MPPSC SSE (State Service) · Module 63 · Mains depth · 21 min
Scheduling, floors and grid puzzles
What MPPSC SSE (State Service) asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims Paper II: General Aptitude Test · Logical reasoning and analytical ability
- Prelims Paper II: General Aptitude Test · General mental ability
MPPSC SSE (State Service) has asked 7 questions from this chapter (2017, 2016); 54 from its whole module.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: who lives on which floor?
Five people, A, B, C, D and E, live on the five floors of a building, one on each floor. The ground floor is floor 1 and the top floor is floor 5. C lives on the top floor and A lives immediately below C. B lives two floors below A, and D does not live on floor 1.
C is on floor 5 and A on floor 4. Two floors below A is floor 2, so B is there. Floors 1 and 3 are left for D and E, and D is not on floor 1.
So D is on floor 3 and E on floor 1, and from the bottom the building reads E, B, D, A, C. This is a linear seating puzzle turned on its side: "above" is "right of" and "below" is "left of".
Why this topic exists. Scheduling and matching are the daily work of administration: who inspects which block on which day, which officer handles which subject, which team uses the hall in which month. These puzzles test the same discipline: record every fact in one table and let the rules squeeze out the answer.
Days of the week as a line
The set-up. Six lectures, P, Q, R, S, T and U, are held on six days, Monday to Saturday, one each day. S is on Wednesday, and only two lectures fall between S and P. Q is on the day immediately after R, T is not on Monday, and U is held before R.
Step 1: fixed and gap clues. Number Monday as 1 and Saturday as 6, so S is day 3. Two lectures between S and P means a gap of 3, so P is day 6, Saturday, since day 0 does not exist. The free days are now Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday.
Step 2: the pair. R and Q need two days in a row, and the only such pairs left are Monday–Tuesday and Thursday–Friday. If R and Q took Monday and Tuesday, U would have to come before R, which is impossible. So R is on Thursday and Q on Friday.
Step 3: the last two. T and U share Monday and Tuesday, and T is not on Monday. So U is on Monday and T on Tuesday, and the week reads U, T, S, R, Q, P.
A week is a line, unless it wraps. Within one week, Monday comes first and Sunday last, so "the day after Sunday" is outside the puzzle. If a puzzle runs over several weeks or speaks of "every seventh day", treat the days as a circle, as in the chapter on calendars.
Why it matters. Schedules use the same words as rows, "immediately after", "before", "between", only with days in place of seats. Once you number the days, every clue becomes simple arithmetic.
The tick-and-cross grid
The set-up. Four friends, Amit, Bina, Chetan and Divya, come from four cities, Patna, Gaya, Ranchi and Pune, and each plays a different sport: cricket, chess, hockey and tennis. Amit is not from Patna or Gaya, and the chess player is from Ranchi. Bina plays hockey, Chetan is from Gaya, and Divya neither plays chess nor comes from Pune; the person from Gaya does not play cricket.
Draw the grid. Put the four names down the side. Across the top put the four cities, then the four sports, making two blocks. Mark a tick where a clue says yes and a cross where it says no; in each block, every row and every column ends with exactly one tick.
Fill the direct clues. Tick Chetan–Gaya and cross the rest of Chetan's city row and of the Gaya column. Cross Amit–Patna and Amit–Gaya, tick Bina–hockey, and cross Divya–chess and Divya–Pune.
Use the linking clue. "The chess player is from Ranchi" links the two blocks. Bina plays hockey and Divya does not play chess, so neither of them is the chess player and neither is from Ranchi. Divya's only city left is Patna, so Bina must be from Pune, and Amit, the only one left, is from Ranchi and therefore plays chess.
Finish. Chetan and Divya share cricket and tennis, and the person from Gaya, Chetan, does not play cricket. So Chetan plays tennis and Divya plays cricket. The answer table is Amit–Ranchi–chess, Bina–Pune–hockey, Chetan–Gaya–tennis and Divya–Patna–cricket.
Why it matters. A grid turns a page of clues into a picture where gaps are visible. Without it, candidates hold facts in memory, lose one and end up with two people from the same city.
