UPSC CAPF AC course‹› 0:00 studied

UPSC CAPF AC · Module 22 · standard depth · 17 min

Historical background: from Company rule to a free Constitution

What UPSC CAPF AC asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Paper I: General Ability and Intelligence · Indian Polity and Economy: The questions shall aim to test candidates’ knowledge of the Country’s political system and the Constitution of India, social systems and public administration, economic development in India, regional and international security issues and human rights including its indicators.

UPSC CAPF AC has asked 2 questions from this chapter (2025); 6 from its whole module.

Cut to standard depth for UPSC CAPF AC. 11 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: who writes the rules of a house?

Think of a family living in a rented house. In the beginning, the landlord makes every rule: when the gate shuts, who may visit, what may be changed. The family has no say.

From tenant to owner: who writes the house rules?

Over the years things change step by step:

  1. The landlord is told by his own elders, "You can't do whatever you like," so they put limits on the landlord.
  2. Then the elders take over the house themselves and appoint a manager.
  3. The family complains loudly, so the manager lets a few family members sit in on meetings, but only to give advice.
  4. Later the family is allowed to run a few rooms themselves, while the manager keeps the keys to the important rooms.
  5. Finally, the family becomes the owner and writes its own house rules. It keeps some useful old rules (the electricity plan, the water pipes), but now the rules serve the family, not the landlord.

This is the story of India from 1773 to 1950. The "landlord" was the East India Company, the "elders" were the British Parliament and Crown, the "family" was the Indian people, and the "new house rules" are our Constitution. Every Act in this chapter is one step on that ladder: who controls India, and how much say do Indians get?

A trading company becomes a ruler

The East India Company came to India to trade, not to rule. But three events turned it into a government:

From 1773 to 1950 on one line
  • 1757, Battle of Plassey: the Nawab of Bengal was defeated. This is usually taken as the start of British rule.
  • 1765, the diwani: the Company got the right to collect revenue in Bengal and Bihar. Collecting tax is what governments do, so a trading company was now acting like a state.
  • 1772: the Company made Calcutta its capital and became directly involved in governance.

Now the problem was clear. A private company, answerable to its shareholders, was ruling millions of people. The British Parliament decided it had to step in. The timeline below shows the long road from that moment to 1950.

Putting a leash on the Company: 1773 and 1784

Regulating Act, 1773. This was the first of a series of laws by the British Parliament to curb the Company and bring order to the lands it controlled. Its main changes:

Who controlled the Company after 1784
  • The Governor of Bengal became the Governor-General of Bengal, with authority over all three Presidencies (Bengal, Madras, Bombay). For the first time, India had one unified head of administration. Warren Hastings was the first Governor-General.
  • A Supreme Court was set up at Calcutta.
  • The Company's charter was limited to periods of twenty years, reviewed on renewal, and the British government got supervisory rights over the Presidencies.

Pitt's India Act, 1784. Eleven years later, Parliament tightened its grip. It created a Board of Control, whose members came from the British cabinet, to supervise the Company. The Act is sometimes called the "half-loaf system", because it tried to split power between Parliament and the Company's directors, giving neither the whole loaf.

Why this matters today: these two Acts are the first time anyone wrote down, in law, who governs India and who checks them. That question, "who checks the government?", is at the heart of every Constitution.

The Charter Acts: trade out, government in

The Company's licence was renewed every twenty years by a Charter Act: 1793, 1813, 1833 and 1853. Each renewal took away a bit of the trader and added a bit of the ruler.

Charter Acts: trader becomes ruler
  • Charter Act 1813: ended the Company's monopoly over trade with India. Other British traders could now come in. The Company's control over revenue, administration and appointments stayed.
  • Charter Act 1833: ended its monopoly of the China trade too. More importantly, it took law-making power away from the Presidencies and concentrated it in the Governor-General and his council. Power was moving to the centre: this is the first seed of the strong Centre you will meet in the salient features.
  • Civil service: from 1806 the Company trained its young recruits at Haileybury College near London. After 1833, it picked officers by a competitive examination among candidates it nominated. After 1853, selection became entirely on merit, and the examination was open to any British subject, Indians included.

That last point is the root of the open, merit-based examination you are preparing for today. Today the Constitution itself creates Public Service Commissions to run such exams, an idea that also came through the 1935 Act.

Courts and the rule of law

Alongside government came courts. Under the Regulating Act, a Supreme Court was created at Calcutta. It had jurisdiction over Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.

