TNPSC Group 1 · Module 34 · Mains depth · 12 min
The Election Commission: guardian of free and fair elections
What TNPSC Group 1 asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Part A: General Studies · Indian polity: Constitution, Union and state governments, local bodies, judiciary, rights and duties.
TNPSC Group 1 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: who referees the biggest election on earth?
In a cricket match, nobody would accept a captain acting as umpire. Elections are the same. The party in power is also a player, so someone outside the government must set the rules, count the votes and declare the result.
Democracy rests on periodic, free and fair elections. If voters doubt the count, the whole system loses legitimacy. So the framers did not leave elections to the government of the day.
Article 324 provides for an independent Election Commission. It has the power of superintendence, direction and control of elections. This chapter looks at how the Commission is built, what it does, how it has reformed elections, and where its independence is still questioned.
Composition and protection of the Commissioners
Who sits on it. The Commission is headed by the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC), with other Election Commissioners. Its secretariat in New Delhi includes Deputy Election Commissioners and other officers.
Protecting the CEC. The CEC can be removed only in the same manner as a Supreme Court judge. This needs a resolution passed by a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament, on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity. So no government can remove a CEC simply for an inconvenient decision.
The other Commissioners. The Election Commissioners can be removed by the President on the recommendation of the CEC. This gives them less protection than the CEC, which critics point out.
Pay and status. Under the 1992 service rules, the CEC draws salary and allowances at par with a Supreme Court judge. Equal status signals that the CEC answers to the Constitution, not to the government.
What the Commission does
Elections it conducts. The Commission conducts elections to:
- The Lok Sabha and the State Legislative Assemblies, whenever due.
- The Rajya Sabha, where one-third of members retire every two years, and the Legislative Councils in the same way.
- The offices of President and Vice-President, including working out the value of each elector's vote.
- By-elections to fill vacancies.
Elections to Panchayats and municipalities are not its job. They are run by State Election Commissions, created by the 73rd and 74th Amendments.
Electoral rolls. The Commission prepares the voters' list for every Lok Sabha and Assembly constituency. Rolls are revised after every Census and before every election. A clean roll is the first defence against fake voting.
Borrowed staff. The Commission has a small permanent staff, yet it runs elections for crores of voters. It does this by requisitioning staff from Central and State governments, who must send them. During elections these officials work as returning and presiding officers under the Commission's control.
Parties and symbols. Since 1989, political parties must register with the Commission. After each general election it recognises parties as national or State parties on the basis of their performance. It also allots symbols, and no two parties may use the same one.
The Model Code and the fight against money power
Why a Model Code? Complaints kept coming that ruling parties misused official machinery, such as vehicles, staff and announcements, during campaigns. From the 1971 Lok Sabha election, the Commission began issuing a Model Code of Conduct for every election. It guides parties and candidates on speeches, meetings, processions and the conduct of the party in power.
Its legal status. The Model Code has no statutory basis. It is a set of rules of electoral morality that works by persuasion, backed by the Commission's moral authority and its control over the election process. Yet in practice parties take it seriously because the Commission can act against violations during polls.
Checking money power. Money can distort the level playing field, so the Commission:
- Fixes legal limits on how much a candidate may spend, revised over time.
- Appoints Income Tax officers as expenditure observers to watch candidates' accounts.
- Requires candidates to declare assets on affidavit with their nomination, and to file expenditure accounts within 30 days of results.
- Cut the campaign period from 21 to 14 days for Lok Sabha and Assembly elections, to reduce costs.
Other powers. The Commission can stop the publication of opinion and exit poll trends that may sway voters. To clean politics, it has asked the Supreme Court for a lifetime ban on convicted politicians contesting elections.
Technology and voter reforms: EVM to NOTA
EVMs. Electronic Voting Machines were first tried experimentally in Kerala's 1982 Assembly election. After testing and legal scrutiny, the Commission adopted them widely. They were brought in to reduce malpractices and give parties confidence in the authenticity of votes.
Voter identity. Electors' Photo Identity Cards (EPIC) were issued from 1993 and became mandatory by the 2004 elections, though other documents are allowed in some situations. In 1998 the Commission began computerising electoral rolls and launched its website. All of these aim to prevent impersonation and fraud.
