KPSC KAS · Module 31 · Mains depth · 12 min
Money between the Centre and the States: fiscal federalism
What KPSC KAS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Paper I: General Studies · Indian polity and economy.
- GS 2 · Indian Constitution and polity.
KPSC KAS has asked 2 questions from this chapter (2020, 2014); 5 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: duties without money
Imagine a family where the elder brother earns most of the income, but the younger one has to run the kitchen, pay school fees and look after the sick. The younger one will keep asking for money, and the elder one will keep asking how it is spent. Something similar happens between the Union and the States.
The States carry many expensive duties, such as police, health, agriculture and schools. But the Centre controls the most elastic sources of revenue, can borrow more easily, and holds the residuary power of taxation. This mismatch between duties and money is called the vertical imbalance.
So the Constitution builds bridges to move money from the Centre to the States. These include sharing of taxes, grants, loans and an independent Finance Commission. How fairly this money moves is one of the most debated issues in Indian federalism.
Who taxes what, and how it is shared
The basic rule. Taxes with an inter-State base are given to the Union, and taxes with a local base to the States. The Concurrent List has no tax at all, which avoids overlapping claims. Any tax not mentioned in the Lists falls under the Union's residuary power.
Collecting is not the same as keeping. A tax in the Union List does not mean the Union keeps all of it. Since the 80th Amendment (2000), the new Article 270 makes all Union taxes and duties shareable with the States. The exceptions are the taxes under Articles 268 and 269, surcharges and cesses.
How the share is fixed. The percentage of the "net proceeds" that goes to the States is fixed by the President after considering the Finance Commission's recommendation. That share does not form part of the Consolidated Fund of India.
Why surcharges and cesses matter. Because surcharges and cesses are not shared, a growing reliance on them shrinks the pool that reaches the States. The Thirteenth Finance Commission asked the Centre to review cesses and surcharges for this reason.
Borrowing.
- Article 292: the Union can borrow on the security of the Consolidated Fund of India, inside and outside India, within limits set by Parliament.
- Article 293: a State cannot borrow outside India. If it owes money to the Union, it needs the Union's consent to borrow more.
The Finance Commission: the referee of money
What it is. Under Article 280, the President appoints a Finance Commission at the end of every fifth year, or earlier if needed. An independent body for this purpose is a unique feature of the Indian Constitution, meant to keep the sharing of money away from arbitrary discretion.
What it recommends.
- How the net proceeds of shareable taxes are divided between the Union and the States (vertical sharing), and among the States (horizontal sharing).
- The principles that should govern grants-in-aid to States from the Consolidated Fund of India.
- Any other matter referred by the President in the interests of sound finance.
Who sits on it. Under the Finance Commission (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1951, it has a chairperson experienced in public affairs and four other members. Members are drawn from people qualified to be High Court judges, or with special knowledge of government finance, wide experience of finance and administration, or economics. The Commission has the powers of a civil court.
A short history. The First Finance Commission was appointed in November 1951 under K.C. Neogi and reported in December 1952.
| Finance Commission | States' share of the divisible pool | Period |
|---|---|---|
| Thirteenth | 32% | 2010–15 |
| Fourteenth | 42% | 2015–20 |
| Fifteenth | 41% | 2021–26 |
| Sixteenth | 41% retained, and the Government accepted it | Report on 17 November 2025 |
Why the jump to 42%? The Fourteenth Commission's big increase gave States more untied money to spend on their own priorities. The Fifteenth described its 41% as effectively the same level as the earlier 42%.
The balancing act. The Commission must be fair by assessing each State's real needs, and efficient by not rewarding poor management. So a State's share is not based only on tax collection, income or population, but on a mix of factors.
Grants, planning and the fight over discretion
Two kinds of grants.
| Grant | Basis | Who decides |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory grants (Article 275) | For States in need of help, and for Scheduled Tribe welfare and Scheduled Area administration | Parliament by law, after the Finance Commission's advice |
| Discretionary grants (Article 282) | Any public purpose | The Union, outside the Finance Commission |
Why Article 282 is controversial. Article 282 was probably meant for emergencies, not for regular help. But discretionary grants grew, and States fear they can be used as a political weapon against a State out of favour with the Centre. States want more money through statutory devolution and less through discretion.
The planning years. The Planning Commission, a non-statutory central body, came to play a major role in moving money to States through plan assistance. States complained that their plans had to match central priorities and that centrally sponsored schemes pushed national programmes on them. Critics said planning pushed the system towards centralisation.
NITI Aayog. On 1 January 2015, the government set up NITI Aayog to replace the Planning Commission. It was described as a think-tank that would foster cooperative federalism, replacing the one-way flow of policy from Centre to States with a partnership.
