TNPSC Group 4 course‹› 0:00 studied

TNPSC Group 4 · Module 5 · basic depth · 23 min

The Bhakti and Sufi movements

What TNPSC Group 4 asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Part B: General Studies · History and culture of India.

TNPSC Group 4 questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to basic depth for TNPSC Group 4. 9 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: two paths of love and devotion

In the chapter on Sultanate society we saw towns grow, new crafts arrive and a new ruling class settle in India. In the same centuries, two great religious movements spread among ordinary people: bhakti among Hindus and others, and Sufism within Islam.

Both said that a person could reach God directly through love and devotion, without depending on priests, rituals or legal scholars. Both used the languages of the people, music and poetry. And both, at their best, cut across caste and creed.

The bhakti saints ranged from Kabir and Nanak, who rejected idols and caste, to Chaitanya and Ramananda, who worshipped Krishna or Rama. The Sufis ranged from the Chishtis, who kept away from kings, to the Suhrawardis, who accepted royal gifts.

Why study this? Exams ask about saints, their regions, orders, texts and teachings, and about the difference between nirguna and saguna bhakti. Mains asks what caused these movements, how far they challenged caste and orthodoxy, and how they shaped a composite culture.

Saints and orders at a glance

Name Region Key point
Kabir Banaras Nirguna; weaver; ridiculed orthodoxy of both religions
Guru Nanak Punjab Nirguna; Khatri; hymns in Adi Granth (1604)
Ramananda Banaras Rama bhakti; common language; relaxed caste
Chaitanya Bengal, Puri Krishna bhakti; sankirtan
Jnaneswar, Namdev Maharashtra Jnanesvari; Namdev carried bhakti to Punjab
Sankaradeva Assam Eka-sarana-dharma; satras
Bahauddin Zakariya Multan Suhrawardi; accepted state patronage
Muinuddin Chishti Ajmer Founder of the Chishti order in India
Nizamuddin Auliya Delhi Greatest Chishti; never visited the court
Nuruddin Wali Kashmir Rishi order, influenced by Lal Ded

The key idea. Bhakti and Sufism grew side by side and influenced each other, but they were separate movements with their own roots.

The roots of bhakti in the south

What bhakti means. Bhakti is devotional surrender to a personally conceived Supreme God in order to attain salvation. The idea is old: it appears in Brahmanical and Buddhist traditions and in scriptures such as the Gita. What was new in the south was that bhakti became a popular movement.

Bhakti in the south: from songs to philosophy

Nayanars and Alvars. Between the seventh and tenth centuries, the Shaiva Nayanar and Vaishnava Alvar saints of South India spread bhakti among people of every caste and both sexes. Some saints came from the 'lower' castes, and some were women. They sang and danced their devotion, and composed their songs in Tamil, not Sanskrit.

Who they opposed. These saints were critical of Buddhists and Jains, who then enjoyed privileged status at southern courts. They won many followers away from those faiths. At the same time, by opening bhakti to all, they quietly resisted the authority of orthodox Brahmans.

The limits. The southern movement never consciously opposed caste or Brahmanism. Idol worship, Vedic mantras and pilgrimages continued, and Brahman-run temples helped the movement grow. In the long run it strengthened rather than weakened caste, and after the tenth century it was absorbed into Brahmanical religion.

The acharyas. As the popular movement faded, scholar-saints called acharyas defended bhakti through philosophy. Ramanuja (eleventh century) balanced orthodoxy with bhakti: he did not give Shudras access to the Vedas, but he opened bhakti to all, including Shudras and outcastes, and tried to remove untouchability.

Nimbarka and Madhava. Nimbarka, a Telugu Brahman and a younger contemporary of Ramanuja, spent most of his life at Vrindavan and preached devotion to Krishna and Radha. Madhava (thirteenth century) based his system on the Bhagavata Purana and saw bhakti as an alternative path for Shudras. The Bhagavata, a Vaishnava text of about the ninth century, links most later Vaishnava movements.

