UKPSC RO / ARO course‹› 0:00 studied

UKPSC RO / ARO · Module 21 · standard depth · 11 min

What the Supreme Court can hear: its jurisdiction and writs

What UKPSC RO / ARO asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Prelims: General Studies (100) and General Aptitude Test (50) · Indian polity and economy: Constitution, Panchayati raj, community development, broad features of Indian economy and planning
  • Mains Paper 1: General Studies (objective, 200 questions) · Indian polity and economy: Constitution, Panchayati raj, community development, economy and planning

UKPSC RO / ARO questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for UKPSC RO / ARO. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: which cases reach the top court?

Imagine a large hospital. Most patients start at a local clinic, and only serious cases are referred to the top specialist. But a few cases go straight to the specialist, such as an emergency only that doctor can handle. And sometimes the government asks the specialist for advice, not about a patient, but about a health policy.

The Supreme Court works in a similar way. Some cases can start there, many reach it on appeal from lower courts, the President can ask it for advice, and it can review its own decisions. Each of these routes is called a jurisdiction, which simply means the power to hear a certain kind of case.

Whatever route a case takes, the result matters for the whole country. Under Article 141, the law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts in India.

Original jurisdiction: the federal umpire

What "original" means. A case is in the Court's original jurisdiction when it starts in the Supreme Court itself, instead of coming up on appeal.

Four doors into the Supreme Court

Disputes within the federation. In India, both the Union and the States get their powers from the same Constitution. When they disagree about who has which power, someone independent of both must decide. Under Article 131, the Supreme Court has exclusive original jurisdiction in disputes:

  • between the Union and one or more States;
  • between two or more States; or
  • between the Union and some States on one side and other States on the other.

Exclusive means no other court in India can hear such disputes. The parties must be units of the federation, that is, governments, not private persons.

Article 131: governments only

A key difference from other federations. Unlike the Supreme Courts of the USA and Australia, the Indian Supreme Court has no original jurisdiction over disputes between residents of different States, or between a State and a resident of another State. Such cases go to ordinary courts.

Guardian of rights: Article 32 and the writs

A direct door for citizens. The Supreme Court also has original jurisdiction as the protector of Fundamental Rights. Under Article 32, a person whose Fundamental Right is violated can go directly to the Supreme Court. The right to do so is itself a Fundamental Right.

Writs. A writ is a formal written order of a court. To enforce Fundamental Rights, the Court can issue five writs, as well as other directions and orders.

Writ Literal idea What it does
Habeas corpus "Produce the body" Brings a detained person before the court to test whether the detention is legal
Mandamus "We command" Orders a public official to perform a legal duty
Prohibition "To forbid" Stops a lower court or tribunal from exceeding its authority
Certiorari "To be informed" Quashes an order passed without authority
Quo warranto "By what authority?" Asks a person holding a public office to show their right to it

Why writs matter. A right on paper is useless if no one can enforce it quickly. Writs give the courts a fast and powerful tool. For example, habeas corpus can free a person held without legal reason, and mandamus can force an office to act on a pending application.

Appellate jurisdiction: the final court of appeal

The Supreme Court is the highest court of appeal from all courts in India. Appeals reach it through four main routes.

The five writs at a glance
Route Article When an appeal lies
Constitutional cases 132 A substantial question of law on interpreting the Constitution, with a High Court certificate or the Supreme Court's special leave
Civil cases 133 A substantial question of law of general importance that needs the Supreme Court's decision
Criminal cases 134 High Court reverses an acquittal and gives a death sentence; or tries a case itself and gives a death sentence; or certifies the case as fit
Special leave — At the Court's discretion, from any judgment or order of any court or tribunal

Special leave: the widest door. The power to grant special leave to appeal is discretionary and very broad. It covers any court or tribunal in India. This lets the Court step in wherever grave injustice might otherwise go uncorrected.

Four routes of appeal

The cost of a wide door. Because almost any case can be brought by special leave, the Supreme Court receives a huge number of petitions. This is one reason for its heavy workload and long delays.

Advice and second looks: advisory and review jurisdiction

Advisory jurisdiction. The President can refer any question of law or fact of public importance to the Supreme Court for its opinion. This is different from an ordinary case in three ways:

Advisory opinion vs judgment
  1. There is no dispute between two parties.
  2. The opinion is not binding on the government.
  3. It cannot be executed like a judgment.

Why have it. It helps the government take sound decisions on important legal questions before acting. The Third Judges case of 1998, which shaped the collegium, was itself an advisory opinion.

