HPSC HCS · Module 35 · Mains depth · 27 min
The President: election, term and removal
What HPSC HCS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · Indian culture, polity and economy
- Mains · GS II: constitution, polity, governance, welfare schemes
HPSC HCS has asked 3 questions from this chapter (2023, 2022, 2021); 4 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: whose name is on the certificate?
Look at a school certificate. It is often signed by the chairman of the school's trust, who also sits on the stage on Annual Day. But ask who decides the timetable, hires teachers and handles a problem in Class 8. It is usually the principal and the staff, who answer to the parents and the board every day.
Both matter. The chairman gives the school a dignified face and steps in only in special moments. The principal runs the school.
India's Union government works in a similar way. The President is the head of the country: laws are signed by the President, and every government order is issued in the President's name. But the day-to-day decisions are taken by the Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers, who answer to the Lok Sabha.
These are called the nominal (name only) executive and the real executive. This chapter is about the first one: who the President is, how the President is elected, and how the office ends. The President's powers are explained in The President: powers and position.
One President, and where the power sits
Article 52 has just one line: "There shall be a President of India." So the office can never be left out; the country must always have a President.
Article 53(1) says the executive power of the Union is vested in the President. The President uses it either directly or through officers subordinate to the President, always in accordance with the Constitution. "Executive power" means the power to run the government: carry out laws, make appointments, run departments.
Article 53(2) adds that the supreme command of the Defence Forces is vested in the President. Its use is regulated by law. So the Army, Navy and Air Force chiefs serve under the President's command, but the President cannot send troops anywhere on a personal whim.
Remember the words "in accordance with this Constitution". Another Article, Article 74, requires the President to act on the advice of the Council of Ministers. That is why the power is vested in the President but used by the elected government.
Who can become President?
Article 58(1) sets three tests. A person can stand for election only if they:
- (a) are a citizen of India;
- (b) have completed 35 years of age; and
- (c) are qualified to be elected to the Lok Sabha.
Article 58(2) adds a fourth test: the person must not hold any office of profit under the Government of India, a State Government, or a local or other authority controlled by them. In simple words, a serving government employee cannot stand. But the Explanation says that being the President, Vice-President, a Governor or a Minister (Union or State) is not treated as an office of profit. So a sitting Governor or Union Minister can contest.
Article 59: once elected.
- The President cannot be a member of either House of Parliament or of a State Legislature. If an MP or MLA is elected, their seat is treated as vacated on the day they enter office as President.
- The President cannot hold any other office of profit.
- The President gets an official residence without rent, and the emoluments, allowances and privileges that Parliament fixes by law (until then, those in the Second Schedule).
- These emoluments cannot be reduced during the term, so no government can pressure a President by cutting the salary.
Who votes for the President?
The people of India do not vote directly for the President. Article 54 gives the vote to an electoral college, a special group of voters made only for this election. It has:
- (a) the elected members of both Houses of Parliament (Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha); and
- (b) the elected members of the Legislative Assemblies of the States.
Notice the word "elected" in both lines. It tells you who is left out:
- nominated members of Parliament (such as the members the President nominates to the Rajya Sabha); and
- members of State Legislative Councils (Vidhan Parishads), the upper Houses that exist in some States.
Delhi and Puducherry. An Explanation added by the 70th Amendment (1992), in force from 1 June 1995, says that for Articles 54 and 55, "State" includes the National Capital Territory of Delhi and the Union territory of Puducherry. So the elected MLAs of these two also vote. Other Union territories without such Assemblies have no MLAs in the electoral college.
Why include the States at all? India is a Union of States. By making State MLAs half the voting strength, the Constitution makes the President a head of the whole federation, not only of the Union Parliament.
Not one vote each: the value of a vote
In most elections, every vote counts as one. In the President's election, a vote has a value, and the value depends on who casts it. Article 55(1) wants uniformity among the States, and Article 55(2) wants parity (equal weight) between all the States together and the Union Parliament.
Step 1: an MLA's vote. Under Article 55(2)(a) and (b):
- divide the State's population by the number of elected MLAs in its Assembly;
- divide the answer by 1,000;
- if the remainder is 500 or more, add one.
Take an imaginary State with a population of 50,00,000 and 100 elected MLAs. 50,00,000 ÷ 100 = 50,000, and 50,000 ÷ 1,000 = 50. So each MLA of that State casts a vote worth 50.
Why divide by population? A crowded State's MLA speaks for more people, so the vote weighs more. That is "uniformity in the scale of representation".
Step 2: an MP's vote. Under Article 55(2)(c), add up the vote values of all the MLAs of all the States. Divide that total by the number of elected MPs in both Houses. Fractions above one-half count as one; smaller fractions are dropped.