Bhakti in the north: why it rose and the monotheists

Many movements, not one. In the Sultanate period, bhakti movements arose in North and East India and Maharashtra. They shared an emphasis on bhakti and religious equality, but each had its own region and context. They should be studied separately, especially the monotheistic movement of Kabir and Nanak, which was fundamentally different from the rest.

Two streams of bhakti

Political causes. Before the Turks, the religious life of the north was dominated by a Rajput-Brahman alliance hostile to heterodox movements. The Turkish conquest ended this alliance and took away the Brahmans' temple wealth and state patronage. This weakened them materially and ideologically, and made room first for the Nathpanthis and then for anti-caste movements.

Social and economic causes. The Turkish ruling class lived in towns and spent its large revenue on goods and luxuries. This expanded the class of urban artisans, who were unhappy with their low place in the caste order and were drawn to the egalitarian message. Traders such as the Khatris of Punjab joined too, and in Punjab Jat peasants later gave Nanak's movement a mass base.

What bhakti was not. Some scholars call bhakti an Indian Protestant Reformation or a revolt against feudal oppression. But the saints did not speak for the peasants against the state or call for the overthrow of the ruling class. The Protestant Reformation was a far greater upheaval linked to the rise of capitalism, so the comparison does not hold.

Kabir. Kabir (c. 1440-1518) was the earliest and most powerful monotheist.

Why bhakti rose in the north

He came from a family of Julaha weavers who had converted to Islam and lived mostly in Banaras. More of his verses entered the Adi Granth than those of any other monotheist, and later saints called themselves his followers.

Other monotheists. Raidas (Ravidas), a tanner of Banaras, belonged to the next generation; Kabir called him a 'saint among saints'. Dhanna was a Jat peasant from Rajasthan, Sen was a barber, and Pipa another saint of the time. They mention one another with respect, showing a shared outlook.

Guru Nanak. Guru Nanak (1469-1539) was a Khatri (trader caste) born in the Punjab village now called Nankana Sahib. He travelled widely and settled at Dera Baba Nanak. His hymns, with those of Kabir, Raidas, Namdev and others, were compiled in the Adi Granth by the fifth Guru, Arjan, in 1604, and his followers grew into Sikhism.

One formless God. The monotheists believed in one God, who was formless (nirankar), eternal (akal) and beyond words (alakh). Their bhakti was therefore nirguna (without attributes), unlike the saguna bhakti of the Vaishnavas, who worshipped incarnations. Kabir often called God Ram, but made clear that his Ram was not the king born at Ayodhya.

A manuscript of the Adi Granth
A manuscript of the Adi GranthPhoto: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Against orthodoxy of both faiths. The monotheists followed a path independent of both Hinduism and Islam. They attacked caste and idolatry, rejected the authority of Brahmans and scriptures, and criticised the superstitions of both religions. Kabir used ridicule and a harsh style, and his 'upside-down' sayings (ulatbasi) were full of paradoxes.

Life among the people. Most monotheists were not ascetics; they married, worked at their family trades and preached among ordinary people. They wrote in a mixed common language understood across the north, in short, easy verses. They stressed the divine name, the guru, group singing (kirtan) and the company of saints (satsang).

Panths. Over time, the followers of each saint formed panths, such as the Kabir panth and the Raidasi panth. Of these, only the Nanak panth grew into a mass religion. The others survive with smaller followings.

Vaishnava bhakti and regional movements

Ramananda. Ramananda (late fourteenth and early fifteenth century) lived in the south early in life and later settled in Banaras. He is seen as the link between southern and northern Vaishnava bhakti. He made Rama, with Sita, the object of devotion, preached in the language of the people and relaxed caste rules, even eating with his 'low-caste' followers.

Bhakti across the regions

Ramananda and the monotheists. Because of his openness, later traditions call Kabir, Raidas, Dhanna, Pipa and Sen his disciples. But none of them mentions him, and they went much further, rejecting Brahmanical religion entirely. His followers are called Ramanandis, and a hymn attributed to him is in the Adi Granth.

Vallabhacharya. Vallabhacharya, a Telugu Brahman of the late fifteenth and early sixteenth century, founded the Pushtimarga ('way of grace') of Krishna bhakti. The poet Surdas and the other ashtachhap poets are believed to have been his disciples. His sect later became popular among merchants and landowners in Gujarat.