Stacks and cases
The set-up. Seven boxes, A to G, are stacked one above another, with position 1 at the bottom. Only three boxes are between A and D, and D is above A. C is immediately above D, B is at the bottom, E is next to A, and F is above G.
Branch at the first open clue. A, D and C occupy positions a, a + 4 and a + 5, all within 7, so A is in position 1 or 2. That gives Case 1: A 1, D 5, C 6 and Case 2: A 2, D 6, C 7. Now "B is at the bottom" kills Case 1, because position 1 would be A's.
Close it. With A in 2, D in 6 and C in 7, E next to A takes position 3. G and F share positions 4 and 5, with F above G, so G is 4 and F is 5. From the bottom the stack is B, A, E, G, F, D, C.
Questions on the result. "How many boxes are between E and D?" Positions 3 and 6 have 2 boxes between them. "Which box is third from the top?" Counting down from 7, it is position 5, which is F.
Top and bottom counting. In a stack of n, the box k-th from the top is at position n − k + 1 from the bottom. This is the ranking formula from the verbal reasoning module, and it saves many mistakes in floor questions.
Why it matters. Stacking puzzles reward the same habit as rows: write cases as short lines and wait for a clue to choose. The bottom and top are fixed ends, just like the ends of a row.
Months, real-world clues and open facts
The set-up. Six people, K, L, M, N, O and P, have birthdays in six different months of the same year: January, March, May, July, September and November. M's birthday is in a month with 30 days, and only one person's birthday falls between M's and K's. L's birthday is in the month just before N's in this list, and O's birthday comes before K's.
A clue from general knowledge. Of the six months, only September and November have 30 days, so M is in one of them. Number the months 1 to 6 in the order given; then M is 5 or 6 and K is two places before, 3 or 4.
Testing the cases. If M were in September, K would be in May, position 3; L and N would need two neighbouring places among 1, 2, 4 and 6, which forces January and March, and then O, who comes before K, would have no place left. So M is in November and K in July.
Two cases survive. The free months are January, March, May and September, and O must come before K. L and N take January–March with O in May, or March–May with O in January; either way P is in September. So "whose birthday is in July?" has the answer K, but "whose birthday is in January?" is cannot be determined, since it is L in one case and O in the other.
One more clue closes it. If we add "O's birthday is not in January", the second case dies and the order is L, N, O, K, P, M. Exams often give the puzzle without this clue and ask exactly the question it would settle.
Why it matters. General knowledge about months, weekdays or weekends is part of the puzzle, not a distraction. And when two cases remain, the right reflex is to compare them, not to choose one.
Mixed puzzles and the final check
Order plus a feature. Many puzzles combine a line with a grid: people on floors who also own pets, or officers on weekdays who also handle departments. Draw the line as a column and add one column per feature beside it. Each row is then one floor or one day with all its facts.
Worked example. Riya, Mohan, Sita and Tara live on four floors, one each, with floor 1 at the bottom, and each owns a different pet: a cat, a dog, a fish and a parrot. The dog owner lives on floor 1, Riya lives immediately above the dog owner and owns the cat, Mohan lives on the top floor and does not own the fish, and Sita does not own the dog.
Solving it. Riya is on floor 2 with the cat and Mohan on floor 4. Sita does not own the dog, so she is not on floor 1, which leaves her floor 3 and puts Tara on floor 1 with the dog. Mohan does not own the fish, so he has the parrot and Sita has the fish.
The final check. Before answering, read every clue against the finished table: dog on floor 1, Riya on 2 with the cat, Mohan on top without the fish, Sita without the dog. All hold. This check takes ten seconds and catches the one slip that would spoil a set of five answers.
Why it matters. In a set of questions, a single wrong cell spreads to every answer. The final check is the cheapest insurance in the whole paper.
Where and why this is asked
Why examiners test it. Scheduling and matching are exactly the problems an officer meets when drawing up rosters, allotting halls or assigning inspection duties under several conditions. The puzzles check whether you can keep many conditions straight and notice when they do not decide everything.
