RPSC Sub Inspector course‹› 0:00 studied

RPSC Sub Inspector · Module 73 · standard depth · 14 min

Arguments and courses of action

What RPSC Sub Inspector asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper II: General Knowledge and General Science · Reasoning and mental ability: statements, assumptions, arguments, conclusions and courses of action, analytical reasoning, series, odd one out, coding-decoding, relations, shapes.

RPSC Sub Inspector questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for RPSC Sub Inspector. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: weighing a view and choosing a step

A town council is asked whether plastic carry bags should be banned. One member says, "Yes, they choke the drains and cause flooding." Another says, "No, shopkeepers like them." Both have spoken, but only one has given a reason that should weigh in a public decision.

A council meeting weighs two views

This is the first skill in this chapter: telling a strong argument from a weak one. The second skill is choosing a sensible course of action when a problem is described. Suppose the drains are already choked and the rains are a week away; what should the council actually do?

Why these skills matter. Public decisions invite many opinions, and not all of them deserve equal weight. A good officer listens to all, but acts on the reasons that are relevant, important and sound. The same officer must then pick steps that work in practice, not just steps that sound tough.

What this chapter does. We learn three tests for a strong argument, the common types of weak ones, and four tests for a valid course of action. We then practise on questions in the style the papers use.

Strong and weak arguments

Three tests for strength. First, the argument must be directly related to the question asked. Second, it must deal with an important point, not a minor convenience. Third, it must be backed by a reason or a widely accepted fact, not by a feeling.

Three tests for a strong argument

Weak type 1: trivial or personal. "No, shopkeepers prefer plastic bags" is related, but convenience is minor next to flooding. Arguments about comfort, taste or the interests of a small group usually fail the importance test.

Weak type 2: sweeping or extreme. "Yes, every other country teaches coding from Class 1" is a sweeping claim that is not true. Words such as "all", "only", "never" and "every" often signal a weak argument. A claim like "cinema is the only entertainment" fails for the same reason.

Weak type 3: vague, opinion or a restatement. "Yes, it is a good idea" gives no reason at all. "No, it will create problems" does not say which problems. "Yes, because the ban is needed" just repeats the question in other words.

Why it matters. In meetings, the loudest view is not always the strongest. These tests let you sort arguments quickly and fairly, whichever side they support.

When both sides are strong

Real debates have two strong sides. For the question of raising the retirement age to 65, "Yes, people now live longer and stay fit for longer" is related, important and true in general. "No, it will reduce openings for young people" is also related, important and reasonable. Both arguments are strong.

Strong does not mean winning. The question asks whether each argument is strong, not which side should win. Students often mark only the side they personally agree with. Judge each argument on the three tests, and keep your own opinion out.

Facts that are widely accepted. An argument may use facts that most educated people accept, such as "plastic does not rot quickly" or "India has a very large number of voters". It may not depend on a doubtful statistic or a rumour. When in doubt, ask whether a fair-minded reader would accept the fact without proof.

Strength is about the reason, not the side. A "No" argument can be stronger than a "Yes" argument on the same question, and the reverse. Read each argument as if it were the only one given.

Why it matters. Policy notes are expected to present both sides fairly before a recommendation. This skill is exactly what such notes require.

Courses of action: what should be done

Four tests. A course of action follows if it is practical, if it solves the problem or reduces its harm, if it lies within the authority of the body acting, and if it does not create a bigger problem. An action that fails any one test does not follow.

Relief now, fix later

Relief now and a fix later. "Dengue cases have risen after the monsoon" can call for both a clean-up drive against stagnant water and extra fever wards in hospitals. The first attacks the cause, and the second limits the harm. Both follow, because a real response often has two layers.

Extreme and punitive steps. "Several shops sell adulterated milk" does not justify banning all milk in the city, which would hurt everyone. Testing samples and prosecuting offenders is the measured step. Arresting all, dismissing all or closing everything rarely follows.