Bengal: the background. Bengali Vaishnavism drew on the Bhagavata Purana and on local Sahajiya Buddhist and Nathpanthi cults. Jayadeva (twelfth century) wrote the Gita Govinda in Sanskrit on the love of Radha and Krishna. Chandidas, the first Bengali bhakti poet, and Vidyapati, who wrote in Maithili, sang of the same theme.

Chaitanya. Chaitanya (1486-1533) turned this tradition into a mass movement. He was seen as an incarnation of Krishna even in his lifetime, disregarded caste, creed and sex in devotion, and popularised sankirtan, group singing with ecstatic dancing. One of his favourite disciples, Haridas, was a Muslim.

A satra in Majuli, Assam
A satra in Majuli, AssamPhoto: Joli Rumi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Chaitanya's limits. Yet Chaitanya did not question the authority of Brahmans or scriptures, and upheld his Brahman disciples' caste prejudices. The six Goswamins he sent to Vrindavan set up an order that kept caste restrictions. Still, his movement promoted a sense of equality in Bengal and remained popular in Bengal and Puri.

Maharashtra. Jnaneswar (1275-1296) pioneered bhakti in Maharashtra with the Jnanesvari, a Marathi commentary on the Gita and one of the earliest works of Marathi literature. Namdev (1270-1350), a tailor of Pandharpur, travelled to Punjab; his songs are in the Adi Granth. In Maharashtra he belongs to the Varkari tradition, while in the north he is remembered as a nirguna saint.

Other regions. In Kashmir, the woman saint Lal Ded led Shaiva bhakti in the fourteenth century. In Karnataka, the Virashaivas of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries preached a radical bhakti with sharp social criticism. In Gujarat, Narsimha Mehta carried bhakti forward.

Assam: Sankaradeva. Sankaradeva (1449-1568), from a family of non-Brahman chiefs, preached devotion to Vishnu or Krishna as eka-sarana-dharma, 'the religion of refuge in One'. Persecuted by orthodox priests of the Ahom kingdom, he moved to Cooch-Behar. He denounced caste, used dance-drama to teach, and founded satras, gatherings that grew into monasteries.

What Sufism is and how it grew

Meaning. Sufism, or tasawwuf, is the name for the mystical movements within Islam. It seeks direct communion with God through personal experience. Sufis accepted the sharia but did not stop at formal observance; they cultivated inner religious experience.

The Sufi path

The path. The Sufi path (tariqa) leads towards divine reality (haqiqat). The disciple (murid) passes through stations (maqamat) and states (hal), under the strict guidance of a master (shaikh, pir or murshid). Practices included zikr (repeating God's name), self-discipline and contemplation.

Sama and khanqah. Many Sufis held sama, musical recitals meant to induce a state of mystical ecstasy, though some orders and the ulema disapproved of it. Sufis were organised into orders (silsilahs), each named after a founder. The khanqah (hospice) was the centre of an order, supported by endowments and charity.

Early Sufis abroad. The earliest centres were Mecca, Medina, Basra and Kufa, where the woman mystic Rabia (d. 801) lived.

Bayazid Bistami of Khurasan introduced ecstasy and the idea of fana (annihilation of the self). Al-Junaid of Baghdad stood for a sober, disciplined Sufism close to orthodoxy.

Hallaj and Ghazzali. Mansur al-Hallaj (d. 922) declared 'I am God'; the ulema called him a blasphemer, and he was imprisoned and hanged. Al-Ghazzali (1058-1111), a theologian who became a Sufi, tried to reconcile Sufis with the ulema by stressing the outward observance of Islamic law.

Orders take shape. In the tenth to twelfth centuries, under the Ghaznavid and Seljuq Turks, the khanqah became a permanent, endowed institution beside the official madrasa. From the late twelfth century, distinct orders formed: the Qadiri (Abdul Qadir Jilani), Suhrawardi (Shahabuddin Suhrawardi), Chishti and later Naqshbandi. Persian Sufi poetry peaked with Attar and Rumi.

Sufi orders in Sultanate India

The first Sufis. Al-Hujwiri (d. c.