Courts in Company Bengal: Calcutta, Dacca, Murshidabad, Patna

If the disputed amount was more than Rs 4,000, its judgment could be appealed to the Privy Council in London. Similar Supreme Courts came up in Madras (1801) and Bombay (1823).

Under Lord Cornwallis, courts of appeal and of circuit sat in four places: Calcutta, Dacca, Murshidabad and Patna.

The British judicial system was built, at least in theory, on two principles:

  • Rule of Law: no one is above the law, and government servants can be sued in court for their official acts.
  • Equality before law: everyone, whatever their caste, class or status, is equal before the law.

These were new ideas in a caste-ridden society. But in practice the colonial state often broke them for its own convenience. The framers kept the words and gave them real force: Article 14 today guarantees "equality before the law" to every person, and a citizen can go to court if the State denies it.

1858: the Crown takes over

In 1857, a great revolt shook Company rule across north India. Britain decided the Company could no longer be trusted with India.

1858: India passes from the Company to the Crown
1858: India passes from the Company to the CrownPhoto: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The Government of India Act 1858 ended Company rule and brought India under the direct rule of the British Crown. Two new offices ran it:

  • a Secretary of State for India, a British minister sitting in London, answerable to the British Parliament;
  • a Governor-General of India, heading the government in India.

Go back to the house picture: the "elders" (the British state) have now taken the house from the landlord and put their own manager in charge. Notice what has not changed yet: Indians still have no say. That comes next, slowly.

Indians get a seat at the table: 1861 to 1919

Step by step, Indians were let into the room where laws were made. Watch how the size of the voice grows at each step:

How Indians slowly got a voice
Act What changed How much say for Indians
Indian Councils Act 1861 Indians associated with law-making A beginning of representative institutions
Indian Councils Act 1892 More members in central and provincial legislatures A bigger room, still advisory
Indian Councils Act 1909 (Morley-Minto) Separate electorates for Muslims Representation, but divided by religion
1919 reforms (Montagu-Chelmsford) Dyarchy, two Houses, direct elections Some subjects run by Indians; key powers kept by the British

What is dyarchy? "Dyarchy" means rule by two. In the provinces, subjects were split into two groups: some were handed to Indian ministers answerable to the legislature, while the important ones stayed with officials answerable only to the British. It is like being allowed to run the kitchen and the garden, while the manager keeps the keys to the safe. Nationalists soon called it a farce, because the key decisions never left British hands.

What is a separate electorate? Voters of one community vote only for candidates of their own community, in seats reserved for them. It gave Muslims representation, but it also divided voters by religion, a choice the framers later rejected.

The national movement pushes back: 1928 to 1931

Reforms given from above were not enough. The national movement now pushed from below.

Members of the Simon Commission, which had no Indian member
Members of the Simon Commission, which had no Indian memberPhoto: Unknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Simon Commission: Britain sent a commission to suggest further constitutional reforms, but it had no Indian member. The message was clear: Indians would not even be asked about their own future. When it landed on 3 February 1928, cities observed a hartal; banners, placards and even kites carried the slogan "Go Back Simon". In Lahore, police hit Lala Lajpat Rai with lathis, and he died a few days later. His death created huge anger against British rule.
  • Purna Swaraj: the Congress adopted complete independence as its goal, and 26 January 1930 was observed as Purna Swaraj Day. Twenty years later, the Constitution was brought into force on the same date, 26 January 1950, to honour it.
  • Round Table Conferences: the First Round Table Conference met in London in November 1930, but the Congress was not represented. Talks between Gandhi and the Viceroy followed in 1931.

The lesson of these years: a Constitution for India could not be drafted in London. It had to be made by Indians.

The Government of India Act 1935: the biggest bridge

The Government of India Act 1935 was the longest and most detailed law Britain passed for India. It:

What the Constitution kept from 1935
  • gave more autonomy to elected members in the provincial legislatures;
  • extended voting rights to a larger share of Indians.

Elections to the provincial legislatures were held in early 1937. The Congress won absolute majorities in five of the eleven provinces and formed governments. Those governments showed that Indians could govern themselves.

Towards the end of 1939, after the Viceroy declared India a party to the Second World War without consulting Indians, all the Congress governments resigned. The Quit India movement followed in August 1942.

