "Rainfall was 30% below normal" does not prove that "the state will face drought". The future depends on many other things, such as stored water and irrigation. Firm predictions rarely follow unless the statement makes them.
Causes. "Onion prices rose after floods damaged the crop" supports "floods damaged the onion crop". It does not prove that prices will stay high all year, or that floods were the only cause of the rise. Keep to what the statement links, and no more.
Value judgements. A neutral statement does not imply praise or blame. "The government opened a school in every large village" does not imply that small villages need no schools, or that the government is generous. Judgements need words in the statement to support them.
Why it matters. Examiners build wrong options from these four patterns. Knowing them lets you strike out two options quickly and focus on the rest.
Either-or answers and five-grade inferences
When either one must hold. "The meeting will be held on Monday or Tuesday, not both" gives two conclusions: "on Monday" and "on Tuesday". Neither follows alone, but one of them must be true. The answer is "either I or II", just as in syllogisms.
Five-grade inference sets. Some papers give a short passage and several inferences, each to be marked on a scale. Definitely true means it follows directly, and probably true means the passage strongly suggests it. Data inadequate means the passage says nothing either way.
The false end of the scale. Probably false means the passage points against it without fully ruling it out. Definitely false means it contradicts the passage. The middle grade is the most common correct answer for inferences that bring in new facts.
Reading tips for inference sets. Underline each fact the passage states as fact, and mark words that show strength, such as "may", "most" and "is expected to". An inference that copies a fact is definitely true, and one that copies a "may" as a "will" is only probably true at best.
Why it matters. Policy notes are full of "likely", "expected" and "may". Grading how strongly a claim is supported is a daily skill, and this format tests it directly.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners test it. An administrator reads orders and reports that are full of claims and hidden beliefs. Acting on a claim the document does not make, or missing a weak assumption, leads to poor decisions. These questions test careful reading of exactly that kind.
Where it shows up. Statement-and-conclusion and statement-and-assumption questions are regular in state PSC mental-ability sections. The UPSC aptitude paper tests the same skill through passage questions that ask for the most logical inference or the assumption made by the author. Some state papers also use five-grade inference sets.
When it goes wrong. The usual slips are bringing in outside knowledge, accepting options with extreme words, treating a prediction as a conclusion and rejecting a restatement as "too obvious". Another is confusing what follows from a statement with what lies behind it.
The habit to build. For a conclusion, ask "must it be true?". For an assumption, flip it and ask "does the statement still make sense?". Strike out options with extreme words that the statement does not use.
Exam lens: five question types and how to beat each
These are practice questions written by us, in the styles the papers use. Real past questions from your exam appear in the PYQ panel of this module.
Type 1: rule and member. "All officers of the rank of SP and above must attend the briefing; Anil is a DIG." Since a DIG ranks above an SP, the conclusion "Anil must attend" follows.
Type 2: the notice. "Visitors are requested not to feed the animals." The notice assumes that visitors might feed the animals and that they will read the notice, so both are implicit.
Type 3: the extreme word. "Regular revision improves exam scores; assumption: revision is the only way to improve scores." The statement says nothing about other ways, so the assumption is not implicit.
Type 4: prediction versus fact. "The state's literacy rate rose from 62% to 70% in ten years; conclusion: the rate will reach 78% in the next ten years." That is a guess about the future, so it does not follow.
Type 5: five-grade inference. "Passage: Most districts reported higher paddy output this year owing to good rains. Inference: Paddy output rose in every district." "Most" leaves room for exceptions but does not say they exist, so the inference is probably false.
Time plan. A two-option conclusion or assumption question should take about forty seconds. An inference set takes about a minute per inference, so read the passage once with care.
Practice set: twelve solved problems
For each problem, choose one answer: only I, only II, either I or II, neither, or both. Each problem says whether it asks for conclusions that follow or assumptions that are implicit. Try each problem first, then read the steps.
1. Statement: Please submit the form before 5 pm to be considered for the scholarship. Assumptions: (I) some applicants may submit after 5 pm; (II) forms submitted before 5 pm will be considered.
The warning makes sense only if late forms are possible, and it promises to consider forms that arrive on time. The answer is both are implicit.
2. Statement: Use our solar lamps and cut your electricity bill. Assumptions: (I) people want to reduce their electricity bills; (II) solar lamps are cheaper than all other lamps.
Without I, the advertisement is pointless. II uses an extreme word the statement does not need, so the answer is only I is implicit.
3. Statement: The government will open a primary school in every village with more than 300 people. Assumptions: (I) villages with fewer than 300 people do not need schools; (II) some such villages do not have a primary school now.
The plan makes sense only if some large villages lack schools. It says nothing about small villages, so the answer is only II is implicit.
4. Statement: All students who scored above 90% in the district this year are from government schools, and Ravi scored 95% in the district this year. Conclusions: (I) Ravi is from a government school; (II) private school students cannot score above 90%.
I follows from the rule applied to Ravi. II turns one year in one district into a general "cannot", so the answer is only I follows.
