UPSC CAPF AC · Module 28 · standard depth · 10 min
Dividing power: legislative and administrative relations
What UPSC CAPF AC asks from this chapter
UPSC CAPF AC has asked 2 questions from this chapter (2020); 2 from its whole module.
Cut to standard depth for UPSC CAPF AC. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.
Start from zero: two governments, one country
A person in Patna or Pune lives under two governments at once. The Union prints the money in their pocket and guards the border, while the State runs the police station and the district hospital. Both make laws, both collect taxes, and both run offices.
Such a system needs clear rules on who does what, or the two governments would keep clashing. The Constitution writes these rules in three areas: legislative, administrative and financial. This chapter covers the first two, and the money side follows separately.
One idea runs through it all. The framers wanted the States to have real powers, but after Partition they also wanted a strong Centre that could hold the country together and drive planned development. So the scheme is federal, but it tilts towards the Union.
The three Lists
How law-making is divided. Article 246 divides legislative power through the Seventh Schedule, which has three Lists.
| List | Who makes laws | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| List I: Union List | Parliament only | Defence, foreign affairs, banking, currency, railways, atomic energy |
| List II: State List | State Legislatures only | Police and public order, public health, agriculture, prisons, irrigation, land revenue |
| List III: Concurrent List | Both | Criminal law and procedure, civil procedure, marriage, trusts, contracts, economic and social planning |
Why these subjects sit where they do. Matters that need one national policy, such as defence or currency, go to the Union. Matters closest to daily life, such as police and public health, are better handled at the State level. Concurrent subjects need common national rules but leave room for local variation.
The leftover box. A subject that appears in no List falls under the residuary powers, which belong to the Union. New areas that the framers could not foresee therefore go to Parliament.
When laws clash. If a Union law and a State law on a Concurrent subject conflict, the Union law prevails. There is one exception: if the State law was reserved for the President and received assent, it prevails in that State. Even then, Parliament can override it by a later law.
How courts read the Lists. Disputes over which entry a law falls under are decided by courts using a few principles:
- in a real overlap, the Union gets predominance;
- each entry is given the widest meaning its words allow; and
- a law is judged by its pith and substance, its true nature, not by incidental effects on another List.
When Parliament can enter the State List
The State List is the States' own field, but it is not sealed. In five situations Parliament can make laws on State subjects.
| Situation | How | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| National interest (Article 249) | Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds of members present and voting | One year at a time, renewable |
| Emergency | Parliament gets power over the whole State List | Laws cease six months after the Emergency ends (Article 250) |
| States' request | Two or more State Legislatures ask Parliament | Applies to those States |
| Treaties | To implement international treaties, agreements and conventions | Any subject, including State subjects |
| President's Rule | Powers of the State Legislature exercised by or under Parliament | While the Proclamation lasts |
Why the Rajya Sabha? The Rajya Sabha represents the States. So the power to step into the States' field in the national interest is given to the House of the States, and only by a large majority.
Why the six-month tail? Laws made during an Emergency do not vanish overnight when it ends. They lapse six months later, giving the States time to take back the field in an orderly way.
Administrative relations: who carries out the laws
Executive follows legislative. In general, each government carries out the laws it can make. The States run the administration of State List subjects, and the Union runs Union List subjects.
Concurrent subjects. Here the executive power ordinarily stays with the States, even when Parliament has made the law. The exceptions are where a Union law gives some functions to the Union, as the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 does, or where the Constitution itself does, as for carrying out an international treaty.
Directions from the Union (Article 257). States must use their executive power so that it does not impede the Union's executive power, and the Union can give directions for this. In normal times, States have to:
- ensure compliance with Union laws;
- avoid interfering with the Union's executive power;
- build and maintain means of communication of national or military importance;
- protect railways within the State;
- carry out schemes for the welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes; and
- run the State's administration according to the Constitution.
Other bridges.
- Article 258: the President can entrust Union functions to a State, with or without conditions.
- Article 262: Parliament can provide by law for deciding inter-State river water disputes.
- Article 263: an Inter-State Council can be set up to discuss common problems.
In an Emergency. The balance changes sharply. The Union can give directions on any matter, and during President's Rule the President takes over the State's executive powers.
Why the scheme leans towards the Centre
| Feature | Why the framers chose it | States' concern |
|---|---|---|
| Long Union List | National subjects need one policy | Little left for the States |
| Residuary powers with the Union | New national needs go to Parliament | New fields keep shifting to the Centre |
| Union law prevails on Concurrent subjects | Uniform rules across the country | States often not consulted |
| Article 249 and Emergency powers | Flexibility in a crisis | Can be used to override States |
| Directions under Article 257 | Union laws must work everywhere | Seen as supervision of States |
The background. The Constitution was written after Partition, amid fears for the country's unity, and at a time when planned development was the national goal. A strong Centre seemed necessary for both. Some scholars describe the result as federal with a unitary bias.
A real example: industries. Industries are essentially a State subject. But Parliament can take control of an industry by declaring Union control expedient in the public interest, and in this way most organised industry has been brought under the Union without any constitutional amendment. States have long complained about this.
Strong Centre or centralisation? A strong Centre is not the same as concentrating all powers at the Centre. A Centre can be strong in defence, currency and national unity while still trusting States with daily governance.
Quick revision
- Article 246 and the Seventh Schedule: Union List, State List, Concurrent List; residuary powers with the Union.
- Concurrent conflict: Union law prevails, unless the State law got the President's assent (Parliament can still override later).
- Parliament on the State List: Article 249 (Rajya Sabha, two-thirds present and voting, one year), Emergency (Article 250, lapse after six months), States' request, treaties, President's Rule.
- Courts use pith and substance, widest meaning and Union predominance in overlap.
- Executive follows legislative; on Concurrent subjects it is ordinarily with the States.
- Article 257: directions; States protect railways, build communications of national importance, run SC/ST schemes.
- Articles 258, 262, 263: entrusting functions, river water disputes, Inter-State Council.
UPSC CAPF AC questions from this chapter
In relation to the powers of the Union Government of India, which one of the following statements is NOT correct?
- (a) The Government of India may undertake legislative functions of a territory outside of India by agreement with the Government of that territory
- (b) The Union Government may not entrust a State Government with functions over matters where executive power of the Union extends
- (c) The Union Government may direct States for construction and maintenance of means of communication of military importance
- (d) The Governor may, with consent of Government of India, entrust its officers with functions on matters which fall within the executive power of the State
Show answer
(b) The Union Government may not entrust a State Government with functions over matters where executive power of the Union extends · our answer; official key awaited
As per provisions of the Constitution of India, which one of the following is correct?
- (a) Only Parliament has the power to legislate over a subject under the Concurrent List
- (b) Both Parliament and State Legislatures have the power to legislate over a subject under the Concurrent List
- (c) A legislation made under the Concurrent List by Parliament should be ratified by half of the State Legislatures so as to become a law of the country
- (d) Only State Legislatures are empowered to make laws under Concurrent List
Show answer
(b) Both Parliament and State Legislatures have the power to legislate over a subject under the Concurrent List · our answer; official key awaited