HPSC HCS course‹› 0:00 studied

HPSC HCS · Module 46 · Mains depth · 17 min

GST: one tax for one market, the GST Council and the 2025 reform

What HPSC HCS asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Prelims Paper I: General Studies · Indian culture, polity and economy

HPSC HCS questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: one country, many tax walls

Imagine a truck carrying soap from a factory in Gujarat to a shop in Bihar. In the past, it could stop at state border check-posts on the way. Each state had its own taxes, forms and rates, and goods had to be checked again and again.

A truck stopped at every state border

Taxes also piled on top of each other. A manufacturer paid tax on raw materials, then on the finished soap. The wholesaler and the shop added their own taxes, often on a price that already included earlier taxes. Economists call this tax on tax, or the cascading effect.

The Goods and Services Tax (GST), launched on 1 July 2017, was designed to break these walls. The idea was simple: one tax on the supply of goods and services, collected in steps, with credit for tax already paid.

This chapter explains how GST works, how the Constitution was changed for it, how the GST Council decides rates, and what changed in the 2025 reform.

How GST works: tax only on value added

Think of a shirt. A cotton farmer sells cotton, a mill makes cloth, a tailor stitches the shirt, and a shop sells it to you. Each step adds value.

Tax on value added at each step

Under GST, each seller collects tax on its sale. But it can subtract the tax it already paid on its inputs. This deduction is called input tax credit. So each step effectively pays tax only on the value it adds.

A simple example at 5%. The mill buys cotton for ₹100 and pays ₹5 tax. It sells cloth for ₹200 and collects ₹10 tax. It pays the government only ₹10 − ₹5 = ₹5, the tax on its value addition of ₹100.

Why this matters: because each step gets credit for earlier tax, there is no tax on tax. The final buyer bears the full tax once, and the tax trail across the chain encourages sellers to keep proper records.

Changing the Constitution: the 101st Amendment

Before GST, the Constitution divided taxing powers: the Centre taxed manufacture and many services, and the states taxed sale of goods. A single tax shared by both needed a constitutional amendment.

Dual GST: CGST, SGST and IGST

The 101st Amendment. Parliament passed the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016. It received the President's assent on 8 September 2016.

Dual GST. GST in India is levied by both the Centre and the states on the same supply. You will see these parts on a bill:

  • CGST: Central GST;
  • SGST: State GST;
  • IGST: Integrated GST.

Article 279A. The amendment added Article 279A, which provides for the GST Council. It came into force on 12 September 2016, and the Council had to be set up within 60 days.

The GST Council: cooperative federalism at work

The GST Council is where the Centre and the states decide GST together: tax rates, exemptions, rules and changes. Its first meeting was held on 22–23 September 2016.

Inside the GST Council

How it votes. Voting is weighted:

  • the Centre's vote counts for one-third of the total;
  • the states together count for two-thirds;
  • a decision needs a three-fourths majority of the weighted votes.

What this means. Neither side can decide alone. The Centre cannot pass a decision without many states, and the states together cannot pass one without the Centre. This forces bargaining and consensus.

Why this matters: the Council is often called the best example of cooperative federalism in India. States gave up their separate power to tax sales, and in return they got a shared voice in one national tax.

The 2025 reform: two main rates

The problem. For its first eight years, GST had a four-tier rate structure. Several rates meant disputes about which rate applied to which product, and more paperwork for businesses.

GST rates before and after September 2025

The change. After the 56th GST Council meeting, the new structure came into effect on 22 September 2025. The 2026 fiscal policy statement describes it as a move to a two-rate structure:

  • a standard rate of 18%;
  • a merit rate of 5%, for essential and common-use items;
  • a special demerit rate of 40%, for a select few goods and services.

Tobacco products. For pan masala, gutkha, cigarettes, zarda, unmanufactured tobacco and bidi, the existing rates continue. They stay until the loans and interest under the compensation cess account are fully repaid.

Why this matters: fewer rates mean simpler compliance and fewer classification disputes. Lower rates on common items also aim to support household spending.

The compensation promise: why States agreed to GST

Start with a fear. Before GST, each State taxed goods made or sold within it, and some States earned a lot from taxes on goods produced in their factories. GST is collected where goods and services are finally consumed, so a State that makes more than it consumes could lose revenue. Asking States to give up a large part of their power to tax, with no guarantee, would have been a hard sell.

How GST compensation worked

The promise. To win their support, States were assured compensation for any loss of revenue arising from GST for five years, starting from 1 July 2017. Their revenue was protected at a growth rate of 14% per year over the base year 2015-16. If a State's actual GST revenue fell short of this protected amount, the Centre would make up the gap.

How it was paid for. The money came from a compensation cess charged on certain goods, such as tobacco products and some luxury items. When the pandemic cut collections in 2020-21 and 2021-22, the cess was not enough to pay the full compensation, so loans were raised, and the cess on tobacco products now continues until those loans and interest are repaid.