Where the Sufi orders took root

1088), author of the Persian treatise Kashf-ul Mahjub, was the earliest eminent Sufi to settle in India; his tomb is at Lahore. Sufi orders came after the Delhi Sultanate was founded, and many Sufis arrived as refugees from the Mongol conquests. By the fourteenth century there were said to be two thousand hospices in and around Delhi.

The Suhrawardis. The Suhrawardi order was founded in India by Shaikh Bahauddin Zakariya (1182-1262) at Multan. He sided with Iltutmish against Qubacha, received the title Shaikh-ul Islam, and accepted state patronage and built up great wealth. Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi took the order to Bengal, where his khanqah ran a free kitchen (langar).

Chishtis and Suhrawardis

Muinuddin Chishti. The Chishti order began at Chisht near Herat and was brought to India by Khwaja Muinuddin Chishti, who settled at Ajmer around 1206. Later legends made him a missionary, but he was not actively involved in conversions and was tolerant towards non-Muslims. His tomb at Ajmer became a great place of pilgrimage.

His successors. Qutbuddin Bakhtiyar Kaki (d. 1235) succeeded him in Delhi.

The great Chishti masters

Hamiduddin Nagauri lived like an ordinary Rajasthani peasant at Nagaur, was a strict vegetarian, and translated Persian Sufi verses into Hindavi. Baba Farid (Ganjshakar) moved to Ajodhan in Punjab, avoided the rich and powerful, and his verses were later included in the Adi Granth.

Nizamuddin Auliya. The greatest Chishti saint was Shaikh Nizamuddin Auliya (1236-1325). He saw seven Sultans but never visited the court. His langar was open to Hindus and Muslims alike, he talked with Nathpanthi yogis, and his conversations were recorded in Fawaid-ul Fuwad by Amir Hasan Sijzi; Amir Khusrau was his devoted disciple.

The dargah of Muinuddin Chishti, Ajmer
The dargah of Muinuddin Chishti, AjmerPhoto: Pinakpani, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Chiragh-i Delhi and the decline. Shaikh Nasiruddin Mahmud, called Chiragh-i Delhi ('lamp of Delhi'), succeeded Nizamuddin and softened practices that offended the ulema. He died in 1356 without naming a successor, and Delhi lost its commanding Chishti figure. Muhammad Tughluq had made some Sufis accept state service and sent others south, but Feroz later gave gifts to the khanqahs.

Spreading to the regions. As the Sultanate weakened, Chishtis dispersed to regional kingdoms. Burhanuddin Gharib took the order to Daulatabad, and Gesu Daraz, who left Delhi around Timur's invasion, settled at Gulbarga, received villages from Feroz Shah Bahmani, and gave the order an orthodox turn. Later Chishti centres grew at Jaunpur, Rudauli, Gangoh (Abdul Quddus Gangohi) and the Shahpur Hillock near Bijapur, and unlike the early masters, most accepted state patronage.

The dargah of Nizamuddin Auliya, Delhi
The dargah of Nizamuddin Auliya, DelhiPhoto: Nehasinha18, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Other orders. The Firdausi order, a branch of the Suhrawardi, settled at Rajgir in Bihar; its leading Sufi was Shaikh Sharfuddin Yahya Maneri (d. 1380).

The Qadiri (late fourteenth century) and Shattari (fifteenth century) were orthodox and close to courts. The Qalandars were wandering dervishes who broke social norms.

The Rishis of Kashmir. In Kashmir, the missionary Mir Saiyyid Ali Hamadani made little impact. The Rishi order founded by Shaikh Nuruddin Wali (d.

  1. was indigenous, rooted in rural Kashmir and inspired by the Shaiva bhakti of Lal Ded. It shaped the religious life of the valley in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries.

Why the Chishtis spread, and Sufi-bhakti meeting points

Why the Chishtis were popular. Many early Chishti practices, such as bowing before the master, shaving a new entrant's head and spiritual music, resembled existing Indian non-conformist traditions. The Chishtis were tolerant, used popular images and Hindavi, and adapted to a mostly non-Muslim environment. So they came to be seen as part of an Indian tradition.