Faults on both sides. States point to the Centre's elastic revenues, unshared cesses and discretionary grants. But States are also faulted for not raising even the revenue they can, and for spending on populist measures.
GST and local bodies: new layers of fiscal federalism
The GST. The Goods and Services Tax brought many indirect taxes of the Centre and the States under one system.
- The Constitution (101st Amendment) Act was enacted in August 2016.
- The GST Council was constituted on 15 September 2016 under Article 279A.
- GST was launched on 1 July 2017.
The GST Council. It is a federal body. Its members are:
- the Union Finance Minister, as chairperson;
- the Union Minister of State in charge of Revenue or Finance; and
- the minister in charge of Finance or Taxation, or another minister nominated, from each State.
Why it matters for federalism. Under GST, the Centre and States decide tax matters together in one forum. In its early years, the Council's decisions were all reached by consensus. This makes it a working example of shared decision-making, where many tax choices are now made jointly rather than by each government alone.
Money for local bodies. After the 73rd and 74th Amendments, India's federalism has a third tier. Each State must set up a State Finance Commission (Articles 243-I and 243Y) to review the finances of panchayats and municipalities. The Union Finance Commission must also suggest ways to add to a State's funds to support its panchayats and municipalities, based on the State Finance Commission's advice.
Mains lens: does the money system respect federalism?
A common question: "Fiscal dependence of the States on the Union weakens Indian federalism." Critically examine.
Why dependence exists:
- The Union has the more elastic taxes, borrowing abroad and residuary taxation.
- States carry costly duties such as health, police and agriculture.
- Surcharges and cesses stay outside the shared pool.
- Discretionary grants and centrally sponsored schemes come with conditions.
What protects the States:
- An independent Finance Commission every five years.
- All Union taxes are shareable since the 80th Amendment; the share rose to 42% and stays at 41%.
- Statutory grants under Article 275 for needy States.
- The GST Council gives States a seat in tax decisions.
Way forward: more money through formula-based devolution and less through discretion; review of cesses and surcharges; stronger own revenue efforts by States; real funds for local bodies. A balanced answer concludes that dependence is built into the design, but predictable, rule-based transfers can keep it from becoming control.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Institution: Discuss the role of the Finance Commission as a balancing wheel of Indian fiscal federalism.
- Article 280: functions, five-year cycle, independence.
- Composition under the 1951 Act.
- Vertical and horizontal sharing; 32% to 42% to 41%.
- Fairness versus efficiency.
2. Reform: How has the GST changed Centre–State fiscal relations?
- 101st Amendment, Article 279A, launch on 1 July 2017.
- GST Council composition and consensus decisions.
- Shared decisions: tax choices made jointly, not by each government alone.
- Example of cooperative federalism.
3. Comparison: Compare the roles of the Planning Commission and NITI Aayog in Centre–State relations.
- Planning Commission: non-statutory, plan assistance, centralisation.
- Centrally sponsored schemes and States' complaints.
- NITI Aayog (2015): think-tank, cooperative federalism.
- Finance Commission remains the main constitutional channel.
Quick revision
- Inter-State base taxes go to the Union, local base taxes to the States; no tax in the Concurrent List; residuary taxation with the Union.
- 80th Amendment (2000): new Article 270, all Union taxes shareable except Articles 268/269 taxes, surcharges and cesses.
- Article 280: Finance Commission every five years or earlier; chair plus four members (1951 Act); First FC November 1951, K.C. Neogi.
- States' share: 32% (13th), 42% (14th), 41% (15th), 41% retained (16th, report 17 November 2025).
- Article 275 statutory grants; Article 282 discretionary grants outside the Finance Commission.
- Article 293: States cannot borrow abroad; need consent if indebted to the Union.
- GST: 101st Amendment (August 2016), Article 279A Council (15 September 2016), launched 1 July 2017, chaired by the Union Finance Minister.
- NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015.
KPSC KAS questions from this chapter
Match List-I with List-II : List-I: A. Stamp duties and duties on medical and toilet preparations; B. Duties on succession to property other than agricultural land; C. Taxes on income other than corporation tax and taxes on agricultural income; D. Excise duty on items other than medical and toilet preparations. List-II: I. Duties levied by the Union Government but collected and appropriated by the State; II. Taxes levied and collected by the Union but assigned to the States; III. Taxes levied and collected by the Union and distributed between the Union and the States; IV. Taxes levied and collected by the Union but which may be distributed between the Union and the States. Choose the correct answer from the options given below (A B C D) :
- (a) I II III IV
- (b) I III IV II
- (c) II I III IV
- (d) I IV III II
Show answer
(a) I II III IV
Discuss the broad features of financial relations between the union and the state in India.