UKPSC RO / ARO course‹› 0:00 studied

UKPSC RO / ARO · Module 32 · standard depth · 13 min

IMF, World Bank, WTO and India

What UKPSC RO / ARO asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Prelims: General Studies (100) and General Aptitude Test (50) · Indian polity and economy: Constitution, Panchayati raj, community development, broad features of Indian economy and planning
  • Mains Paper 1: General Studies (objective, 200 questions) · Geography and population of India and Uttarakhand, important national and international organisations and agreements
  • Mains Paper 1: General Studies (objective, 200 questions) · Indian polity and economy: Constitution, Panchayati raj, community development, economy and planning

1 UKPSC RO / ARO questions in our bank come from this module (External sector).

Cut to standard depth for UKPSC RO / ARO. 7 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: rules for a world market

Think of a big weekly market in a town. Hundreds of traders sell goods, and they need some common rules. Someone must check weights, settle quarrels, and help a trader who has run out of cash so that the whole market doesn't panic.

The 1944 Bretton Woods meeting

The world economy needs similar rules and helpers. Without them, countries can harm each other with high tariffs and sudden currency moves, and a crisis in one place can spread everywhere.

So in July 1944, as World War II was ending, 44 countries met at Bretton Woods in the USA. The IMF says it was "conceived" there, and the World Bank was born from the same meeting. Much later, in 1995, the World Trade Organization (WTO) was created to set the rules of world trade.

The Mount Washington Hotel at Bretton Woods, USA, where the 1944 conference met
The Mount Washington Hotel at Bretton Woods, USA, where the 1944 conference metPhoto: King of Hearts, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

This chapter explains what each of these bodies does and how India relates to them.

The IMF: guardian of stability

What it does. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) works for global monetary stability. It watches members' economies, gives advice, and lends to countries facing balance of payments problems. It has 191 member countries.

The IMF and its SDR

Quotas. Each member pays a quota. The IMF says quotas are its primary source of funding and reflect a member's size and position in the world economy. Quotas also shape how much a country can borrow and how much say it has.

The SDR. The IMF created the Special Drawing Right (SDR) in 1969 as a supplementary international reserve asset. Its value is based on a basket of five currencies: the US dollar, euro, Chinese renminbi, Japanese yen and British pound. The renminbi joined in October 2016. SDRs are part of India's forex reserves (see Exchange rate, forex reserves and convertibility).

IMF headquarters in Washington, D.C.
IMF headquarters in Washington, D.C.Photo: APK, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

India and the IMF. In August 1994, India accepted Article VIII obligations, making the rupee convertible on the current account.

The World Bank Group: lender for development

While the IMF focuses on short-term stability, the World Bank focuses on long-term development. The World Bank Group says it is five organisations, with 189 member countries.

The five World Bank Group institutions
Institution Role
IBRD: International Bank for Reconstruction and Development Loans and policy advice
IDA: International Development Association Grants and low-interest loans to low-income countries
IFC: International Finance Corporation Private sector investment
MIGA: Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency Political risk insurance for investors
ICSID: International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes Settlement of investment disputes

Two kinds of work. IBRD and IDA deal mainly with loans and grants, while IFC, MIGA and ICSID deal with private investment, investor risk and disputes.

Why this matters: the IMF steadies, while the World Bank Group builds; both are sources of finance and advice for developing countries.

The WTO: rules for world trade

Origins. After 1948, world trade was governed by the GATT (General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade). The WTO says it was created by the Uruguay Round negotiations (1986-94) and was established on 1 January 1995. It is located in Geneva and has 166 members, representing 98% of world trade.

The WTO farm-support boxes

India's membership. India has been a member of GATT since 8 July 1948 and of the WTO since 1 January 1995, so it is a founding member of both.

The farm "boxes". The WTO's Agreement on Agriculture sorts government support to farmers into boxes:

  • Amber box: all domestic support except blue and green box measures. It must be limited, with a de minimis level generally of 5% of the value of production for developed countries and 10% for most developing countries.
  • Blue box: the "amber box with conditions", designed to reduce distortion.
  • Green box: support allowed without limits, if it meets the criteria in Annex 2.

The WTO notes that the Agreement has no red box.

