UPSC IES / ISS course‹› 0:00 studied

UPSC IES / ISS · Module 28 · standard depth · 10 min

The Governor: constitutional head and the Centre's representative

What UPSC IES / ISS asks from this chapter

Syllabus lines this chapter covers:

  • General Studies (IES and ISS) · The paper will also include questions on Indian Polity including the political system and the Constitution of India, History of India and Geography of a nature which a candidate should be able to answer without special study.

UPSC IES / ISS questions from this module are being sorted into our bank.

Cut to standard depth for UPSC IES / ISS. 8 deeper paragraphs are in the full chapter.

Start from zero: a head who does not rule

Think of a school with a respected principal who signs every certificate and opens every function. Day-to-day decisions, though, are taken by the teachers' committee, and the principal signs what they decide. Yet when the committee breaks down and no one is in charge, the principal must step in.

The Governor of a State plays a similar part. India has a parliamentary system in the States as well. The Governor is the constitutional head, and the real power lies with the Council of Ministers led by the Chief Minister, who answer to the elected Assembly.

But the Governor has a second identity too. The Governor is appointed by the President and serves at the President's pleasure, which makes the office a link between the State and the Centre. Most debates about the Governor come from the tension between these two roles.

Appointment and tenure: why it matters who appoints

How the Governor is chosen. The Governor is appointed by the President, not elected by the people of the State. The term is five years, but the Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President. A Governor can be reappointed to the same State or to another State.

The Governor's two hats

What "pleasure" means in practice. Since the President acts on the advice of the Union Council of Ministers, the Governor can in effect be removed whenever the Union government wishes. Governors have sometimes been removed after a change of government at the Centre.

The Chief Minister's voice. A convention was suggested that the Chief Minister should be consulted before a Governor is appointed to that State. In practice, it has often not been followed.

Why the framers chose appointment. The Constituent Assembly debated this at length. An appointed Governor, linked to the Centre, was meant to help hold the country together at a time of divisive pressures. An elected Governor might also have clashed with an elected Chief Minister, creating two rival centres of power in one State.

Executive and judicial powers

Executive powers. The entire executive work of the State is carried on in the Governor's name. The Governor:

What the Governor appoints, and the pardoning power
  • appoints the Chief Minister, and other Ministers on the Chief Minister's advice;
  • appoints the Advocate General and the members of the State Public Service Commission; and
  • makes many other senior appointments.

Acting on advice. In nearly all of this, the Governor acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers. As long as a stable Ministry enjoys the confidence of the Assembly, the Governor has little discretion.

Pardoning power. The Governor can grant pardons, reprieves, respites or remissions, and can suspend, remit or commute sentences. This power covers offences against laws on matters to which the State's executive power extends.

Legislative powers: assent, veto and ordinances

Part of the legislature. The Governor is a part of the State Legislature. The Governor can address it and send it messages, summon and prorogue it, and dissolve the Legislative Assembly.

What the Governor can do with a Bill

Four options on a Bill. When a Bill passed by the legislature reaches the Governor, there are four choices:

  1. Give assent, and the Bill becomes law.
  2. Withhold assent, and the Bill does not become law.
  3. Return the Bill with a message, if it is not a Money Bill. If the legislature passes it again, with or without changes, the Governor must give assent.
  4. Reserve the Bill for the President. The President may assent, withhold assent, or return it. The legislature must reconsider a returned Bill within six months, but even if it passes the Bill again, the President is not bound to assent.

A real veto. The first two options are normally exercised on the Council of Ministers' advice. Returning and reserving Bills involve the Governor's discretion. Reservation gives the Governor and the President a real veto over State laws, which opposition parties criticise as a dent in State autonomy.

Life of a Governor's Ordinance

Ordinances. When the legislature is not in session, the Governor can issue Ordinances with the force of law. An Ordinance must be placed before the legislature when it meets, and it lapses six weeks after the legislature reassembles, unless disapproved earlier. The power covers only matters on which the State legislature can make laws.

Discretion: where controversy begins

When one party has a clear majority, the Governor has almost no choice to make. Trouble starts when the Assembly is divided and no one has a clear majority. Then the Governor's discretion comes into play, and this has made the Governor's office the most controversial constitutional office in the country.