Where it shows up. Floor, box and day-wise puzzles are standard in state aptitude papers and in bank, railway and teacher recruitment exams, usually as a set of three to five questions. The union aptitude paper favours shorter matching puzzles of three or four people with two features each.
When it goes wrong. The common slips are numbering floors from the top, reading "above" as "immediately above", forgetting that a linking clue rules out cells in both blocks, and picking one case when two are still alive.
The habit to build. Number the slots, draw a grid for features, put every clue on paper before reasoning, and end with a check of the finished table against the clue list.
Exam lens: five question types and how to beat each
These are practice questions written by us, in the styles the papers use. Real past questions from your exam appear in the PYQ panel of this module.
Type 1: floors. "Six people live on six floors, floor 1 at the bottom. A is on floor 3, B immediately above A and C on the top floor. How many floors are between B and C?" B is on 4 and C on 6, so 1 floor lies between them.
Type 2: days. "Seven talks are held from Monday to Sunday, one a day. T is on Thursday, only two talks fall between T and V, and V is not on Sunday. On which day is V?" Three days either side of Thursday are Monday and Sunday, so V is on Monday.
Type 3: matching. "X, Y and Z come from Delhi, Agra and Pune, one each. X is not from Delhi and Y is from Agra. Where is Z from?" X must be from Pune, so Z is from Delhi.
Type 4: stacks. "Five boxes are stacked. P is second from the top, Q is immediately below P and R is at the bottom. How many boxes are above Q?" P is at 4 and Q at 3, so 2 boxes are above Q.
Type 5: open fact. In the birthday puzzle of this chapter, before the last clue, "whose birthday is in January?" The two surviving cases disagree, so the answer is cannot be determined.
Time plan. Types 1 to 4 take under 30 seconds each. A full puzzle with a set of questions deserves three to four minutes for the table, after which each question is a lookup.
Practice set: twelve solved problems
Try each problem first, then read the steps. Floor 1 and box position 1 are at the bottom, and the problems go from easy to hard.
1. P, Q, R, S and T live on five floors. P is on the top floor, Q on the bottom floor and R immediately below P, while S lives above T. Who lives on floor 2?
P 5, Q 1, R 4, and S above T puts T on 2 and S on 3. The answer is T.
2. Six lectures run from Monday to Saturday. A is on Tuesday, B is three days after A and C is immediately before B. On which day is C?
B is on Friday, so C is on the day before. The answer is Thursday.
3. Ram, Shyam and Ravi each like a different colour: red, blue and green. Shyam likes blue and Ram does not like red. Who likes red?
Ram must like green, so red is left for Ravi. The answer is Ravi.
4. Six boxes are stacked. A is at the bottom, F at the top, B immediately above A and C immediately below F, while D is above E. Which box is fourth from the bottom?
A 1, B 2, C 5, F 6, and D above E puts E on 3 and D on 4. The answer is D.
5. Seven people have one meeting each from Monday to Sunday. P meets on Wednesday and Q two days after P. How many meetings fall between P and Q?
Q is on Friday, and only Thursday lies between. The answer is 1.
6. In an eight-storey building, X lives on an even floor, Y lives on floor 7 and two floors lie between X and Y. On which floor does X live?
X is on floor 4 or floor 10, and there is no floor 10. The answer is floor 4.
7. A, B, C and D teach maths, science, history and English, one subject each. A teaches neither maths nor science, B teaches English, C does not teach maths and D does not teach history. Who teaches maths?
A must teach history, so C, who cannot teach maths, teaches science. The answer is D.
8. Teams P, Q, R, S and T meet in January, February, March, April and May, one team a month. Q meets in the month that has 28 or 29 days, and R immediately after Q; P meets after R but not in May, and S meets before T. Which team meets in May?
Q is in February, R in March and P in April, and S before T puts S in January. The answer is T.
9. Six people live on six floors. A lives on floor 2, only one floor lies between A and B, and C lives immediately above B. On which floor does C live?
B is on floor 4, since floor 0 does not exist. The answer is floor 5.
10. Five boxes are stacked. P is at the top, Q at the bottom and R immediately below P. Which box is second from the bottom?
S and T can take positions 2 and 3 either way. The answer is cannot be determined.
