HPSC HCS · Module 38 · Mains depth · 12 min
The State Legislature: Assembly, Council and control over government
What HPSC HCS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper I: General Studies · Indian culture, polity and economy
- Mains · GS II: constitution, polity, governance, welfare schemes
HPSC HCS has asked 1 question from this chapter (2022); 1 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: the State's law-making room
Think about the rules that touch daily life most closely: land records, police, local markets, State taxes. Many of these are made not in Delhi but in the State capital, by the State Legislature. Laws give the government both a policy framework and the powers it needs to act.
Every State must have at least one House, the Legislative Assembly. A State may also choose to have a second House, the Legislative Council. So some States are unicameral and others bicameral, and the State itself decides which.
The Legislature does two big jobs. It makes laws, and it keeps a daily watch on the government, which answers to it. This chapter looks at how the two Houses are built, how Bills move between them, and how the Legislature controls the executive.
The Legislative Assembly and the choice of a second House
The Assembly. The Legislative Assembly has between 60 and 500 members. They are chosen by direct election on the basis of adult suffrage from territorial constituencies. Its term is five years, unless the Governor dissolves it earlier.
Extension in an Emergency. During an Emergency, Parliament can extend the Assembly's term. Even then, it cannot go on beyond six months after the proclamation ends.
Creating or abolishing a Council. A State does not need an amendment of the Constitution to get or drop a Council. Two steps are needed:
- The Assembly passes a resolution by a special majority: a majority of its total membership and at least two-thirds of members present and voting.
- Parliament then passes an Act to create or abolish the Council.
Why leave it to the States? Not every State needs or can afford a second House. The framers left the choice to each State, with Parliament giving the final legal shape. States such as West Bengal, Punjab and Andhra Pradesh have used this procedure in the past to abolish their Councils.
The Legislative Council: a House of many voices
Size. The Council can have at most one-third of the Assembly's membership, and never fewer than 40 members. This keeps it clearly smaller than the Assembly.
Who chooses the members. The Council is built to bring in voices that the Assembly may miss:
| Share | Chosen by | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1/3 | Members of local bodies | Voice for local government |
| 1/12 | Graduates of three years' standing | Voice for the educated |
| 1/12 | Teachers with three years' experience in secondary schools or above | Voice for education |
| 1/3 | MLAs, from among persons who are not MLAs | Link with the Assembly |
| 1/6 | Nominated by the Governor | Experts and eminent people |
How the elections work. Elected members are chosen by proportional representation through the single transferable vote. This gives smaller groups a fair chance of a seat.
A permanent House. The Council is never dissolved as a whole. One-third of its members retire every second year, so there is always continuity.
How Bills move between the two Houses
Money Bills. A Money Bill can start only in the Assembly. The Council cannot reject or amend it, and can only make recommendations, which the Assembly may accept or ignore. If the Council does not return the Bill within 14 days, it goes straight to the Governor.
Ordinary Bills. An ordinary Bill can start in either House. If the Assembly passes it, the Council may reject it, amend it, or simply not pass it for three months. If the Assembly passes the Bill again, the Council can hold it for only one more month on its second journey.
A Bill from the Council. If a Bill starts in the Council and the Assembly rejects it, the Bill ends there. The Council has no way to override the Assembly.
| Point | Parliament | Bicameral State Legislature |
|---|---|---|
| Money Bill: upper House's time | 14 days, recommendations only | 14 days, recommendations only |
| Deadlock on an ordinary Bill | Joint sitting of both Houses | No joint sitting; the Assembly's will prevails |
| Upper House's real power | Can share in deciding the outcome | Can only delay, at most three months plus one month |
Why the difference? In Parliament, the Rajya Sabha represents the States, so it is given a real share through a joint sitting. A State's Council represents no such federal unit, so the elected Assembly always has the last word.
After both Houses. The Bill then goes to the Governor, who may assent, withhold assent, return it or reserve it for the President. The Governor's options on a Bill are covered with the Governor's powers.