Why this matters for India: government support to farmers, such as price support, is judged against these box rules. We look at this closely in Module 8.

Who has a say at the IMF?

Start with a housing society. Imagine a society where each family's vote depends on how much it paid into the common fund. The richest families pay the most, so they get the most votes and can block big decisions. New families who have grown richer must wait for the rules to be changed before their voice grows.

How IMF votes are counted

Quotas decide money and votes. At the IMF, each member has a quota, which reflects its size in the world economy. Quotas decide a member's voting power and how much it can borrow from the IMF. A member's votes are its basic votes, which are the same for every member, plus votes based on its quota.

Why reform is slow. Any change in quotas needs 85% of total voting power. So any member or group that holds more than 15% of the votes can block a change, which gives the largest shareholders a strong hand. The formula used to calculate quotas was agreed in 2008.

The reviews. The 14th General Review was completed in 2010 but came into effect only in 2016, because members took years to approve it. It doubled quotas and aimed to give more weight to fast-growing emerging and developing countries such as India. In December 2023, the IMF's Board of Governors approved a 50% increase in quotas under the 16th Review, but members still had to consent before it could take effect.

Why it matters. Emerging economies now produce a much larger share of world output than in 1944, but their voting share has risen slowly. India has long argued that quotas should reflect today's economy, so that the IMF stays legitimate and fair. A good Mains answer explains why slow reform pushes countries to build alternatives and regional safety nets.

Food security at the WTO

Start with a ration shop. The government buys wheat and rice from farmers at a fixed price and stores it to give cheap grain to poor families. This keeps farmers' incomes steady and protects the poor from hunger. But under WTO rules, buying grain at a price above the market can count as trade-distorting support, which is limited.

Why an old price makes support look big

The problem of an old price. The WTO measures this support by comparing the government's buying price with a fixed reference price from 1986-88. Prices have risen a lot since then, so even a modest buying price today looks like a large subsidy on paper. Developing countries said this made their food security programmes look illegal when they were not distorting trade much.

The peace clause. At the Bali Ministerial Conference on 7 December 2013, members agreed an interim solution. Developing countries' public stockholding programmes for food security would not be challenged legally, even if their limits on trade-distorting support were breached. In November 2014, members clarified that this peace clause would stay in force until a permanent solution is agreed.

Still no permanent solution. India, a member of the G-33 group of developing countries, has pushed hard for a permanent solution. Members aimed for one by the end of 2015 and later set further deadlines, but no final agreement has been reached. So the peace clause remains India's legal shield for its procurement and stock-holding.

Why it matters. For India, this is about the food security of hundreds of millions of people and the incomes of farmers. Rich countries worry that stocks bought with support could be dumped on world markets and hurt other exporters. A good Mains answer explains both sides and argues for updating the reference price or a permanent solution.

Why these global bodies were created: when, where and why

The memory of the 1930s. In the 1930s, countries cut the value of their currencies to grab trade from each other. These competitive devaluations contributed to the Great Depression, and everyone lost. In July 1944, at Bretton Woods, 44 countries planned institutions so this would not happen again.

Global economic bodies: a timeline

Why the IMF. The IMF was created to avoid repeating the competitive currency devaluations of the 1930s. Its missions include international monetary cooperation and the expansion of trade and growth. It gives loans and other financial aid to members to restore stability and growth.

Why the World Bank. Developing poorer countries needs long-term, low-cost finance and advice. Today its five organisations lend, give grants, invest in private firms, insure investors and settle investment disputes.

Why the WTO (1995). Rules for trade in goods began under GATT, which India joined in 1948, and the Uruguay Round (1986-94) created the WTO in 1995. Its stated goal is to use trade as a means to improve people's living standards.

Implications. These bodies give smaller countries rules and a forum, but voting power in the IMF follows quotas, which reflect economic size. That is why quota reform, and fair farm rules at the WTO, are recurring debates for India.