The risk. It can also give the government a soft option on politically difficult issues. When the government referred aspects of the Ayodhya dispute to the Court, critics felt that a political problem was being passed to the judiciary, with the risk of drawing the Court into politics.

Review jurisdiction. The Supreme Court can review any judgment or order it has made. This allows it to correct an error apparent in its own decision. Because the Supreme Court is the last court, review is the only way to take a second look within the same court.

How powerful is our Supreme Court?

Compared with the US Supreme Court. The American Supreme Court mainly hears cases about the federal relationship and the validity of laws and treaties. The Indian Supreme Court does all that and more:

How powerful is our Supreme Court?
  • it is also the general court of appeal in civil and criminal matters;
  • it can hear appeals from any court or tribunal, at its discretion; and
  • it has an advisory jurisdiction, which the US court does not have.

But it has limits. The Supreme Court is a creature of the Constitution. Parliament can change its powers by amending the Constitution, within the limits of the basic structure. Its powers can also be affected during an emergency.

The workload problem. Because its doors are so wide, the Court receives far more cases than a top court can handle carefully. Suggestions to ease this have included:

  • a separate Constitutional Court to deal only with constitutional questions; and
  • Zonal Courts of Appeal in different regions, to hear ordinary appeals closer to people.

Each idea has a trade-off. A separate court could speed up constitutional cases, but might weaken the unity of the system. Regional benches could reduce travel and cost, but might produce conflicting decisions.

Why each jurisdiction exists

Jurisdiction Problem it solves Concern
Original, Article 131 Union and States need a neutral umpire Few cases, but politically sensitive
Original, Article 32 Rights need fast enforcement Adds to the Court's load
Appellate Errors in lower courts need correction; uniform law Long delays in final decisions
Special leave Grave injustice anywhere can be corrected Flood of petitions
Advisory Government gets legal clarity before acting Court drawn into political disputes
Review The last court can still correct its own mistakes Can delay finality

The common thread. Each power makes justice more complete, but each also brings more cases. This is why debates on the Supreme Court keep returning to the same question: how to keep its doors open without letting it drown.

Each door helps, each door adds cases

Quick revision

  • Article 141: law declared by the Supreme Court binds all courts in India.
  • Four jurisdictions: original, appellate, advisory, review.
  • Article 131: exclusive original jurisdiction in disputes between governments (Union and States, or States among themselves).
  • Article 32: direct remedy for Fundamental Rights; five writs: habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, quo warranto.
  • Appeals: 132 constitutional, 133 civil, 134 criminal; special leave from any court or tribunal, at the Court's discretion.
  • Advisory: on the President's reference; no parties; not binding; not executable.
  • Review: the Court can review its own judgments.
  • More powerful than the US Supreme Court, but can be limited by amendment and affected in an emergency.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. Under Article 131, the Supreme Court has exclusive original jurisdiction in a dispute between:

  2. Which Article makes the law declared by the Supreme Court binding on all courts in India?

  3. Which writ is issued to test the legality of a person's detention?

  4. A writ asking a person to show by what authority they hold a public office is:

  5. Consider: 1. Prohibition is issued to stop a lower court from exceeding its authority. 2. Certiorari quashes an order already made without authority. 3. Mandamus orders a public official to perform a legal duty. Which are correct?

  6. Consider the advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court: 1. A reference is made by the President. 2. The opinion is binding on the government. 3. There are no two contesting parties. Which are correct?

  7. The Supreme Court's power to grant special leave to appeal:

  8. Appeals to the Supreme Court in civil cases from High Courts are provided under:

  9. Which power does the Indian Supreme Court have that the US Supreme Court lacks?

  10. Consider the following statements: 1. The Supreme Court of India cannot review a judgment it has already delivered. 2. The opinion given by the Supreme Court on a reference by the President is binding on the government. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The Supreme Court of India has become a court of appeals rather than a constitutional court.' Examine and suggest reforms. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Wide special leave power brings ordinary appeals; constitutional cases wait
    • Why wide role: correct grave injustice, uniform law (Art 141), access for the poor
    • Reforms: Constitutional Court, Zonal Courts of Appeal, stricter special leave, better lower courts
    • Balance constitutional role with access to justice

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

What is the original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court?

Under Article 131 it has exclusive original jurisdiction over disputes between the Union and a State, between States, or between groups of States.

What does habeas corpus mean?

It is a writ that brings a detained person before the court so the court can test whether the detention is legal.

What is special leave to appeal?

A discretionary power under which the Supreme Court may allow an appeal against any judgment or order of any court or tribunal in India.

Is the Supreme Court's law binding on all courts?

Yes. Article 141 makes the law declared by the Supreme Court binding on all courts within India.