Steps that miss the cause. If children drop out because the nearest upper primary school is 10 km away, penalising parents does not touch the cause. Opening schools nearer or giving transport does. A course of action must aim at what is actually causing the problem.

Why it matters. Officers are judged by whether their steps work. Choosing measured, practical and well-aimed actions is the core of good administration.

Reading the question carefully

Look at the exact problem. A course of action must match the problem as stated, not a larger problem you imagine. If one office had a minor fire from a faulty wire, the right steps are about wiring and fire safety in that building. Shutting the whole building forever goes far beyond the facts.

Look at who is acting. Some questions say "the municipal body should" or "the school should". A step outside that body's power, such as a school changing a national law, does not follow. When no actor is named, assume a reasonable government authority.

Look for hidden extremes. Words such as "immediately ban", "all" and "permanently" often turn a sensible idea into an extreme one. "Increase ticket checking" is measured, while "jail every ticketless traveller" is not. Read each action to the end before judging it.

Arguments in pairs. Many arguments come as a "Yes" and a "No". Judge each separately, and remember that both can be strong, both weak, or one of each. Strength never depends on which side you favour.

Why it matters. Most wrong answers come from reading the options too quickly. Slowing down for a few seconds on the actor, the scope and the wording saves many marks.

Where and why this is asked

Why examiners test it. Administration is a stream of decisions on contested questions and urgent problems. Officers must weigh competing views fairly and choose steps that are firm but proportionate. These question types put both skills on paper.

Where it shows up. Strong-and-weak arguments and courses of action are regular in state PSC mental-ability sections and in staff-selection style exams. The UPSC aptitude paper tests the same judgement through decision-making situations and through passages that ask for the most reasonable step. Mains essay and ethics answers also reward balanced arguments and practical solutions.

When it goes wrong. The usual slips are marking only the side you agree with, accepting extreme or punitive steps because they sound decisive, and missing that both a relief step and a long-term step can follow. Another is accepting a sweeping fact that is not true.

The habit to build. For an argument, run the three tests: related, important, backed. For a course of action, run the four tests: practical, aimed at the problem, within authority, no bigger harm.

Practice set: twelve solved problems

Problems 1 to 6 ask which arguments are strong, and problems 7 to 12 ask which courses of action follow. Choose one answer: only I, only II, either I or II, neither, or both. Try each problem first, then read the steps.

1. Should plastic carry bags be banned in cities? (I) Yes, they choke drains and add to urban flooding; (II) no, shopkeepers prefer them.

I is related, important and backed by a known effect. II is a matter of convenience, so the answer is only I is strong.

2. Should voting be made compulsory? (I) Yes, it would raise turnout and make results more representative; (II) no, it would take away the freedom not to vote and is hard to enforce among crores of voters.

Each argument rests on a real and important consequence. The answer is both are strong.

3. Should all schools teach coding from Class 1? (I) Yes, every other country already does so; (II) no, many schools still lack basic teachers and computers.

I rests on a sweeping claim that is not true. II points to a real limit, so the answer is only II is strong.

4. Should the retirement age of government employees be raised to 65? (I) Yes, people now live longer and stay fit for longer; (II) no, it would reduce job openings for young people.

Both points are related, important and reasonable. The answer is both are strong.

5. Should cinema halls be closed on weekdays? (I) Yes, students waste time there; (II) no, cinema is the only entertainment people have.

I is a sweeping judgement about all students, and II uses an extreme "only". The answer is neither is strong.

6. Should tolls be removed from national highways? (I) No, tolls fund the upkeep of roads and new roads; (II) yes, travellers dislike paying.

I gives an important reason. Dislike is not a reason of public weight, so the answer is only I is strong.

7. Problem: Many children drop out after Class 5 because the nearest upper primary school is 10 km away. (I) Open upper primary schools nearer or give transport; (II) penalise parents whose children drop out.

I attacks the cause. II punishes families for a problem they did not create, so the answer is only I follows.