How the Legislature controls the government
Making laws is only half the Legislature's job. The other half is acting as the people's watchdog over the administration. In a parliamentary democracy, this control works through several tools.
| Tool | How it works |
|---|---|
| Questions | Members ask questions and supplementary questions; the government must answer and often promise corrective action |
| Discussions and motions | Debates, Call Attention Motions and Adjournment Motions on urgent public matters; even a disallowed motion draws out information |
| Budget | No money can be raised or spent without the Legislature's vote |
| Audit | The CAG audits State accounts and sends the report to the Assembly through the Governor; the Public Accounts Committee examines it |
| Committees | Estimates Committee, Committee on Public Undertakings, Committee on Assurances and others study government work in detail |
| Ministerial responsibility | A no-confidence vote, or defeat on the budget or a major Bill, can remove the government |
Why committees matter. The Assembly is too large to examine government work line by line. Small committees can study files, question officers and point out waste or failure.
The strongest weapon. Enforcing ministerial responsibility is the Legislature's most potent function. Civil servants are answerable to the Legislature indirectly, through their Ministers.
Two opposite complaints. Some say the administration is still not responsive enough despite these controls. Others argue that controls, especially through audit, are too tight and kill the initiative of officers.
Why the State Legislature was designed this way
| Feature | Reason | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Second House optional | States differ in size, needs and resources | Each State chooses, with Parliament's Act |
| Council partly indirectly elected | Bring in local bodies, graduates, teachers and experts | A House of review, not of rival power |
| Council can only delay | The directly elected Assembly must prevail | Second thought without deadlock |
| No joint sitting | The Council does not represent a federal unit | Assembly supreme in every case |
| Permanent Council | Continuity of experience | One-third retire every second year |
The big idea. The State Legislature is built to give the elected Assembly the last word while letting a smaller, more varied House take a second look where a State wants one.
Mains lens: is the Legislative Council worth keeping?
A common question: "Examine the role of Legislative Councils in the States. Do they serve a useful purpose?"
The case for a Council:
- It brings in local bodies, graduates and teachers, and the Governor can nominate experts.
- It gives Bills a second look, and its delay of up to four months allows rethinking.
- It is a permanent House, giving continuity.
- Single transferable vote gives smaller groups a voice.
The case against:
- It can only delay, never decide, so its power is limited.
- On Money Bills it can only recommend within 14 days.
- With no joint sitting, the Assembly always prevails.
- Several States have abolished their Councils, showing the doubt about their value.
Way forward. A balanced answer suggests that Councils make sense where they add real expertise and review, and that the State's own choice, confirmed by Parliament, is the right way to decide.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Analysis: Discuss the ways in which the State Legislature controls the administration.
- Questions, supplementaries, discussions and motions.
- Budget control and audit through the CAG and the Public Accounts Committee.
- Committees such as Estimates, Public Undertakings and Assurances.
- Ministerial responsibility, and the debate on too much or too little control.
2. Comparison: Compare the legislative procedure in Parliament and in a bicameral State Legislature.
- Money Bills: 14 days, recommendations only, in both.
- Ordinary Bills: three months plus one month in the States.
- Joint sitting in Parliament, none in the States, and why.
- Supremacy of the Assembly.
3. Evaluation: "Legislative control over administration in the States is more formal than real." Comment.
- Tools available on paper.
- Majority government gets its budget passed.
- Value of debate, committees and audit in exposing weakness.
- Ways to strengthen committees and follow-up.
Quick revision
- Every State has a Legislative Assembly of 60 to 500 members, directly elected; term five years.
- A Council is created or abolished by an Assembly resolution (special majority) plus an Act of Parliament.
- Council size: at most one-third of the Assembly, at least 40.
- Council shares: local bodies 1/3, MLAs 1/3, Governor's nominees 1/6, graduates 1/12, teachers 1/12; single transferable vote.
- Council is permanent; one-third retire every second year.
- Money Bill: starts only in the Assembly; Council recommends within 14 days.
- Ordinary Bill: Council can delay three months, then one month; no joint sitting.
- CAG's report reaches the Assembly through the Governor; the Public Accounts Committee examines it.
HPSC HCS questions from this chapter
Consider the following statements: 1. A Bill pending in the legislature of a state shall lapse by reason of the prorogation of the House or Houses thereof. 2. A Bill pending in the legislative council of a state which has been passed by the legislative assembly shall lapse on a dissolution of the assembly. 3. A Bill which is pending in the legislative assembly of a state, or which having been passed by the legislative assembly is pending in the legislative council, shall not lapse on a dissolution of the assembly. Which of the statements above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 2 only
Show answer
(d) 2 only · our answer; official key awaited