HPSC HCS · Module 41 · Mains depth · 13 min
NITI Aayog and the administrative reform commissions
What HPSC HCS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · Indian culture, polity and economy
- Mains · GS II: constitution, polity, governance, welfare schemes
HPSC HCS has asked 2 questions from this chapter (2023, 2019); 4 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: who plans, and who reforms?
After independence, India set out to change a poor, largely rural country through planned effort. A government that wants rapid growth needs two kinds of help. It needs a body to think ahead: to set priorities and design policies. It also needs bodies to fix the machinery of administration that carries those policies out.
For the first job, India created the Planning Commission in 1950. It worked until the end of 2014, and on 1 January 2015 it was replaced by the National Institution for Transforming India, better known as NITI Aayog.
For the second job, the government set up many committees and commissions on administrative reform. The administrative machinery inherited from colonial rule was found weak for the new welfare and development tasks. The two biggest of these bodies were the First Administrative Reforms Commission (1966) and the Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2005).
Unlike the Election Commission or the CAG, none of these bodies is created by the Constitution. NITI Aayog and the ARCs were set up by government resolution, so they are executive bodies that advise rather than decide.
NITI Aayog: how it is organised
NITI Aayog brings the Prime Minister, Union ministers, experts and the States to one table. Its structure shows this mix:
| Part | Who |
|---|---|
| Chairperson | The Prime Minister |
| Vice-Chairperson | Appointed by the Prime Minister |
| Governing Council | Chief Ministers of all States and Lt. Governors of Union Territories |
| Regional Councils | Chaired by the PM, with the CMs and LGs of a region, for issues affecting more than one State, for a fixed tenure |
| Members | Full-time members; up to 2 part-time members from universities or research bodies, by rotation; up to 4 ex-officio Union ministers nominated by the PM |
| CEO | Appointed by the PM for a fixed tenure, of the rank of Secretary to the Government of India |
| Special invitees | Experts and practitioners nominated by the PM |
Seven pillars. NITI says it works on seven pillars: pro-people, pro-activity, participation, empowerment, inclusion, equality and transparency. Participation means involving citizens, empowerment includes women, and inclusion covers SCs, STs, OBCs, minorities and the poor.
What NITI Aayog does
NITI is meant to be a think tank and a meeting point, not a body that commands. Its main functions are:
- Shared vision. It evolves national development priorities and strategies together with the States.
- Cooperative federalism. It works with the States on a continuing basis, on the idea that strong States make a strong nation.
- Plans from below. It develops ways to make credible plans at the village level and add them up at higher levels of government.
- Security in economics. It makes sure national security interests are built into economic strategy.
- Those left behind. It pays special attention to groups that may not benefit enough from economic progress.
- Long-term policy with monitoring. It designs long-term policies and programmes, monitors them, and uses the lessons for mid-course correction.
- Knowledge hub. It encourages partnerships with research institutions, supports innovation and entrepreneurship, and keeps a resource centre on good governance and best practices.
- Problem-solver. It offers a platform to settle inter-sectoral and inter-departmental issues so that development work moves faster.
Why the shift matters. NITI's own stated functions stress States as partners and plans built from the village upward. That is why it is often linked to cooperative federalism, a theme you met in Centre–State tensions and cooperation.
Seventy years of administrative reform
From 1947, the government repeatedly asked experts to examine how its own machinery worked. The main milestones are worth knowing in order:
| Year | Body | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| 1947 | Secretariat Reorganisation Committee (Girija Shankar Bajpai) | Manpower shortages and work procedures in the Central Secretariat |
| 1950 | N. Gopalaswamy Ayyangar report | Grouping of ministries, better personnel, O&M Division |
| 1951 | A.D. Gorwala Committee | Efficient public enterprises, discipline, minister–civil servant relations |
| 1953, 1956 | Paul H. Appleby (American expert) | Administrative reorganisation; government industrial and commercial undertakings |
| 1962 | Committee on Prevention of Corruption (K. Santhanam) | Causes of corruption and ways to check it; led to the CVC |
| 1966 | First Administrative Reforms Commission | The whole of public administration, Centre and States |
| 1977 | National Police Commission (Dharam Vira) | Role of police, crime control, investigation, prosecution |
| 1981 | Economic Reforms Commission (L.K. Jha) | Modernising economic administration |
| 1983 | Commission on Centre-State Relations (R.S. Sarkaria) | Review of Union–State arrangements in all spheres |
| 2005 | Second Administrative Reforms Commission | A blueprint for revamping public administration |
The thread that runs through. Early reports focused on efficiency: staff, procedures and public enterprises. Later bodies turned to integrity, policing and federal relations, and the Second ARC put citizens, ethics and information at the centre.
The First Administrative Reforms Commission (1966)
Set up. The First ARC was constituted by the Ministry of Home Affairs by a resolution dated 5 January 1966, to review the whole public administration system. It was first chaired by Morarji Desai and later by K. Hanumanthaiah.
