HPSC HCS · Module 64 · Mains depth · 20 min
Time and work, pipes and cisterns
What HPSC HCS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · General mental ability
- Prelims Paper II: CSAT · Basic numeracy and data interpretation (Class X level)
HPSC HCS has asked 6 questions from this chapter (2023, 2022); 26 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: a wall cut into strips
Ramesh can paint a school wall in 12 days, and Suresh can paint the same wall in 6 days. If they work together, how long will it take? Many students add the days and say 18, but two people working together must finish faster than either one alone.
Think of the wall as 12 equal strips. Ramesh paints 12 strips in 12 days, so he paints 1 strip a day. Suresh paints 12 strips in 6 days, so he paints 2 strips a day. Together they paint 3 strips a day, and 12 strips take 12 ÷ 3 = 4 days.
The key idea is the rate of work: how much of the job is done in one unit of time. Days do not add, but rates do. Once you know each person's rate, every question in this chapter becomes simple addition and division.
Why this topic exists. Every project, from a road to a vaccination drive, asks the same question: with these people and these machines, how long will it take? Planners estimate labour and time before money is released. The puzzles in this chapter are small, clean versions of that everyday planning.
Rates add, days do not
The fraction way. If a person finishes a job in n days, he does 1⁄n of it in one day. Ramesh does ¹⁄₁₂ a day and Suresh ¹⁄₆ a day. Together they do ¹⁄₁₂ + ¹⁄₆ = ³⁄₁₂ = ¼ a day, so the job takes 4 days.
The two-person formula. For A in a days and B in b days, the joint rate is 1⁄a + 1⁄b = (a + b) ÷ ab. Turning the rate upside down gives the time: ab ÷ (a + b) days. For 12 and 6 days this is 72 ÷ 18 = 4 days, the same answer.
Three people. Add all three rates. If A, B and C take 10, 15 and 30 days, the rates are ¹⁄₁₀ + ¹⁄₁₅ + ¹⁄₃₀ = ⁶⁄₃₀ = ⅕, so together they need 5 days. Do not try to use the two-person formula twice on three people without care; adding rates is safer.
Working backwards. If A and B together take 8 days and A alone takes 12, then B's rate is ⅛ − ¹⁄₁₂ = ¹⁄₂₄. So B alone needs 24 days. Subtracting rates finds the missing person.
A quick sense check. The time taken together is always less than the time of the faster worker alone. If two people take 12 and 6 days, the answer must be below 6. Any option above 6 can be struck off at once.
Why it matters. The rate idea is the backbone of the whole chapter, and of speed and distance in the next chapter too. Learn to ask "how much in one day?" before anything else.
The unit method: no fractions at all
The trick. Fractions with different denominators are slow to add. Instead, take the total work as the LCM of the given days. Then every person's daily work is a whole number, called their efficiency.
Example. A, B and C take 10, 15 and 30 days, and the LCM is 30, so call the job 30 units. A does 30 ÷ 10 = 3 units a day, B does 2 and C does 1. Together they do 6 units a day, so the job takes 30 ÷ 6 = 5 days, with no fractions anywhere.
Efficiency and time. If A is twice as efficient as B, A takes half the time. Efficiency and time are inversely proportional, because efficiency × time = total work, which stays fixed. So "A is 50% more efficient than B, and B takes 30 days" means A takes 30 ÷ 1.5 = 20 days.
Sharing wages. Pay is shared by work done, not by days present. If A and B do a job together for ₹9,000 and their efficiencies are 3 and 2 units a day, they did work in the ratio 3 : 2. So A gets ₹5,400 and B gets ₹3,600.
When a third person helps. Suppose A and B together take 6 days for a ₹6,000 job, but with C's help they finish in 4 days. The job is 12 units, so A and B do 2 units a day and all three do 3. C did 1 unit a day for 4 days, that is 4 of the 12 units, so C earns ⅓ of ₹6,000 = ₹2,000.
Why it matters. The unit method is the single biggest time-saver in this chapter. It turns every question into small whole numbers that you can handle in your head under exam pressure.
Man-days: more workers, fewer days
The idea. A job needs a fixed amount of labour, measured in man-days or man-hours. If 10 workers finish a road patch in 12 days, the patch needs 10 × 12 = 120 man-days. Then 15 workers need 120 ÷ 15 = 8 days.
The full rule. When hours a day and the amount of work also change, use M₁ × D₁ × H₁ ÷ W₁ = M₂ × D₂ × H₂ ÷ W₂. Here M is the number of workers, D the days, H the hours a day and W the work. The left side and the right side are both "labour per unit of work", which does not change for the same kind of job.
Example. 12 workers working 8 hours a day dig a 240 m drain in 10 days. How many days will 16 workers working 6 hours a day take for a 360 m drain? Put the numbers in: 12 × 10 × 8 ÷ 240 = 16 × D × 6 ÷ 360, so 4 = 96D ÷ 360 and D = 15 days.
A direction check. More workers mean fewer days, fewer hours a day mean more days, and more work means more days. Before multiplying, ask whether each change should push the answer up or down. This catches most slips.
