UPSC CSE course‹› 0:00 studied

UPSC CSE · Module 55 · Mains depth · 20 min

The greenhouse effect: how the Earth keeps warm

What UPSC CSE asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • Prelims Paper I: General Studies · General issues on Environmental ecology, Bio-diversity and Climate Change - that do not require subject specialization.

UPSC CSE questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Read at full depth: basics, the standard layer and the Mains analysis.

Start from zero: why does a parked car get so hot?

Think of a summer afternoon. Your father parks the car in the sun and closes all the windows. An hour later you open the door and a wave of hot air hits your face.

A car in the sun and a planet in the sun

The seat burns your legs. But the air outside is not that hot. Why is it hotter inside the car?

Here is what happens, step by step:

  • Sunlight comes in. Sunlight passes easily through the glass windows. It falls on the seats and the dashboard.
  • The seats get warm. When something soaks up sunlight, it gets warm. A black seat soaks up a lot.
  • Warm things give off heat. Every warm object gives off invisible heat rays. You can feel them if you hold your hand near a hot iron without touching it.
  • The heat gets stuck. Those heat rays cannot get out of the closed car as easily as the sunlight came in. So heat keeps building up, and the inside gets hotter and hotter.

A greenhouse works the same way. Gardeners in cold countries grow vegetables inside houses made of glass. Sunlight enters, the plants and soil warm up, and the warmth stays inside, so the plants grow even when it is cold outside.

Now here is the big idea of this chapter. Our whole planet has something like a glass cover. It is not made of glass.

A glass greenhouse
A glass greenhousePhoto: Mostafameraji, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

It is made of a thin layer of air around the Earth, called the atmosphere. A few gases in this air behave a little like the car's windows: they let sunlight come in, but they hold back some of the heat that the Earth tries to send out. These gases are called greenhouse gases, and the warming they cause is called the greenhouse effect.

You will also learn that this "cover" is not a bad thing. Without it the Earth would be frozen. The problem starts when humans make the cover thicker, by burning coal, petrol and diesel and by cutting forests.

Then the planet traps more heat than before and slowly warms up. That is global warming, and the long-term changes in weather that follow are called climate change.

Keep three questions in your head as you read: How does the Earth trap heat? Why is that a good thing? And what changes when humans add more of these gases?

Sunlight in, heat out: the Earth's energy budget

Every household has a budget: money comes in, money goes out. If more comes in than goes out, savings grow. The Earth has an energy budget in exactly the same sense.

Where the Sun's energy goes

Energy comes in from the Sun, and energy goes out to space. If the two are equal, the Earth's temperature stays steady. If a little more comes in than goes out, the Earth slowly warms.

What comes in. The Sun is extremely hot, and very hot objects shine mostly in visible light, the light our eyes can see. Most of the Sun's energy reaches us in this form, and this light passes through clean air easily.

Where it goes. Imagine 100 units of sunlight arriving at the top of the atmosphere. Scientists who track the Earth's energy budget find that these units split three ways:

  • about 29 units are reflected straight back to space by clouds, ice, snow, deserts and other bright surfaces. This reflecting power is called albedo. Fresh snow and ice have a high albedo; dark oceans and forests have a low one;
  • about 23 units are absorbed in the atmosphere itself, by water vapour, dust and ozone;
  • about 48 units are absorbed by the surface, by land and oceans. This is what warms the ground we stand on.

What goes out. The warmed Earth must give energy back, otherwise it would keep heating forever. But the Earth is far cooler than the Sun, so it does not glow with visible light.

It gives off thermal infrared radiation, the invisible heat rays you felt near the hot iron. This is the key difference to remember:

  • the Sun sends energy mainly as visible light (short waves);
  • the Earth sends energy back mainly as infrared heat (long waves).

Clean air lets the incoming light pass, but some gases in the air are very good at catching the outgoing infrared. That is where the greenhouse effect begins, so let us now meet these gases.

Why this matters for the exam. Many questions test whether you know that greenhouse gases trap outgoing infrared (terrestrial) radiation, not incoming sunlight. Also remember albedo: when ice melts and dark sea or land is exposed, less sunlight is reflected and more is absorbed. The extra warmth then melts still more ice, so the change feeds itself.

Greenhouse gases: the few that catch heat

Air is mostly nitrogen and oxygen. Together they make up almost all of it. Surprisingly, these two do not trap heat in the way greenhouse gases do. So the heat-trapping must be done by other gases, and those gases are present only in tiny amounts.

Why some gases trap heat and others don't

A simple picture. Think of the outgoing infrared rays as balls being thrown upward from the ground. Nitrogen and oxygen molecules are made of two atoms joined tightly, and the balls fly past them.

