TNPSC Group 1 · Module 55 · Mains depth · 18 min
SAARC and BIMSTEC: why regionalism stalled in South Asia
What TNPSC Group 1 asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Part A: General Studies · Current events.
- Paper III: GS II · Indian polity, emerging political trends across the world affecting India.
TNPSC Group 1 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: neighbours who rarely trade
Imagine a row of houses on one street. They share a water line, a road and a market. Common sense says they should cooperate, buy from each other and solve problems together. But if two families in the middle are always quarrelling, every meeting of the street committee ends in a fight, and nothing gets done.
South Asia is a little like that street. Its countries share rivers, mountains, culture and a long history. Yet trade among them is very low, and their main regional body, SAARC, has not held a summit for more than a decade.
India has therefore turned more and more to another grouping, BIMSTEC, which links the countries around the Bay of Bengal. This chapter explains what each grouping is, why SAARC stalled, and why BIMSTEC has risen.
Why it matters. Regional cooperation is a frequent Mains theme, often framed as "SAARC versus BIMSTEC". Prelims asks about founding dates, members, secretariats and summits.
SAARC: a big idea for South Asia
When and where. The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) was established on 8 December 1985, when leaders adopted the SAARC Charter in Dhaka. Its Secretariat is in Kathmandu, Nepal. It gave the countries of South Asia their first common regional platform.
Who is in it. SAARC has eight members: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. India is by far the largest member in size, population and economy. This imbalance shapes everything in SAARC, because smaller members sometimes fear India's dominance.
What it aims to do. SAARC aims to promote the welfare of the peoples of South Asia and to speed up growth through collective self-reliance and mutual cooperation. Its framework agreements on trade include SAPTA, the South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA) and an agreement on trade in services, SATIS. These were meant to lower barriers and make the region one market.
Institutions. SAARC has built some lasting bodies. The SAARC Development Fund is based in Thimphu. The South Asian University in New Delhi was set up under an agreement adopted at the 14th summit in 2007, and began classes in 2010; India pays its full capital cost and 59% of its operating budget.
Why it matters. On paper SAARC had everything: a charter, a secretariat, trade agreements and institutions. Its weak results show that structures alone cannot overcome political distrust.
Why SAARC stalled
Low trade. Despite its trade agreements, intra-regional trade remains less than 6% of the members' total trade. South Asian countries trade far more with distant partners than with each other. When neighbours do not depend on each other economically, there is little pressure to keep cooperation going.
The last summit. SAARC's 18th summit was held in Kathmandu on 26-27 November 2014, under the theme "Deeper Integration for Peace and Prosperity". The 19th summit was due to be hosted by Pakistan, but it has not taken place. Summit-level work has stayed stalled because of a lack of consensus among members and concerns about cross-border terrorism.
Terrorism and trust. India's position is that meaningful regional integration needs an environment free from terrorism. For India, regional cooperation and cross-border terrorism cannot go together. Without India, the largest member, a SAARC summit makes little sense.
The deeper problem. SAARC needs consensus among its members, so deep disagreement between any two of them can block progress. The India-Pakistan rivalry has repeatedly spilled into SAARC meetings. Smaller members also worry about being caught between the two.
Why it matters. SAARC's paralysis is a classic example of how bilateral conflict can freeze a whole region. In Mains, you should present SAARC not as dead but as dormant, waiting for better political conditions.
Inside SAARC: rules, summits, centres and the trade story
Rules written for trust. Smaller members feared India's size, so the SAARC Charter was built on sovereign equality, territorial integrity, political independence and non-interference. Every decision needs consensus, so one member can block any step. Bilateral and contentious issues are kept out of SAARC meetings, which is why Kashmir or river disputes never sit on its agenda.
Safe subjects first. Early on, SAARC chose non-controversial areas such as agriculture, health, science, culture and sports. Smaller members kept trade off the agenda at first, fearing that Indian goods would flood their markets. This cautious start explains why SAARC built many meetings but little economic integration.
From SAPTA to SAFTA. Trade finally entered with the SAARC Preferential Trading Arrangement (SAPTA), signed at Dhaka in 1993 and launched in 1995. It covered too few goods and had no firm timetable. The South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA) was signed at the Islamabad summit of 2004 and came into force in 2006, with tariff cuts on a timetable and 'sensitive lists' of goods each country could protect.
