MPSC Rajyaseva · Module 41 · Mains depth · 22 min
Environmental ethics and justice: views of nature, who pays, and the Anthropocene
What MPSC Rajyaseva asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Paper I: General Studies · Economic and social development: sustainable development, poverty, inclusion, demographics and social sector initiatives.
- Paper I: General Studies · General issues on environmental ecology, biodiversity and climate change.
- GS III · Conservation, environmental pollution, impact assessment and climate change.
- GS III · Disaster management.
MPSC Rajyaseva questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: is it wrong to harm a river?
Most people agree that stealing, lying and hurting others are wrong. But is it wrong to cut down an old forest that no one owns? Is it wrong to dirty a river if no person is harmed today? These questions take ethics beyond human beings to nature itself.
Laws tell us what we must not do, but they are written by people with values. If a society believes nature exists only for human use, its laws will allow more exploitation. If it believes nature has worth of its own, its laws will protect more.
Ethics also asks a second question: who bears the cost of environmental damage? Often the poorest people live next to the dumps, mines and polluting factories, while others enjoy the benefits. This is the question of environmental justice.
This chapter explains why we need environmental ethics, the main views about nature, and the ideas of equity and justice. It then looks at religious and Indian traditions, the idea of the Anthropocene, and how individual and collective action can make a difference. These ideas are useful for ethics papers and essays as much as for environment questions.
Why we need a new ethic for the environment
What ethics is. Ethics asks what is right and wrong in a broad, universal sense. Moral values reflect what a particular culture believes, and they can differ between societies. Some people think wasting resources is immoral, while others argue that high consumption is good because it drives growth and jobs.
What environmental ethics studies. Environmental ethics studies the moral relationship between human beings and the environment. It also asks whether non-human things, such as animals, plants, rivers and ecosystems, have value and moral status of their own. It emerged as a separate field in the early 1970s.
Reason one: new effects on nature. Modern technology lets humans change nature on a scale never seen before, from clearing whole forests to altering the climate. Actions with such large effects need ethical examination. Old rules written for small communities are not enough.
Reason two: new knowledge. Science now shows how human actions change the environment in ways not understood earlier. For example, scientists have shown that burning fossil fuels and clearing forests raise carbon dioxide and change the climate. This new knowledge brings new responsibilities on a global scale.
Reason three: expanding moral concern. For most of history, ethics dealt with human rights: of individuals, families and groups. Today, many argue that animals, plants and even the environment deserve moral consideration. This widening circle of concern calls for a new ethic.
Three cultural views of nature
The Western view. In the past, the dominant Western view, from Europe and North America, saw nature as alien and hostile to human beings. Nature had to be conquered and brought under human control. This view supported rapid industrial exploitation of natural resources.
The East Asian view. The traditional view in China, Korea and Japan sees nature as beautiful and perfect, inspiring aesthetic awe. Humans are seen as part of nature, each with a place in it. Yet nature is also shaped and transformed, as in carefully designed gardens, to be loved.
The Indian view. The Indian spiritual tradition draws on Hindu, Buddhist and Jain thought. Here nature is a mother and a goddess, who cannot be tamed by her children. This view encourages reverence and restraint rather than conquest.
Why these views matter. A society's view of nature shapes its policies on forests, rivers and wildlife. A conquest view tends to favour large-scale extraction, while a reverential view supports protection. Real societies mix these views, and modern India too balances reverence with rapid development.
Attitudes towards nature: from human-centred to Earth-centred
Anthropocentrism. An anthropocentric or human-centred attitude gives far greater value to humans than to anything else. Nature has only instrumental value, as a means to human ends; Aristotle held that nature made all things for the sake of man. A milder form, enlightened anthropocentrism, says we should protect nature because our duties to other humans, including future generations, require it.
Stewardship. Many tribal and indigenous communities see themselves as caretakers of a particular forest, river or land. In the stewardship view, humans are partners within nature, not its masters, and all living things are like members of one household. Stewardship does not reject science; it asks us to use it to improve the world rather than degrade it.
Ecofeminism. Ecofeminists argue that both views come from a system built on domination, which ranks men above women and culture above nature. They see a link between the exploitation of nature and the exploitation of women. They value care, kinship and reciprocity over ownership and control, though critics call the view impractical and say not all development harms women.
Biocentrism. Many environmentalists find stewardship still too human-centred. A biocentric attitude holds that all living organisms have value and rights, whether or not they are useful to us. Killing a species for profit is wrong even if humans gain.
Ecocentrism. Ecocentrism goes further, giving moral value to whole ecosystems and even non-living parts such as rivers, mountains and natural processes. Aldo Leopold's land ethic treated the whole biotic community as part of the "land" and argued that our circle of rights should widen to include it. This idea echoes in recent debates about giving rivers legal rights.
Environmental equity and justice: who pays the price?
Equity: fair treatment. Environmental equity is the ideal that all groups, whatever their income, caste, race or ethnicity, are treated equally under environmental laws. Inequity can take three forms. Each shows a different way the burden of pollution can fall unfairly.