Mandate. It was asked to consider how to achieve the highest standards of efficiency and integrity in public services, so that they could meet social and economic goals. It reviewed:
- The machinery of the Government of India and its procedures, and the planning machinery at all levels.
- Centre–State relations, and administration at the State and district levels.
- Financial, personnel, economic and agricultural administration.
- Redress of citizens' grievances.
Exclusions. It could leave out Defence, Railways, External Affairs, and security and intelligence, and subjects that already had separate commissions. It was still free to consider them while recommending reorganisation of the whole machinery.
Output. It submitted 20 reports, on subjects from citizens' grievances and planning machinery to public sector undertakings, Centre–State relations and the Reserve Bank. It made 580 recommendations, and the Central government accepted about 80 per cent of them.
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2005)
Set up. The Second ARC was set up in 2005 by a Government of India resolution, to prepare a detailed blueprint for revamping public administration. It was chaired by Veerappa Moily, with three members and a member secretary.
Mandate. It was asked to suggest how to make administration proactive, responsive, accountable, sustainable and efficient at all levels. Its subjects ranged from the organisational structure of the Government of India and ethics in governance to local self-government, e-governance, citizen-centric administration, federal issues, crisis management and public order.
The 15 reports. Several titles are frequently asked in exams:
| No. | Report |
|---|---|
| 1 | Right to Information: Master Key to Good Governance |
| 3 | Crisis Management: From Despair to Hope |
| 4 | Ethics in Governance |
| 5 | Public Order: Justice for Each, Peace for All |
| 6 | Local Governance |
| 8 | Combating Terrorism |
| 11 | Promoting e-Governance: The Smart Way Forward |
| 12 | Citizen Centric Administration: The Heart of Governance |
| 15 | State and District Administration |
Follow-up. On 30 March 2007, the government formed a Group of Ministers under the External Affairs Minister to consider the recommendations and guide ministries. From 21 August 2009, it was reconstituted under the Finance Minister. A core group under the Cabinet Secretary examined all 15 reports.
Mains lens: advice without authority
A common question: "NITI Aayog marks a shift from top-down planning to cooperative federalism." Critically examine.
Arguments for:
- The Governing Council brings every Chief Minister and UT Lt. Governor into the body.
- Regional Councils address problems shared by groups of States.
- Its functions stress plans from the village upward, a shared vision with States, and the idea that strong States make a strong nation.
Points to weigh:
- The PM chairs it and appoints the Vice-Chairperson and CEO, so the Centre still sets the tone.
- It was created by executive resolution, so its role can be changed without Parliament.
- It is an advisory think tank; implementation depends on ministries and States.
A second angle: why do reform reports gather dust? The First ARC saw about 80 per cent of its 580 recommendations accepted, but acceptance is not implementation. The Second ARC's reports went to a Group of Ministers and a core group, a slow, layered process. Reform needs political will, monitoring and time limits, not just good reports.
Way forward. Give advisory bodies a clear follow-up mechanism, publish action-taken reports, and keep States as real partners.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Institutions: Discuss the composition and functions of NITI Aayog. How is it different from a constitutional body?
- PM chair; VC and CEO by PM; Governing Council; Regional Councils; members.
- Functions: shared vision, cooperative federalism, village-level plans, monitoring.
- Executive resolution, advisory; contrast with the Finance Commission (Article 280).
2. Governance: "The Second Administrative Reforms Commission placed the citizen at the centre of administration." Discuss with reference to its reports.
- RTI as the master key (1st report); Ethics in Governance; Citizen Centric Administration.
- e-Governance, Local Governance, Public Order.
- Follow-up through the Group of Ministers and the core group.
3. History of reform: Trace the evolution of administrative reform in India since independence.
- Efficiency phase: Bajpai, Ayyangar, Gorwala, Appleby.
- Integrity and comprehensive review: Santhanam (1962), First ARC (1966).
- Policing, economy, federalism (1977, 1981, 1983); Second ARC (2005).
Quick revision
- Planning Commission: 1950 to end of 2014; NITI Aayog from 1 January 2015.
- NITI: PM chairs; VC and CEO appointed by PM; Governing Council of all CMs and UT LGs; Regional Councils for a fixed tenure.
- Members: full-time; up to 2 part-time (rotation); up to 4 ex-officio Union ministers.
- Seven pillars: pro-people, pro-activity, participation, empowerment, inclusion, equality, transparency.
- First ARC: resolution 5 January 1966 (MHA); Morarji Desai, then K. Hanumanthaiah; 20 reports, 580 recommendations, about 80% accepted.
- Second ARC: 2005, Veerappa Moily; 15 reports, first on RTI; GoM 30 March 2007 (EAM), reconstituted 21 August 2009 (FM).
- Other bodies: Santhanam 1962, Police Commission 1977 (Dharam Vira), L.K. Jha 1981, Sarkaria 1983.
HPSC HCS questions from this chapter
Bring out the co-relation between growth, development and inclusive growth. Trace the strategy of NITI Aayog for inclusive growth in India.
NITI Aayog