Here is a worked example. If all MLAs together have 5,44,971 votes and there are 776 elected MPs, each MP's vote is 5,44,971 ÷ 776 = 702.28, which becomes 702. The result is that all MPs together and all MLAs together carry about the same weight. That is the "parity" the Constitution wants.
Which census? The Explanation to Article 55 says "population" means the 1971 census figures, until the figures of the first census after 2026 are published. The year 2026 was put in by the 84th Amendment (2001). So vote values are frozen on 1971 numbers for now.
Counting by preferences: the single transferable vote
Article 55(3) says the election is held by proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote, and voting is by secret ballot. The name sounds hard, but the idea is simple.
On the ballot paper, the voter does not put one cross. The voter writes 1 against the first choice, 2 against the second choice, and so on, for as many candidates as they wish. A ballot is invalid if the "1" is missing or is marked against more than one candidate.
The quota. To win, a candidate must get more than half of the valid votes. The quota is worked out as: total valid votes ÷ (1 + 1), plus 1. With 30,000 valid votes, the quota is 30,000 ÷ 2 + 1 = 15,001.
Counting, round by round. Imagine three candidates, A, B and C:
- Round 1 (first preferences only): A gets 13,000, B gets 9,000, C gets 8,000. Nobody reaches 15,001.
- So the lowest, C, is eliminated. C's 8,000 ballots are read again for their second preference. Suppose 2,500 of them marked A next, and 5,500 marked B.
- Round 2: A has 13,000 + 2,500 = 15,500, and B has 9,000 + 5,500 = 14,500. A has crossed the quota, so A is elected.
The vote is "transferable" because it moves to the next choice when the first choice drops out. This way the winner has the support of a true majority, not just the biggest group. MLAs vote in their State capitals, MPs vote in Delhi, and the counting is done in New Delhi.
Oath, term and re-election
Article 60: the oath. Before entering office, the President takes an oath or affirmation in the presence of the Chief Justice of India. If the Chief Justice is absent, the senior-most available Judge of the Supreme Court takes their place. The President promises to "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution and the law" and to serve the well-being of the people of India.
Notice the difference from a Minister's oath. A Minister swears to bear true faith to the Constitution; the President swears to defend it. This is why the President is often called the guardian of the Constitution.
Article 56: the term. The President holds office for five years from the date of entering office. Within that period:
- (a) the President may resign by writing to the Vice-President, who must tell the Speaker of the Lok Sabha at once (Article 56(2));
- (b) the President may be removed by impeachment for violation of the Constitution (Article 61);
- (c) even after five years, the President continues in office until the successor enters office. So the chair is never empty just because a term has ended.
Article 57: re-election. A person who is or has been President is eligible for re-election. The Constitution sets no limit on the number of terms. The first President, Dr Rajendra Prasad, was elected for two full terms.
Impeachment: removing a President
A President can be removed before the term ends in only one way: impeachment under Article 61. Impeachment is a quasi-judicial process, meaning Parliament acts a little like a court. The only ground is "violation of the Constitution". A President cannot be impeached simply because the government dislikes a decision.
The four steps:
- Notice. A resolution to bring the charge can be moved in either House only after at least 14 days' written notice, signed by not less than one-fourth of the total members of that House.
- First House votes. The resolution must pass by not less than two-thirds of the total membership of that House. The charge is now "preferred".
- Second House investigates. The other House investigates the charge, or has it investigated. The President has the right to appear and be represented, in person or through a lawyer.
- Second House votes. If that House passes a resolution by two-thirds of its total membership declaring the charge sustained, the President is removed from the date the resolution passes.
Why so hard? The procedure is kept intentionally difficult so that no President is removed on flimsy grounds. It is even harder than in the USA, where a simple majority in the House of Representatives can start the proceedings.
Notice "total membership" at both votes. Absent members still count in the denominator, so a thin House on a quiet day cannot remove the head of the country.
When the chair falls empty
Article 62: filling the vacancy.
- If the term is ending normally, the election must be completed before the term ends.
- If the office falls vacant through death, resignation or removal, the election must be held as soon as possible, and in no case later than six months.
- The newly elected President gets a full five-year term, not just the remainder of the old one.
Article 65: who sits in the chair meanwhile.
- In a vacancy, the Vice-President acts as President until the new President enters office.
- If the President is absent, ill or unable to work for any other reason, the Vice-President discharges the functions until the President resumes. The difference: here the Vice-President does the work without becoming "acting President".
- While doing so, the Vice-President has all the powers and immunities of the President, and the President's emoluments.
If both are unavailable. Article 70 lets Parliament provide for any situation the Chapter does not cover. In 1969, after President Zakir Hussain died and Vice-President V. V. Giri resigned, Parliament made a provision under which the Chief Justice of India acts as President.