Procedural inequity. This is about unfair process. Examples include boards and committees packed with business interests, public hearings held in remote places to limit attendance, and documents only in a language that local people cannot read. Even good rules fail if the process shuts people out.
Geographical inequity. Some places get the benefits of industry, such as jobs and taxes, while others get the costs, such as waste dumps and polluted air. Communities that host waste facilities usually gain less than those that produce the waste. A city's garbage often ends up next to a poor village.
Social inequity. Environmental decisions often mirror the power structure of society. Disadvantaged groups, whether by race, caste or class, are more likely to live near hazardous sites, and some areas have even been called "sacrifice zones". In India, slums near drains and dumps, and tribal villages near mines, often face the worst pollution.
Environmental justice. Environmental justice is the pursuit of equal protection under environmental laws without discrimination by race, ethnicity or socio-economic status. It also means equal access to relief and meaningful participation in decisions by government and industry. It rejects the idea that a clean environment is a luxury only the rich can afford, and insists that the poor have the strongest stake in it.
Religion, tradition and the duty of care
Humans as trustees. Many world religions teach that land, rivers, mountains and oceans are held in trust. Humans may use them wisely for the general welfare, but they have no right to destroy them. No major religion sanctions the destruction of our habitat.
Indian traditions. Reverence for nature runs deep in Indian culture. Tree worship appears in the Indus civilisation, and the Rigveda praises Aranyani as the spirit of the forest and mother of wild animals. The peepal, banyan and tulsi, and rivers like the Ganga, are still treated as sacred.
Other Indian thought. Jainism teaches ahimsa, non-violence towards all living beings, even the smallest. Buddhism stresses compassion for all sentient beings and moderation in wants. Kautilya's Arthashastra reflects a sense of reciprocity between people and nature in matters of state policy.

Why this matters today. Sacred groves, protected by local faith, have preserved patches of old forest across India. Religious and cultural values can move people in ways that laws alone cannot. Yet sacred status has not saved the Ganga from pollution, which shows that reverence must be matched by action.
The Anthropocene: the age of humans
What the word means. "Anthropo" means human and "cene" comes from a Greek word meaning recent. The Anthropocene is the proposed name for the age in which human activity has become a major force shaping the planet. Humans have caused extinctions, polluted the oceans and changed the atmosphere.
When did it begin? Scholars disagree. Some trace it to the start of farming, which changed how humans relate to land. Others point to the fossil-fuel-driven Industrial Revolution, which freed humans from the limits of muscle power, and geologists continue to debate whether it should be a formal unit of geological time.
The Great Acceleration. Human impact rose so sharply after 1945 that this period is called the Great Acceleration. Within about three human generations, around three-quarters of the human-caused build-up of carbon dioxide took place. World plastic production rose from about 1 million tonnes in 1950 to nearly 300 million tonnes by 2015, and synthetic nitrogen for fertilisers rose many times over.
Planetary boundaries. Scientists have identified nine planetary boundaries that mark a "safe operating space" for humanity. They are climate change, biosphere integrity, biogeochemical flows, stratospheric ozone depletion, ocean acidification, freshwater use, land-system change, atmospheric aerosol loading and novel entities such as new chemicals and plastics. Scientists warn that several of these boundaries have already been crossed.
Why it matters ethically. The Anthropocene means humans can no longer treat nature as a backdrop; we are now responsible for the planet's condition. The first and worst effects of crossing boundaries fall on the poorest people. This links the Anthropocene directly to the question of justice.
From ethics to action
Individual choices. Ethics becomes real only through action. Using less, wasting less, choosing public transport and saving water and electricity are everyday ethical choices. India's mission promoting mindful consumption is explained in the chapter on India's climate missions.
Why collective action works better. Acting alone, it is easy to feel discouraged by slow change. Working in a group gives encouragement, shared knowledge and greater power. The anthropologist Margaret Mead said that a small group of committed citizens can change the world.
Students and campaigns. Student environment groups can teach ecology and ethics and take up community projects such as tree planting, waste segregation and water saving. A good campaign includes all stakeholders, benefits ordinary people and rests on sound science. India's own movements, from forest protection to saving rivers, show that ordinary people can shape environmental policy.
Mains lens: three live debates on environmental ethics and justice
1. Human-centred or Earth-centred policy? Anthropocentrism values nature mainly for what it gives people: food, water, timber and clean air. Ecocentrism gives value to whole ecosystems, rivers and forests in their own right, whether or not people use them. Most public policy in India is still human-centred, because it is written for citizens and voters.
Supporters of the human-centred view say that it is practical, because people protect what serves them. Supporters of the Earth-centred view say that this logic lets us destroy anything that seems useless today, like a remote wetland or an unknown species. A balanced answer favours stewardship, the view that humans are caretakers within nature, which keeps human welfare at the centre while respecting limits that cannot be crossed.
