HPSC ADA & legal course‹› 0:00 studied

HPSC ADA & legal · Module 15 · standard depth · 16 min

The Vice-President

What HPSC ADA & legal asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Screening test (general) · General studies (as for HPSC screening tests)

HPSC ADA & legal questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for HPSC ADA & legal. 9 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: the vice-captain

Every cricket team names a vice-captain. On most days the vice-captain is simply one of the senior players, helping set the field and keeping the team in order. But if the captain is injured or has to leave the ground, the vice-captain takes charge at once. Nobody has to hold a meeting; the plan is already made.

Vice-captain: ready to step in

India's Vice-President works in a similar way, with one difference. The Vice-President does have a regular daily job: running the Rajya Sabha as its Chairman. And if the President's chair falls empty, or the President is ill or away, the Vice-President steps in.

So the office has two hats. This chapter explains how the Vice-President is chosen, how long they stay, how they can be removed, and what each hat involves. Compare each rule with the President's, because the exam loves the small differences between the two offices.

One office, two roles

Article 63 is a single line: "There shall be a Vice-President of India." Like the President, the office must always exist.

Two hats of the Vice-President

Article 64 gives the first role: the Vice-President is ex officio Chairman of the Council of States. "Ex officio" means because of the office: whoever becomes Vice-President automatically becomes Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. No separate election is held for it. The same Article says the Vice-President shall not hold any other office of profit.

The second role comes from Article 65: acting as President, or discharging the President's functions, when needed.

The two roles never run together. The proviso to Article 64 says that while the Vice-President is acting as President or discharging the President's functions, they do not perform the duties of Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. They also get no salary or allowance payable to the Chairman under Article 97 for that period. One person cannot be both the head of the country and the presiding officer of one House of Parliament at the same time.

Who elects the Vice-President?

Article 66(1) says the Vice-President is elected by the members of an electoral college consisting of the members of both Houses of Parliament. The method is the same as for the President: proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote, by secret ballot.

Who elects the Vice-President

Compare carefully with the President's election:

  • No State Legislatures. MLAs have no vote for the Vice-President. The Vice-President's main daily job is in Parliament, so Parliament alone chooses.
  • "Members", not "elected members". Article 54 (President) says "elected members". Article 66(1) (Vice-President) just says "members of both Houses". So nominated members of Parliament, such as the twelve nominated to the Rajya Sabha, can vote for the Vice-President.
  • No vote values. Article 55's formula of weighting votes by population applies to the President's election, not to Article 66. Each MP's vote here is simply one vote.

A small history point. The original text said the Vice-President was elected by "members of both Houses of Parliament assembled at a joint meeting". The 11th Amendment, in force from 19 December 1961, replaced this with the "electoral college" wording. So the two Houses no longer need to sit together for this election.

Who can become Vice-President?

Article 66(3) sets three tests. A person is eligible only if they:

  • (a) are a citizen of India;
  • (b) have completed 35 years of age; and
  • (c) are qualified for election as a member of the Council of States (Rajya Sabha).

Article 66(4) adds that a person holding an office of profit under the Government of India, a State Government or a local or other authority controlled by them cannot be elected. As for the President, the Explanation says that being the President, Vice-President, a Governor or a Minister is not treated as an office of profit.

Article 66(2): the Vice-President cannot be a member of either House of Parliament or of a State Legislature. If a member is elected, their seat is treated as vacated on the day they enter office as Vice-President.

Why "Rajya Sabha-qualified"? The Vice-President's daily job is to chair the Rajya Sabha. It makes sense to ask that the person be fit to sit in that House. For the President, the test is the Lok Sabha instead.

Term, resignation and removal

Article 67 gives a five-year term from the date of entering office. Then three provisos:

Removing a Vice-President
  • (a) Resignation: the Vice-President may resign by writing to the President. (The President, you remember, resigns to the Vice-President.)
  • (b) Removal: by a resolution of the Council of States passed by a majority of all the then members of the Council, and agreed to by the House of the People. No such resolution can be moved without at least 14 days' notice.
  • (c) Continuing: even after five years, the Vice-President continues until the successor enters office.

