UPPSC PCS · Module 29 · Mains depth · 12 min
Tension and cooperation: autonomy demands, Sarkaria and the Inter-State Council
What UPPSC PCS asks from this chapter
Syllabus lines this chapter covers:
- Prelims: General Studies I · Indian polity and governance
UPPSC PCS questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.
Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.
Start from zero: why the Centre and States argue
Every federation has two governments pulling in slightly different directions. A State wants freedom to follow its own priorities, while the Centre wants national policies to work everywhere. Some tension is natural and even healthy.
In India's early years, there was little open conflict. One party ruled at the Centre and in almost all States, so disputes were settled inside the party. The Centre acted like a patriarch, guiding States through Chief Ministers of its own party.
Centralisation was defended for two reasons: national unity after Partition, and planned development of a newly independent country. This chapter traces how that system came under strain, what the States demanded, and what has been done to build cooperation.
1967 and after: the areas of tension
The turning point. In the 1967 elections, the Congress weakened at the Centre and lost its majority in eight States. New non-Congress governments, especially in Kerala, West Bengal and Tamil Nadu, refused to accept the Centre's directions blindly and stressed State autonomy. From then on, Centre–State relations became a real political issue.
Five main areas of tension.
| Area | What States complained about |
|---|---|
| Governor | Appointed as the Centre's agent, often active politicians, without consulting the Chief Minister |
| President's Rule | Used to dismiss opposition governments |
| Reservation of Bills | Governors reserved Bills against the State Ministry's advice |
| Finances | Dependence on the Centre; discretionary grants and planning |
| Electronic media | All India Radio and Doordarshan used against opposition States |
Reservation of Bills. Under Article 200, the Governor may reserve certain State Bills for the President. Even if the State legislature passes a returned Bill again, the President is not bound to assent. Opposition-ruled States said this was used to create difficulties for them, and West Bengal asked that Articles 200 and 201 be deleted, or that the Governor act only on the Ministry's advice.
The media. Broadcasting is a Union subject. In the 1980s, opposition parties accused All India Radio and Doordarshan of being the Centre's mouthpiece. Private channels and Prasar Bharati later reduced the Centre's monopoly, though the power to regulate broadcasting still lies with the Union.
The demand for autonomy
As regional parties grew, several States set out what autonomy should mean.
| Demand | Year | Main proposals |
|---|---|---|
| Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu) | Set up 1969, report 1971 | Readjust the Seventh Schedule; residuary powers to States; repeal Article 249; review Article 356; change the Finance and Planning Commissions |
| West Bengal memorandum | December 1977 | 'Federal' for 'Union' in the Preamble; repeal Articles 356, 357 and 360; States' consent for new States or boundary changes |
| Anandpur Sahib resolution (Akali Dal) | 1973, revised 1978 | Centre limited to defence, foreign relations, communications, railways and currency; residuary powers to States |
| Opposition conclave, Srinagar | 1983 | States to legislate on their subjects without the President's assent; less power for the Planning Commission and discretionary grants |
The argument for autonomy. Supporters argue that a country as diverse as India can be united only through voluntary effort. Handling diversity from one central point, they say, heightens tension, while decentralisation uses local talent and meets people's hopes better.
The argument for a strong Centre. Others feel that a strong Centre is needed for unity and integrity. But a strong Centre and centralisation of powers are two different things, and the debate is often about where one ends and the other begins.
The Sarkaria Commission
The background. The Administrative Reforms Commission, appointed in 1967, had recommended maximum delegation of powers to States and an Inter-State Council under Article 263, but little was done. As tensions grew in the early 1980s, the Union government appointed a Commission on 24 March 1983 under Justice (Retd.) R.S. Sarkaria.
The report. The Commission reported on 27 October 1987, with 265 recommendations under twenty areas. Its basic view was that the existing constitutional scheme was sound, and what was needed was a mechanism for collective decision-making. It favoured a strong Centre, but said that centralisation had distanced the Centre from the people and harmed national integration.
Key recommendations.
| Area | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Governor | An eminent person from outside the State, not intimately connected with its politics, not too active in politics recently; not eligible for other office or office of profit afterwards |
| Article 356 | Very sparingly, as a last resort, after warning the State; Assembly not dissolved before Parliament considers the Proclamation |
| Concurrent List | Consult the States before legislating |
| Finance | Make corporation tax shareable with the States |
| River waters | Tribunal within one year of a State's request; award effective within five years |
| Planning | Rename the National Development Council as the National Economic Development Council and make it the top inter-governmental body for planning |
| Cooperation | A permanent Inter-State Council under Article 263 |
How far it went. Many observers felt the recommendations were limited and still biased towards the Centre. Most stayed on paper, but the Inter-State Council was established.