Terrorism on the agenda. As early as the Bangalore summit of 1986, leaders agreed a Regional Convention on Suppression of Terrorism, and later added a protocol on terrorist financing. Yet terrorism finally froze SAARC itself. After the Uri attack of September 2016, India pulled out of the Islamabad summit, and Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Bhutan, the Maldives and Sri Lanka followed, so the summit was called off.
Observers and centres. SAARC has nine observers: Australia, China, Iran, Japan, South Korea, Mauritius, Myanmar, the USA and the EU. Its regional centres include the Agriculture Centre in Dhaka, the TB and HIV/AIDS Centre in Kathmandu, the Energy Centre in Islamabad and the Cultural Centre in Colombo. A Disaster Management Centre was re-established in 2016 by merging four older centres.
Why it matters. The rules that made SAARC safe for small states, consensus and no bilateral issues, are the same rules that let one quarrel freeze it. China's wish to move from observer to member is another reason India now invests more in BIMSTEC.
BIMSTEC: the Bay of Bengal bridge
How it began. BIMSTEC came into existence on 6 June 1997 through the Bangkok Declaration. It began with four members under the name BIST-EC: Bangladesh, India, Sri Lanka and Thailand. Myanmar joined in December 1997, and Nepal and Bhutan in 2004, when it took its present name.
What the name means. BIMSTEC stands for the Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation. Its seven members are five South Asian countries, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal and Sri Lanka, and two South-East Asian countries, Myanmar and Thailand. It is a unique link connecting South Asia with South-East Asia.
Size. The BIMSTEC region brings together 1.7 billion people, about 22% of the world's population, with a combined GDP of about US$5 trillion. A permanent Secretariat was set up in Dhaka in 2014.
Stronger foundations. For years BIMSTEC had no founding treaty. The BIMSTEC Charter was adopted at the 5th summit in Colombo on 30 March 2022 and came into force on 20 May 2024, giving the group a firm legal base.
Seven sectors. Cooperation is organised in seven sectors, each led by one member. India leads security, which covers counter-terrorism and transnational crime, disaster management and energy security. Bangladesh leads trade and investment, Bhutan environment, Nepal people-to-people contacts, Myanmar agriculture, Sri Lanka science and technology, and Thailand connectivity.
Why it matters. BIMSTEC lets India cooperate with its eastern neighbours without the India-Pakistan deadlock. It also fits India's Neighbourhood First and Act East policies, because it ties the Bay of Bengal to South-East Asia.
BIMSTEC today: the Bangkok summit and India's push
The 6th summit. BIMSTEC leaders met in Bangkok on 4 April 2025, with Thailand as chair, under the theme "BIMSTEC: Prosperous, Resilient and Open". They adopted the Bangkok Vision 2030, a road map for the region's shared prosperity. They also signed the BIMSTEC Maritime Transport Agreement, which gives ships, crew and cargo of members fair treatment in each other's ports.
India's 21-point plan. At the summit, India proposed a 21-point Action Plan covering business, digital technology, disaster management, space, security, capacity building, youth and culture. One key idea is BODHI, short for BIMSTEC for Organized Development of Human Resource Infrastructure, which offers training and scholarships to young people of member countries.
Centres and links. India offered centres of excellence on disaster management, sustainable maritime transport, traditional medicine and agriculture research. It also proposed a BIMSTEC Chamber of Commerce and the first BIMSTEC Games in 2027, to mark the group's 30th anniversary. These steps aim to build ties between people, not only between governments.
Why it matters. BIMSTEC is moving from a talk shop to a group with a charter, a secretariat and real projects. For India, success in BIMSTEC is a test of whether it can lead its region by offering benefits, not by size alone.
Side by side: how the two groupings differ
Comparing the two groupings feature by feature shows why one stalled and the other moved ahead.
| Feature | SAARC | BIMSTEC |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1985, Dhaka | 1997, Bangkok |
| Members | Eight, all South Asian | Seven: five South Asian, two South-East Asian |
| Pakistan | Member | Not a member |
| Secretariat | Kathmandu | Dhaka, since 2014 |
| Founding document | SAARC Charter, 1985 | Bangkok Declaration 1997; Charter in force 2024 |
| Last summit | 2014, Kathmandu | 2025, Bangkok |
| Geography | Land-based South Asia | Around the Bay of Bengal |
Read the rows one by one. The biggest differences are membership and momentum: BIMSTEC does not include Pakistan, and it has held summits and strengthened its rules while SAARC has stood still.