Quick revision

  • The IMF was conceived in July 1944 at Bretton Woods by 44 countries, and it now has 191 members.
  • Its main funding comes from member quotas, which reflect each country's size and position in the world economy.
  • The SDR was created in 1969, and its value rests on a basket of five currencies: the dollar, euro, renminbi (added in October 2016), yen and pound.
  • The World Bank Group has five bodies, namely IBRD, IDA, IFC, MIGA and ICSID, and 189 member countries.
  • The WTO came into being on 1 January 1995 after the Uruguay Round (1986-94), is based in Geneva, and has 166 members.
  • India has been in GATT since 8 July 1948 and in the WTO since 1 January 1995, and it accepted IMF Article VIII in August 1994.
  • WTO farm-support rules sort subsidies into boxes: the amber box has a de minimis limit of 5% for developed and 10% for developing countries, the blue box holds amber support with production limits, and the green box has no limits (Annex 2).
  • There is no red box in agriculture, which is a common exam trap.
  • IMF quotas decide voting power and access to funds; votes = basic votes + quota votes; quota changes need 85%; the 14th Review (2010, effective 2016) doubled quotas and the 16th Review approved a 50% rise in December 2023, pending members' consent.
  • The WTO peace clause (Bali, December 2013) protects developing countries' public stockholding for food security from legal challenge until a permanent solution; support is measured against a fixed 1986-88 reference price.

Common confusions and exam traps:

IMF, World Bank and WTO compared
  • IDA, not IBRD, gives grants and low-interest loans to low-income countries.
  • MIGA gives political risk insurance; ICSID settles investment disputes.
  • The WTO replaced GATT as an organisation in 1995, not in 1948.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. According to the IMF, the primary source of IMF funding is:

  2. Consider the following statements about the SDR: 1. It was created by the IMF in 1969. 2. Its basket includes the Chinese renminbi. 3. Its basket includes the Indian rupee. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. Which World Bank Group institution provides political risk insurance for investors?

  4. Grants and low-interest loans to low-income countries are provided by:

  5. India has been a member of GATT since:

  6. Under the WTO Agreement on Agriculture, the de minimis limit for amber box support for most developing countries is generally:

  7. Which WTO 'box' covers domestic farm support that is allowed without limits if it meets Annex 2 criteria?

  8. The IMF was conceived at Bretton Woods in 1944 mainly to:

  9. Consider the following statements about IMF quotas: 1. Quotas determine a member's voting power and its access to IMF resources. 2. Any change in quotas can be approved by a simple majority of votes cast. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  10. The WTO 'peace clause' on public stockholding for food security purposes was first agreed at which Ministerial Conference?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. Are the IMF, World Bank and WTO fair to developing countries? Discuss with reference to India. (250 words)

    Show answer points
    • Bretton Woods 1944 (44 countries); WTO 1995 (Uruguay Round)
    • IMF: 191 members, quotas = funding + voice; SDR 1969; India Article VIII 1994
    • WBG: five bodies, 189 members
    • WTO: 166 members; boxes, de minimis 10%
    • Criticisms: voting by size, loan conditions, farm rules
    • India's stance: reform, food security; conclusion
  2. Why does India seek a permanent solution on public stockholding for food security at the WTO? Discuss the concerns on both sides. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Explain how procurement at administered prices is counted as trade-distorting support against a fixed 1986-88 reference price.
    • Explain the Bali 2013 peace clause and the 2014 clarification that it lasts until a permanent solution.
    • Present India's case (food security, farmers' incomes) and others' concerns (stocks spilling into world markets).
    • Suggest ways forward: updating the reference price, transparency safeguards, a permanent solution.

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

When and where was the IMF conceived?

The IMF was conceived in July 1944 at the United Nations Bretton Woods Conference, attended by 44 countries. It now has 191 member countries.

What is a Special Drawing Right (SDR)?

The SDR is a supplementary reserve asset created by the IMF in 1969. Its value is based on five currencies: the US dollar, euro, Chinese renminbi, Japanese yen and British pound.

What are the five World Bank Group organisations?

IBRD (loans and advice), IDA (grants and cheap loans to poorer countries), IFC (private sector investment), MIGA (political risk insurance) and ICSID (investment dispute settlement).

What is the amber box in the WTO?

Under the Agreement on Agriculture, the amber box covers trade-distorting domestic farm support, other than blue and green box measures, and is capped by a de minimis limit, generally 5% of production value for developed countries and 10% for developing ones.