Building cooperation: the Inter-State Council and after
The Inter-State Council. Article 263 had allowed such a council from the start, but none was set up for decades. After the 1989 elections, the new government established it by presidential notification on 25 May 1990.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Chair | The Prime Minister, or a Cabinet minister nominated by the Prime Minister in his absence |
| Members | Chief Ministers of all States; Chief Ministers or Administrators of Union Territories; six Union Cabinet ministers |
| Meetings | Meant to meet at least three times a year, in camera |
| Decisions | By consensus |
A landmark resolution. At its meeting in August 2003, the Council resolved that the Centre may impose President's Rule under Article 356, but should do so sparingly and only as a last resort.
Why central interference declined. Several changes worked together:
- Regional parties grew strong and became partners in coalition governments at the Centre.
- An active President and judiciary, especially after the Bommai judgment, checked the Centre's discretion.
- Forums such as the Inter-State Council gave States a voice.
Newer forums.
- NITI Aayog (2015) was set up to foster cooperative federalism, on the idea that strong States make a strong nation.
- The GST Council brings the Union and State Finance Ministers together in a federal body to decide tax matters jointly.
What still remains. India remains a fairly centralised system, with appointed Governors, Article 356 and long Union and Concurrent Lists. What matters most is a federal spirit and healthy conventions, not only changes in the text.
Mains lens: confrontation or cooperation?
A common question: "Indian federalism has moved from confrontation towards cooperation." Discuss.
The confrontational phase:
- After 1967, opposition States challenged central dominance.
- Article 356 was used against opposition governments, including mass dismissals in 1977 and 1980.
- Governors acted as agents of the Centre and reserved State Bills.
- Discretionary grants, planning and media were seen as partisan tools.
Signs of cooperation:
- Sarkaria's call for collective decision-making; the Inter-State Council (1990) and its 2003 resolution.
- Coalition governments with regional partners at the Centre.
- Judicial checks after Bommai.
- NITI Aayog (2015) and the GST Council as joint forums.
Conclusion. The move is real but incomplete. Structural features that favour the Centre remain, so the health of federalism depends on political practice and conventions. A balanced answer ends by stressing consultation, trust and the principle that strong States make a strong nation.
Mains practice: more questions, different angles
Practise each with a 150-word answer. The points give the skeleton, and the facts come from this chapter.
1. Evaluation: Assess the major recommendations of the Sarkaria Commission and their implementation.
- Background: ARC 1967, rising tension, appointment in 1983, report in 1987.
- Governor, Article 356, Concurrent List consultation, corporation tax, river waters, NEDC.
- Inter-State Council set up; most others on paper.
- Criticism: limited and Centre-biased.
2. Institution: Discuss the role and usefulness of the Inter-State Council.
- Article 263; long delay; notification of 25 May 1990.
- Composition and consensus.
- 2003 resolution on Article 356.
- Limits: advisory, depends on political will.
3. Analysis: Why have States demanded greater autonomy?
- End of one-party dominance in 1967; regional parties.
- Rajamannar, West Bengal memorandum, Anandpur Sahib, Srinagar conclave.
- Grievances: Governor, Article 356, finances, media.
- Strong Centre versus centralisation.
Quick revision
- 1967: Congress lost its majority in eight States; autonomy debate began (Kerala, West Bengal, Tamil Nadu).
- Tension areas: Governor, President's Rule, reservation of Bills, finances, media.
- Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu, 1969; report 1971): residuary powers to States, repeal Article 249, review Article 356.
- West Bengal memorandum (December 1977): 'Federal' for 'Union'; repeal Articles 356, 357, 360.
- Anandpur Sahib (1973, revised 1978): Centre limited to five subjects.
- Sarkaria Commission: set up 24 March 1983, report 27 October 1987, 265 recommendations; strong Centre, not centralisation.
- Inter-State Council: notification 25 May 1990; PM chairs; all CMs, UT heads, six Union ministers; consensus.
- August 2003: Inter-State Council resolution, Article 356 "sparingly" and as a "last resort".