Notice three things about removal:

  1. It starts only in the Rajya Sabha, the House the Vice-President chairs. The Lok Sabha only agrees.
  2. The majority is "a majority of all the then members", that is, more than half of the House's full strength at that time, not just of those present.
  3. The text names no ground, and the word "impeachment" is not used. For the President, Article 61 needs "violation of the Constitution" and two-thirds in both Houses. So removing a Vice-President is easier than removing a President.

Article 68: vacancies. An election at the end of a term must be completed before the term ends. A vacancy caused by death, resignation or removal is filled "as soon as possible". Unlike Article 62 for the President, no six-month limit is written here. The person elected gets a full five-year term.

The oath: a different promise

Article 69 says every Vice-President takes the oath before the President, or some person appointed by the President for this purpose.

The promise is to "bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of India as by law established" and to "faithfully discharge the duty" of the office. Compare this with the President's oath under Article 60, taken before the Chief Justice of India, to "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution and the law".

Why the difference? The President is the head of the country and its guardian, so the oath is to defend the Constitution. The Vice-President's oath is closer to that of other office-holders: loyalty to the Constitution and faithful performance of duty.

First hat: Chairman of the Rajya Sabha

On a normal day, the Vice-President's work is in the Rajya Sabha. The Chairman's duties are those of any presiding officer:

  • keeping order in the House;
  • allowing members to speak and ask questions;
  • putting Bills and motions to vote.

The vote question. The Vice-President is not a member of the Rajya Sabha (Article 66(2) forbids it). So the Vice-President does not vote in the House like a member. But if the votes are tied, the Vice-President uses a casting vote so that a decision can be reached.

When the other hat is on. If the Vice-President is acting as President, the proviso to Article 64 says they do not perform the Chairman's duties and get no Chairman's salary under Article 97. Who presides in the meantime is covered in the Parliament module.

Think of the Chairman as the umpire of the Rajya Sabha: present in every over, but not batting or bowling, except to break a tie.

Second hat: standing in for the President

Article 65 gives the second role:

  • Vacancy (death, resignation, removal or otherwise): the Vice-President acts as President until the new President enters office.
  • Absence, illness or any other cause: the Vice-President discharges the President's functions until the President resumes. Here the Vice-President does the work without becoming "acting President".
  • In both cases, the Vice-President has all the powers and immunities of the President, and the emoluments fixed for the President.

How long can this last? For a vacancy, Article 62 requires a new President to be elected within six months. So the Vice-President's time in the President's chair is, at most, about six months.

Disputes. Article 71 applies to both offices: any doubt or dispute about the election of a Vice-President is decided by the Supreme Court, and its decision is final. Acts done before an election is declared void remain valid.

President and Vice-President side by side

Statement questions often swap one detail between the two offices. This table puts them next to each other:

President and Vice-President side by side
Point President Vice-President
Electoral college Elected MPs + elected MLAs (Art 54) All MPs of both Houses, including nominated (Art 66)
Vote value formula Yes (Art 55) No
Qualification (c) Qualified for Lok Sabha Qualified for Rajya Sabha
Oath before Chief Justice of India (Art 60) President or a person appointed by the President (Art 69)
Resigns to Vice-President President
Removal Impeachment for violation of the Constitution; 2/3 of total membership in both Houses (Art 61) Rajya Sabha resolution by majority of all then members, Lok Sabha agrees; no ground stated (Art 67)
Vacancy to be filled Within six months (Art 62) As soon as possible; no limit written (Art 68)

Same in both: citizen, 35 years, no office of profit, five-year term, continues till successor, STV with secret ballot, disputes to the Supreme Court (Art 71).

Why the Vice-President's rules differ from the President's

Almost every difference between the two offices follows from one fact: the Vice-President's daily job is in Parliament, as Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. Read each rule with that in mind.