8. Problem: Dengue cases have risen sharply in a town after the monsoon. (I) Clear stagnant water and spray against mosquitoes; (II) set up extra fever wards in the district hospital.

I tackles the cause and II limits the harm. The answer is both follow.

9. Problem: A bridge on a busy road has developed cracks. (I) Stop heavy vehicles on it at once and get engineers to inspect it; (II) demolish every bridge built in the same year.

I is practical and proportionate. II is sweeping and wasteful, so the answer is only I follows.

10. Problem: Several shops in a city sell adulterated milk. (I) Ban the sale of milk in the city; (II) test samples regularly and prosecute offenders.

I would harm everyone who needs milk. II targets the wrongdoers, so the answer is only II follows.

11. Problem: Many passengers travel without tickets on suburban trains. (I) Increase ticket checking and fines; (II) make buying tickets easier through mobile apps and more counters.

I deters ticketless travel, and II removes an excuse for it. The answer is both follow.

12. Problem: A minor fire broke out in one office because of a faulty wire. (I) Shut the whole building permanently; (II) arrest all electricians in the city.

Both steps are extreme and do not fit a minor, local fault. The answer is neither follows.

Quick revision

One-page summary box
  • A strong argument is related to the question, important, and backed by a reason or accepted fact.
  • Weak arguments are trivial, vague, opinion-based, sweeping or a restatement of the question.
  • Opposite arguments can both be strong; judge each on its own.
  • A course of action must be practical, aimed at the problem, within authority and free of bigger harm.
  • An immediate relief step and a long-term fix can both follow.
  • Extreme, punitive and sweeping steps rarely follow.
  • Match the action to the exact problem and to the body that is acting.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 12 answered

  1. Should plastic carry bags be banned in cities? (I) Yes, they choke drains and add to urban flooding; (II) no, shopkeepers prefer them.

  2. Should voting be made compulsory? (I) Yes, it would raise turnout and make results more representative; (II) no, it would take away the freedom not to vote and is hard to enforce among crores of voters.

  3. Should all schools teach coding from Class 1? (I) Yes, every other country already does so; (II) no, many schools still lack basic teachers and computers.

  4. Should the retirement age of government employees be raised to 65? (I) Yes, people now live longer and stay fit for longer; (II) no, it would reduce job openings for young people.

  5. Should cinema halls be closed on weekdays? (I) Yes, students waste time there; (II) no, cinema is the only entertainment people have.

  6. Should tolls be removed from national highways? (I) No, tolls fund the upkeep of roads and new roads; (II) yes, travellers dislike paying.

  7. Problem: Many children drop out after Class 5 because the nearest upper primary school is 10 km away. (I) Open upper primary schools nearer or give transport; (II) penalise parents whose children drop out.

  8. Problem: Dengue cases have risen sharply in a town after the monsoon. (I) Clear stagnant water and spray against mosquitoes; (II) set up extra fever wards in the district hospital.

  9. Problem: A bridge on a busy road has developed cracks. (I) Stop heavy vehicles on it at once and get engineers to inspect it; (II) demolish every bridge built in the same year.

  10. Problem: Several shops in a city sell adulterated milk. (I) Ban the sale of milk in the city; (II) test samples regularly and prosecute offenders.

  11. Problem: Many passengers travel without tickets on suburban trains. (I) Increase ticket checking and fines; (II) make buying tickets easier through mobile apps and more counters.

  12. Problem: A minor fire broke out in one office because of a faulty wire. (I) Shut the whole building permanently; (II) arrest all electricians in the city.

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Should all cars be banned to cut pollution?

An argument for a total ban is weak because it is extreme and impractical.

Can two courses of action both follow?

Yes, for example an immediate relief step and a long-term fix.

Is an argument quoting another country's example strong?

Only if conditions are comparable; otherwise it is weak.

Why do punitive actions often not follow?

They may not fix the cause and can create bigger problems.