Why it matters. Man-days is how labour budgets are actually written. Rural employment schemes, for example, measure work done in person-days, and a block officer reads such figures every week.
Pipes, cisterns and leaks
Same idea, with signs. A pipe that fills a tank in 6 hours adds ⅙ of the tank each hour. A pipe or leak that empties it in 12 hours removes ¹⁄₁₂ each hour. So pipes and cisterns are time and work where some workers have a minus sign.
Example with units. Pipe A fills a tank in 20 hours, pipe B in 30 hours and a leak C empties it in 60 hours. Take the tank as 60 units: A adds 3 units an hour, B adds 2 and C removes 1. The net rate is 3 + 2 − 1 = 4 units an hour, so the tank fills in 60 ÷ 4 = 15 hours.
Finding a leak. A pipe alone fills a tank in 8 hours, but because of a leak it takes 10 hours. Take the tank as 40 units: the pipe adds 5 units an hour, while the actual net is 4. The leak removes 1 unit an hour, so on its own it would empty the full tank in 40 hours.
When the tank never fills. If the emptying rate is greater than the filling rate, the net rate is negative and the tank will not fill at all. A full tank in that case empties at the net rate. Always check the sign of the net rate before dividing.
Why it matters. Tanks, reservoirs and storage all work on inflow minus outflow. The same arithmetic runs a village water tank, a dam's storage and even a bank balance with income and spending.
Leaving midway and working by turns
Leaving midway. A and B can do a job in 12 and 18 days; they start together, and A leaves after 4 days. Take the job as 36 units: A does 3 a day and B does 2, so in 4 days they finish 20 units. B does the remaining 16 units alone in 8 days, so the job takes 12 days in all.
Joining later. The method is the same in reverse. Count what the first person does alone, then let both share the rest at their combined rate. Draw a short time line with phases, and the arithmetic becomes easy to follow.
Working by turns. A and B take 6 and 9 days, and they work on alternate days, starting with A. With 18 units, A does 3 and B does 2, so one two-day cycle does 5 units. Three cycles (6 days) do 15 units, A does 3 more on day 7, and the job ends exactly on day 7.
The last-day trap. In alternate-day questions, do not simply divide the total by the work per cycle. Run whole cycles until little is left, then go day by day, because the job may finish part-way through someone's turn. Check who works on the final day.
Pipes by turns. The same method works when pipes are opened and closed in turns. Treat each hour as one turn, add the net units hour by hour and watch for the moment the tank becomes full.
Why it matters. Real projects rarely have the same team from start to finish. Breaking work into phases is exactly how a project manager tracks progress against a plan.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners test it. Time and work checks whether you can think in rates, which is the heart of planning. An officer must judge whether a contractor's promise of finishing a bridge in a month is realistic with the labour on site. The same reasoning tells how many health workers a vaccination drive needs.
Where it shows up. The topic appears in the aptitude papers of the union and state services, usually as one or two direct questions. State papers often ask the classic pipes and cisterns question. Recruitment exams for teachers, police and clerks ask it almost every year.
When it goes wrong. The usual slips are adding days instead of rates, dividing wages by days present, forgetting the minus sign of a leak and missing the last day in alternate-day questions. Each slip has a matching wrong option waiting in the paper.
The habit to build. Convert every statement into units a day using the LCM. Write the rates in a small row, add or subtract them, and divide the total work only at the end.
Exam lens: five question types and how to beat each
These are practice questions written by us, in the styles the papers use. Real past questions from your exam appear in the PYQ panel of this module.
Type 1: together and alone. "A can do a job in 15 days and A and B together in 10 days. How long will B alone take?" With 30 units, A does 2 a day and both do 3, so B does 1 a day and needs 30 days.
Type 2: efficiency. "A is twice as efficient as B, and together they finish a job in 18 days. How long will A alone take?" Rates 2 and 1 give 3 units a day for 54 units, so A alone needs 54 ÷ 2 = 27 days.
Type 3: man-days. "20 men build a wall in 15 days. How many men are needed to build it in 12 days?" The wall needs 300 man-days, so 300 ÷ 12 = 25 men.
Type 4: pipes with a leak. "Two pipes fill a tank in 12 and 15 hours, and a third empties it in 20 hours. If all are opened together, when is the tank full?" With 60 units the net rate is 5 + 4 − 3 = 6 units an hour, so it fills in 10 hours.
Type 5: phases. "A and B can finish a job in 20 and 30 days. They work together for 6 days, and then A leaves. How long does B take for the rest?" With 60 units they do 30 in 6 days, so B needs 30 ÷ 2 = 15 more days.
Time plan. Types 1, 2 and 3 should take under a minute each. Types 4 and 5 can take a minute and a half, so set up the units first and write the phases on a line.
Practice set: twelve solved problems
Try each problem first, then read the steps. The problems go from easy to hard.
1. A can do a job in 10 days and B in 15 days. How long will they take together?
Use ab ÷ (a + b) = 150 ÷ 25. The answer is 6 days.