Why the 1935 Act matters most for the Constitution: it became the major source of the present Constitution's structure. The Constitution took from it:

  1. the federal scheme;
  2. the office of Governor;
  3. the judiciary;
  4. the Public Service Commissions;
  5. the emergency provisions.

Think of it as the plumbing and wiring of the old house, which the new owner kept because it worked. What changed was who controls the switches.

1946 to 1950: the family becomes the owner

1946–50: from Assembly to Republic
  • Cabinet Mission (1946): its plan set up the Constituent Assembly, the body that would write India's Constitution. Its full story is told in Making of the Constitution.
  • Indian Independence Act 1947: ended British rule. India became free on 15 August 1947, but the country was partitioned into India and Pakistan, with terrible communal violence.
  • A sovereign Assembly: with independence, the Constituent Assembly became a fully sovereign body, no longer bound by any British law. After Partition it had 299 members (as on 31 December 1947), of whom 229 were elected by the provincial assemblies.
  • 26 January 1950: the Constitution came into force. Its Article 395 formally repealed the Indian Independence Act 1947 and the Government of India Act 1935. The old house rules were torn up; the new ones, written by Indians, took their place.

Why each law came, and what it left behind

Every colonial law in this chapter was a reaction to a problem. If you know the problem, the law is easy to remember, and so is its legacy in today's Constitution.

Law Problem it reacted to What it left behind
Regulating Act 1773 A trading company was ruling territory with little control from Britain Idea of a central head (Governor-General) and a Supreme Court at Calcutta
Pitt's India Act 1784 The 1773 Act had not given Parliament enough control Political control by a Board drawn from the British cabinet
Charter Acts 1813, 1833, 1853 Pressure to open trade and to run India as a government, not a business Central law-making (1833) and merit-based civil service (1853), roots of today's services
Government of India Act 1858 The revolt of 1857 showed Company rule had failed Direct Crown rule; a Secretary of State answerable in London
Councils Acts 1861, 1892 Rulers needed Indian opinion after 1857 First seeds of legislatures with Indian members
Councils Act 1909 Demands for more seats; colonial interest in dividing communities Separate electorates, which the Constitution rejected through Article 325
Act of 1919 Indian demands after the First World War Direct elections and two Houses; dyarchy kept real power with the rulers
Act of 1935 Growing national movement; need for a federal plan Provincial autonomy and much of today's administrative machinery

The pattern. Each step gave Indians a little more voice, but kept final power with Britain. The Constitution broke this pattern. Article 395 repealed the 1935 Act and the Indian Independence Act, and power now flows from "We, the people".

Why this history matters for exams. It explains three things in today's Constitution: why so much administrative detail looks like the 1935 Act, why the framers insisted on one common electoral roll (Article 325) after the experience of separate electorates, and why equality before law (Article 14) was written as a right of every person.

Quick revision

One-page summary
  • The Battle of Plassey was fought in 1757, and the Company got the diwani of Bengal and Bihar in 1765.
  • The 1773 Regulating Act created the post of Governor-General of Bengal (Warren Hastings) and a Supreme Court at Calcutta. It was the first law by which Parliament controlled the Company.
  • The 1784 Pitt's India Act set up the Board of Control, an arrangement often called the "half-loaf system".
  • The Charter Acts came in 1793, 1813, 1833 and 1853. The 1813 Act ended the India trade monopoly, the 1833 Act ended the China trade monopoly and centralised law-making, and the 1853 Act opened the civil service fully to merit.
  • The 1858 Government of India Act brought Crown rule and created the Secretary of State for India.
  • Representative institutions began in 1861, and more members came in 1892. Separate electorates came in 1909, and dyarchy, two Houses and direct elections came in 1919.
  • The Simon Commission was boycotted in 1928. Purna Swaraj Day was marked on 26 January 1930, and the First Round Table Conference met in November 1930.
  • The 1935 Government of India Act is the major source of the Constitution. In the 1937 elections the Congress won majorities in 5 of 11 provinces, and Quit India began in August 1942.
  • The 1946 Cabinet Mission led to the Constituent Assembly. India became independent and was partitioned on 15 August 1947, and Article 395 later repealed the 1935 and 1947 Acts.