Why it matters. Examiners like comparison questions. A clear feature-by-feature contrast lets you show both facts and judgement in a short space.
When, where and why: two groupings at a glance
This table puts the key dates of SAARC and BIMSTEC side by side.
| When | What and where | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| 8 Dec 1985 | SAARC Charter adopted, Dhaka | South Asia's first regional body |
| 6 Jun 1997 | Bangkok Declaration creates BIST-EC | A bridge to South-East Asia |
| 2004 | Nepal and Bhutan join; name BIMSTEC | Seven members |
| 2014 | BIMSTEC Secretariat set up, Dhaka | Permanent machinery |
| Nov 2014 | 18th SAARC summit, Kathmandu | The last SAARC summit so far |
| After 2014 | 19th SAARC summit not held | Terrorism and lack of consensus |
| 30 Mar 2022 | BIMSTEC Charter adopted, Colombo | Legal base for BIMSTEC |
| 20 May 2024 | BIMSTEC Charter in force | Group becomes treaty-based |
| 4 Apr 2025 | 6th BIMSTEC summit, Bangkok | Bangkok Vision 2030; India's 21-point plan |
Read each row from left to right: a date, what happened and where, and why it matters. Notice how BIMSTEC gained strength in the same years that SAARC stalled.
Mains lens: SAARC versus BIMSTEC
- Why SAARC stalled. Low intra-regional trade, the India-Pakistan rivalry, cross-border terrorism and decision by consensus together froze SAARC. A summit has not been held since 2014. In an answer, show that the problem is political, not institutional.
- Why BIMSTEC rose. BIMSTEC avoids the India-Pakistan deadlock and links South Asia to South-East Asia. It now has a Charter in force, a Secretariat and sector leaders, with India in charge of security. It also supports India's Neighbourhood First and Act East policies.
- Not a simple replacement. BIMSTEC does not include Pakistan, Afghanistan or the Maldives, so it cannot fully replace SAARC. It is better seen as a parallel track that lets cooperation continue where it is possible. A balanced answer keeps the door open for SAARC.
- India's responsibility. As the largest economy, India must offer benefits such as connectivity, skilling and disaster help to win trust. Programmes like BODHI and centres of excellence are steps in that direction. The test is delivery on the ground, not announcements.
Mains practice: five questions, five angles
These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam are in the PYQ panel of this module.
| Angle | Question | Key points to cover |
|---|---|---|
| Failure | Why has SAARC failed to fulfil its promise? Suggest a way forward. | Below 6% trade, 2014 last summit, terrorism, consensus rule. |
| Alternative | "BIMSTEC is a natural platform for regional cooperation in South Asia and South-East Asia." Discuss. | Members, 22% of world population, Charter 2024, sectors. |
| Policy fit | How does BIMSTEC support India's Neighbourhood First and Act East policies? | Bay of Bengal link, Myanmar and Thailand, connectivity, maritime agreement. |
| Security | Examine India's role as the lead country for security in BIMSTEC. | Counter-terrorism, disaster management, energy security, trust. |
| Regionalism | "Bilateral disputes are the biggest barrier to regionalism in South Asia." Critically examine. | India-Pakistan, fear of dominance, low trade, success of sub-regional groups. |
How to use this table: each answer should give one dated fact for each grouping, explain the cause, weigh one counter-point and end with a practical step India can take.
Quick revision
- SAARC: Charter adopted in Dhaka on 8 December 1985; Secretariat in Kathmandu; eight members.
- SAARC aims at the welfare of South Asian peoples; intra-regional trade remains below 6%.
- Last SAARC summit: 18th, Kathmandu, 26-27 November 2014; the 19th, to be hosted by Pakistan, has not been held.
- SAARC Development Fund in Thimphu; South Asian University in New Delhi, India pays full capital cost and 59% of running costs.
- BIMSTEC: Bangkok Declaration, 6 June 1997, as BIST-EC; Myanmar in 1997; Nepal and Bhutan in 2004; seven members; Secretariat Dhaka 2014.
- BIMSTEC Charter adopted Colombo 30 March 2022, in force 20 May 2024; seven sectors, India leads security.
- BIMSTEC region: 1.7 billion people, 22% of world population, about US$5 trillion GDP.
- 6th summit, Bangkok, 4 April 2025: Bangkok Vision 2030, Maritime Transport Agreement, India's 21-point plan and BODHI.