After five years. The five-year period ran out in 2022, and a few States asked for the compensation to be extended beyond the transition period. Many States had built their budgets around 14% growth, which was higher than their GST revenue actually grew in several years. The end of compensation therefore pushed States to improve their own collections.

Why it matters. The compensation promise was the price of building trust between the Centre and the States, and without it GST might not have been agreed at all. It also shows the trade-off of a shared tax: States gain a common market but lose the freedom to set their own rates. A good Mains answer uses compensation to discuss fiscal federalism, asking how States can be given more revenue certainty within GST.

Following the paper trail: e-way bills and e-invoices

Start with a truck. A truck carrying goods worth lakhs crosses three States in two days. Under the old system, check-posts at State borders stopped it to inspect papers, which cost time and invited bribes. GST removed most check-posts, but the tax department still needed a way to know what was moving and to stop fake bills.

From invoice to e-way bill

The e-way bill (2018). From 1 April 2018, an e-way bill became mandatory for all inter-State movement of goods. Before the truck leaves, the supplier generates the bill online with details of the goods, the buyer and the vehicle. Officers can check it electronically on the way, so most trucks move without long stops.

The e-invoice (2020). Fake invoices let some businesses claim input tax credit for taxes that were never paid. From 1 October 2020, taxpayers with an aggregate turnover of ₹500 crore and above must issue an e-invoice, which is registered on a government portal and gets a unique number. Because the invoice is reported at the moment it is issued, the buyer's credit can be matched with the seller's tax, which makes fake bills much harder.

Why it matters. These tools show how GST relies on technology to replace physical checks. They cut delays for honest traders and catch fraud that paper systems missed, and the data also helps the government understand the economy in real time. A good Mains answer notes the gains and also the costs for small traders who must learn and comply with digital systems.

Why India built one tax out of many: when, where and why

The problem: tax on tax. Before GST, a factory paid central excise, a trader paid state VAT, a service provider paid service tax, and goods crossing a state border paid more. Credit for tax paid at one stage often could not be used at the next, so tax was charged on tax (cascading). With different taxes and rules in each state, India behaved like many small markets rather than one.

The long road to GST

Where the idea came from (2003 to 2016). The Kelkar Task Force on indirect tax suggested a comprehensive GST in 2003. The Budget Speech of 2006-07 first proposed a national GST by 1 April 2010, and the Empowered Committee of State Finance Ministers was asked to prepare its design. Bills were introduced in 2011 and 2014 before the 101st Constitutional Amendment finally received assent on 8 September 2016.

Why it took a constitutional amendment. The Constitution had divided taxing powers: the Centre taxed manufacture and services, the states taxed sales. A tax on every supply by both levels needed new powers for both, and a forum where they decide together. That forum is the GST Council (Article 279A), with the Centre holding one-third of the votes and the states two-thirds.

What it replaced. GST subsumed central taxes such as excise, service tax and CVD, and state taxes such as VAT, CST, entertainment tax, octroi and entry tax, purchase tax and luxury tax. Seamless input tax credit through the chain is meant to remove cascading and make India one common market.

Implications. States gave up much of their independent power over indirect taxes in return for a shared base and a seat on the Council, which is why GST is also called an experiment in cooperative federalism. The September 2025 move to two main rates (5% and 18%) shows the system still evolving towards simplicity.

Mains lens: has GST delivered?

1. The gains.

Has GST delivered?
  • One national market: goods move across states with one tax system, which cuts delays and costs.
  • Less cascading: input tax credit removes tax on tax.
  • More formal economy: the invoice trail brings more businesses into the tax net.
  • Cooperative federalism: the Council has made the Centre and states decide together.

2. The problems.

  • Complexity: frequent changes in rules and rates in the early years raised compliance costs, especially for small firms.
  • Disputes: classification of products and input tax credit claims have led to litigation.
  • States' revenue worries: states gave up an independent tax and depend on the Council's decisions and on the Centre for some transfers.
  • Items outside GST: some major items are still outside GST, which breaks the credit chain.

3. The 2025 reform addresses complexity by moving to two main rates. Its success will depend on stable rules and on how revenues hold up.

A good conclusion: GST is among India's biggest tax reforms. Simpler rates, stable rules and trust between the Centre and states will decide whether it fully becomes "one nation, one tax".

Mains practice: five questions, five angles

These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam are in the PYQ panel of this module.