VVPAT. A Voter-Verified Paper Audit Trail prints a slip so the voter can see that the vote went to the intended candidate. It was first used with EVMs in the Noksen Assembly by-poll in Nagaland in September 2013, and in eight Lok Sabha constituencies in 2014. If EVM and VVPAT counts do not match, the slips are counted manually and the slip count prevails.
NOTA. In 2014, "None of the Above" (NOTA) was added as an option on voting machines. Its symbol, a ballot paper with a black cross, came on 18 September 2015. It lets voters record that they reject all candidates.
SVEEP. Since 2009, the Systematic Voters' Education and Electoral Participation programme has been the Commission's flagship effort to raise turnout and informed voting. It designs campaigns to fit each State's social profile and past turnout.
How independent is the Commission?
Silent Constitution. The Constitution does not lay down the qualifications or tenure of the CEC. These were left to the President, guided by laws made by Parliament. Critics argued that this let the government of the day choose a person on political considerations.
The reform debate. The Goswami Committee on Electoral Reforms (1990) suggested a more consultative method, so that the government alone would not choose the CEC. The aim was a selection that both ruling and opposition sides could trust.
Weaker protection for other Commissioners. As seen earlier, Election Commissioners can be removed on the CEC's recommendation. This protects them from the government, but it can make them dependent on the CEC.
No control over its own staff. Unlike the Supreme Court or the UPSC, the Commission has no right to recruit or regulate the service conditions of its staff. During elections it depends on officers borrowed from governments whose parties are contesting.
Why the Commission still enjoys trust. Despite these gaps, the Commission has used its broad Article 324 powers firmly. Its reforms, such as the Model Code, photo identity cards, EVMs, VVPAT and expenditure observers, have made Indian elections widely respected.
Mains lens: strengthening the guardian of elections
A common question: "Discuss the role of the Election Commission in ensuring free and fair elections. What reforms are needed to strengthen its independence?"
Role:
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections.
- Rolls, borrowed staff under its control, party registration, recognition and symbols.
- Model Code since 1971; expenditure limits and observers; asset affidavits.
- Technology: EVM, EPIC, VVPAT, NOTA; voter education through SVEEP.
Challenges:
- Constitution silent on CEC qualifications and tenure; weaker protection for other Commissioners.
- No control over its own staff; dependence on governments during polls.
- Money and muscle power; the Model Code has no statutory backing.
Reforms suggested:
- A transparent, consultative appointment process, as the Goswami Committee proposed.
- Equal removal protection for all Commissioners.
- An independent secretariat and staff.
- Firmer powers against criminalisation and money power.
Conclusion. The Commission's credibility comes as much from its conduct as from the Constitution. Institutional safeguards would make that credibility less dependent on individuals.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Debate: Should the Model Code of Conduct be given statutory backing?
- Origin in 1971; rules of electoral morality; persuasion only.
- For: certainty, enforceability.
- Against: courts and delays during short campaigns; flexibility lost.
2. Technology: How have EVMs and VVPAT changed the conduct of elections in India?
- EVM trial 1982; fewer malpractices, more confidence in the authenticity of votes.
- VVPAT 2013–14: voter verification and audit.
- Trust-building through stakeholder involvement.
3. Money power: Examine the steps taken by the Election Commission to check money power in elections.
- Spending limits, IRS expenditure observers, affidavits, accounts within 30 days.
- Shorter campaign period.
- Limits of these measures.
Quick revision
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections.
- CEC removed only like a Supreme Court judge; other ECs by the President on the CEC's recommendation; CEC pay at par with an SC judge.
- Conducts: Lok Sabha, Assemblies, Rajya Sabha, Councils, President, Vice-President, by-elections; not Panchayats or municipalities.
- Party registration since 1989; recognition as national or State party; symbols.
- Model Code since 1971; no statutory basis.
- Money power: limits, IRS observers, affidavits, accounts within 30 days, campaign 21 → 14 days.
- EVM: Kerala 1982. EPIC: 1993, mandatory by 2004. Rolls computerised and website 1998. SVEEP: 2009.
- VVPAT: Noksen, Nagaland, September 2013; eight Lok Sabha seats 2014. NOTA: 2014; symbol 18 September 2015.
- Goswami Committee (1990): consultative CEC selection.