Molecules made of three or more atoms, like carbon dioxide (CO2), water (H2O) and methane (CH4), can bend and wobble. When an infrared ball hits them, they catch it, wobble, and then throw it out again in any direction, including back down towards the ground. So part of the heat that was leaving comes back, and the lower air and surface stay warmer.

The official definition. The UN climate treaty (UNFCCC, Article 1) defines greenhouse gases as those gaseous parts of the atmosphere, both natural and man-made (anthropogenic), that absorb and re-emit infrared radiation. Notice both key words: absorb and re-emit.

Who emits greenhouse gases

The main greenhouse gases:

  • Water vapour (H2O). The most important and most abundant greenhouse gas. But it is not a direct cause of climate change, because the amount in the air depends on temperature.
  • Why water vapour is a feedback. Warmer air holds more water vapour, which then traps more heat. So water vapour amplifies warming started by other gases, and scientists call it a feedback, not a driver.
  • Carbon dioxide (CO2). The second most important, and the main gas that humans are adding, mostly by burning coal, oil and gas, and by cutting forests.
  • Methane (CH4). From paddy fields, cattle, landfills, and leaks from coal mines and gas pipelines.
  • Nitrous oxide (N2O). Mainly from nitrogen fertilisers and some industries.
  • Ozone (O3) near the ground. A pollutant formed from vehicle and industrial fumes; it also traps heat.
  • Fluorinated gases. Man-made gases used in refrigerators, air-conditioners and industry: hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs), sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and nitrogen trifluoride (NF3). They are present in tiny amounts but some are extremely powerful.

Why this matters. Prelims often asks "Which of the following are greenhouse gases?" or tests the role of water vapour. Remember: nitrogen and oxygen are not; water vapour is, and it is the most abundant one; CO2 is the main gas humans add. For Mains, the point about water vapour as a feedback explains why even a small push from CO2 can lead to a bigger total warming.

The natural greenhouse effect is a friend; the enhanced one is the problem

Students often think "greenhouse effect" is a bad word. It is not. The natural greenhouse effect is the reason life exists on Earth.

Natural vs enhanced greenhouse effect

A blanket on a winter night. On a cold night your body keeps making heat. Without a blanket, the heat escapes quickly and you shiver. With a blanket, the heat stays close and you sleep comfortably.

The blanket does not make heat; it only slows down its escape. Greenhouse gases are the Earth's blanket. The IPCC explains that without the natural greenhouse effect, the average temperature at the Earth's surface would be below the freezing point of water. Rivers, lakes and oceans would freeze, and life as we know it would not be possible.

Now add a second blanket. A blanket is good, but on a warm night two thick blankets make you sweat. Since the Industrial Revolution, humans have been adding more CO2, methane and nitrous oxide to the air. This makes the blanket thicker.

Three words often mixed up

More outgoing heat is caught and sent back, so the energy budget goes slightly out of balance: a little more energy comes in than goes out, and the Earth warms. This extra warming caused by human-added gases is called the enhanced greenhouse effect. Its result is global warming.

Three words that are often mixed up:

  • Greenhouse effect: the natural process of trapping heat. Always present. Good for life.
  • Global warming: the rise in the Earth's average surface temperature caused mainly by the enhanced greenhouse effect.
  • Climate change: the wider, long-term change in climate (temperature, rainfall patterns, monsoon, extreme weather, sea level) that follows. The UN climate treaty uses this meaning: a change of climate attributed directly or indirectly to human activity that alters the composition of the global atmosphere, in addition to natural variability.

Is it really humans? Yes. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the UN body that assesses climate science, said in its Sixth Assessment Report (AR6, 2021): "It is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land." "Unequivocal" means there is no doubt left. This sentence is one of the most quoted lines in climate science, and it is worth remembering word for word for Mains.

The IPCC and its verdict

Who is the IPCC? The IPCC was set up in 1988 by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organization (WMO). Its job is to assess climate science for governments. Its First Assessment Report, published in 1990, played a decisive role in the creation of the UN climate treaty, the UNFCCC.

Who is the IPCC? The IPCC was set up in 1988 by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organization (WMO). Its job is to assess climate science for governments. Its First Assessment Report, published in 1990, played a decisive role in the creation of the UN climate treaty, the UNFCCC.

Mains lens: how to explain the mechanism

UPSC often asks you to explain the greenhouse effect itself before it asks about policy. A clear answer shows the flow of energy, separates the natural effect from the enhanced one, and ends with why it matters.