5. Statement: Rainfall this year was 30% below normal across the state. Conclusions: (I) the state will face a drought; (II) rainfall was below normal this year.
I is a prediction that depends on other factors. II restates the statement, so the answer is only II follows.
6. Statement: If you want to stay healthy, walk for 30 minutes daily. Assumptions: (I) walking helps health; (II) walking is the only way to stay healthy.
The advice assumes walking works, but not that nothing else does. The answer is only I is implicit.
7. Statement: The library will remain closed on Sunday for repairs. Assumptions: (I) the library is usually open on Sundays; (II) readers will see this notice.
Announcing a Sunday closure makes sense only if Sunday is normally open, and every notice assumes it will be read. The answer is both are implicit.
8. Statement: Only those who cleared the written test will be called for the interview, and Meena has been called. Conclusions: (I) Meena will be selected; (II) Meena cleared the written test.
II follows from the "only" rule. Selection depends on the interview, so the answer is only II follows.
9. Statement: Onion prices rose sharply after floods damaged the crop. Conclusions: (I) floods damaged the onion crop; (II) onion prices will stay high all year.
I restates part of the statement. II is a prediction, so the answer is only I follows.
10. Statement: Carry umbrellas, as it may rain this evening. Assumptions: (I) it will definitely rain this evening; (II) umbrellas give protection from rain.
"May" rules out I, which turns a possibility into a certainty. The advice needs II, so the answer is only II is implicit.
11. Statement: The meeting will be held on Monday or Tuesday, not on both days. Conclusions: (I) the meeting will be on Monday; (II) the meeting will be on Tuesday.
Neither follows alone, but exactly one must be true. The answer is either I or II follows.
12. Statement: The new bridge was opened to traffic last week. Conclusions: (I) traffic jams in the city have ended; (II) the old bridge has been closed.
The statement says nothing about jams or about the old bridge. The answer is neither follows.
Quick revision
- A conclusion follows only if it must be true when the statement is true.
- Use only the statement and common knowledge; a fair restatement always follows.
- An assumption lies behind the statement; flip it, and if the statement loses its sense, it is implicit.
- Notices, advertisements and advice assume they will be read and will work.
- Extreme words and firm predictions usually go beyond the statement.
- When exactly one of two conclusions must hold, the answer is either I or II.
- Five grades: definitely true, probably true, data inadequate, probably false, definitely false.
HPSC HCS questions from this chapter
Statement: The rise in inflation is likely to increase interest rates. Conclusions: (I) There will be decline in the number of borrowers. (II) There will be more deposits in bank. (III) The rate of unemployment will fall.
- (a) Only I follows
- (b) Only III follows
- (c) Both I and II follow
- (d) Both II and III follow
Show answer
(c) Both I and II follow · our answer; official key awaited
Statement: To save the environment, a complete ban on illegal mining should be imposed on the whole country. Assumptions: (I) Mining done legally does not cause any harm to the environment. (II) Mining is one of the factors responsible for environmental damage.
- (a) Only Assumption (I) is implicit.
- (b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (c) Neither Assumption (I) nor Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (d) Both Assumption (I) and Assumption (II) are implicit.
Show answer
(b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit. · our answer; official key awaited
Statement: The largest computer manufacturer has reduced the prices of most of the models of the desktop by about 15 percent with immediate effect. Assumptions: (I) The company may incur huge losses due to the reduction in desktop prices. (II) The sales of desktops manufactured by the company may increase significantly in the near future.
- (a) Only Assumption (I) is implicit.
- (b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (c) Neither Assumption (I) nor Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (d) Either Assumption (I) or Assumption (II) is implicit.
Show answer
(b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit. · our answer; official key awaited
Statement: Before giving full work to the employees, give them work-related training. Assumptions: (I) Training helps the employees to increase their performance. (II) Employees do not have any skills prior to training.
- (a) Only Assumption (I) is implicit.
- (b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (c) Neither Assumption (I) nor Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (d) Both Assumption (I) and Assumption (II) are implicit.
Show answer
(a) Only Assumption (I) is implicit. · our answer; official key awaited
Statement: It is necessary to grow different types of crops in each alternate season to replenish the nutrients in the soil. Assumptions: (I) No crop can be grown for the second time in the same field. (II) If a different crop is grown in the next season, the soil does not require additional nutrients like fertilizers.
- (a) Only Assumption (I) is implicit.
- (b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (c) Neither Assumption (I) nor Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (d) Either Assumption (I) or Assumption (II) is implicit.
Show answer
(c) Neither Assumption (I) nor Assumption (II) is implicit. · our answer; official key awaited
Statement: If farmers want better yield then they should use organic manure instead of chemical manure. Assumptions: (I) Chemical fertilizers have some bad effects on health. (II) Chemical fertilizers do not produce as much yield as organic fertilizers.
- (a) Only Assumption (I) is implicit.
- (b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (c) Neither Assumption (I) nor Assumption (II) is implicit.
- (d) Both Assumption (I) and Assumption (II) are implicit.
Show answer
(b) Only Assumption (II) is implicit. · our answer; official key awaited