Angle Question Key points to cover
Why (origin) Why did India adopt GST? What problems was it meant to solve? Explain cascading, the many separate taxes and the fragmented national market. Then trace the idea from the Kelkar Task Force of 2003 and the Budget of 2006-07 to the 101st Amendment.
Federalism "The GST Council is a model of cooperative federalism." Critically examine. Explain the vote weights of one-third and two-thirds and the three-fourths majority. Then weigh this against the states' loss of fiscal autonomy and the disputes over compensation.
Evaluate Assess the performance of GST since 2017. Credit GST with building a common market and improving compliance, and note the rate rationalisation of 2025. Then discuss the problems of refunds and disputes.
Reform Discuss the significance of the GST rate reform of September 2025. Explain the move to two main rates of 5% and 18% and a 40% rate for demerit goods. Then discuss the gain in simplicity and the effects on consumption and revenue.
Way forward Should petroleum products and electricity be brought under GST? Discuss. Explain that keeping them out causes cascading in inputs. Then weigh the states' dependence on this revenue and the need for consensus in the Council.

How to use this table: each answer should explain the what, then the why from the section above, and end with a way forward.

Quick revision

  • GST was launched on 1 July 2017, after the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016 received the President's assent on 8 September 2016.
  • Article 279A, which creates the GST Council, came into force on 12 September 2016, and the Council first met on 22–23 September 2016.
  • In the Council, the Centre holds one-third of the votes and the states together hold two-thirds, and a decision needs three-fourths of the weighted votes.
  • India has a dual GST, so the Centre levies CGST, the states levy SGST, and IGST applies to supplies between states.
  • Input tax credit lets each seller subtract the tax already paid on inputs, which removes tax on tax.
  • The 2025 reform, in effect from 22 September 2025, moved to an 18% standard rate, a 5% merit rate and a 40% special rate for demerit goods.
  • Tobacco items keep their existing rates until the loans taken for compensation cess, with interest, are repaid.
  • States were promised compensation for five years from 1 July 2017, with revenue protected at 14% growth a year over 2015-16, paid from a compensation cess.
  • The e-way bill became mandatory for inter-State movement of goods from 1 April 2018, and e-invoicing began on 1 October 2020 for turnover of ₹500 crore and above.

Common confusions and exam traps:

Revision card: GST
  • The Centre does not have a veto by itself: one-third is less than the three-fourths needed, but without it the states cannot reach three-fourths either.
  • The 40% rate is a special demerit rate for a few items, not a general slab.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. GST was launched in India on:

  2. Consider the following statements: 1. GST was enabled by the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016. 2. Article 279A provides for the GST Council. 3. Article 279A came into force on 1 July 2017. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. In the GST Council, decisions require:

  4. After the GST reform effective 22 September 2025, the two main rates are:

  5. Assertion (A): Tobacco products such as cigarettes and bidi kept their existing GST rates after the September 2025 reform. Reason (R): Their rates continue until loan and interest obligations under the compensation cess account are fully discharged.

  6. Input tax credit under GST mainly helps to:

  7. A comprehensive Goods and Services Tax for India was first suggested by:

  8. Which one of the following taxes was NOT subsumed in GST?

  9. Under the GST compensation arrangement, States' revenue was protected at what annual growth rate over the base year 2015-16?

  10. Consider the following statements: 1. The e-way bill became mandatory for all inter-State movement of goods from 1 April 2018. 2. E-invoicing became mandatory for all GST taxpayers from 1 October 2020. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. How has the GST Council embodied cooperative federalism? Evaluate the September 2025 rate reform. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • GST 1 Jul 2017; 101st Amendment 2016; Art 279A (12 Sep 2016)
    • Council: Centre 1/3, states 2/3, 3/4 needed; no one decides alone
    • ITC removes cascading; one national market; formalisation
    • Problems: complexity, disputes, states' revenue autonomy
    • Sep 2025: 18% standard, 5% merit, 40% special demerit; tobacco until cess loans repaid
    • Conclusion: stable rules, trust
  2. Why was compensation to States central to the adoption of GST, and what does its end mean for fiscal federalism? (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Explain why producing States feared losing revenue under a tax collected where goods are consumed.
    • State the promise: five years from 1 July 2017, 14% protected growth over 2015-16, funded by a compensation cess.
    • Discuss the pandemic shortfall, the loans, and States' requests to extend compensation after 2022.
    • Conclude on ways to give States revenue certainty within GST, such as better compliance tools and a stronger GST Council process.

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

When was GST implemented in India?

GST was launched on 1 July 2017, after the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016 received the President's assent on 8 September 2016.

How are decisions taken in the GST Council?

The Centre's vote has a weight of one-third and the states together two-thirds. A decision needs a three-fourths majority of the weighted votes.

What are the GST rates after the 2025 reform?

From 22 September 2025, the four-tier structure was replaced by a standard rate of 18% and a merit rate of 5%, plus a special demerit rate of 40% for a few goods.

Which taxes did GST replace?

GST subsumed central taxes such as Central Excise Duty, Service Tax and Additional Customs Duty, and state taxes such as VAT, Central Sales Tax, Entertainment Tax and Octroi.