Where bhakti and Sufism met

Equality in the khanqah. Chishti khanqahs had no caste distinctions and rejected the Turkish nobles' division of people into 'high-born' and 'low-born'. Merchants, artisans, peasants and even sweepers became followers. Life in the khanqah was based on unsolicited charity (futuh), and the langar fed all.

Aloof from power. Early Chishti masters kept away from the court, refused state patronage and rejected the externalism of the ulema. Their combination of simple Islamic precepts with Sufi teaching won wide respect. The ulema in turn disliked sama and the Chishti search for common ground.

Sufis and the state. Except for the early Chishtis and the Shahpur Hillock Chishtis, most Sufis accepted state endowments. Even the great Chishtis never questioned the political system or class structure; at most they urged officials to be lenient with peasants. This made the later Chishti shift towards court patronage easy.

Sufis and conversion. Later legends portrayed Sufis as active missionaries, and some Suhrawardis and Hamadani's followers were evangelists. But conversion was not part of all Sufis' work: Nizamuddin Auliya said every community had its own path and way of worship. Many low-caste people were drawn to dargahs, and over generations some groups came under Islamic influence.

Qawwali singers at a dargah
Qawwali singers at a dargahPhoto: Joshua Singh, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Khanqahs and the economy. Some khanqahs cultivated waste land, built public buildings and planted gardens. The yearly urs at a saint's tomb boosted trade and local crafts. Khanqahs also played a part in the growth of towns.

Where bhakti and Sufism met. The two movements shared monotheism, the central role of the guru or pir, the idea of mystical union with God, and criticism of orthodoxy in their own religions. Kabir's links with Sufis lack firm evidence, but Nanak's meetings with Sufis appear in the janam-sakhis.

Nathpanthis as a bridge. Nathpanthi yogis visited Chishti khanqahs and discussed mysticism, and a yoga text, Amrit-kund, was translated into Persian. Kabir took the Nathpanthis' heterodox attitude and paradoxical style, but rejected their asceticism and breath-control practices. The Rishi order shows influence flowing the other way, from Lal Ded to Sufism.

A shared culture. Chishtis spoke and wrote in Hindavi, and khanqahs inspired mystical poetry in regional languages; Mulla Daud's Chandayan combined mysticism with Indian themes. Chishti sama gave rise to qawwali, said to begin with Amir Khusrau. Both movements also helped the growth of vernacular languages.

Quick revision

  • Nayanars (Shaiva), Alvars (Vaishnava), 7th-10th c., Tamil; against Buddhists and Jains; did not attack caste.
  • Acharyas: Ramanuja (bhakti for all, not Vedas), Nimbarka (Vrindavan, Krishna-Radha), Madhava (Bhagavata Purana).
  • Causes in north: end of Rajput-Brahman alliance; Brahmans lose temple wealth; urban artisans, Khatris, Jats; not a Protestant Reformation; not a Hindu defence against Islam.
  • Nirguna: Kabir (Julaha, Banaras), Raidas (tanner), Dhanna (Jat), Sen (barber), Pipa, Nanak (Khatri; Nankana Sahib; Dera Baba Nanak); Adi Granth 1604 (Guru Arjan); panths.
  • Saguna: Ramananda (Rama, Banaras), Vallabha (Pushtimarga; Surdas, ashtachhap), Chaitanya (sankirtan; Haridas; Goswamins at Vrindavan).
  • Bengal background: Jayadeva (Gita Govinda), Chandidas, Vidyapati (Maithili). Maharashtra: Jnaneswar (Jnanesvari), Namdev (tailor, Varkari). Lal Ded (Kashmir), Virashaivas (Karnataka), Sankaradeva (Assam, eka-sarana-dharma, satras).
  • Sufi terms: tasawwuf, tariqa, pir/murid, maqamat, hal, zikr, sama, silsilah, khanqah, futuh; abroad: Rabia, Bistami (fana), Junaid, Hallaj ('I am God'), Ghazzali.
  • Hujwiri (Kashf-ul Mahjub, Lahore); Suhrawardi: Bahauddin Zakariya (Multan, Shaikh-ul Islam), Jalaluddin Tabrizi (Bengal).
  • Chishti: Muinuddin (Ajmer), Bakhtiyar Kaki (Delhi), Hamiduddin Nagauri (Nagaur, Hindavi), Baba Farid (Ajodhan, Adi Granth), Nizamuddin Auliya (7 Sultans, never at court, Fawaid-ul Fuwad, Amir Khusrau), Chiragh-i Delhi (d. 1356).
  • Spread: Burhanuddin Gharib (Daulatabad), Gesu Daraz (Gulbarga), Gangoh, Jaunpur; Firdausi (Maneri, Bihar), Qadiri, Shattari, Qalandari; Rishi (Nuruddin Wali, Kashmir).
  • Chishti popularity: Indian-like practices, tolerance, Hindavi, equality, futuh, aloof from court; meeting with Nathpanthis; qawwali from sama (Amir Khusrau); Chandayan.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 11 answered