Chief Justice Hidayatullah acted under it.
A real example came in 1977. When President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed died, Vice-President B. D. Jatti acted, and a new President was elected within six months.
Article 71: election disputes. Any doubt or dispute about the election of a President or Vice-President is decided only by the Supreme Court, and its decision is final. If an election is declared void, the acts done by that person before the decision stay valid. An election also cannot be challenged just because some seats in the electoral college were vacant.
Privileges and protections of the office
The head of the country must be able to act without fear of being dragged into court every week. That is why the President has these privileges and immunities:
- The President is not answerable to any court for the exercise of the powers and duties of the office.
- No criminal proceedings can be started, and the President cannot be arrested, during the term.
- The President cannot be asked to appear in any court during the term.
- Before a civil case is filed against the President, two months' prior notice must be served.
Add the financial protections from Article 59: rent-free official residence, emoluments fixed by Parliament, and emoluments that cannot be cut during the term.
Does this put the President above the law? No. These are protections of the office, not of the person forever. The President can still be impeached for violating the Constitution, and the protection from criminal cases lasts only during the term. Also, most decisions are taken on ministers' advice, and ministers do answer to Parliament.
Why the President is chosen and removed this way
Each rule about the President's election and removal solves a specific problem. Read the table, then the two big ideas below it.
| Rule | Why it is there | What it means in practice |
|---|---|---|
| Indirect election (Art 54) | A directly elected President could claim a mandate rival to the PM's | The President stays a constitutional head; real power stays with the Council of Ministers |
| MLAs in the electoral college | The President is head of a Union of States, not only of Parliament | States have a real say in choosing the head of State |
| Vote value by population (Art 55) | Large and small States must be weighed fairly, and the States as a whole must balance Parliament | An MLA from a big State carries more weight; States and Parliament carry equal total weight |
| Single transferable vote (Art 55(3)) | The winner should have the support of more than half the voters | Preferences are counted until someone crosses the quota |
| Oath to "preserve, protect and defend" (Art 60) | The head of State is the guardian of the Constitution | Gives moral weight to the President's advice and warnings |
| Hard impeachment (Art 61) | The head of State should not be removed for party reasons | Needs two-thirds of total membership in both Houses, only for violating the Constitution |
| Vice-President steps in (Art 65) | The office of head of State must never be empty | Continuity; a new election within six months (Art 62) |
Big idea 1: a head who unites, not one who rules. Every part of the election design keeps the President above party politics but rooted in the whole country. Parliament and the States both vote, and no single region dominates.
Big idea 2: secure, but not untouchable. The President cannot be removed easily, which protects the office from day-to-day politics. But impeachment exists, so the President is still answerable to the Constitution.
Mains lens: why not elect the President directly?
A common question: "Explain the method of election of the President of India and the reasons for an indirect election."
Introduction: the President is the head of State and the nominal executive in a parliamentary system (Articles 52, 53, 74). Then describe the method in two lines: an electoral college of elected MPs and elected MLAs (Article 54), weighted votes (Article 55(2)), single transferable vote and secret ballot (Article 55(3)).
Reasons for indirect election (analysis):
- Fits a parliamentary system. Real power lies with the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers. A President elected directly by crores of voters could claim a separate mandate and clash with the elected government.
- Federal balance. Including State MLAs makes the President the head of the whole Union. The parity rule gives the States together the same weight as Parliament.
- Fair weight to each State. Linking an MLA's vote to population gives uniformity, so a small State's MLA does not count the same as a large State's MLA.
- Majority, not plurality. The single transferable vote makes sure the winner has more than half of the valid votes.
- Practical reasons. A nationwide direct election for a mostly ceremonial office would be costly and political.
Criticism to mention: voters have no direct say, and the result is usually decided by the party or alliance with most MPs and MLAs. Vote values also rest on 1971 population figures for now.
Conclusion: the indirect method matches the President's role: a dignified, federal head of State who stays above party competition, while the elected government governs.
Mains lens: impeachment, a high wall by design
A common question: "The impeachment procedure of the President of India is quasi-judicial and deliberately difficult." Discuss.
Why quasi-judicial:
- There must be a specific charge: "violation of the Constitution" (Article 61(1)).
- One House frames the charge; the other House investigates it, like a court hearing evidence (Article 61(3)).
- The President has the right to appear and be represented, which is a basic rule of a fair hearing.
Why deliberately difficult:
- 14 days' notice signed by one-fourth of the total members prevents a sudden move.
- Two-thirds of the total membership is needed in both Houses, not just of those present.
- Compare it with the USA, where a simple majority in the House of Representatives can start proceedings.