Rule Why it is there What it means in practice
Elected by Parliament only (Art 66) The main work is chairing a House of Parliament MLAs have no vote; the contest is decided inside Parliament
Nominated MPs also vote Every member of the House the Vice-President chairs should have a say The electorate is all MPs, not only elected ones
No joint meeting needed (11th Amendment) Calling both Houses together just to vote was a practical burden MPs vote as an electoral college
Rajya Sabha-qualified (Art 66(3)) The person will preside over the Rajya Sabha Same basic test as a Rajya Sabha member
Not a member of any House (Art 66(2)) A presiding officer should be neutral No ordinary vote; only a casting vote in a tie
Removal by Rajya Sabha resolution (Art 67(b)) The House the Vice-President chairs should be able to withdraw its trust Easier than impeaching a President; the Lok Sabha must agree
No Chairman's duties while acting as President (Art 64) One person cannot be head of State and presiding officer at once Clear separation of the two hats

The logic in one line. The President's rules are built for a head of the whole Union, so States vote and removal is hard. The Vice-President's rules are built for a neutral chair of Parliament, so Parliament alone votes and the Rajya Sabha can remove them.

Why it matters. A neutral, respected Chairman keeps the Rajya Sabha working when debates get heated. And because the Vice-President is ready to step in at once, the country never goes without a head of State.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • Under Art 63 there is one Vice-President, and under Art 64 the Vice-President is ex officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha and holds no other office of profit; while acting as President, they do not perform the Chairman's duties or draw that salary (Art 97).
  • Under Art 66(1), the Vice-President is elected by all members of both Houses, nominated ones too, by STV and secret ballot, and MLAs do not vote; the old "joint meeting" wording was replaced by the 11th Amendment (from 19 Dec 1961).
  • Under Art 66(2)-(4), the Vice-President is not a member of any legislature, and must be a citizen, at least 35, Rajya Sabha-qualified and holding no office of profit.
  • Under Art 67, the term is five years and the Vice-President resigns to the President. Removal is by a Rajya Sabha resolution passed by a majority of all its then members and agreed to by the Lok Sabha, after 14 days' notice, and the Vice-President continues till a successor takes over.
  • Under Art 68, a vacancy is filled as soon as possible (no six-month limit is written), and the new Vice-President gets a full five-year term.
  • Under Art 69, the oath of true faith and allegiance is taken before the President or a person the President appoints.
  • Under Art 65, the Vice-President acts as President or discharges the President's functions, with all powers and immunities, and under Art 71 election disputes go to the Supreme Court.
  • The Vice-President presides over the Rajya Sabha, with no ordinary vote but a casting vote in a tie.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 6 answered

  1. The Vice-President of India is elected by:

  2. Consider the following statements about removal of the Vice-President: 1. A resolution to remove the Vice-President can be moved only in the Rajya Sabha. 2. The Constitution calls the removal of the Vice-President 'impeachment' and requires a two-thirds majority in both Houses. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. The Vice-President takes the oath of office before:

  4. Which Amendment replaced the 'joint meeting' of both Houses with an 'electoral college' for electing the Vice-President?

  5. Consider the following statements about the Vice-President: 1. While acting as President, the Vice-President continues to preside over the Rajya Sabha. 2. To be Vice-President, a person must be qualified for election as a member of the Rajya Sabha. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  6. With reference to the election of the Vice-President of India, consider the following statements: 1. Elected members of the State Legislative Assemblies vote in the election. 2. Nominated members of Parliament vote in the election. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The office of the Vice-President of India is more than a stand-by for the President.' Discuss. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Ex officio Chairman of Rajya Sabha (Art 64); casting vote
    • Continuity: acts as President with all powers (Art 65)
    • Neutrality: not a member of any legislature (Art 66(2))
    • Limits: no independent executive power; easier removal (Art 67(b))

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Who elects the Vice-President?

All members of both Houses of Parliament, including nominated members. Unlike the presidential election, State Legislatures have no part.

How is the Vice-President removed?

By a Rajya Sabha resolution passed by a majority of all its then members and agreed to by the Lok Sabha, after at least 14 days' notice. The Constitution names no ground for removal.

What is the minimum age for the Vice-President?

35 years. The person must also be a citizen and qualified for election to the Rajya Sabha.

Does the Vice-President chair the Rajya Sabha while acting as President?

No. While acting as President, the Vice-President does not perform the duties of Rajya Sabha Chairman and does not draw the Chairman's salary.