2. A and B together finish a job in 12 days, and A alone in 20 days. How long will B alone take?
With 60 units, both do 5 a day and A does 3, so B does 2. The answer is 30 days.
3. A, B and C can do a job in 12, 15 and 20 days. How long will all three take together?
With 60 units, the rates are 5, 4 and 3, which make 12 a day. The answer is 5 days.
4. 15 men can dig a pond in 16 days. How many days will 20 men take?
The pond needs 240 man-days, and 240 ÷ 20 = 12. The answer is 12 days.
5. A is three times as efficient as B, and B alone takes 24 days. How long will they take together?
A takes 8 days, so with 24 units the rates are 3 and 1. The answer is 6 days.
6. A pipe fills a tank in 6 hours and another empties it in 8 hours. If both are open, when is the tank full?
With 24 units the net rate is 4 − 3 = 1 unit an hour. The answer is 24 hours.
7. A and B can do a job for ₹4,500 in 10 and 15 days. They work together. What is A's share?
Their work is in the ratio 3 : 2, so A gets ³⁄₅ of ₹4,500. The answer is ₹2,700.
8. Two pipes fill a tank in 10 and 12 hours, and a leak empties it in 20 hours. With all three open, when is the tank full?
With 60 units the net rate is 6 + 5 − 3 = 8 units an hour, and 60 ÷ 8 = 7.5. The answer is 7½ hours.
9. 8 workers working 9 hours a day finish a job in 20 days. How many days will 12 workers working 8 hours a day take?
Use 8 × 20 × 9 = 12 × D × 8, so D = 1,440 ÷ 96. The answer is 15 days.
10. A and B can do a job in 15 and 20 days. They work together for 4 days, and then A leaves. How many more days does B need?
With 60 units they do 28 in 4 days, and B does the other 32 at 3 a day. The answer is 10⅔ days.
11. A pipe fills a tank in 4 hours, but a leak makes it take 5 hours. How long will the leak take to empty a full tank?
With 20 units the pipe adds 5 an hour and the net is 4, so the leak removes 1. The answer is 20 hours.
12. A and B can do a job in 4 and 6 days. They work on alternate days, starting with A. On which day does the job end?
With 12 units, each two-day cycle does 5 units, so after 4 days 10 units are done. On day 5, A does the last 2 units, needing only ⅔ of the day. The answer is day 5.
Quick revision
- One day's work = 1 ÷ (days for the whole job), and rates of people working together add.
- Two people taking a and b days finish together in ab ÷ (a + b) days.
- Take the total work as the LCM of the days, so each person's daily work is a whole number.
- Efficiency × time = total work, so a person twice as efficient takes half the time.
- Wages are shared in the ratio of work done.
- Man-days rule: M₁ × D₁ × H₁ ÷ W₁ = M₂ × D₂ × H₂ ÷ W₂.
- Filling pipes add, emptying pipes and leaks subtract.
- With phases or turns, add the work of each phase and watch the last day.
HPSC HCS questions from this chapter
One contractor had undertaken a construction work. To complete the given job, he sought labour comprising 24 men for 12 days for working 10 hours a day. But due to festival season, as the labour had gone to their respective hometowns, he could get only 15 men and they too were willing to work 8 hours a day. With this much labour, in how many days would he be able to complete the same job?
- (a) 20 days
- (b) 22 days
- (c) 24 days
- (d) 26 days
Show answer
(c) 24 days · our answer; official key awaited
Rajender engages Sunil and Vijay to do some construction work in his office. Sunil is highly skilled and is 3½ times as good a workman as Vijay. Therefore, he is able to finish his work in 45 days less than Vijay. In how many days they both working together, can finish the work?
- (a) 26 days
- (b) 22 days
- (c) 18 days
- (d) 14 days
Show answer
(d) 14 days · our answer; official key awaited
P does a job in 11 days while Q takes 12 days and R takes 22 days for the same job. P and Q started working together. But, after two days they left and R had to complete the job. Find the number of days required to complete the job.
- (a) 46/3 days
- (b) 49/3 days
- (c) 52/3 days
- (d) 55/3 days
Show answer
(b) 49/3 days · our answer; official key awaited
A tap can fill a tank in 45 minutes and another tap can empty it in 3 hours. If both taps are opened at 11:30 AM, then the tank will be filled by:
- (a) 12:30 PM
- (b) 01:30 PM
- (c) 02:30 PM
- (d) 03:30 PM
Show answer
(a) 12:30 PM · our answer; official key awaited
45 people take 18 days to dig a pond. If the pond would have to be dug in 15 days, then the number of people to be employed will be
- (a) 50
- (b) 54
- (c) 60
- (d) 72
Show answer
(b) 54 · our answer; official key awaited
A stock of food is enough for 240 men for 48 days. How long will the same stock last for 160 men?
- (a) 54 days
- (b) 60 days
- (c) 64 days
- (d) 72 days
Show answer
(d) 72 days · our answer; official key awaited