Balance with accountability: the President enjoys wide immunity during the term, so impeachment is the one route to hold the office to account. Keeping the route open but narrow protects the President from party politics while still guarding the Constitution.
Conclusion: the high bar reflects the President's role as a non-partisan head who must not be removed for political reasons. The President is removed only when both Houses, by large majorities, agree that the Constitution itself was violated.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton; add facts from this chapter.
1. Design: Explain how the formula for the value of votes keeps a balance between the States and the Union in the Presidential election.
- Give the MLA vote value: State population ÷ elected MLAs ÷ 1,000 (Art 55(2)).
- Give the MP vote value: total value of MLA votes ÷ elected MPs.
- Show the result: the States together and Parliament carry equal total weight.
- Conclude that federal balance is built into the arithmetic.
2. Comparison: Compare the removal of the President of India with that of the US President.
- Explain India's rule: the President can be impeached only for violation of the Constitution, by two-thirds of the total membership of both Houses (Art 61).
- Compare it with the USA, and show that removal is harder in India.
- Give the purpose: to protect the office from party politics.
- Conclude that the design prefers stability over easy removal.
3. Accountability: The President enjoys personal immunity from courts. Does this place the office above the law?
- Explain the immunity: the President is not answerable to any court for official acts, and cannot be arrested or face a criminal case during the term.
- Show that impeachment still remains as a check.
- Add that official acts are done on ministerial advice, and Ministers answer to the Lok Sabha.
- Conclude that immunity protects the office, while accountability flows through other routes.
4. Current relevance: Why does India need a President at all when real power lies with the Prime Minister?
- Explain continuity and unity: the President is a non-party head of State.
- List the formal powers, such as giving assent to Bills, summoning Parliament and making appointments.
- Show the guardian role that comes from the oath under Article 60.
- Conclude that the President is the keystone that holds the parliamentary arch together.
Quick revision
- Under Art 52 there is one President, and under Art 53 the executive power of the Union, including supreme command of the Defence Forces (regulated by law), is vested in the President.
- Under Art 58, a candidate must be a citizen, at least 35, qualified for the Lok Sabha and holding no office of profit (the posts of President, VP, Governor and Minister do not count). Under Art 59, the President is not a member of any legislature, and emoluments cannot be reduced during the term.
- Under Art 54, the electoral college is the elected MPs of both Houses and the elected MLAs, including Delhi and Puducherry (70th Amendment); nominated members and MLCs do not vote.
- Under Art 55, an MLA's vote = population ÷ elected MLAs ÷ 1,000, and an MP's vote = total MLA votes ÷ elected MPs, using the 1971 census until the first census after 2026 (84th Amendment). Voting is by STV and secret ballot, and the quota is valid votes ÷ 2 + 1.
- Under Art 60, the oath is taken before the CJI, to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution. Under Art 56 the term is five years, the President resigns to the VP and continues till a successor takes over, and Art 57 allows re-election.
- Under Art 61, impeachment is only for violation of the Constitution: it needs 14 days' notice signed by 1/4 of the members and 2/3 of the total membership in each House, and the other House investigates the charge.
- Under Art 62, a vacancy is filled within six months, and the new President gets a full five-year term. Under Art 65 the VP acts as President, the CJI acts if both are unavailable (1969 provision), and under Art 71 election disputes are decided by the Supreme Court.
HPSC HCS questions from this chapter
Consider the following statements. 1. The election to the office of the President of India is held in accordance with the system of proportional representation by means of single non-transferable vote. 2. The value of the vote of each Member of Parliament from Uttar Pradesh is greater than the value of the vote of the MP from Goa. 3. Electors cannot use the provision of NOTA in the election of President. 4. The provisions of Anti-defection law are not applicable in Presidential election. How many of the statements given above are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 3 and 4 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 4 only
Match List I with List II: List I (Articles) a. 61 b. 72 c. 54 d. 123 e. 76 List II (Provisions) I. Impeachment II. Pardoning powers III. Election IV. Ordinance V. Appointment of Attorney General
- (a) a-I, b-V, c-II, d-III, e-IV
- (b) a-IV, b-III, c-II, d-I, e-V
- (c) a-I, b-II, c-III, d-IV, e-V
- (d) a-II, b-III, c-I, d-IV, e-V
Show answer
(c) a-I, b-II, c-III, d-IV, e-V · our answer; official key awaited
Which of the following Union Territories are included in the electoral college for election to the office of President of India by the Constitution (70th Amendment) Act, 1992 for purposes of Articles 54 and 55? A. NCT of Delhi B. Goa C. Puducherry D. Lakshadweep
- (a) A and B only
- (b) B and C only
- (c) A and C only
- (d) C and D only
Show answer
(c) A and C only · our answer; official key awaited