Discretion in practice: cases from the chapter
Area Examples The criticism
Appointing a Chief Minister Madras 1952: largest party's leader C. Rajagopalachari invited without a majority. West Bengal 1970: Jyoti Basu, leader of the largest party, not invited. Different standards in similar situations
Dismissing a Ministry West Bengal 1967: the Ajoy Mukherjee Ministry dismissed for not calling the Assembly in time Majority should be tested in the House, not decided by the Governor
Dissolving the Assembly Chief Ministers' advice to dissolve refused in Punjab 1967, Uttar Pradesh 1968 and 2003 Seen as acting on the Centre's wishes
Recommending President's Rule Kerala 1959; Jammu and Kashmir and Andhra Pradesh 1984 Governments removed without a floor test

Article 356 and the Governor. If the Governor is satisfied that the State's government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution, the Governor can report this to the President. The President may then take over the State government's powers and hand the legislature's powers to Parliament. In 1959, a report from the Governor of Kerala led to the dismissal of the State's first non-Congress government, a step widely criticised.

The lesson drawn. Many jurists argue that the question of majority should be settled on the floor of the House, not in the Governor's office.

Why the office was designed this way

Feature Reason Concern
Appointed, not elected Avoid a rival power centre to the elected Chief Minister No local accountability
Holds office at the President's pleasure Keep a link between State and Centre Removal when the Centre's ruling party changes
Acts on ministers' advice Parliamentary government in the States Discretion unclear in a hung Assembly
Power to reserve Bills Check on laws that may clash with national interests Weakens State autonomy
Report under Article 356 Respond to a real breakdown of government Misused to remove opposition governments

The dual role. The Governor is meant to be both an impartial head of the State and the President's representative. Because the President acts on the Union Cabinet's advice, the second role can pull the Governor towards the wishes of the party ruling at the Centre. The framers accepted this risk for the sake of national unity, but how well the office works depends on the people chosen to fill it.

Why the office was designed this way

Quick revision

The Governor on one page
  • The Governor is the constitutional head of the State and acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers led by the Chief Minister.
  • Appointed by the President; term five years; holds office during the President's pleasure; can be reappointed.
  • Appoints the Chief Minister, Ministers (on the CM's advice), the Advocate General and State PSC members.
  • Summons, prorogues and addresses the legislature; dissolves the Assembly.
  • On a Bill: assent, withhold, return (bound if re-passed) or reserve for the President (President not bound).
  • Ordinances lapse six weeks after the legislature reassembles.
  • Can report a breakdown to the President under Article 356; the President acts.
  • Discretion in a hung Assembly has made the office the most controversial constitutional office.

Check yourself

Exam-style questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see the explanation. 0 of 10 answered

  1. The Governor of a State is appointed by:

  2. Consider: 1. The Governor's term is five years. 2. The Governor holds office during the pleasure of the President. 3. A Governor cannot be reappointed to another State. Which are correct?

  3. A State Bill (not a Money Bill) returned by the Governor is passed again by the legislature. The Governor:

  4. Consider: 1. A Bill reserved by the Governor and returned by the President must be reconsidered by the State legislature within six months. 2. If the legislature passes it again, the President must give assent. Which are correct?

  5. An Ordinance issued by the Governor ceases to operate:

  6. Under Article 356, President's Rule in a State is proclaimed by:

  7. The Governor's power to grant pardons extends to offences against laws:

  8. In which case did a Governor invite the leader of the largest party, without a majority, to form the government?

  9. The 'dual role' of the Governor refers to being:

  10. Consider the following statements: 1. The Governor of a State holds office during the pleasure of the President. 2. The Constitution gives the Governor a fixed term of five years that cannot be cut short. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Mains answer practice

Write your answer first, then open the points a good answer should cover.

  1. 'The office of the Governor has become the most controversial constitutional office in India.' Examine the causes and suggest reforms. (150 words)

    Show answer points
    • Dual role; appointment and removal at the Centre's will
    • Discretion in hung Assemblies: Madras 1952 vs West Bengal 1970
    • Dismissals and dissolutions; Article 356 reports without floor tests (Kerala 1959, 1984 cases)
    • Reservation of Bills dents State autonomy
    • Reforms: floor test, CM consultation, secure tenure, non-political Governors, Article 356 as last resort

Previous year questions

Previous year questions for UPSC CSE will appear here once each one is checked word for word against the official question paper.

Frequently asked questions

Who appoints the Governor?

The President, for a term of five years. The Governor holds office during the President's pleasure and can be reappointed to the same or another State.

What can a Governor do with a Bill?

Give assent, withhold assent, return a non-Money Bill with a message (and assent if it is passed again), or reserve it for the President's consideration.

When does the Governor's discretion matter most?

When no party has a clear majority, for example in choosing whom to invite as Chief Minister. This has made the office the most debated constitutional post.

Whom does the Governor appoint?

The Chief Minister and, on the CM's advice, the other Ministers, as well as the Advocate General and members of the State Public Service Commission.