UPSC CAPF AC questions from this chapter

  1. 2025 · UPSC CAPF AC Prelims · General Ability and Intelligence · 2 marks

    Match List-I with List-II and select the answer using the code given below the Lists: List-I (Act of the British Parliament) A. The Pitt's India Act, 1784 B. The Charter Act, 1813 C. The Charter Act, 1833 D. The Charter Act, 1853 List-II (Key Provision) 1. Enlargement of the Governor-General's Legislative Council 2. Discrimination against Indians removed in matters of employment and higher service 3. Board set up by the Crown to control affairs of India 4. Termination of monopoly of East India Company over Indian trade

    1. (a) A-1, B-4, C-2, D-3
    2. (b) A-1, B-2, C-4, D-3
    3. (c) A-3, B-4, C-2, D-1
    4. (d) A-3, B-2, C-4, D-1
    Show answer

    (c) A-3, B-4, C-2, D-1 · our answer; official key awaited

  2. 2025 · UPSC CAPF AC Prelims · General Ability and Intelligence · 2 marks

    Consider the following statements regarding the Government of India Act, 1919: 1. It divided the subjects of administration in two categories—central and provincial. 2. The central subjects were divided into 'reserved' and 'transferred' subjects. 3. Provincial Governments were granted the power to make their own budgets and levy taxes.

    1. (a) 1 and 2 only
    2. (b) 2 and 3 only
    3. (c) 1 and 3 only
    4. (d) 1, 2 and 3
    Show answer

    (c) 1 and 3 only · our answer; official key awaited

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 19 answered

  1. Which was the first law passed by the British Parliament to control the East India Company?

  2. A Supreme Court was first set up at Calcutta under:

  3. The Board of Control was created by:

  4. Consider the following statements: 1. The Charter Act of 1813 ended the Company's monopoly over trade with India. 2. The Charter Act of 1833 concentrated law-making power in the Governor-General and his council. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  5. After which Charter Act did selection to the civil service become entirely based on merit through an open examination?

  6. Which Act ended Company rule and brought India under the direct rule of the British Crown?

  7. Separate electorates for Muslims were introduced by the:

  8. Dyarchy in the provinces was introduced by the reforms of:

  9. Consider the following statements: 1. The Indian Councils Act 1861 associated Indians with the law-making process. 2. The Indian Councils Act 1892 reduced the number of members in the legislatures. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  10. Which pre-independence Act became the major source of the present Constitution?

  11. 26 January was chosen as the day the Constitution came into force because on 26 January 1930:

  12. After Partition, how many members did the Constituent Assembly have as on 31 December 1947?

  13. In 1765 the East India Company obtained the diwani, the right to collect revenue, in:

  14. Which Act is sometimes called the 'half-loaf system'?

  15. Consider the following statements about the Supreme Court set up at Calcutta under the Regulating Act: 1. Its jurisdiction covered Bengal, Bihar and Orissa. 2. Its judgments could never be appealed outside India. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  16. Under the Cornwallis system, which of these was NOT a seat of the provincial courts of appeal and circuit?

  17. The Simon Commission was boycotted mainly because:

  18. In the 1937 provincial elections held under the 1935 Act, the Congress won absolute majorities in:

  19. Which Article of the Constitution repealed the Government of India Act 1935 and the Indian Independence Act 1947?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The Constitution of India owes much to the Government of India Act, 1935, yet it marks a clear break from colonial rule.' Discuss. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Continuity: 1935 Act the major source; strong Centre since 1833; elected legislatures 1919, 1935
    • Break: made by Indians in their own Assembly; 'We, the people'; every adult votes
    • Machinery borrowed, purpose changed: from controlling a colony to running a democracy
  2. How did the colonial experience of separate electorates and dyarchy shape the choices of the Constitution's framers? (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • 1909 separate electorates divided voters by religion; Article 325 single general roll
    • Rule of law in theory; Fundamental Rights enforceable in court
    • Dyarchy gave responsibility without power; full responsible government
    • Colonial period as workshop and warning

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Which was the first law to control the East India Company?

The Regulating Act of 1773 was the first. It made the Governor of Bengal the Governor-General of Bengal and set up a Supreme Court at Calcutta; Warren Hastings was the first Governor-General.

What did Pitt's India Act of 1784 do?

It increased the British Parliament's control over the Company by setting up a Board of Control, whose members came from the British cabinet.

When did Company rule end in India?

The Government of India Act 1858 ended Company rule. It set up direct rule of the British Crown, with a Secretary of State for India and a Governor-General of India.

Which Charter Act ended the Company's trade monopoly with India?

The Charter Act of 1813 ended the Company's monopoly over trade with India. The Charter Act of 1833 later ended its China trade monopoly and centralised law-making in the Governor-General's council.