11. In the floors-and-pets example of this chapter, who owns the fish?
Tara has the dog, Riya the cat and Mohan the parrot. The answer is Sita.
12. Seven officers, A to G, inspect on the seven days from Monday to Sunday, one a day. D inspects on Thursday, only two inspections fall between D and A, and A is not on Sunday; B inspects the day after A, E the day after F, and C later than E. Who inspects on Sunday?
A is on Monday and B on Tuesday; the pair F E fits Friday–Saturday or Saturday–Sunday, and C later than E forces F Friday, E Saturday and C Sunday, leaving G on Wednesday. The answer is C.
Quick revision
- Floors, stacks, weekdays and months are one ordered line; number the slots first.
- Floor 1 is at the bottom; k-th from the top is n − k + 1 from the bottom.
- "Immediately" means the next slot; "above", "after" or "later" means any later slot.
- "k between" means a gap of k + 1 in slot numbers.
- Matching: one tick per row and per column in each block of the grid.
- A clue joining two features links two blocks; a cross in one is a cross in the other.
- Months with 30 days: April, June, September, November; February has 28 or 29.
- Two surviving cases: answer shared facts, mark differing ones "cannot be determined".
- Finish every puzzle by checking the final table against each clue.
MPPSC SSE (State Service) questions from this chapter
Six persons A, B, C, D, E and F read one copy of a novel, one at a time. Two persons read it before E. C gives the novel to the last person. B and D finish before F reads. Three persons read it between A and F. A does not receive the novel from D. Who is the first person to read the novel?
- (a) D
- (b) A
- (c) B
- (d) F
Show answer
(c) B · our answer; official key awaited
Six persons A, B, C, D, E and F read one copy of a novel, one at a time. Two persons read it before E. C gives the novel to the last person. B and D finish before F reads. Three persons read it between A and F. A does not receive the novel from D. Who is the fourth person to read the novel?
- (a) D
- (b) A
- (c) B
- (d) F
Show answer
(a) D · our answer; official key awaited
There are five persons P, Q, R, S and T. One is a tennis player, one is a chess player and one is a hockey player. P and S are unmarried women and do not play any sport. None of the women plays either chess or tennis. Among them there is a married couple in which T is the husband. Q is the brother of R and is neither a chess player nor a hockey player. Who is the tennis player?
- (a) P
- (b) Q
- (c) R
- (d) S
Show answer
(b) Q · our answer; official key awaited
There are five persons P, Q, R, S and T. One is a tennis player, one is a chess player and one is a hockey player. P and S are unmarried women and do not play any sport. None of the women plays either chess or tennis. Among them there is a married couple in which T is the husband. Q is the brother of R and is neither a chess player nor a hockey player. Who is the hockey player?
- (a) P
- (b) Q
- (c) R
- (d) S
Show answer
(c) R · our answer; official key awaited
There are five persons P, Q, R, S and T. One is a tennis player, one is a chess player and one is a hockey player. P and S are unmarried women and do not play any sport. None of the women plays either chess or tennis. Among them there is a married couple in which T is the husband. Q is the brother of R and is neither a chess player nor a hockey player. Who is the chess player?
- (a) P
- (b) Q
- (c) R
- (d) T
Show answer
(d) T · our answer; official key awaited
There are five persons P, Q, R, S and T. One is a tennis player, one is a chess player and one is a hockey player. P and S are unmarried women and do not play any sport. None of the women plays either chess or tennis. Among them there is a married couple in which T is the husband. Q is the brother of R and is neither a chess player nor a hockey player. Who is the wife of T?
- (a) P
- (b) Q
- (c) R
- (d) S
Show answer
(c) R · our answer; official key awaited
There are five persons P, Q, R, S and T. One is a tennis player, one is a chess player and one is a hockey player. P and S are unmarried women and do not play any sport. None of the women plays either chess or tennis. Among them there is a married couple in which T is the husband. Q is the brother of R and is neither a chess player nor a hockey player. The three ladies are
- (a) P, Q, R
- (b) Q, R, S
- (c) P, Q, S
- (d) P, R, S
Show answer
(d) P, R, S · our answer; official key awaited