Answer plan: explain the mechanism

The question shape: "Explain the mechanism". Example: "Explain the greenhouse effect. Why is the enhanced greenhouse effect a matter of concern?"

  • Intro: Define the greenhouse effect in one line as the trapping of outgoing infrared heat by greenhouse gases.
  • Body: Draw a simple flow diagram in which sunlight comes in, infrared goes out and the gases absorb and re-emit it. Then contrast the natural and the enhanced effect, mention two feedbacks, and give the evidence that CO2 rose from about 280 ppm before industrialisation to 410 ppm in 2019 while the Earth warmed by 1.09 °C (IPCC AR6).
  • Conclusion: Conclude that the natural effect sustains life while the enhanced effect threatens it, so emissions must fall.

Linking across papers. This topic feeds GS-I (climatology), GS-III (environment) and the Essay paper. A one-line definition and a simple energy-flow diagram will serve you in all three.

Mains practice: six questions, six angles

These are practice questions written by us, not past papers. Past questions from each exam appear in the PYQ panel of this module.

Angle Question Key points to cover
Mechanism Explain the greenhouse effect. Why is the enhanced greenhouse effect a matter of concern? Show sunlight coming in as visible light and heat leaving as infrared, which some gases absorb and re-emit. Then separate the natural effect, which keeps the Earth above freezing, from the enhanced effect caused by human-added gases.
Concepts Distinguish between the greenhouse effect, global warming and climate change. Define each term in one line and show how one leads to the next. Then quote the UNFCCC meaning of climate change as a change caused by human activity in addition to natural variability.
Energy balance What is the Earth's energy budget? How can a small imbalance change the climate? Give the 29, 23 and 48 split of incoming sunlight and explain albedo. Then show that when a little more energy comes in than goes out, the Earth warms slowly, and melting ice lowers albedo further.
Science Why do nitrogen and oxygen not trap heat while carbon dioxide and methane do? Explain that molecules of three or more atoms can bend and wobble, so they catch and re-emit infrared. Then add the UNFCCC Article 1 definition, which covers both natural and man-made gases.
Feedback Water vapour is the most important greenhouse gas, yet it is not called a driver of climate change. Explain. Explain that the amount of water vapour depends on temperature, because warmer air holds more of it. Then show that it amplifies warming begun by CO2, which is why scientists call it a feedback.
Misconception The greenhouse effect and ozone depletion are often confused. Bring out the differences. Compare the radiation involved (infrared against ultraviolet), the layer of the atmosphere and the treaty that deals with each. Then note that CFCs play a part in both, which explains the confusion.

How to use this table: each answer should first explain the what, then give the why from this chapter, and end with a way forward.

Quick revision

Greenhouse effect vs ozone hole
  • Sun sends visible light; Earth sends back infrared heat. Greenhouse gases trap the outgoing infrared.
  • Energy budget: about 29% reflected, 23% absorbed by the atmosphere, 48% absorbed by the surface. Reflecting power = albedo.
  • Nitrogen and oxygen are not greenhouse gases. Water vapour is the most abundant one but acts as a feedback; CO2 is the main human-added gas.
  • Without the natural greenhouse effect, the Earth would be below freezing.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 9 answered

  1. Greenhouse gases mainly trap which kind of radiation?

  2. Consider the following gases: 1. Nitrogen 2. Water vapour 3. Methane 4. Oxygen. Which of these are greenhouse gases?

  3. Assertion (A): Water vapour is the most abundant greenhouse gas. Reason (R): Water vapour is the main direct cause of present-day climate change.

  4. Of the sunlight reaching the top of the atmosphere, about how much is reflected back to space?

  5. Consider the following statements about the UNFCCC definition of greenhouse gases: 1. They are gaseous parts of the atmosphere that absorb and re-emit infrared radiation. 2. Only man-made gases count as greenhouse gases. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  6. Without the natural greenhouse effect, the average temperature at the Earth's surface would be:

  7. Which report stated that 'it is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land'?

  8. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) was set up in 1988 by:

  9. Assertion (A): The Earth gives off its energy mainly as infrared radiation, not as visible light. Reason (R): The Earth is much cooler than the Sun.

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Which is the most abundant greenhouse gas?

Water vapour; among gases added by humans, carbon dioxide contributes most to warming.

What is global warming potential?

A measure of how much heat a gas traps compared with carbon dioxide over a set period, usually 100 years.

Which gas has the highest global warming potential?

Sulphur hexafluoride (SF6), with a GWP in the tens of thousands over 100 years.

What are the main sources of methane?

Livestock digestion, rice paddies, landfills, wetlands and leaks from coal, oil and gas.