2. Who pays for pollution? Polluting industries, waste dumps and mines are often placed near poor, tribal or marginalised communities, who have the least power to object. They breathe the smoke and drink the water, while the benefits of the factory or the city flow elsewhere. This is the core concern of environmental justice.
One side argues that such siting is about cheap land, not discrimination. The other side says that the outcome is unequal whatever the intention, and that equal protection under environmental laws must mean equal results. In Mains, define justice in three ways: fair procedure, fair location and fair social outcome, and support answers with examples such as the Bhopal gas tragedy or mining regions.
3. Can tradition solve modern problems? Indian traditions worshipped trees, rivers and forests, praised the forest spirit in early hymns and saw a give-and-take between people and nature in statecraft. Sacred groves still protect patches of forest in many regions. This shows that care for nature is not a foreign idea in India.
Critics warn that worship does not stop a river from being polluted, as the state of many sacred rivers shows. They also say that tradition alone cannot manage climate change or industrial chemicals. A balanced answer uses tradition as a source of values and community action, while relying on science, law and institutions for scale.
Why it matters: Ethics is the reason behind every environmental law and treaty. Mains questions in GS-III, GS-IV and the Essay paper often ask "should we", not just "how", and these debates help you answer that.
Mains lens: two kinds of questions and how to answer them
Type 1: "Distinguish and choose" (ethical approaches). Example: "Distinguish between anthropocentric and ecocentric approaches to the environment. Which should guide public policy in India?"
- Intro: Define environmental ethics as the study of the moral relationship between people and nature.
- Body, the approaches: Explain anthropocentrism, stewardship, biocentrism and ecocentrism, using the land ethic as an example of the last.
- Body, India's needs: Show that a developing country must meet human needs, but that some ecosystems, like rivers and forests, are too vital to trade away.
- Body, a choice: Argue for stewardship with ecocentric limits for critical ecosystems.
- Conclusion: Conclude that good policy protects people by protecting the systems they depend on.
Type 2: "What does the idea imply?" (a big concept). Example: "What is the Anthropocene? What does it imply for how we think about development?"
- Intro: Define the Anthropocene as the proposed age in which human activity has become a major force changing the planet.
- Body, the evidence: Explain the sharp rise in human impact after 1945, called the Great Acceleration.
- Body, the limits: Describe the nine planetary boundaries, such as climate change, biosphere integrity, freshwater use and novel entities.
- Body, the implication: Show that development must now stay within these limits, which calls for cleaner energy, circular use of materials and protection of ecosystems.
- Conclusion: Conclude that in the Anthropocene, humans are not just users of nature but its managers, with matching responsibility.
Linking across papers. This chapter is the core of GS-IV questions on environmental ethics and of many Essay topics. It also strengthens GS-III conclusions and GS-I answers on social movements.
Mains practice: six questions, six angles
These are practice questions we have written, not past papers. Past questions for each exam are in this module's PYQ panel.
| Angle | Question | How to approach |
|---|---|---|
| Ethics | Distinguish between anthropocentric and ecocentric approaches to the environment. Which should guide public policy in India? | Define both, with enlightened anthropocentrism and the land ethic. Argue for a balanced, stewardship-based approach with examples. |
| Justice | "The burden of pollution falls hardest on those who benefit least from development." Discuss with Indian examples. | Use procedural, geographical and social inequity. Give examples of dumps, mines and industrial disasters, and suggest participation and fair compensation. |
| Tradition | Can traditional Indian values help address modern environmental problems? Critically examine. | Discuss nature as mother, sacred groves, ahimsa and restraint. Contrast with the polluted Ganga and argue that values need laws and action. |
| Gender | What is ecofeminism? How far does it help explain environmental movements in India? | Explain the link between domination of nature and of women. Use women's role in forest protection, and note the criticisms. |
| Planet | What is the Anthropocene? What does it imply for how we think about development? | Define it, explain the Great Acceleration and the nine planetary boundaries. Argue for growth within planetary limits and fair sharing. |
| Essay | "We do not inherit the Earth from our ancestors; we borrow it from our children." | Use intergenerational equity, trusteeship and stewardship. Bring in the Anthropocene, justice and everyday action, and end with hope. |
How to use this table: each answer should first explain the what, then give the why from this chapter, and end with a way forward.
Quick revision
- Environmental ethics: moral relation of humans and environment; needed due to new effects, new knowledge, expanding moral concern.
- Views of nature: Western (hostile, conquer), East Asian (beautiful, humans part of it), Indian (nature as mother).
- Anthropocentrism (instrumental value; Aristotle; enlightened version), stewardship (caretakers, partners), ecofeminism (domination of nature ↔ women), biocentrism (all living beings), ecocentrism (whole ecosystems; Aldo Leopold, land ethic).
- Equity: procedural, geographical, social. Environmental justice: equal protection, access to relief, participation.
- Traditions: humans as trustees; Aranyani (Rigveda); sacred trees and rivers; Jain ahimsa; Kautilya.
- Anthropocene; Great Acceleration (after 1945); nine planetary boundaries.