  1. The Alvars of South India were devotees of:

  2. Consider the following statements about the Nayanar and Alvar saints: 1. They composed their songs in Tamil. 2. They opposed Buddhists and Jains. 3. They consciously attacked the caste system. Which of the statements given above are correct?

  3. Match the acharyas with their teaching: A. Ramanuja B. Nimbarka C. Madhava D. Vallabhacharya 1. Pushtimarga of Krishna bhakti 2. Bhakti for all including Shudras, without the Vedas 3. Devotion to Krishna and Radha at Vrindavan 4. System based on the Bhagavata Purana

  4. Which one of the following saints belonged to the nirguna (monotheistic) stream of bhakti?

  5. The Adi Granth, containing hymns of Guru Nanak, Kabir and others, was compiled in 1604 by:

  6. Assertion (A): Urban artisans were among the main followers of the monotheistic bhakti saints. Reason (R): Town-based Turkish rule expanded urban crafts, and artisans were unhappy with their low place in the caste order.

  7. Eka-sarana-dharma and the satra institution are associated with:

  8. In Sufi terminology, 'sama' refers to:

  9. Consider the following statements about the Suhrawardi order in India: 1. It was founded in India by Shaikh Bahauddin Zakariya at Multan. 2. Its leaders refused all state patronage. 3. Shaikh Jalaluddin Tabrizi took the order to Bengal. Which of the statements given above are correct?

  10. Match the Chishti saints with their centres: A. Muinuddin Chishti B. Baba Farid C. Hamiduddin Nagauri D. Burhanuddin Gharib 1. Ajodhan 2. Daulatabad 3. Ajmer 4. Nagaur

  11. The Rishi order of Sufis, inspired by the woman saint Lal Ded, was founded in Kashmir by:

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. How did the Chishti silsilah and the monotheistic bhakti saints contribute to a composite culture in medieval India? Also note their limits. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Shared ground: one God, guru or pir, mystical union, criticism of orthodoxy
    • Chishti practices resembling Indian traditions; Hindavi; langar open to all; futuh; aloofness from court
    • Nizamuddin's view that every community has its own path; slow conversion via dargahs
    • Nathpanthi contacts; Amrit-kund in Persian; Kabir's ulatbasi; Rishi order and Lal Ded
    • Sama, qawwali and Amir Khusrau; Chandayan; growth of vernaculars; Adi Granth includes Baba Farid
    • Limits: no challenge to state or class order; later Chishtis took patronage; Vaishnava saints kept caste
    • Conclusion: mutual influence, not one-way borrowing

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between saguna and nirguna bhakti?

Saguna bhakti worships God with form, such as Rama or Krishna; nirguna bhakti, as with Kabir and Nanak, worships a formless God.

Who brought the Chishti order to India?

Khwaja Muinuddin Chishti, who settled at Ajmer in the late 12th century. Nizamuddin Auliya of Delhi was a later famous Chishti saint.

Which philosopher taught Vishishtadvaita?

Ramanuja in the 11th-12th century, who gave bhakti a philosophical base against Shankara's Advaita.

Who was Basavanna?

A 12th-century reformer in Karnataka who founded the Lingayat or Virashaiva movement, rejecting caste and ritual.